Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Canadian Privacy Commissioner Addresses 'Lawful Access'

Posted by michael on from the prying-eyes dept.

EvilAlien writes "The Privacy Commissioner of Canada has commented on the federal Government's Lawful Access proposal calling the proposed legislation "a grave, needless and unjustifiable deterioration of privacy rights in our country". Canadian news sources have covered the comments, bringing the issue to the forefront of public awareness. For discussion on the Lawful Access Consultation, see the earlier Slashdot story in YRO."

22 comments

  1. america doesn't care about canada by joe094287523459087 · · Score: 2

    no U.S. news source will mention this at all, just like no U.S. news source mentioned the softwood logging tariff or the canadian who went to a U.S. jail for a month for crossing the border into U.S. by 10 feet at a U.S. gas station with a gun in his car.

    1. Re:america doesn't care about canada by Embedded+Geek · · Score: 4, Interesting
      I think your title is a little harsh, but your point is otherwise disturbingly accurate. I'm an (US) American but have glanced at a map of North America once or twice in my day. I find it interesting that our president (no, I didn't vote for him) keeps talking about the UK as "our most important friend" when in fact the countries that meet that description are to our north and south. Nothing against the UK, but if Canada had the SAS or Mexico had a few aircraft carriers floating off the coast of Iraq, maybe the current administration's short attention span would be piqued.

      Of course, one of the sad proofs of your post is the location of this whole story - buried under the YRO topic and not on /.'s font page.

      --

      "Prepare for the worst - hope for the best."

    2. Re:america doesn't care about canada by sdjunky · · Score: 3, Interesting

      "...just like no U.S. news source mentioned the softwood logging tariff..."

      You mean like this?

      I understand that that is old news but we do get some Canadian related material even if it is few and far between.

      However, I must agree that Americans can be extremely US centric in their news. I see quite a bit of world wide information in news.bbc.co.uk but nothing like that on CNN. However, I must say that we have news that doesn't quite make the limelight that is US based that I feel should so it's not just Canadian news that is pretty much ignored.

    3. Re:america doesn't care about canada by Alsee · · Score: 2

      However, I must agree that Americans can be extremely US centric in their news.

      Yeah, people keep mentioning that, but there's a pretty good reason. If the states hadn't united they would comprise a signifigant chunk of international news. A single US state is often comparable to an entire country.

      Canada population 31.9 Million ~ California population 33.9 Million

      Australia 19.5 ~ New York 19

      England 49.1 ~ Texas 20.9 + Florida 16 + Pennsylvania 12.3 = 49.2

      France 59.7 ~ Illinois 12.4 + Ohio 11.4 + Michigan 9.9 + Massachusetts 6.3 + Washington 5.9 + Missouri 5.6 + Wisconsin 5.4 + Maryland 5.3 = 62.2

      Netherlands 16 ~ Georgia 8.2 + North Carolina 8 = 16.2

      Norway 4.5 ~ Maryland 5.3

      Sweden 8.8 ~ New Jersey 8.4

      Switzerland 7.2 ~ Virginia 7.1

      Denmark 5.3 ~ Tennessee 5.7

      Isreal 6 ~ Indiana 6.1

      Then there's THIRTY MORE STATES with another 68 million, plus Puerto Rico 3.8 million, Washington DC, and some minor territories. You can match the left over population up against either Germany or a slew of small countries.

      -

      --
      - - You can't take something off the Internet! That's like trying to take pee out of a swimming pool.
    4. Re:america doesn't care about canada by ShwAsasin · · Score: 1

      Actually Canada has an elite military wing called JTF2. It replaced our Airborne unit which had some issues in Somalia (too trigger / knife / beating happy). There is only one known image of them in their gear and next to nothing information wise about their operations in Afhganistan.

    5. Re:america doesn't care about canada by Embedded+Geek · · Score: 2
      I stand corrected. I do recall hearing about the Somalia issue in the news. I am glad there's been some reform, although the very secrecy of their replacement unit (while understandable) makes me wonder.

      You sound like a reasonable poster, but I feel compelled to add the following for anyone who might have taken my post the wrong way: I had no intention of slighting the Canadian armed forces. Nor the Mexican Navy, for that matter. I had merely used the SAS as an example because of their reputation as a counter terrorist unit, not just as a commando unit.

      And for those who are going to take my clarification the wrong way: I steadfastly refuse to get into a debate about the SAS'es historical role in Northern Ireland and the "terrorist" vs. "freedom fighter" semantics.

      --

      "Prepare for the worst - hope for the best."

    6. Re:america doesn't care about canada by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      A single US state is often comparable to an entire country.

      By that logic, all of your news should be in Chinese...

      :)
    7. Re:america doesn't care about canada by Alsee · · Score: 2

      By that logic, all of your news should be in Chinese... :)

      A point worth considering.

      I'd say one of the primary reasons it isn't is that China is very isolationist. Little news goes in or out. A lesser contributing factor is that China is on average far less developed than any of the other contries I listed.

      -

      --
      - - You can't take something off the Internet! That's like trying to take pee out of a swimming pool.
  2. I am American, and I care about Canada by TamMan2000 · · Score: 5, Funny

    I am an able-bodied 24 year old. I need to have someplace to go so I don't get drafted!

    Bush is a war-mongering buffoon

    --
    "I'll have a Guinness, no wait, make that a Coors Light" -Grad student I work with, who shall remain anonymous...
    1. Re:I am American, and I care about Canada by optikSmoke · · Score: 1
      Bush is a war-mongering buffoon

      Or, in the words of a senior aid to Prime Minister Chretien (of Canada, in case you didn't know :)), he's a "moron."

      Not that I would be surprised if that didn't make American news. She slipped and said what everyone else was thinking, too much of that could be dangerous :)

  3. Very OT: LOL by Embedded+Geek · · Score: 1
    It would figure you'd post this five minutes after I ran out of mod points. I haven't modded a "Funny" this week.

    Nice one. :)

    --

    "Prepare for the worst - hope for the best."

  4. Go Figure by chriso11 · · Score: 2

    Of course, you need to remember the mantra "Blame Canada".

    So Canada does a lot of things right such as Universal Health Care (cue libertarian nuts to reply with 500 posts knocking it), and they seem to have a clue regarding the internet.

    I've visited Canada several times, and it seems like a metric version of the U.S. without as many assholes (or stupid presidents). Of course, I never visited Quebec, so I may be naive on that point.

    --
    No, I don't trust in god. He'll have to pay up front, like everybody else.
    1. Re:Go Figure by still+cynical · · Score: 1

      Universal Health Care? Ask a few Canadians about that. Then compare the number of Americans going to Canada for medical treatment with the number of Canadians headed south.

      Government-sponsored health care may work in principle, but the Canadian model is NOT the way to go about it.

      --
      Ignorance is the root of all evil.
    2. Re:Go Figure by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am a Canadian and I like it just fine thank you very much. It doesn't cost me $80,000 to have surgery and the quality of the work is at par with the rest of the world.

  5. This is the worse story ever by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    All replies are off topic or trolls.

    I'm not about to help /. out here.

    First Post.

    Troll Out.

  6. At least someone is watching... by Chemical+Serenity · · Score: 1

    For all his relative ineffectiveness in actually stopping such ugly legislation, it's a good thing that we have a privacy advocate watching out for this sort of chicanery.

    It's given me the heads up, and I plan on spreading the word to interested parties around town (universities and the like). Maybe I'll drop in on my MP/MLA and have a brief chat with why this bill would be A Bad Thing For Canadians(tm).

    --
    "People will pay big bucks for the luxury of ignorance."
  7. W00T! by Reece400 · · Score: 1

    Well, this is definatly gotta piss the americans off,, they pretty much passed a bunch of bills to do just the opposite in their country, didn't they? on the bad side,, they're never gonna shut up about how we're "harbouring terrorists" just because we believe in true freedom...

    all i can say is, W00T W00T! Go Canada!

    Reece ;)

  8. It's about time. by Trane+Francks · · Score: 1

    It's nice to see that there is the potential here for some good to be done. As I'm Canadian, I really want to see the government there do something right.

    trane

    --
    ...a FreeDOS contributor: http://www.freedos.org/
  9. This is coming from a GOVERNMENT agency by debest · · Score: 2

    The Privacy Commission is an independant body of the Canadian government. Its existance, and its stance, gives me as a Canadian at least a bit of comfort that there is someone with influence who is looking out for some of my rights.

    My question is regarding the USA. Is there an equivalent body in the American government? Is anyone "official" (read: not like lobbying bodies such as ACLU, EFF, etc.) looking out for the US citizenry's privacy rights? If so, have they been muzzled during the last 15 months?

    --
    Look at the tomato! Isn't it sad? He can't dance! Poor tomato!
  10. Switch by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Switch!

    http://bantha.cjb.net/john/video.php?type=mov

  11. For more info, including extra-national sources... by EvilAlien · · Score: 2
    ... see Lex Informatica's Cybercrime page.

    Other than that, do people in the US really care as little as they appear to about what is happening in Canada? I know we're not even a terribly significant trading partner, but we share a border dammit =)

    --
    perl -e 'print $i=pack(c5, (41*2), sqrt(7056), (unpack(c,H)-2), oct(115), 10)'