Slashdot Mirror

youngcfan asks: "I've been tasked with finding strategies for a test database that can be used effectively by both software developers and the QA team. We're a J2EE shop with most of the interesting pieces of the application interacting heavily with the database -- so we need to test it. We're ramping up on JUnit, but are looking for ways to test the database-driven pieces of code. Since QA needs the same database for functional testing separate from developers' unit tests, DBUnit doesn't seem to suffice. We also have the challenge of working on multiple releases at the same time, which only complicates how and when to add new data to the test database in a way that's useful and valid for everyone. We're looking for strategies for using a test database in a way that meets both the QA's and the developers' needs, works for multiple releases, and isn't a heavy burden to maintain given that the schema and code can change anytime before any of the multiple upcoming releases. Any suggestions?"

Frank Buss writes "Common Lisp is an ANSI standard, which defines a general purpose language and library, and is implemented by free and commercial compilers and IDEs; see *hyper-cliki* for more general information about Common Lisp. The book Practical Common Lisp explains the language with many practical examples and is available in full text online, too." Read on for the rest of Buss' review. Practical Common Lisp author Peter Seibel, Gary Cornell (Editor) pages 500 publisher Apress rating 8 reviewer Frank Buss ISBN 1590592395 summary A book for learning and using Common Lisp

Unlike other good books about Lisp, which are focused on a specific domain, like AI (such as Paradigms of Artificial Intelligence Programming ) or basic computer science (for example Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs for the Lisp-like language Scheme), this book focuses on solving real-world problems in Common Lisp, like web programming, testing etc., after introducing the language by examples in the first chapters. I started with Lisp half an year ago, and it has helped me a lot in learning it. But even if you already know Lisp, this book may be useful for you, because it has a fresh view on the language and the examples in the later chapters are usable in your day-to-day work as a programmer.

The first chapter tells you something about the author (he was a good Java programmer before starting with Lisp) and the history of Lisp and Lisp dialects like Scheme. The next chapters are a tour through all Lisp features, written in easy-to-understand steps, beginning with the installation of a Lisp system and an introduction to the interactive REPL. You don't need any experience in other languages to understand it.

The general concept throughout is to explain a feature first, then show an example of how to use it, with detailed discussion of what the example does and possible pitfalls. A nice example is the APPEND function, which does not copy the last argument:

The reason most list functions are written functionally is it allows them to return results that share cons cells with their arguments. To take a concrete example, the function APPEND takes any number of list arguments and returns a new list containing the elements of all its arguments. For instance:(append (list 1 2) (list 3 4)) ==> (1 2 3 4)

From a functional point of view, APPEND's job is to return the list (1 2 3 4) without modifying any of the cons cells in the lists (1 2) and (3 4). One obvious way to achieve that goal is to create a completely new list consisting of four new cons cells. However, that's more work than is necessary. Instead, APPEND actually makes only two new cons cells to hold the values 1 and 2, linking them together and pointing the CDR of the second cons cell at the head of the last argument, the list (3 4). It then returns the cons cell containing the 1. None of the original cons cells has been modified, and the result is indeed the list (1 2 3 4). The only wrinkle is that the list returned by APPEND shares some cons cells with the list (3 4). The resulting structure looks like this:

In general, APPEND must copy all but its last argument, but it can always return a result that shares structure with the last argument.

In chapter 9, the first larger practical example is developed, a unit testing framework (like JUnit), which is easy to use and to enhance.

Certain Lisp implementation behaviors can be confusing, such as those for for building pathnames. The pathname concept in Lisp is very abstract, leading to different choices in different implementations. This is no problem if you use only one implementation, but chapter 15 develops a portable pathname library, which works on many implementations. By doing this, it shows you how to write portable Lisp code, using different code for different implementations with reader macros.

After an introduction to the Common Lisp Object System (CLOS) and a few practical FORMAT recipes (the printf for Lisp, but more powerful), chapter 19, "Beyond Exception Handling: Conditions and Restarts", is really useful. The exception handling in Lisp (called "condition system") is more general than other exeption systems: In Lisp you can define restarts where you generate an exception and the exeption handler can call these restarts to continue the program. After reading this chapter, you'll never again want to use the restricted version of Java or C++ exception handling.

Chapters 23 to 31 show real world examples: a spam filter, parsing binary files, an ID3 parser, Web programming with AllegroServe, an MP3 database, a Shoutcast server, an MP3 browser and an HTML generation library with interpreter and compiler. If you ever thought that Lisp is an old language, only used for AI research, these chapters prove you wrong: Especially the binary files parser shows you, how you can extend the language with macros for implementing binary file readers, which looks nearly as clear and compact as the plain text binary file description itself. I'm using some of the ideas for a Macromedia Flash SWF file reader/writer I'm currently writing. Take a look at my Web page for my currently published Lisp projects.

The Web programming chapters demonstrates how to use a dynamic approach for generating web pages. You just start a Web server in your Lisp environment; then you can publish static Web pages or define functions, which are called when the page is requested by a browser. The author demonstrates how to define dynamic pages with formulars in Lisp and Lisp HTML generators.

After reading Practical Common Lisp, you will know most of Common Lisp and how to write real-world programs with it. Some special features, like set-dispatch-macro-character, or using one of the non-standard GUI libraries, are not explained, but it is easy to learn the rest of Common Lisp and to use other Lisp libraries, with the knowledge gained from this book.

You can purchase Practical Common Lisp from bn.com. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to see your own review here, read the book review guidelines, then visit the submission page

vertigo writes "I am reasonably proficient in C and C++ as well as the more common scripting languages, but i always felt the lack of a sweet spot between the hard and fast low-level programming languages and the loosely typed scripting languages. Lately, my interest in the Mono project has been growing. The C# language appears to offer just that sweet spot between power and productivity I've been looking for, and its class libraries like Gtk# seem to provide the programmer with a very clean and intuitive API." Read on for vertigo's review of Mono: A Developer's Handbook from O'Reilly. Mono: A Developer's Handbook author Edd Dumbill and Niel M. Bornstein pages 278 publisher O'Reilly Media, Inc. rating 8 reviewer vertigo ISBN 0596007922 summary An introduction to programming with Mono

When learning a new language such as C#, or working with a new development environment such as Mono, it usually takes some time before you get up to speed in developing programs. Wading through the reference documentation and reading other people's source code often provides much-needed information on how to do certain things. Both, however, are very time consuming and tedious.

Enter Mono: A Developer's Notebook. This book provides a series of task-driven chapters which are thin on theory, but rich on practical content and example code. The featured code snippets are, in contrast to ones in books that teach theory and concepts, not solely designed to illustrate a specific theoretical aspect of programming. Each one is designed to perform a useful task that is essential in day-to-day application programming. What sets this book apart from the multitude of .NET books already available on the market? In order to answer this question it is neccesary to provide a short introduction on Mono.

Mono is essentially an open source cross-platform implementation of Microsoft's .NET development framework and implements the API's which are standardized by ECMA. It is, however, not an exact clone. Besides providing a (partially implemented) stack that provides compatibility with Microsoft's .NET API's, Mono adds a whole new API-stack of its own, consisting of open source technologies such as the Gtk+ toolkit and the Gecko HTML rendering engine. This makes it possible to develop cross-platform applications based on open source technology while (mostly) compiling from a single code-base. In contrast to most .NET books available on the market, which focus primarily on Microsoft's API's in the context of Visual Studio.NET, this book concentrates on the basic ECMA API's and Mono's own open source stack. A complete coverage of .NET and the Mono architecture is outside of this review's scope, so for more information you are advised to check the Mono Project's website.

Before we dive deeper into the content of the book, a short introduction on the Developer's Notebook series by O'Reilly may be useful. The books in this series are styled to resemble the kind of notebooks college students carry around during their classes in which to take notes or, more commonly, draw caricatures of their teachers. The 'notebook' theme persists throughout the look-and-feel of the book. The 278-page thick paperback has a glossy blue cover, complete with faux post-it note and coffee-stains. Inside, the pages are not clean white but lined like the pages found in math notebooks. In the margin, useful comments are scribbled in a font that resembles handwriting. At first I suspected that the 'busy' look would distract from the content, but in practice this was no problem, thanks to the thick black typewriter font in which the bulk of the text is printed.

The chapters in this book are referred to as labs. Each of them focuses on a specific set of tasks and/or features and is divided into several paragraphs. Most paragraphs consist of a number of standard sections following a rigid formula that help you understand a certain aspect of working with Mono. The most common sections are:

• How do I do that?: Often using a liberal amount of practical code, this section shows how to accomplish the task at hand, for example working with files.
• How it works: In this section, the code and concepts involved in the previous section are explained more in depth, step by step.
• What about...: Offers a short focus on more advanced topics or pitfalls.
• Where to learn more: If you are craving more information after reading the previous sections, you are often offered a helping hand on where to find more information, providing url's to relevant documentation such as MSDN and other websites.

The first chapter, Getting Mono Running, describes how to get Mono up and running on Linux, Windows or Mac OS X, and how to compile from source on other platforms. The installation instructions for Windows only describe how to install Mono and Gtk#. Integration of Gtk# only in an existing Visual Studio.Net installation falls outside of the scope of the book, but a recent blog entry offers some hints on how to accomplish this. Besides installation, the first chapter offers a short description of the individual tools that make up the mono development. After installation, you will want some kind of editor or IDE to work with. Both the MonoDevelop IDE and several other ways of integrating Mono into your existing environment as a Java or Windows developer are covered. Finally, the community is an important aspect of every open source project. Ways of interacting with the community as well as a guide on how to submit bugs and links to some working Mono/C# applications are part of this chapter.

The C# introduction in the second chapter, Getting Started with C#, is tailored towards people who have at least some proficiency in using an object-oriented language such as C++ or Java. Some differences between C#, Java and C++ are discussed, as well as the differences between value- and reference types, the basics of error handling, working with assemblies and more. Concepts such as classes, methods, inheritance and namespaces are assumed to be known territory. If you have no previous programming experience, Mono: A Developer's Notebook is only useful in combination with a book that teaches programming with C# such as The C# Programming Language by Anders Hejlsberg.

An important part of any modern language is its class libraries. The third chapter, Core .NET, provides an introduction to the standard Framework Library Classes, which describes essential everyday tasks that are part of every program, such as working with files, strings, searching for text patterns and handling collections of data. Besides those basic functions, the chapter also dives deeper into the internals of a compiled assembly, the handling of processes and easy multitasking using threads. Finally, the last paragraph explains how to use a .NET version of the JUnit Java Unit testing framework, Nunit, to test your code.

Developing Gtk-applications with Mono and C# is remarkably easy. Chapter 4, Gtk#, describes the basics of writing Gtk# applications. First, it's neccesary to remark that Gtk# might be a bit of a misnomer. Besides the raw Gtk+ toolkit functionality, Gtk# also includes most of the Gnome libraries like gconf, the gnome canvas, libglade and more. Chapter 4 describes functionality available in the Gtk namespace, the basic Gtk+ toolkit. Gtk+ is a constraints-based toolkit, which means that widgets are not positioned using absolute pixel coordinates but rather on basis of their logical relation to each other. This can be a bit confusing for novices, but this chapter provides a good introduction to the basic principles of writing layouts using Gtk#. The authors provide descriptions of essential operations that almost every application needs, such as creating menus and drawing pixmaps (or more advanced things like using the treeview widget and drag-and-drop), assisted by easy-to-read code snippets.

While chapter 4 introduces basic Gtk# functionality, chapter 5, Advanced Gtk#, delves deeper into more advanced features of the Gtk# library which also include functionality outside of the basic Gtk-namespace, such as the Gnome libraries. Working with Gnome button toolbars, the Glade user interface designer, storing your application settings in Gconf, setting up some preferences through the use of a wizard/druid, asynchronous operations and threading to increase responsiveness of your application while performing background tasks, rendering HTML in your application using the Gecko rendering engine and internationalisation and translation of applications are all described in this chapter.

The use of XML is tightly integrated throughout the Mono framework. It is, for example, the underlying format of the messages that web services use to communicate using the SOAP and XML-RPC protocols. The 6th chapter, Processing XML, describes the XML functionality available in Mono. It starts off by simple operations, reading and writing to an XML-file using relevant examples such as RSS and Dashboard clue-packets. It then proceeds to describe how to modify XML in memory, how to navigate and transform XML using Xpath and XSLT, how to constrain XML in several ways and how to serialize and deserialize objects into and from their XML representation. As in previous chapters, the information density is very high so it might take several reads to grok everything explained. The code examples and accompanying text however are very clear and concise.

The 7th chapter called Networking, Remoting, and Web Services describes the networking functionality available in Mono. The chapter starts off with ASP.NET. Mono's stand-alone XSP webserver and Apache integration with mod_mono are discussed, as well as the basics of writing a web application using ASP.NET's code-behind functionality which enables web applications to completely seperate presentation from the underlying code. Communication using plain tcp/ip, remoting using binary serialized objects and invoking remote procedures using XML-RPC as an alternative to SOAP are also described in this chapter. You might want to encrypt the data you send over the network, so a basic description of the Mono cryptographic API is provided. Finally, a short introduction to database handling using ADO.NET concludes chapter 7.

The 8th and last chapter titled Cutting Edge Mono starts off with an introduction on how to use the GNU Automake, Autoconf and the pkg-config tools to create an easy to build source package of your project. It then proceeds to describe various pitfalls and considerations in case you want to write cross-platform applications using Mono, such as filesystem layout, configuration storage and the calling of native code using p/invoke. A particularly cool project is IKVM, which translates Java bytecode into the Common Intermediate Language bytecode Mono uses. This enables Mono to run Java applications and allows Java and Mono code to inter-operate. A short introduction on the use of IKVM is provided, as well as some code examples on how to call Mono assemblies from Java and use the Java class libraries from within Mono applications. The chapter ends with some other cutting-edge functionality, like how to run a development version of Mono, a preview of the Generics (templates in c++) implementation available as featured in C# 2.0 and how to write Mono programs in Basic.

What is missing? The book doesn't contain a reference section on any of the described API's. If you need detailed information on the C# language specification or an API reference you will need to consult external resources such as the documentation provided with Mono, MSDN, or a separate book covering the topic to make optimal use of the information contained in this book. Fortunately, the book kindly provides pointers on where to find those. The information-density is much higher than you would expect from a book this size. This means the information contained in it is terse. Many topics are treated in a only a couple of pages and the book doesn't take time to explain a lot of programming concepts. The information gets you 'on the road' quickly however, which is exactly what this book is supposed to do.

The strength of this book is that it fills the gap between the earlier-mentioned reference documentation and the need to go out and try to read sourcecode to find out how a particular thing is done. The writing style is clear, concise and neutral. Some topics are clarified by the use of screenshots, which is especially useful in the chapters dealing with Gtk# widgets. All in all, if you are a developer with previous experience in object-oriented programming, Mono: A Developer's Notebook will provide you with an excellent introduction into many of the aspects of working with Mono, its associated libraries and programs.

More information and a sample chapter can be found at the book's homepage.

You can purchase Mono: A Developer's Handbook from bn.com. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to see your own review here, read the book review guidelines, then visit the submission page.

Will Gwaltney writes "The Pragmatic Programmers have done it again. This time it's with volume 2 of their Pragmatic Starter Kit series, Pragmatic Unit Testing in Java with JUnit. In the friendly, accessible style we've come to expect from Andy Hunt and Dave Thomas, the book provides a gentle introduction to unit testing in general and the JUnit testing package in particular. Of course, by the time you've read through the introduction you're hooked, at which point Andy and Dave give you enough information to make you not just a good unit tester, but a better developer to boot." Gwaltney offers this disclaimer: "I know both authors and was one of the proofreaders for this book. I have no financial stake in either the book or their company." With that grain of salt, read on for the rest. Pragmatic Unit Testing in Java with JUnit author Andrew Hunt and David Thomas pages 159 publisher The Pragmatic Bookshelf rating 10 reviewer Will Gwaltney ISBN 0974514012 summary Unit Testing introduction, tutorial, and developer's guide

What's the Approach? You can go a long way in the unit testing world with this book. It's a great starter guide for learning about unit testing; the first chapter has several small sections which answer many of the questions a novice might have about the subject, including some of the most common objections to unit testing. Then the book launches into a detailed user guide to the JUnit package, including some useful but lesser-known topics like writing your own custom asserts.

After you've got the basics down, the book spends several chapters drilling into the concepts, considerations, and best practices for writing good tests. This section of the book is quite practical, and is where the true worth of the book comes out. Any developer who reads this section will come away better for it even if they never consistently write unit tests. It's amazing how many testing issues turn out to be development issues at their core; this section of the book points some of them out. Simply being aware of these issues can help you to avoid a number of common pitfalls.

Finally, the book discusses common unit testing problems and their solutions. This section is a lot of fun because of the anecdotes that Andy and Dave include; unfortunately some of them I recognized from my own experiences as a developer. (What, me do that? No, uh, of course not!)

Who's it For? This book is primarily for developers (and testers who are intimately involved in the development process), since unit testing per se is primarily a developer task. Depending on the organization of the software shop, by the time code gets to a formal testing or QA group it's probably too late to apply unit testing methods effectively. (Note I said unit testing methods here.) The book is ideal for the unit testing novice, and there's a lot of good information here for more advanced developers to ponder.

The book is targeted at those who want to learn "how to think about tests, how testing affects design, and how to handle certain team-wide issues you may be having" (from the Preface). In particular the book is an excellent source of information for those developers who have recently moved into the Java area and are looking for a good testing framework.

No matter what your role in the development process, this book can help give you a fresh perspective into unit testing and related issues. It prods you to think about issues that perhaps you hadn't considered before.

Pros As you can probably tell, I like the Pragmatic Programmer writing style. It's informal and friendly without being chatty or wordy, and the main text moves along well. More technical discussions are reserved for sidebars, and there are "Joe Asks..." sections throughout the book that anticipate questions that Joe Programmer might ask about the current topic.

The examples in the book are excellent. Many books err on the side of code snippets that don't have enough context to be understandable, or multi-page code extravaganzas that bury the details of the topic at hand under mountains of cruft. I found the examples here to give just the right amount of detail to understand what's going on. And the source for all the examples is available from the author's web site.

Cons What this book is not is a reference manual for JUnit. The book doesn't include a javadoc listing for the JUnit package, nor does it have a section that digs into JUnit's internals. This is not necessarily a Bad Thing because that information is available from the JUnit web site, but it does bear mentioning.

If there was anything I found to complain about it was the use of acronyms in the concepts section of the book. I'll admit right here that I'm no lover of acronyms, so I felt that using things like Right-BICEP, CONNECT, and A-TRIP as mnemonics for the concepts was a bit over the top. (Read the book to see what I mean.) However, I have to admit that they help me remember the concepts discussed, so I guess they do their job (grumble).

Why Should I Read this Book?

If you hate testing, this book will very probably change your mind, and you'll have fun in the process (the stories are great!). And even if you still hate testing after you've finished the book, you will have enhanced your development skills enough to be able to delude yourself that testing isn't necessary for you (well, maybe not that much). At the very least, this book will make you aware of the various issues that proper testing can expose and maybe help you try to avoid them. By shining a light into these areas, it can still make you a more effective developer... maybe effective enough to realize how much more solid your work could be with this type of testing coverage.

If you love testing, this book will remind you why you began the love affair. Your love will be strengthened and deepened, and the tests you write will undoubtedly get better, too.

For Java developers specifically, this book will get you started writing JUnit tests painlessly and effectively and will take you a long way down the road to unit test proficiency. It will give developers in any language quite a bit to take "back to the terminal" regarding design and process as well as testing. An excellent and much needed book.

Like volume 1 of the Pragmatic Starter Kit series ( Slashdot Review), this book is available from the Pragmatic Programmer website. The printed version is $29.95 and there's a PDF version available for $20.00. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to see your own review here, read the book review guidelines, then visit the submission page.

Simon P. Chappell writes "The Eclipse IDE has thundered into the collective consciousness of Java developers since its release by IBM as Open Source Software. Up until this time, the majority of available documentation at the Eclipse website has been for plug-in developers, with scant attention given to the rest of us that actually want to use the tool for anything else. This book restores the balance and brings much needed help to those interested in this IDE." Read on for the rest of Simon's review, about which he says "Full Disclosure: I received a free, review copy of this book, so feel free to assume that I've been bought off and have traded my technical integrity to put about an inch of dead tree on my shelf." Eclipse in Action author Gallardo, Burnette and McGovern pages 383 (15 page index) publisher Manning rating 8 reviewer Simon P. Chappell ISBN 1930110960 summary A good book that lives up to its name.

Overview With a book like this it's difficult to know where to pitch the level. Do you aim for the lowest common denominator or do you assume some experience on the part of your reader? This book seems to have pitched itself well, not pandering to the absolute Java newbie, not afraid to get down into the code and yet gentle enough that newer Java developers can follow easily. The heavyweight chapter on writing plug-ins is at the back where it shouldn't frighten those of a sensitive nature.

The book is divided into two sections. The first and largest section concerns actual use of Eclipse during Java application development. The second section is for those who wish to write plug-ins for Eclipse.

The book takes a very 'Test Driven Development' approach to Java development and this shows in the manner that Eclipse is presented and taught. Emphasis is given to the tools that come with Eclipse, especially Ant, Junit and the CVS client. For those already skilled in these tools, this might seem like filler, but remember that there are still pitifully few Java developers using even these simple and free tools. My hat is off to the authors for their TDD evangelism, skillfully disguised as Eclipse usage instruction.

What's To Like I liked the progression followed in the book, first teaching the basic operation of Eclipse and then moving on to the tools that come with the base install. What's To Consider Some may consider that the material on Ant, Junit and CVS is filler. The 'Test Driven Development' theme may be a little too much evangelism for some.

I use Eclipse on a Mac OS X box and I felt that there was very little discussion concerning the cross-platform attributes of the tool. All of the screenshots were from a Microsoft Windows build of the software; a Linux or OS X screenshot would have been helpful.

One more niggle and then I'm done. There is no information on using Eclipse with other programming languages (a couple of paragraphs in the introduction chapter doesn't really count). I've recently started tinkering with Ruby and have used a Ruby plug-in to allow me to work within Eclipse as I learn the language. This is a wonderful testament to the power and extensibility of Eclipse.

Summary This is a good book. You know it's a good book when you already use the tool (both pure Eclipse and IBM's WSAD) regularly and you find yourself learning things that you had not previously been aware of. If you are working with Java and want a good free IDE that's going to grow with you, then Eclipse is a tool you should try -- and consider this book the User's Guide that would have been in the box if Eclipse came shrink-wrapped.

Table Of Contents

1. Using Eclipse
2. 1. Overview
   2. Getting started with the Eclipse Workbench
   3. The Java development cycle: test, code, repeat
   4. Working with source code in eclipse
   5. Building with Ant
   6. Source control with CVS
   7. Web development tools
3. Extending Eclipse
4. 1. Introduction to Eclipse plug-ins
   2. Working with plug-ins in Eclipse

You can purchase Eclipse in Action from bn.com. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to see your own review here, read the book review guidelines, then visit the submission page.

Bill Venners writes "In this article, three programmers tell the story of how their frustration with JUnit's API led to the creation of Artima SuiteRunner, a free, open source test toolkit and JUnit runner. These programmers simply wanted to create a small add-on tool to JUnit, but found JUnit's design non-intuitive and API documention poor. After spending time reading through JUnit's source code and attempting to guess at the API contracts, they gave up and rewrote it."

smarks writes "Java Development with Ant effectively shows the reader how Ant can be used as the foundation for the most complex Java software configuration solutions. The book is divided into beginner, intermediate and advanced sections, which makes it appropriate for a variety of audiences. The book has a comprehensive survey of tools that can be used with Ant such as JUnit, CheckStyle, Middlegen and XDoclet Even the experienced Ant user will find these sections helpful. Overall, Java Development with Ant is an excellent resource." Read on for the rest of Spencer's review. Java Development with Ant author Eric Hatcher, Steve Loughran pages 634 publisher Manning rating 8.5 reviewer Spencer Marks ISBN 1930110588 summary How to use Ant to meet all (or most of) your poject's software configuration needs

Pros:

• Excellent coverage of optional Ant tasks
• Good division of beginner, intermediate and advanced content
• Thorough discussion of how to use Ant to solve a variety of software configuration management situations
• Shows how to use Ant for tasks outside of typical configuration management roles such as the automated code generation of EJB and Application Server deployment descriptors
• Shows how Ant helps with a variety of software development methodologies including XP's suggested best practices of continual integration and JUnit testing
• Catalogs IDEs that integrate well with Ant including my personal favorite, Intellij's IDEA development environment

Cons:

• Some of the examples could have benefited from more detail. For example, the section on the PropertyFile task could have shown how to solve the problem of platform specific path separators in Java property files.
• At the time of this review, the book's accompanying website was a bit meager. For example, a comprehensive list of Ant on-line resources would have been helpful.

What the book offers

I consider myself an intermediate Ant user and when books on Ant first appeared I thought they would add little to the excellent free documentation and examples readily available. With its clean, straight forward syntax and structure, Ant has a low of cost of entry, and being rooted in Java and XML it is extremely flexible and extensible. I found Ant refreshingly easy to use as part of a configuration management system that included continual integration and a unit testing strategy. It was much better suited for Java development than the tool I previously used which was make. So when I agreed to do this review, I was skeptical that I would find the book useful. However, the book proved to be rich in valuable information that is well organized and clearly presented. Java Development with Ant, written by Erik Hatcher and Steve Loughran who are both committers to the Apache Ant project, is a great resource for anyone wishing to learn how to integrate Ant into his personal set of best practices for software configuration management solutions.

Coming to the book as a long time Ant user, I was glad to see that it offered material appropriate for others than just those approaching Ant for the first time. The book is divided into three sections each of which could probably find a niche as useful (and thinner) separate book: Learning Ant, Apply Ant, and Extending Ant. Only the first section of the book is devoted to first-time users, or those Learning Ant. The reminder of the book is about Ant in action. It covers an interesting variety of third-party Ant tasks, various ways of applying Ant to software development projects, and an in-depth section on how to extend Ant writing your own Java classes.

After a short but helpful introduction to the general topic of software configuration management, the first section, Learning Ant, launches into a thorough explanation of Ant's fundamental concepts and operation. JUnit test integration is treated as part of of the basic operation of Ant, which I was happy to see because unit testing should be a fundamental part of any software configuration management process.

Despite having used Ant on a number of projects since the summer 2000, at no point have I had to become truly expert with it in order to solve the wide range of software configuration problems I encountered. This is because Ant is easy to use. Typically, I figure out what I want the software configuration management to do, and then look for Ant examples that I can easily tweak to get the job done. I think it is a great credit to the Ant and its designers that I can do this successfully. Even though I've had this success with Ant, the introductory material filled in some of the gaps I had in my understanding of Ant's operation. For example, I was introduced to the PropertyFile taskdef which up until then had escaped my notice but which solved a problem for which I previously had a less elegant solution.

The most interesting part of the book was the second section that talked about a variety of Ant add on programs (called taskdefs) like Middlegen (an EJB descriptor tool) and XDoclet. XDoclet had been on the periphery of my radar for a while now, so I welcomed the book's thorough discussion of it in both a general and Ant specific sense. In addition there are helpful chapters devoted to using Ant as an aide to production deployment, web site generation including the compilation of JSP pages and the automatic generation of EJB descriptors. There are also chapters on working with Web Services using SOAP and a section on how Ant can be used as part of a continuous integration process complete with email notification. There is even a section on using Ant for Java projects that have a native code component. (Ant can be used to compile native code and the book shows how it can be helpful in dealing with the complexities surrounding JNI.) The book works well as a reference text. There's no need to read it from cover to cover in order for it to be extremely helpful.

The third part of the book also looks interesting, but it is intended for a more hardcore audience than myself. I've been fortunate to find ready made solutions for all the configuration management services I wanted to provide my clients. So, learning how to extend Ant has never been an issue. Every time I think I might have to develop my own answer, I find that someone else has already beaten me to it. Such is the nature of successful Open Source projects. However, I am glad this section exists, because I am sure at some point I will use it myself or refer a student or client to it.

The book even has some material on using Ant outside of the context of Java. Not having much experience with these technologies, I didn't pay close attention to these sections. (I am sure I'll be amused when I encounter my first .NET project that is using Ant for its configuration management solution).

In closing, if you are more than casually interested in software configuration management for Java projects then I recommend this book with enthusiasm. Beginners will be up and running with Ant in short order, while the book contains many interesting and useful nuggets for more experienced Ant users.

Ant on the web

• The Ant Project -- be sure to see their resources section.
• Ant FAQ at jguru.com (moderated by the book's co-author: Erik Hatcher)
• Ant forum at jguru (moderated by the book's co-author: Erik Hatcher)
• JUnit: A regression testing framework written by Erich Gamma and Kent Beck. It is used to implement unit tests in Java.
• CheckStyle: A development tool to help programmers write Java code that adheres to a coding standard.
• Middlegen:A general-purpose database-driven code generation engine.
• XDoclet: An extended Javadoc Doclet engine. It's a generic Java tool that lets you create custom Javadoc @tags and based on those @tags generate source code or other files (such as xml-ish deployment descriptors) using a template engine it provides.
• Intellij's IDEA "Develop with Pleasure" with this award winning Java IDE featuring full Ant integration that Marin Flower says: has succeeded in really moving forward the state of the art...
• The NetBeans and Eclipse Open Source IDEs also integrate nicely with Ant.

You can purchase Java Development with Ant from bn.com. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to see your own review here, read the book review guidelines, then visit the submission page.

smarks writes "Java Development with Ant effectively shows the reader how Ant can be used as the foundation for the most complex Java software configuration solutions. The book is divided into beginner, intermediate and advanced sections, which makes it appropriate for a variety of audiences. The book has a comprehensive survey of tools that can be used with Ant such as JUnit, CheckStyle, Middlegen and XDoclet Even the experienced Ant user will find these sections helpful. Overall, Java Development with Ant is an excellent resource." Read on for the rest of Spencer's review. Java Development with Ant author Eric Hatcher, Steve Loughran pages 634 publisher Manning rating 8.5 reviewer Spencer Marks ISBN 1930110588 summary How to use Ant to meet all (or most of) your poject's software configuration needs

Pros:

• Excellent coverage of optional Ant tasks
• Good division of beginner, intermediate and advanced content
• Thorough discussion of how to use Ant to solve a variety of software configuration management situations
• Shows how to use Ant for tasks outside of typical configuration management roles such as the automated code generation of EJB and Application Server deployment descriptors
• Shows how Ant helps with a variety of software development methodologies including XP's suggested best practices of continual integration and JUnit testing
• Catalogs IDEs that integrate well with Ant including my personal favorite, Intellij's IDEA development environment

Cons:

• Some of the examples could have benefited from more detail. For example, the section on the PropertyFile task could have shown how to solve the problem of platform specific path separators in Java property files.
• At the time of this review, the book's accompanying website was a bit meager. For example, a comprehensive list of Ant on-line resources would have been helpful.

What the book offers

I consider myself an intermediate Ant user and when books on Ant first appeared I thought they would add little to the excellent free documentation and examples readily available. With its clean, straight forward syntax and structure, Ant has a low of cost of entry, and being rooted in Java and XML it is extremely flexible and extensible. I found Ant refreshingly easy to use as part of a configuration management system that included continual integration and a unit testing strategy. It was much better suited for Java development than the tool I previously used which was make. So when I agreed to do this review, I was skeptical that I would find the book useful. However, the book proved to be rich in valuable information that is well organized and clearly presented. Java Development with Ant, written by Erik Hatcher and Steve Loughran who are both committers to the Apache Ant project, is a great resource for anyone wishing to learn how to integrate Ant into his personal set of best practices for software configuration management solutions.

Coming to the book as a long time Ant user, I was glad to see that it offered material appropriate for others than just those approaching Ant for the first time. The book is divided into three sections each of which could probably find a niche as useful (and thinner) separate book: Learning Ant, Apply Ant, and Extending Ant. Only the first section of the book is devoted to first-time users, or those Learning Ant. The reminder of the book is about Ant in action. It covers an interesting variety of third-party Ant tasks, various ways of applying Ant to software development projects, and an in-depth section on how to extend Ant writing your own Java classes.

After a short but helpful introduction to the general topic of software configuration management, the first section, Learning Ant, launches into a thorough explanation of Ant's fundamental concepts and operation. JUnit test integration is treated as part of of the basic operation of Ant, which I was happy to see because unit testing should be a fundamental part of any software configuration management process.

Despite having used Ant on a number of projects since the summer 2000, at no point have I had to become truly expert with it in order to solve the wide range of software configuration problems I encountered. This is because Ant is easy to use. Typically, I figure out what I want the software configuration management to do, and then look for Ant examples that I can easily tweak to get the job done. I think it is a great credit to the Ant and its designers that I can do this successfully. Even though I've had this success with Ant, the introductory material filled in some of the gaps I had in my understanding of Ant's operation. For example, I was introduced to the PropertyFile taskdef which up until then had escaped my notice but which solved a problem for which I previously had a less elegant solution.

The most interesting part of the book was the second section that talked about a variety of Ant add on programs (called taskdefs) like Middlegen (an EJB descriptor tool) and XDoclet. XDoclet had been on the periphery of my radar for a while now, so I welcomed the book's thorough discussion of it in both a general and Ant specific sense. In addition there are helpful chapters devoted to using Ant as an aide to production deployment, web site generation including the compilation of JSP pages and the automatic generation of EJB descriptors. There are also chapters on working with Web Services using SOAP and a section on how Ant can be used as part of a continuous integration process complete with email notification. There is even a section on using Ant for Java projects that have a native code component. (Ant can be used to compile native code and the book shows how it can be helpful in dealing with the complexities surrounding JNI.) The book works well as a reference text. There's no need to read it from cover to cover in order for it to be extremely helpful.

The third part of the book also looks interesting, but it is intended for a more hardcore audience than myself. I've been fortunate to find ready made solutions for all the configuration management services I wanted to provide my clients. So, learning how to extend Ant has never been an issue. Every time I think I might have to develop my own answer, I find that someone else has already beaten me to it. Such is the nature of successful Open Source projects. However, I am glad this section exists, because I am sure at some point I will use it myself or refer a student or client to it.

The book even has some material on using Ant outside of the context of Java. Not having much experience with these technologies, I didn't pay close attention to these sections. (I am sure I'll be amused when I encounter my first .NET project that is using Ant for its configuration management solution).

In closing, if you are more than casually interested in software configuration management for Java projects then I recommend this book with enthusiasm. Beginners will be up and running with Ant in short order, while the book contains many interesting and useful nuggets for more experienced Ant users.

Ant on the web

• The Ant Project -- be sure to see their resources section.
• Ant FAQ at jguru.com (moderated by the book's co-author: Erik Hatcher)
• Ant forum at jguru (moderated by the book's co-author: Erik Hatcher)
• JUnit: A regression testing framework written by Erich Gamma and Kent Beck. It is used to implement unit tests in Java.
• CheckStyle: A development tool to help programmers write Java code that adheres to a coding standard.
• Middlegen:A general-purpose database-driven code generation engine.
• XDoclet: An extended Javadoc Doclet engine. It's a generic Java tool that lets you create custom Javadoc @tags and based on those @tags generate source code or other files (such as xml-ish deployment descriptors) using a template engine it provides.
• Intellij's IDEA "Develop with Pleasure" with this award winning Java IDE featuring full Ant integration that Marin Flower says: has succeeded in really moving forward the state of the art...
• The NetBeans and Eclipse Open Source IDEs also integrate nicely with Ant.

You can purchase Java Development with Ant from bn.com. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to see your own review here, read the book review guidelines, then visit the submission page.

David Kennedy writes: "This is a review of Brett McLaughlin's new O'Reilly title, Building Java Enterprise Applications. Volume 1: Architecture, subtitled Designing with EJBs, Databases, and Directory Servers." Read David's in-depth review, below. Building Java Enterprise Applications, Volume I: Architecture author Brett McLaughlin pages 300 publisher O'Reilly rating 9 reviewer David Kennedy ISBN 0596001231 summary Practical guide, with examples, for building a J2EE application from scratch.

Summary: Building Java Enterprise Applications is an excellent book, and ought to be on the bookshelf of every J2EE programmer working on the mid- and back-tier. If you are like me, then you then have a series of books on various parts of the J2EE alphabet soup -- a few on EJB/JNDIs, one on JMS, one on RMI, one on JDBC, a database/SQL primer, a J2EE patterns book (I recommend Depur et al. by the way), maybe even some hyped-up case studies from Sun's press etc -- but nothing on how to design an entire J2EE application from scratch. There is nothing scarier than a blank piece of paper at the beginning of a project -- this book provides a combination of a tutorial and worked example, along with an insight into the thought processes of the designer.

There are not enough books of this type for the J2EE platform; the emphasis on tying together disparate technologies to build a coherent system is exactly what I need at this stage of my career, and I found the author's constant revisions and tweaking of his design fascinating and reassuring. I'm going to pre-order Vols. II and III.

Check your sources.

You might recognise the author's name -- Brett McLaughlin is the author of another O'Reilly title, Java & XML*, and writes for flashline.com, IBM Developer Works, JavaWorld and others. You can either Google for these or visit the web-site newInstance. In my opinion he knows his onions, is aware of what other root vegetables are out there, and, most important, he can communicate well.

What's the book about? I'll give you a bit of the blurb first, as it's a fair description of the material:

"Java has many enterprise APIs: JNDI, EJB, JMS, JAXP, and the other XML APIs, JDBC and more. But how do you as a developer put the pieces together and build something that works? How do these components integrate with back-end servers (databases and directories) and with front-end platforms (web servers and web services)?"

"[This] is Volume I of that series; it covers the business logic and back-end of an enterprise system, including entity EJBs, JDBC, JNDI (...), and JMS. Volume II will discuss architectures for web applications; Volume III will venture into the still-uncharted territory of web services."

That's quite an ambitious series; and something of a departure in style for O'Reilly, who have built their enviable reputation by providing definitive titles on one technology at a time. This more a book on when to use a tool, and which tool to use, rather than how to use a tool. I think it's good to see O'Reilly branching out in this way, but it brings them into the preserve of other publishers. It might be interesting to see how this new type of title does.

So what is covered in detail? Let's have a detailed look at the contents:

1. Introduction
2. Blueprints
   This chapter outlines the case study that the author uses for the remainder of the book. This takes the form of a simple, but not trivial, financial-services tool. The blueprints are high-level sketches of the business need, the Data Layer, the Business Layer, and the Presentation Layer.
3. Foundation
   This covers designing the data stores, databases and directory servers.
4. Entity Basics
   Basic design patterns, coding and deploying beans.
5. Advanced Entities
   IDs and CMP, data modeling and the nasty details.
6. Managers
   Managers, in the facade sense, for entity beans and the LDAP directory.
7. Completing the data layer
   Nasty details, populating the data store.
8. Business Logic
   The facade pattern and stateful/stateless design.
9. Messaging and packaging
   JMS on the client and server. Packaging.
10. Beyond flexibility
    The wrap-up chapter, covers the major design points, discusses adapting the material to your own projects, and hints and what presentation layers may be added as a teaser for Vols. II and III.

As you can see there are no surprises in the contents. Once the high-level problem and solution is laid out, there's just a sensible progression through the layers. I particularly liked the practice of stopping and reviewing at regular checkpoints -- it helped tie the material together and emphasize the layering in the design.

There are some detailed appendices giving vendor specific instructions for databases, containers etc. This section also contains all the non-unique code for each layer, e.g., all the entity beans that weren't discussed in detail.

• SQL Scripts
  Cloudscape, InstantDB, MySQL, Oracle, PostgreSQL.
• SQL Deployment
  Ditto.
• Directory server setup
  iPlanet, OpenLDAP.
• Application server setup
  BEA Weblogic only.
• Supplemental code listings
  All code also available in completed final form on the associated web-site.

Sounds wordy... It's not. This is a short book, only about 300 pages including appendices and index. (Compare that to something like Roman's classic EJB book ...) Chapter content is only 200 pages. Fully a third of the content of the book is code; this is definitely one for the programmer, those of you who delight in detailed breakdowns of requirements, user stories, schedules, etc will find little or nothing of interest here.

Equally, there is little in the way of explicit (non-coding) high-level design discussion -- all the code is evolved directly from the well-written text. This is not a bad thing at all -- the design seems sensible and straightforward, always a good sign, and mostly presents an admirable example to any young programmers watching.

All this doesn't mean you are reading a listing though. As on any project involving EJBs, there is a lot of more-of-the-same code between beans -- most of this code is concentrated in the appendices, and only the material under discussion is presented. New code is always presented in full, from package declaration to closing brace. This is refreshing and permits you to actually get something working as you read through the text, although you'll need to be prepared to set up app servers, databases etc to get maximum benefit.

Target audience? Experienced Java programmers who have started using the J2EE platform and are fairly comfortable with all the bean types, JMS, JNDI etc. This book states several times that it is not a primer on any one technology, and provides ample references to more detailed texts when appropriate.

This is very much a book for a wannabe J2EE developer who can't quite figure out how to fit the pieces together, or, like me, just has a gap in his/her skillset when it comes, to, say, LDAP.

What's good? Lots of it. Mainly, the best thing is the clear presentation of a LOT of code via a well partitioned example application (which will also be re-used in Vols II and III). The code is of good quality too, and presents several idioms that while obvious now, were unknown to me when I started EJB work... with the usual reworking-over-a-weekend later on. In particular, there are some commonsense pieces of code -- like a nested exception class for those of us still using pre-1.4 (and remember, you're tied to what your app server supports), some simple session and entity bean Adapter classes, simple Value Object classes etc. As I said, nothing earth-shatteringly novel, but it's nice to see a lot of these idioms used together to simplify the code.

Another admirable thing about the book is the handling of the detail. I've read several books which follow the practice of putting in Gotcha! box-outs, and to be honest, few of them are that useful unless you are a novice. I'm been programming for a few years now, and was amazed at the silly difficulties I've had with my first EJB project -- as a result I'm pleased to say that the box-outs indicating problem areas sound like the voice of bitter experience. For example, there is discussion on following the correct style for accessors/mutators under CMP (getId works, getID cheerfully fails), advice on the very fixed order in the deployment descriptor XML, problems with case-sensitive searches in JNDI, etc. Those of you who've worked with, particularly, EJB1.0/1.1, will undoubtedly have groaned as you realised the problem de jour was something simple-but-outside-your-code like those examples.

Admittedly it's not my area really, but I also found the whole treatment of directory servers very clear and useful. For the first time I understood (a) how they work (b) when they complement databases (c) how to use them easily from my code. Again, I admire the level of detail achieved without being confusing -- I don't see many introductory books include things like the default port number for directory servers using SSL (636 - well, I didn't know that!).

What's bad?

Not much. By nature of the book it doesn't go into huge detail on all technologies used -- there were a few areas where I wanted more. In particular I would have liked to have seen more on testing; now that XP is pretty much mainstream, no one can deny that unit testing is vital on production projects. (When I started using EJBs I had to kludge together a nasty version of JUnit which fitted into the sub-optimal build and client-server framework we were using. I've since found that there are better ways to test EJB layers, but I can still only think of one book, by Richard Hightower, which walks you through examples.) Although the build files in the example use Ant, which makes JUnit and other tools very easy to integrate, there is no mention of unit testing. This is a pity.

The only other things that caught my eye were minor -- coding style in particular. The coding style in the book is very straightforward and Sun-standard, but I have to admit that I'd have liked more JavaDoc'ed code. The code on the website is much more fully commented. I understand that printing this means more paper, and thus a thicker and more expensive book, but on some of the custom methods it would have clarified things for me.

In particular, and I'm being picky here, I didn't find that the authors practice on handling nulls and errors fitted with my own -- admittedly I don't so much practice "defensive coding" as "paranoid coding." Most methods were not null safe, and that can be a nightmare to debug in an n-tier system. Also, he took the line of returning null to indicate failure or error. I understand it's a valid design decision -- my experience says to go with more explicit errors in a larger project, and I would have liked a page or two on the choices here.

Another area where I feel there is room for improvement in the presented style is in the use of hard-coded Strings for lookups - for example, in the AccountManager object there are several lookups of the AccountHome, e.g.:

    AccountHome accountHome = (AccountHome)context.lookup(

        "java:conp/env/ejb/AccountHome";  // Whoops, finding this can be tough!

From experience code reviewing EJB based projects, it's going to save a lot of pain looking for typos if this repeated hard-coded String is (a) extracted as a constant so it can only be mistyped in one place and (b) refactored into a lookup method. It's a fairly minor point, but useful to do right from the start on an EJB project and worth pointing out to someone starting their first one. (Mis-typed meta-data like this is a bit of a weakness in the J2EE framework in my opinion - I always feel that I'd save a lot of time if the compiler or some J2EE aware verifier could check over those Strings to see if they match anything else in the build... I've used vendor tools which claimed to do so, but as they didn't even check that methods/lookup names were in the bean source I wasn't sure what was being verified!)

One last thing: I know it's minor, but why the insistence on importing explicitly? I feel it makes maintenance more difficult -- change one LinkedList to an ArrayList and you're off fiddly with minor imports again. I also didn't find this:

import javax.jms.JMSException;
import javax.jms.Message;
import javax.jms.MessageListener;
import javax.jms.ObjectMessage;
import javax.jms.Session;
import javax.jms.TextMessage;
import javax.jms.Topic;
import javax.jms.TopicConnection;
import javax.jms.TopicConnectionFactory;
import javax.jms.TopicSession;
import javax.jms.TopicSubscriber;

as appropriate for a printed book as this:

import javax.jms.*;

It would have been nice to trade those 10 lines wasted for some custom JavaDoc. However, all told there is remarkably little to grumble about in this book -- I couldn't even spot the obligatory editorial mistake. (That really annoyed me.)

Alternate titles?

Can't think of a good one. (Either a sign that this book is one you might want to look at or else so completely specialised as to be of use to only one person in the world, and that person is probably the author. Luckily, I think it's the former in this case.)

It is however worth a trip to the bookstore for companion, as opposed to alternate, titles before reading this - it assumes detailed knowledge of several J2EE areas, but provides suggested (O'Reilly) titles for reference.

Sounds good -- but what do you know anyway?

Time for the disclaimers. Some material in the book I found useful because I lack experience -- in particular, some database and LDAP stuff.

However, 5 years of getting paid to play^H^H^H^Hcode, and a personal reference library of some 120+ books has made it easier to spot the rare decent title! Most of my J2EE books are from my experience of EJBs for the last year or two, so I know what mistakes are easy to make, as I've made 'em. [I'm actually catching up on my reading, and hence reviewing, due to the Great Telecomms Downturn finally affecting me - anyone want a J2EE developer? :-) ] Finally, I paid for this book (which isn't the case for some of my other reviews).

You can purchase Building Java Enterprise Applications, Volume I from bn.com. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to see your own review here, read the book review guidelines, then visit the submission page.

(* Bonus mini-review: a useful book, but not easy reading, I found it hard to slog through, but managed my first XLST work in about 10 minutes using it.)

Peter Wayner writes: "In a world where Ali had to meet Frazier and Luke had to meet his father, it was only a matter of time before buzzwords like Java and eXtreme Programming found themselves together on the same marquee. A pair of new books examines some open source Java development tools and outlines how they can be put to use by those trying to master their workload by adopting the techniques of eXtreme programming." Read on for his latest review, which is really two reviews in one. (see each) author (see each) pages (see each) publisher (see each) rating (see each) reviewer Peter Wayner ISBN (see each) summary Two books which explore the use of Ant in Java software development

The two books are excellent examples of how the book industry organizes and disciplines the often crazy explosion of new tools, approaches, structures and metaphors developed by the software industry. Ant: The Definitive Guide by Jesse Tilly and Eric Burke comes from O'Reilly, the masters of producing missing manuals for open source projects. The other, Java Tools for eXtreme Programming: Mastering Open Source Tools including Ant, JUnit, and Cactus by Richard Hightower and Nicholas Lesiecki was published by John Wiley and Sons. Both provide a clear, example-driven exploration of the tools at hand.

The books are probably driven by the success of Kent Beck's Extreme Programming Explained: Embrace Change , a manifesto that outlined Beck's belief that the best way to develop code was with small teams of programmers and users who constantly reworked the software. His most controversial and attention grabbing notion demanded that the programmers work in pairs sharing one computer, one mouse and one keyboard. The constant interaction forced everyone to actually communicate with each other without sending emails and that, more than anything else, may be responsible for the success of his vision. His book spawned a few others on how programmers can plan to apply his vision.

Meanwhile, on the other side of the buzzword galaxy, the Apache group was quietly creating some of the coolest Java development and deployment tools around. Ant was and still is one of the most revolutionary, even though it was just a simple reworking of the classic UNIX make command. Its creator, James Davidson, grew so frustrated with the shell interface of the make command that he wrote a Java-centric version that moved all of the compilation, compression, and distribution inside one Java process. Now, no one has to wait for another Java Virtual Machine to start up to compile each class file independently.

While Davidson's Ant isn't much different than make at first glance, it's hard to overestimate the power of giving programmers a clever tool with plenty of hooks into the development process. Anyone can write new tasks for Ant, and some clever folks have built great new widgets that do things like enforce style guidelines or grab new code from a CVS tree. The structure of Ant lets the programmer dig deeply into the build process. The organic growth and dynamic flexibility shows how close Java can be to Lisp.

Tilly and Burke do a good job capturing the spirit of the tool. Their book follows O'Reilly's time-tested and market-proven simple-examples technique to illustrate how to use Ant for your projects. The chapters in the first half of the book outline how to use and extend Ant for your project. The strength of the book may be the way the authors casually include practical advice about the bugs and idiosyncracies of the tool. While Ant is quite capable, there are a number of little limitations to the XML parser that can drive new users a bit nuts. The second half of the book is a detailed description of the API, the data types and the other practical documentation.

In one sense, it's not really fair to lump this book in with all of this gloss about Extreme Programming. because it's just another methodical O'Reilly book with Dover artwork on the cover. It's important to realize that these tools aren't directly tied to the extreme programming movement. Ant was just created by a Java programmer who hated to wait. Everything else came afterwards when he opened the API.

Ant: The Definitive Guide author Jesse Tilly & Eric M. Burke pages 260 publisher O'Reilly rating 7 ISBN 0-597-00184-3 summary A methodical, in-depth look at the Java tool.

The other book, however, explicitly illustrates how some popular open source tools can help the process of extreme programming. Hightower and Lesiecki's book is much broader than Tilly and Burke's because they want to tackle so much more. They don't want to just provide a missing manual for the tool-- they want to give the world a road map on how they use Ant and its cousins JUnit, HTTPUnit, and Cactus to build better applications. It should be noted that Hightower and Lesiecki work for a consulting group called eBlox and a number of other eBlox programmers are listed as contributors to the book. I think it's fair to say that anyone who hires eBlox will get eXtreme Programming results built with this methodology.

The best part about this book is the wide scope. Ant remains the central taskmaster responsible for building the software, but the book explains how to incorporate other tools for testing the software. The authors embrace one of the extreme programming central beliefs that programmers should define how to test their code before it is actually written. The book explains how to use JUnit, Cactus, and HTTPUnit to set up rules to test every class file. After ANT fires up the compiler, it turns around and runs the tests on the code.

Java Tools for eXtreme Programming author Richard Hightower and Nicholas Lesiecki pages 513 publisher John Wiley and Sons rating 7 ISBN 0-471-20708-X summary How to use some Java tools to transform extreme programming theory into reality.

I don't think that eXtreme Programming or any of these tools is the last word on the subject. The biggest problem is that testing a piece of code is guaranteed to be fairly rudimentary. No programmer can come up with test cases to push all of buttons in all possible combinations. The structure and discipline provided by this approach can help, but the book makes it clear that no amount of pairs programming or extremism will remove the need for the guidance of good programmers.

If anything these tools and the books about them should serve as inspiration for the next round of tools even more focused on extreme programming. The tools are impressive, but there is plenty of room for more innovation. None of them is aimed at explicitly coordinating the work of multiple developers and none of them is designed to provide much structure to the refactoring process. These areas are still very much arts, but there's no reason why tool suites like Ant can't evolve some rational approach to solving them. Perhaps the Slashdot audience can provide some informative postings with pointers to the next generation of cool tools.

Hightower and Lesiecki's book feels a bit more rudimentary and basic than Tilly and Burke's, in part because they cover so much more ground. Although their book is broader, it doesn't go into as much depth about Ant as Tilly and Burke's. The examples are simpler, too, and Hightower and Liesiecki seem mainly interested in getting you excited about building and testing software with the tools. There just isn't as much room for details. If you're interested in learning as much as you can about Ant, choose the book devoted to it. If you want to learn how to use a diverse set of tools to build and test your program in an extreme way, go for that book.

Peter Wayner blends the buzzwords of security, privacy, and data warehousing together in his latest book, Translucent Databases. It shows how to ensure that only the right people see the right information and the wrong people get nothing. His other new book, Disappearing Cryptography, mixes the buzzwords of being, nothingness, steganography, and cryptography. You can purchase both Ant: The Definitive Guide and Java Tools for eXtreme Programming from bn.com. Slashdot welcomes readers' book reviews -- to submit yours, read the book review guidelines, then hit the submission page.

David Kennedy writes: "Java Tools For Exteme Programming: Mastering Open Source Tools including Ant, JUnit and Cactus by Hightower & Lesiecki is a welcome addition to my bookshelf at work. It tackles a gap in the Java book market in dealing with the thorny issues of testing, integration and deployment." The rest of his review is below. Java Tools For Exteme Programming: Mastering Open Source Tools including Ant, JUnit and Cactus author Richard Hightower & Nicholas Lesiecki pages 516 publisher Wiley Computer Publishing rating 8 reviewer David Kennedy ISBN 047120708X summary Practical introduction to Java tools for Extreme Programming, with an emphasis on immediate results rather than deep theory.

In recent years there has been a increased emphasis on Agile Software Development. The most prominent of these methodologies is probably Extreme Programming.

What sets Extreme Programming apart from most other Agile Technologies, in my opinion at least, is that it has provided practical, easy-to-use tools to support its way of working. Most of these tools (Ant, JUnit etc) are Open Source and freely available. However popular these tools have been with the Open Source and Extreme Programming communities, it has arguably been difficult to introduce them to traditional IT development environments. This has been primarily due to the problems of justifying spending time on 'playing' with something and the difficulties of retro-fitting new tools to an existing development environment (think projects of 150+ people which have been releasing for 5-10 years for some idea of the potential problems).

It's worth noting that when embarking on a new, large-scale project it's very difficult to find a book discussing the issues of controlled builds, integration and deployment in practical terms. The most valuable aspect of Java Tools for eXteme Programming is that it's alone in its market niche.

The book is mainly useful as (a) an introduction to the various building and continuous testing tools out there and (b) a tutorial to getting them setup and working on your computer. As the authors note, there's a critical period where the user must get some result after playing with the tool for a short period of time or just give it up as 'too difficult.'

From a technical standpoint the book is very readable, but it doesn't tackle any one subject in great depth. It certainly provides enough information to get you up and running, and also, perhaps more valuably, illustrates how to integrate the tools together. It's an excellent primer for those who want to use the tools but are unsure of how exactly to start.

What's covered? Here are the chapter headings:

1. Introduction and Key Concepts
   1. Introduction to Extreme Programming
   2. J2EE Deployment Concepts
   3. Example applications
2. Mastering the Tools
   1. Continuous integration with Ant
   2. Building Java Applications with Ant
   3. Building J2EE applications with Ant
   4. Unit testing with JUnit
   5. Testing Container Services with Cactus
   6. Functional Testing with HttpUnit
   7. Measuring Application Performance with JMeter
   8. Load Testing with JUnitPerf
3. API and Tag Reference
   1. Ant Tag Reference
   2. Ant API Reference
   3. JUnit API Reference
   4. Cactus API Reference
   5. HttpUnit API Reference

If you use some of these tools already will you learn anything? Probably -- I personally have been using JUnit to test EJBs for almost nine months now but didn't know about JUnitPerf or Cactus.

Should you buy it? If you're new to the tools, then Yes. If you work in a professional but traditional IT shop, I'd buy one for the group (I have). It'd be particularly useful when dealing with management and proposing changes to working processes, or when trying to bring co-workers up to speed and sell them the benefits of agile ways of working.

You can visit the book's website at Wiley. You can purchase the Jave Tools For Extreme Programming from bn.com. Want to see your own review here? Just read the book review guidelines, then use Slashdot's handy submission form.