Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

DVD-R/W In Unix?

Posted by Cliff on from the next-generation-CDR dept.

Vilorman asks: "So has anyone been successful at writing DVD's in Unix? At work, we're primarily a Solaris shop and we just got an IDE CD-RW working but it's a little small. We need to archive a four gig filesystem and DVD sounds like the way to go. I do have a few concerns: how well does Solaris or Linux supoort the DVD media; and what type of drive works best under either OS (IDE, SCSI, Firewire, etc)? I've found IDE and FireWire drives but SCSI DVR-R/W still seems to be a little scarce. One would assume (from looking at the code) that Schilly's CD-Record and mkisofs would get the job done with a DVD, right?"

25 comments

  1. The new iMac by TTop · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    The new iMac will do it, and it's running a BSD-derived Unix. For that matter, it makes it easy. Without all the mkisofs stuff.

    Apple just seems to be getting cooler all the time, I never owned a Mac until OSX tempted me into an iBook.

    1. Re:The new iMac by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      I'm sure this guy will be changing over from Solaris servers to Imacs...

    2. Re:The new iMac by foobar104 · · Score: 2, Flamebait

      I'm sure this guy will be changing over from Solaris servers to Imacs...

      Maybe you were trying to be facetious or funny or something, but you just ended up looking dumb.

      Take an iMac with OS X. Mount your server's filesystem via NFS. Dump the filesystem to DVD with the OS X disk utility. What's the problem?

      If you don't want to back up a live filesystem, then drop to single user and do a dump, then burn the dump to DVD.

      Either way, it's a hell of a lot easier to do stuff like that with OS X than it is with Windows (Unix interoperability not included) or Linux (DVD burning not included).

  2. Yes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    Microlite supports DVD-RAM on Linux. If you want to spend a lot of money, Lineo has a pricey product.

    Of course, with the new Linux kernel there is native DVD-RAM support. I can't swear to Solaris but, I'm pretty sure it's in there too. Use IDE, it's cheaper, more readily available and just as fast.

    1. Re:Yes by SuzanneA · · Score: 1
      Dunno where you're getting that you need special support from, I've been using a Hitachi (scsi) DVD-RAM on linux for over a year. It appears as 'scd1' which linux can handle just fine, I tend to avoid using UFS because it feels slower than just writing ext2/ext3 partitions to the drive.

      DVD-R shouldn't need anything special, cdrecord claims to support DVD-R drives, and correctly recognises my DVD-RAM as a DVD-RAM drive - even though I don't use cdrecord, but just treat the DVD-RAM as 'any other block device'. for writing DVD's you'll need some tool to make a UFS image, of course, or you could use mkisofs (most DVD players will play DVDs on ISO disks).

    2. Re:Yes by Jamie+Zawinski · · Score: 2

      DVD-R shouldn't need anything special, cdrecord claims to support DVD-R drives

      I see a lot of people saying ``it should work'' or ``I read in this README that it should work'' but I haven't seen anyone standing up and saying, ``YES, by God, I have successfully burned a DVD-R on Linux.''

      Because I've been searching for someone saying that for a few years now, I still believe that it has not been done, and is not possible.

      Prove me wrong, please.

  3. Here by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Informative

    Google you schmuck!

  4. Re:?_? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Are you licking yourself again Howard?

  5. cdrecord and linux UDF by MonMotha · · Score: 1

    I'm not familiar with solaris, but I know schilly cdrecord claims to work on DVD media (right on the front page), and linux has UDF support (the filesystem used on most DVDs, though ISO9660 is used too). However, like a CD, you can put any filesystem you want on it as long as the OS can read it.

    --MonMotha

  6. scsi-ide by NotoriousQ · · Score: 1

    I believe that linux cdrecord has to run over scsi-ide, so make sure to use the scsi-ide module.

    The following are some relevant docs:

    cdrecord They mention something about dvd-r, so it seems that cdrecord can record dvds. They say it works on most unices.

    The frontend i use

    http://www.linuxdoc.org/HOWTO/CD-Writing-HOWTO.htm l
    and the obligatory HOWTO.

    Hope that helps

    --
    badness 10000
    1. Re:scsi-ide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's assuming he's going to be using an ide device, and from what he's said, it doesn't sound like it.

  7. easy by qurob · · Score: 2, Informative



    DVD+RW on Linux

  8. "It depends." by willfe · · Score: 4, Informative

    Ah, yes, that old favorite answer. Unfortunately, it's true in this case.

    Some points of note:

    • Out-of-the-box cdrecord does not write DVD-R(W) discs. You have to pay for the author's "cdrecord-prodvd" release or apply the free patches I found at http://www.abcpages.com/~mache/cdrecord-dvd.html.
    • While DVD-RAM fares better than DVD-RW in Linux (DVD-RAM doesn't need that damned packet writing stuff that the gang at http://packet-cd.sourceforge.net/ haven't updated since 2.4.7-ish), it still has plenty of problems. If you hit a media error, kiss your session goodbye and prepare to reboot. And despite much marketing efforts to the contrary, DVD-RAM discs aren't readable by anything I've been able to throw them at.
    • Whether you're using the "official" DVD version of cdrecord (the test version, at least, limited to -dummy mode or 1GB images) or the one based on the free patch, if you hand the Pioneer DVD-A03 "cheap" DVD-RW media, it always seems to give up. Sadly, Nero Burning ROM in 'doze writes to the same pieces of media just fine. This stings to admit, since I'm quite the Linux junkie :)
    • You can forget about packet writing if you're using a DVD-RW drive, unless someone out there has updates (or something better to use) than the packet-cd project at Sourceforge. The patches there won't even apply to kernels newer than 2.4.12 (according to the mailing list), and even then it's still unfriendly and unreliable.

    I would love it if someone could disprove any of the above; I have a QPS (Que!) external Firewire drive (the Pioneer DVD-A03 stuffed into a firewire enclosure) that I really wish was more reliable in Linux than it is right now. Packet writing would be lovely. As it stands now, I can write DVD-Rs okay with the free patched cdrecord, but the only DVD-RW media that's writable in Linux seems to be the one that shipped with the drive. Nothing else has worked :(

    --
    Read my stuff.
    1. Re:"It depends." by willfe · · Score: 1

      I stand partially corrected. I dug around some more and found a patch for 2.4.17 to add packet writing. Nevermind that it doesn't work :) But hey, at least patches exist:

      http://w1.894.telia.com/~u89404340/patches/packet/ keeps all the more current patches available.
      --
      Read my stuff.
  9. Why not tape? by scheme · · Score: 3, Insightful

    A DLT or DDS tape drive will give you on the order of 2-40 GB per tape depending on the format you use, comes in scsi version, and is well supported under solaris and linux. You can get a decent 15/30GB DLT drive on ebay for about $100. With DLT drives, the media will cost about the same as a blank DVD, you'll get more storage capacity, better support and the option to upgrade to autoloading tape drives if your backup needs grow beyond the capacity of a single tape. Plus some of the newer tape drives will let you boot from tape and begin a restore automatically.

    --
    "When you sit with a nice girl for two hours, it seems like two minutes. When you sit on a hot stove for two minutes, it
  10. Throughput by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    You forgot to mention that the throughput to such a tape drive is going to be several orders of magnitude faster than any DVD solution.

    1. Re:Throughput by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      An order of magnitude is an exponential growth, retard.
      hardly an order of magnitude

      possibly several times faster.

  11. DVD-RAM works fine for me (as a filesystem) by joe_n_bloe · · Score: 1

    I have a 4.7/9.2 GB SCSI DVD-RAM that works fine as a plain old filesystem ... /dev/scd0 mounts rw on /mnt/dvdram as an ext2.

    (Last time I checked, mkreiserfs refused to make a filesystem on this device. Wonder why? Haven't tried under 2.4.17 though.)

    I am using 2.4.17. There have been a number of DVD patches to 2.4 so use the latest version. On an earlier kernel, for example, the reported media size was off by a factor of two. :-)

    I use it for backup and storage mostly. No idea about whether it has any utility for writing something a DVD reader can use. The cost of the media is coming down. $20-25 a pop for the 9.4 GB (double-sided) media if you look around. I'm happy with it! Beats the heck out of tape if what you want to save will fit on a 4.7 GB side.

    Joseph N. Hall

  12. unfortunately by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    DVD-RW and DVD+RW are not, actually, the same thing. They're different, incompatible standards.

  13. Working DVD-RAM by Pooh · · Score: 1

    We just got a RS/6000 @Series, 6 CPUs and 8G of RAM, it come by default with a DVD-RAM, which actually work under AIX with a IBM proprietary software.

    You too, could get a DVD-RAM writer for 100 000$!

  14. What is ProDVD? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Would someone clearly explain what Schilly's "ProDVD" is? From looking at his site, it looks like a prototype for DVD-burning which will eventually be folded into the cdrtools package. I see no clear mention of it being payware.