Slashdot Mirror


World's Oldest Tree To Be Cloned

Pirogoeth writes "Scientists have taken seedlings from the world's oldest tree, a 4,768-year-old bristlecone pine named Methuselah, and plan on plan on altering them to make them clones of the ancient tree. Their goal is to study them to find the secret of their longevity and to see if cloned trees can survive in different climates."

55 comments

  1. Maybe not the oldest... by fingal · · Score: 3, Informative

    Not confirmed but maybe the Fortingall Yew may well be older. Well worth a visit as it is in a very beautiful part of the country...

    --

    The only Good System is a Sound System

    1. Re:Maybe not the oldest... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not only is it not confirmed, but it is merely imagined!

    2. Re:Maybe not the oldest... by shfted! · · Score: 1

      It's 404ing now. Sigh.

      --
      He who laughs last is stuck in a time dilation bubble.
    3. Re:Maybe not the oldest... by fingal · · Score: 2, Informative
      Ho hum. slashcode doesn't really seem to like URLs with spaces in them and is closing them up. such is life. If anyone is really interested in the Fortingall Yew, then do this:-
      • go to the home page
      • click on big tree map in LHS menu
      • click on FORTINGALL YEW (second from bottom on extreme LHS legends on map).
      --

      The only Good System is a Sound System

    4. Re:Maybe not the oldest... by srvivn21 · · Score: 1

      http://www.perthshirebigtreecountry.co.uk/Bigtree Fortingall.htm Or just use %20 instead of a space...

      Thanks for the original link, and the instructions on how to get to the desination.

      BTW, RFC2616 (HTTP/1.1) recomends the striping of white space from URLs. Not that it is often followed.

    5. Re:Maybe not the oldest... by tommck · · Score: 1
      That sight sucks... You can't even see the tree!

      T

      --
      ---- It puts the lotion on its skin or else it gets the hose again. It does this whenever it's told.
  2. As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrough by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    Memo to all y'all city folk out there in /. land: People have been cloning plants since time immemorial.

    You cut off a little piece of the branch, plop it in some potting soil, keep it wet, and in a coupla months, la voila: It's sprouted a root system!!!

    Just about 100% of all commercial plant offerings are clones [possibly grafted onto a foreign root system, which is itself likely a clone].

  3. Aaaahhhh!!!! by gooru · · Score: 2, Funny

    Oh no, it's the invasion of the cloned trees!!!!!!! Run for your lives!!!!!!

    1. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by Black+Parrot · · Score: 1, Funny


      > Oh no, it's the invasion of the cloned trees!!!!!!! Run for your lives!!!!!!

      Gee, I wish I could think of a Standard Slashdot Joke to post in reply to that one.

      --
      Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
    2. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by The+Mayor · · Score: 2, Funny

      OK. I know I'll burn karma with this one, but how about:

      Imagine a Beowulf cluster of these!

      --
      --Be human.
    3. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by ghost. · · Score: 3, Funny

      Well I for one welcome our new wooden overlords.

      --
      Bush is a cylon.
    4. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by Smidge204 · · Score: 1

      I, for one, welcome our new cloned botanical overloards...

      =Smidge=

    5. Re:Aaaahhhh!!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      No kidding. Why does this story say, "altering them to make them clones", when it's just a standard grafting technique? I know it's a clone, but every granny smith apple you've ever eaten has been done this way. Big Whup!

      Ok, I guess it wouldn't be Slashdot without overblown write ups.

    6. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by gooru · · Score: 1

      Save the human race! Man your axes!

    7. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by Jonsey · · Score: 3, Funny

      Fine...

      In Soviet Russia Trees run from yew!

      I hate myself sometimes.

      --
      I assert that my comment is only my opinion, not that of any employer, past, present or future.
    8. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by kimota · · Score: 1

      >Gee, I wish I could think of a Standard Slashdot Joke to >post in reply to that one.

      I for one welcome our Standard Slashdot joke overlords!

      --Kimota!

      --
      Who moderates the meta-moderators?
    9. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by hondo77 · · Score: 1
      1. Old tree.
      2. Clone.
      3. Profit!
      --
      I live ze unknown. I love ze unknown. I am ze unknown.
    10. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A Standard Slashdot meta Standard Slashdot joke!!

      LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO!!!L!!!111!!1one!!!

    11. Re: Aaaahhhh!!!! by Alsee · · Score: 1

      I think the correct term is "Beowulf grove".

      -

      --
      - - You can't take something off the Internet! That's like trying to take pee out of a swimming pool.
  4. i seem to remeber them finding a creosote shrub by Unknown+Poltroon · · Score: 1

    or something thats even older. BUt this is probably the oldest actual tree. ALthough i thought they found one in england that was older?

    --
    All Troll + "offtopic" mods are meta moderated as "Unfair", because you abused the system.
    1. Re:i seem to remeber them finding a creosote shrub by Black+Parrot · · Score: 3, Informative


      > or something thats even older. BUt this is probably the oldest actual tree.

      IMO reckoning up the age of a creosote ring is a dubious comparison, due to its clonal propagation. An analogous argument would say that microbes that "reproduce" by splitting are billions of years old, which might be true in some sense but not very interesting for comparing the "age" of a microbe to the age of a tree.

      > Although i thought they found one in england that was older?

      I vaguely recall hearing about a much older plant as well, though I can never seem to find the story when the subject comes up.

      Given human nature, there's probably a lot of nationalistic spin on who has the oldest plant, so I always take "the world's oldest plant" to mean "the oldest one that has a good PR firm in my culture".

      --
      Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
  5. Excellent. by mikelu · · Score: 3, Funny

    Now I can attain immortality through the simple process of replacing my feeble human body with enduring tree parts. Mwahahahahahahahaha.

    1. Re:Excellent. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can see the ad campaign now:
      "Got Wood?"

    2. Re:Excellent. by gl4ss · · Score: 1

      you'll be burned at the stake!!

      everybody knows robots will be the future!!

      and besides, when you're a robot you still look the same.. but they only make them 5 feet tall.

      x-ray vision is a plus though.

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
  6. Picky, picky, picky by RobertB-DC · · Score: 1

    Scientists have taken seedlings from the world's oldest tree, a 4,768-year-old bristlecone pine named Methuselah, and plan on plan on altering them to make them clones

    Looks like they've already gotten off to a good start, by cloning the words in the article. *rimshot*

    (Isn't anyone going to welcome our new Bristlecone masters?)

    --
    Stressed? Me? Of course not. Stress is what a rubber band feels before it breaks, silly.
    1. Re:Picky, picky, picky by I+Like+Swords!!! · · Score: 1, Funny

      Well, I for one WELCOME our new Bristlecone overlords!

      There... I said it. Couldn't just LEAF it alone.. could you? Satisfied?

      --
      .unsigged
  7. I cloned an ivy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    by taking a cutting and planting it.

    This article isn't much in the way of science news.

    But really, is there any zygote-modifying plant cloning (i.e like they do with animals) going on anywhere? Please provide links.

  8. Re:As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrou by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Too bad you can't do that with humans. You know, like chop off a leg, plant it in the ground and watch it sprout into a replica of the original...

  9. Act 1, Scene 1 by Jonsey · · Score: 1, Funny

    [ scientist in forest ]

    [ bumbling around ]

    [ See REALLY LARGE tree ]

    [ Takes Sample ]

    [ Ents Crush Him, after much deliberation ]

    Fini.

    --
    I assert that my comment is only my opinion, not that of any employer, past, present or future.
  10. Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by RobertB-DC · · Score: 5, Interesting

    In 1989, a vandal used a strong poison and nearly killed the Treaty Oak, a 500-year-old Live Oak said to be the place where Stephen F. Austin signed a treaty with the local Native American tribes. Heroic efforts (funded by H. Ross Perot) went into saving the tree, but nobody knew if they would be successful.

    To preserve the tree's legacy, it was "cloned" -- several still-living branches were rooted just as the parent poster described. One of these trees is now growing next to the original. It's clearly an exact genetic duplicate, and if that's not a clone, I don't now what is.

    I agree with the parent poster -- what's the big deal? Why can't they just cut off a branch of the Methuselah tree and root it?

    By the way, the story of the Treaty Oak has a happy ending. Despite fears that it would only be good for commemorative pen sets, the tree made a comeback, and started bearing acorns again in 1997 -- 8 years after the attack. Seedlings are now available, for "just" $125 bucks.

    The poisoner, on the other hand, likely had a bit rougher time -- 9 years in a Texas state prison. No word on the fate of his acorns...

    --
    Stressed? Me? Of course not. Stress is what a rubber band feels before it breaks, silly.
    1. Re:Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by Alsee · · Score: 1

      The poisoner, on the other hand, likely had a bit rougher time -- 9 years in a Texas state prison.

      Sigh.

      Yeah, it's a famous tree, but it's still just a freaking TREE. He'd probably have gotten a shorter term for raping and (attempted) poisoning grandma.

      Well, at least he didn't commit copyright infringment. Then his acorns would be in BIG trouble.

      -

      --
      - - You can't take something off the Internet! That's like trying to take pee out of a swimming pool.
    2. Re:Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by pohl · · Score: 1

      What if the vandal burned one of the original copies of the Constitution? Would that be punishable in your view? Just a part of some old plant with some marks on it, after all...

      --

      The "cue the foo posts in 3, 2, 1..." posts will commence with no subsequent foo posts in 3, 2, 1...

    3. Re:Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I agree with the parent poster -- what's the big deal? Why can't they just cut off a branch of the Methuselah tree and root it?
      You should be ashamed. The article is a few paragraphs, and you wouldn't be asking this question if you had read it.

      Moderators who moderated you up should have their testicles stripped by metamoderators for judging the posts without reading the article.

      Slashdot is as dumb as we want it to be. Not, I'm not new here.

    4. Re:Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by Alsee · · Score: 1

      Would that be punishable in your view?

      Hold on a second. Where did I say he shouldn't be punished? I just commented that the sentence was a bit absurd. 9 years for "attempted treeicide"?

      -

      --
      - - You can't take something off the Internet! That's like trying to take pee out of a swimming pool.
    5. Re:Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by pohl · · Score: 1

      What sentence would you recommend in the hypothetical case I proposed?

      --

      The "cue the foo posts in 3, 2, 1..." posts will commence with no subsequent foo posts in 3, 2, 1...

    6. Re:Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by RobertB-DC · · Score: 1

      You should be ashamed.
      What, did I wet the bed?

      The article is a few paragraphs, and you wouldn't be asking this question if you had read it.

      I did RT[f]A, and I can't find the answer to my question in those few paragraphs. I suspect I'm missing something... but what? Could you please elaborate?

      Oh, you're AC... you'll never even *see* this message, much less reply to it. So much for doing something about "dumb as we want it to be."

      --
      Stressed? Me? Of course not. Stress is what a rubber band feels before it breaks, silly.
    7. Re:Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by RobertB-DC · · Score: 1

      What sentence would you recommend in the hypothetical case I proposed?

      I'm no fan of punishing tree-abusers more strongly than people-abusers. In fact, it really gets me mad when someone gets probation or a light sentence for killing with a car (especially if they're a football player), but someone gets thrown in jail for putting an ostrich to sleep the old-fashioned way.

      But as far as determining an "appropriate" sentence... please keep in mind that this happened here in Texas, where justice can be a bit capricious. Heck, if Toby Keith had his way, he's be strung up from the remaining branches of the tall oak tree... for all the people to see...

      I think the guy probably considers himself lucky.

      --
      Stressed? Me? Of course not. Stress is what a rubber band feels before it breaks, silly.
    8. Re:Austin (TX) Treaty Oak by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...and here I thought Steve Austin was a bionic ex-astronaut...

  11. Re:As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrou by geek42 · · Score: 1

    You seem to imply that the article is uninteresting because of the methods used. The interesting part is that they're reproducing a bloody old tree. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it'll be the oldest thing ever to be 'cloned'. This is interesting, even if it is easy to do, because it'll allow all kinds of experiments that you wouldn't want to carry out on the original.

  12. is it really that hard by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The story contains just over 50 words. Is it really that hard to edit out the repeating words in the middle of the post?

    "plan on plan on"

  13. As per the article (aka RTFA) by phorm · · Score: 1

    to study and eventually clone the world's great trees.

    So they are planning to clone 'em. The initial seedlings aren't considered full clones because...

    The seedlings aren't exact copies of Methuselah...they only contain half of the gnarled old tree's genetic materials.

    So they add more DNA to complete the process:

    the Milarchs plan to graft them with more genetic material taken from Methuselah

    I think that parts from the branch or cones would be considered offspring of the parent - it's the extra DNA splicing that makes it a clone.

  14. Which tree? by ChopSocky · · Score: 1

    A binary search tree or a red-black tree? Seriously, I "clone" these all the time.

    --

    "Joan of Arc, up top!" - Ghandi, Clone High
  15. Re:As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrou by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    It's called propagation, typically through cuttings.

    Many ornamental plants are done this way.

    Specifically, all of those pretty Christmas Poinsettias are froma single mother plant.

    They find the one plant that exhibits the characteristics they like, take cuttings, make more plants, make more cuttings, etc, etc, etc.

    Most everything you see in the Garden Center at your local Home Depot are made this way.

  16. Re:As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrou by eastsidephil · · Score: 1

    The bristelocones grow at a high elevation (10,000 ft +) in dry, alkali soil. I'm not sure that traditional cloning techniques for trees will work for this variety of tree.

  17. Yes, they have been cloning trees forever it seems by bigmoosie · · Score: 0

    But, Thats not the point of the article. They wan t to see what the clones will do in different environments. How well do they survive, what kinds of deformities they will grow. And maybe even the secret to why this tree is so old. Maybe someday we'll all have huge trees like this one to cut up into 2x4's :-D just think about how many 2x4's are already in a 4K year old tree :-D ~ryan

  18. Re:As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrou by Scaba · · Score: 1

    You must be doing something wrong, 'cause I cloned my hobo army this way.

  19. Re:As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrou by John+Hasler · · Score: 1

    > Memo to all y'all city folk out there in /. land:
    > People have been cloning plants since time
    > immemorial.

    Memo to those who know less than everything about botany: traditional methods don't work on all plants.

    --
    Warning: this article may contain humor, sarcasm, parody, and perhaps even irony. Read at your own risk.
  20. Tree, bush, shrub by bananahammock · · Score: 1, Informative

    I guess not technically called trees (then again bonsais, which tend to be pretty small, low to the ground, are really a tree/shrub grown in a pot), however here are a couple articles concerning organisms (read shrub or bush) which may be older than the Methuselah.

    http://www.death-valley.us/article652.html

    http://www.exn.ca/Stories/1996/10/21/01.asp

  21. oldest plant? by mcryptic · · Score: 2, Informative

    a quick google came up with a 43,000 year old plant (Tasmanian native holly), which has already been cloned in order to save it.

    http://forests.org/archive/spacific/ausoldpl.htm

  22. Re:As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrou by veritasr · · Score: 1

    Most flowering wisteria you see were grown from cuttings as well. If you grow one from seed, you have to wait ten years to see whether you bought one that blooms.

  23. Script kiddy pun by Fuzzy+Bo · · Score: 1

    Where can I get a root kit for *that* system?

  24. Is it a clone? by MoobY · · Score: 1

    Hehe, there's something in the article I don't really get. Only half of the seedlings' genes were inherited from the great pine, whereas the other half came from another pine. That's like how I was made. Half of my genes are my mother's and the other half come from my dad. And I'm not a clone.

    These guys have simply grew plants from the seeds of the great pine, just as the pine would have reproduced in nature, so I don't really see the point of the whole thing, and I can't figure out why anybody feels like putting a label "cloning" on this story.

    --
    --- Sigmentation Fault - Comments Dumped
  25. Re:As if cloning a plant is any kind of breakthrou by Mensurationist · · Score: 1

    Unfortunately, this is not true. It works for only a limited number of species. Take some salix, for example, and shove it in the ground ... bingo. New salix. Try it with your average Pinus, though, and all you'll get is stakes.

  26. There is only one way to figure that age... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    for sure. Chop the tree down and count the rings.