Ask Slashdot: Rugged E-book Reader?
First time accepted submitter Augury writes "I'm about to undertake a lengthy trip involving travel through dusty, damp and drop-inducing environments. When it comes to packing for such a trip, reading is a fundamental need, to help while away the inevitable hours spent in transit lounges, at bus stops and on beaches. The weight and bulk of the dead tree approach makes it impractical, so an e-book reader seems ideal — does anyone have any experience with ruggedising an e-book reader for such conditions?"
If you get a proper hard case, and a waterproof bag (there are plenty out there intended for tablets, ebook readers and the like), then you can probably choose any ereader, while being protected against impact while travelling, and dirt/moisture when using it on the beach.
I've had a couple of Kindle screens die on me simply from being bent slightly while in my rucksack to/from work. They were in a case too, but it wasn't the sturdiest of cases. I have a 10" tablet anyway, so now I use that for reading when I travel. Obviously the battery life is nowhere near as good, but it's fine if you're able to recharge every day or two.
which is totally what she said
I have used this on kayaking trips
http://www.rei.com/product/833250/seattle-sports-dry-doc-kindle-case
It is cheap and does the job
There's so much to do at Burning Man. Don't read a book, go volunteer at the post office or get into some crazy shit.
Oh shit! I forgot to click "Post Anonymously"...
Buy Kindle. Get a hard cover for it. It flips open and closes with a strap.
Oh, and learn not to drop it.
Just pack the kindle, kobo or whatever with your camera gear in a hard case.
Seems like something like this or this is what you're after. These cases are generic, so most ebook readers will fit in them. I guess you'd still need to be a bit careful dropping them, but from the post it seems like you want the device to be protected from moisture/dust/sand rather than rough handling.
I loved my Amazon Kindle. For about 3 weeks, after which it broke. It wasn't abused; I just wasn't willing to spend another 30% of the purchase price for a cover. I replaced it with a smartphone and haven't missed the Kindle since.
away the inevitable hours spent in transit lounges, at bus stops and on beaches. The weight and bulk of the dead tree approach makes it impractical, so an e-book reader seems ideal
Don't forget to pack a lead acid battery or a crank alternator... just in case the inevitable hours are longer than expected. You know... "anything that can possibly go wrong, does".
Some of these readers are becoming cheap enough that unless you are doing things that are sure to destroy it, it's not worth spending a lot of money ruggedizing it. Get a $99 Nook and a $20 case for it and call it good enough. It will survive rips to the beach unless you throw it into the water.
I took my Nook Color with me to annual training at Camp Shelby with the National Guard. It rolled around in the back of a humvee for a week and a half and was fine. There was some pretty intense rain for a couple of days, too. With a case from Wal-Mart I didn't have any problems. Obviously, I wasn't standing out in the rain trying to read a book, so I'm not going to claim it's waterproof, but being a little damp didn't seem to faze it.
http://www.otterbox.com/Amazon-Kindle-Fire-Defender-Series-Case/AMZ2-FIRE1,default,pd.html
Sorry, but gray text on gray background is making my eyes bleed.
I think it would likely be easier to find a ruggedized case for a popular cell phone than an eReader, and then you could load the eReader app of all the popular sites onto it. (Amazon, B&N, and Kobo all have Smartphone apps that work with their services)
I'm actually quite fond of reading on my cell phone. I carry it with me everywhere anyway, so any time I have a few seconds to read, I've got it out with a book open.
Thomas A. Knight
Author of The Time Weaver
does anyone have any experience with ruggedising an e-book reader for such conditions?
There is no ereader that meets those criteria.
And if there were, you'd be paying over $1,000
So, I say, get your $99 ereader, use it until it breaks, and then get a new one - B&N allows for backups on a PC.
Let's face it, we live in a disposable world.
I wouldn't worry too much. I have a plain pleather case for my Kindle ($10), and I'm never particularly kind to it. In fact, I left it on the top of my car, and had it fly off at about 40 km/h. It survived intact and unharmed.
I'd worry more about how convenient the case is. If you're going to have to dig through a Pelican briefcase to get to your Kindle, you're never going to read it--and it's going to weigh a ton.
I use a ziploc bag to read on the beach. Simple, cheap and efficient.
Personally, I'd only take a smartphone with a protective case. I really enjoy reading books on the kindle app for iPhone and Andriod. This saves you the trouble of caring around yet another unnecessary bit of hardware. Virtually all phones have cases you can get that ruggedize them.
Advantages:
* Cheap (dispensable), $90 on eBay as a refurb. If anything happens you just take your microSD out and put it into a replacement.
* Rubberized case is easy to hold with one hand
* Lots of case options (neoprene, hard front to protect the screen, etc)
* Next/Back buttons are part of the skin, not individual keys that take in dust.
* Screen is inset from frame, adding some protection
* Roots easily so you can add more options (RSS readers, customize screen refresh options, dictionaries, PDF and other ereaders).
* No other ports/connectors other than micro-usb, If you're really worried, you could hack together a micro-usb plug to close off the port.
Cons
* On/off is handled using a push button on the back of the case.
I've had good luck with my PocketBook e-reader. I've traveled a lot with it and it has taken a lot of abuse.
Dish towel and a large ziplock bag. You're welcome.
What in the hell does this have to do with an Ebook reader?
It seems to me an eInk display is a good idea here because of its performance under open sunlight.
The Nook is rootable, fits in a cargo pants pocket, and has incredible battery life.
There's waterproof cases to be had on eBay, but I prefer a pleather booklet cover. The Nook's front face seems pretty watertight and I use a drybag for watertight storage.
It's only barely useable for browsing, but it's a beast for ePubs and passable for PDFs.
. We've got computers, we're tapping phone lines, you know that ain't allowed - Talking Heads, "Life During Wartime"
Sounds like you doing something like this might be useful for you. Takes a small bit of technical know-how but nothing serious. I've been thinking about making my e-reader solar powered for a while I just have'nt had a good enough reason to do it yet.
http://www.instructables.com/id/Solar-charging-ereader/
I've traveled a little with my e-ink (B&W) Nook from a few years ago, including a couple week-long road trips on my motorbike. The basic e-ink models are pretty cheap and the battery life is better than the color ones. That's about as "ruggedized" as you're going to find.
You want to be a bit protective of the screen; if poked hard by something else in your bag (such as a corner of a hard object pressed against it), it can damage the layer that changes black-to-white and leave a permanent dark spot. I got a couple of those which aren't too bad, but a little annoying to look at. So I'd recommend fitting a sealable durable freezer bag with a same-size rigid shield of some kind (firm plastic, thick cardboard), and put the Nook in that (with the screen facing the board) for protection, and hope for the best.
http://alternatives.rzero.com/
Erk, I mean, I live in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, and I prefer the Sony Reader PRS-T1. ( http://wiki.mobileread.com/wiki/PRST1 ) It's the slimmest one on the market, and is easily hacked to handle the Amazon, B&N, and other online stores, as well as your local library. It has a microSD slot, and you can easily convert your e-books with the Calibre software. I picked mine up for $100 at Best Buy. It's worked well in the sand, dust, and heat here in Saudi, and the Reader and other eInk devices hold a charge for around a month. It definitely beats having to recharge every day or two with LCD devices.
Get the basic kindle and invest in a decent case. I have the official amazon case with the built-in light which is very handy for travelling. The light uses the Kindle's battery, which still manages to last for several weeks.
I think it's rugged enough. There's no glass in the screen, and no vents for dust to get in. No, it's not waterproof, but it's only $100. Anything more rugged (if it exists) will be more expensive and just as prone to theft.
"A week in the lab saves an hour in the library"
If it not too small for you a Motorola defy would work the screen is sharp, battery life is reasonable (not it the same league as a kindle but a solar charger would sort that) plus it waterproof and it pretty shock shock resistant. Its also pretty cheap too
I work in the bush 260+ days a year and what works great are zip-lock bags with the double seal. You put your electronics in them and then close the bag most of the way and then suck out the air to vacuum seal it. Touch screens still work through the plastic at least for blackberry torches and iphones. My kindle is first gen and doesn't have touch, only buttons. The nice thing about the bags are they are a lot cheaper than pelican cases.
Just making sure we cover all the bases here.
When all you have is a tin foil hat, everything looks like a communist alien mind control ray.
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.
Next!
If it can withstand the brutal torture of a 3 year old, it can withstand anything.
-- By all means let's be open-minded, but not so open-minded that our brains drop out.
http://www.lifeproof.com/ipad
If you are traveling you may just want to pick up a few paper books. Several reasons for this. 1) cost. Although some paper books can and do cost a lot if you pick something cheap it makes sense. 2)you don't have to worry about power 3) Stealing something valuable. Where ever you go you have to be on your guard since they see you have this high price item and will be thinking you got a lot of cash, time to liberate it for themselves. 4) Safety. See #3. If you have something nice and shiny, depending upon the people around you someone could follow you and want to take it way, putting you in harms way. Although as everyone knows it could just be something else they are looking at like your watch, cloths and so on. On trips I always try to look nondescript so no one thinks I got any cash or valuable stuff on me. In my car I got a lot of trash in the back seats so people think my car is crap and wouldn't want it.
Just my thoughts.
Paul: Father... father, the sleeper has awakened! - Dune
For just storage use a formed hard nylon case then when your using it make sure its in a waterproof case with strap so you can wear it and protect it from falling and water damage.
If you can get around bringing the ebook reader just get some books on tape and put them on a tiny mp3 player or phone. If find this much easier to get my stories while traveling and one less device to lug around with me.
Back in the PDA days I had an awesome rugged case for my compaq, the case was really thick, enough to absorb shock from falls and sealed enough to protect it from a little water. Tried finding something like it for ebooks or tablets but no luck, maybe you can google some more and find something.
The Kindle Non-Touch could be your device.
Background
The shell is metal (titanium? aluminium?) - and can withstand serious knocks.
The device itself is very slim, so easier to slide into the back of backpacks, pockets, etc.
The e-ink display seems to take substantial abuse before it cracks - and if it does crack,amazon replaces the device for free.
Jusitifications
You're asking for something rugged - most people don't abuse their devices.
I've just got back from a 12,400KM trip on motocycle from France to Kazakhstan - my kindle was in the top of the tank case for the entire trip.
It endured being dropped on concrete multiple times ( the shell has chunks missing, but the device marches on ) - and also a small accident when I put the bike down - the tank case ripped off, flew through the air, had a solid impact - and the Kindle marches on. There's a tiny black dot (e-ink equivalent of 'dead pixels', I guess) - where there was significant pressure, but works perfectly.
You can telnet / SSH to the device without modification, you can replace the screensavers, you can download / pirate books if it's your fancy.
It's a pretty damned amazing device, especially for the price of $99.
Anti-DRM = cheap bitchy bastards. Pay for stuff you use or at least write books, music, movies, TV shows or games to contribute to a community of free content. Bitching about DRM and being a leech of content is waste of everybody's time.
I haven't thought of anything clever to put here, but then again most of you haven't either.
Last year I spent a few months living on a small sailboat. One of the issues I had was that, well, I'm a geek. Solar panels, batteries, laptop, android phone, kindle... it all had to survive. As for my phone I just got a motorola defy, no further protection needed... it's worked great and have taken no end of abuse without a hiccup. As for my ebook reader, I got myself a cheap kindle and a cheap waterproof bag from some dealer on amazon. I think it's called TrendyDigital or some such. It has a neckstrap as well, so I'd just carry my kindle with me, sit around reading, and was able to drop it at a moments notice without worrying about it falling and breaking. I'm not recommending any particular brand here, I'm sure a regular ziploc bag would do the trick, and you could probably add a strap to that as well with some thought to it.
And true, if it had fallen, or slammed against something hard when I bent over, it would have been bye bye kindle. It's not a hardcase... but honestly the kindle is so cheap that it would be a waste of money to protect it with a hardcase. If it breaks I wouldn't even call up the insurance company - the deductible would be the majority of the price of a new one. Just treat it with some care, and if it breaks - get the next model and treat that one with some MORE care.
I regularly read on my Kindle in the bath. I just double-bag with regular ziploc bags, and I've never had any issues.
If you are going to use you phone as a reader get the droid commando by GzOne it is shock resistant and water proof not water resistant. All ports are sealed with rubber gaskets.
Reinforcing a 7" Android tablet was easy for me; a $20 semi-hard cover with a built-in USB keyboard provides ample impact and pressure protection - said combo gets bumped and rattled in my backpack to and from work and work-sites every day. An inexpensive tablet, if you're careful about which one you buy, is significantly cheaper than a dedicated e-reader these days and makes an excellent e-reader + movie player + plus web browser (wifi or 3G/4G) + music player. The complete combo, including a decent set of headphones and a 32GB microSD card, ran me $150 after shipping - a good name brand e-reader with similar accessories will cost you at least $200 new and frequently doesn't include an SD slot. I also agree with the others about using a ziploc bag (or even a double-bagged ziploc for serious dust and moisture protection) to provide cheap and easy waterproofing.
And go Cheap. Buy the cheapest Kindle Amazon sells, skip the bulk of a heavy case. As long as it survives most of your trip, call it disposable. If you can find one used, do that. Sometimes rugged is not worth the hassle.
ERROR: Null
RUGGED? Like and iPad with a carpet?
"Flyin' in just a sweet place,
Never been known to fail..."
Battery life will be significantly worse than an eReader, but a Panasonic Toughpad FZ-A1 should be able to withstand the conditions you describe.
I have a kindle fire which I immediately put in a Otterbox Defender case. With the front cover on the Kindle Fire its very resilient. Not only did I take it through a year and a half in Afghanistan (thrown in my pack or body armor), but I have been letting my 3 year old, and 12 year old boys (affectionately known as FOD's or Force Of Destructions) use it. They have had it for a year and it works great, is small enough to fit in the oldest back pocket (and sit on unfortunately), and uses so little power I was able to charge it with a mobile solar charger while in Afghanistan. Its also a cheap option... Kid and battle proven.
In terms of protecting e-readers, I've found that a 4x6inch resealable plastic bags (look on eBay for sellers offering 100 micron / 'extra heavy duty' ones) is more useful (& much cheaper) than an Aquapac or similar for anything short of actual submergence. Both these bags (and aquapacs) soon pick up pinholes in general use, if you have a set of spare bags, it's seconds to change. They're also useful for phones, gadgets, tobacco, toothpaste, cosmetics, food etc in any vaguely extreme environment.
In terms of cases, all the commercially available faux leather ones have been a joke. I have a 'case' made out of two pieces of 1.5mm thick aluminium sheet with a duck-tape hinge, covered in tape to avoid scratches.
With most of the dry lock bags they start getting scuffed and become fogged and translucent instead of transparent. A quick wipe with Armor All and transparency returns. I use some double tough ziplock freezer bags as well and the Armor All works to clean them up as well.
"Anti-DRM = cheap bitchy bastards"
No. I've run into problems where Amazon's Kindle app decides my main computer has an issue, so every few days, it needs to be re-authorized, which eats another of the five allowable licenses. After a couple of weeks, when I go to read it, it tells me I need to buy the book again if I want to read it. Oh, yeah, I can just go in and de-authorize all my devices and start over again, but why should I have to put up with that crap? This is what I get when I play by their rules? No. This is not acceptable, and it is only because of their damned DRM.
I was semi-excited when cheap 7" tablets came out. I didn't ever understand the appeal of tablets, but when they dipped under $100 I decided I might
as well get one and see what the fuss is about, and 7" is the right size -- it fits in my pocket so that I will actually have one on me.
Bullshit. It fits in my pocket? No, it breaks in my pocket (cracked screen; still works but it's just a matter of time, now). Whether that's because I bought cheap crap (I did, so it's somewhat possible that's why it cracked, I'll admit) or because of the stresses (particularly when sitting in car, with chorkie on my lap), I'm not sure, but I am pretty sure it wouldn't have happened, if I had used the cheapo case that I bought but never use. The problem is that with the case, it doesn't fit in my pocket anymore, thereby undermining the entire "tablet experiment." (If the best computer is the one you have, then the most useless computer is one you don't have.)
And that's why I've reversed my opinion on 7" tablets -- they're losers too, just as bad as 10" ones. And if you have to use a case and therefore can't pocket it anyway, then 10" isn't really any worse than 7". My next gizmo will be 5" maximum, plus case. And that's for ruggedness reasons, which is why I mention it here.
Use case. Make that part of your spec. Then shop around, within that size-increasing constraint.
As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
Get one of the OLPC tablets they just released. Rugged enough for a bunch of third world young'uns should be perfect.
Find a lightweight aluminum box at a craft store (try the rubber stamp aisle) that will fit the e-reader, line it with some foam from the same store for a snug but not tight fit, then put the e-reader in a ziplock bag inside the box. That should protect it from just about anything you can throw at it. Should be very inexpensive, also. If it gets broken, you've got bigger problems to worry about.
My wife has used her Kindle in the bathtub inside a ziplock bag without any complaints. A clean ziplock does not obscure the screen enough to really even notice.
I got a Google Nexus with their case, it's thin rubber and still small enough - in the case - to fit in a front pocket.
I've been careful not to lean against things, but otherwise no problems so far.
Ask the enthusiasts at MobileRead. The Pocketbook 360 Plus has a nifty snap-on cover, good battery life, and survives ocean spray and bathtubs (not sure about underwater though). Or get a reader app for your phone as backup, which you've probably already toughened. Better yet, forget the ereader and visit with whoever's around, explore the surroundings, step away from the digital blue pill and into full spectrum analog life.
Nope, sorry. Being Anti-DRM doesn't mean you want to easily steal everything. Heck, as you know, DRM is easy to strip from just about everything anyway.
The problem with DRM is that DRM systems change, become obsolete / unsupported, and sometimes cause technical problems with devices. Content that you have rightfully paid for can be denied to you - forcing you to go through hurdles to access it again, or even worse, force you to buy a second copy.
DRM doesn't stop piracy and it inhibits legal content usage. It's just plain bad.
Not part of your question -- but you may want to seriously consider the perk of having FREE wireless internet access that works anywhere in the world (if there is cell phone coverage). I took my kindle DXG and it was amazing to be able to check/send gmail from Tanzania, Kenya, and even Amsterdam along the way. I love the DXG and it's been pretty rugged for me over the last year. I think if you are a hacker enough you can SSH from it to EC2 computers.
A Pelican case, and you're protected from just about anything that you could survive. http://www.pelicancases.com/1055CC-p/1055cc.htm
No it is not. Even people like me who actually (used to) pay for what they use do bitch about DRM because it is bad solution technically. The arguments of industry are flawed to say the least and the legal fight against 'pirates' reminds to much racket to be allowed to continue.
I too am looking for a reader to accompany me on travels to the third world countries. A flexible device may be ideal for rough handling.
Wexler Flex One uses the new LG's flexible epaper, http://goodereader.com/blog/electronic-readers/wexler-flex-one-hands-on-review/
As far as I know it is the only one, currently. Hopefully more are coming soon. It is also very light and pocketable.
Ive had two sony ereaders
They had survived a number of years. falling two stories onto concrete. being chewed EXTENSIVELY = and slobered over by a dog (the current one STILL has teeth marks all over the aluminium casing - apparently the leather case was too appealing for my partners dog to resist) I have to admit - after the dog event it was flakey for a few days and I thought I might have to replace it but then it settled down and its been rock solid ever since - probably the slobber inside just needed to dry out (maybe ?)
Ive traveled all around the world with it... business and pleasure - USA, europe and south america, NZ (and across Australia where I live)
Humidity and Baking summer temperatures well over 100 F in the car and they BOTH coped well. The first one was a 505 and now I have a daily reader. I think the 505 was a little better but I liked them both.
Anti-DRM means I want my book/mp3/video to work like my paper book/cd/dvd. If I buy the physical version from the store, they won't send someone to remove it from my shelf at home if they made a mistake. Amazon famously removed a repackaged copy of "1984" from people's kindles. Ironically, the repackaged versionwas copyrighted & Amazon didn't have the right to sell it, but "1984" is public domain.
Also, w/o DRM, I can read it w/ a different reader. I can even convert it to something else in the future.
I used to use mobipocket on a Palm, then on a Blackberry. I haven't been able to find a good epub reader for it. I've also been able to read on a chinese reader running fbreader.
I choose to buy from non-drm sources like O'Reilly, Tor and Linux Journal.
I'm not sure about others experience, but I can share the following information:
1) Have 3 year old son.
2) Purchased an Asus tf101.
He has dropped it from a meter onto concrete, stood on it, dumped apple juice all over it, regularly throws it when he loses a game, flipped it onto it's screen and used it to skate across the floor.
The first time these things happened, I was thinking, "whelp, that is that, it's life is over". But I wipe it down with a wet cloth, and hand it back to him, and repeat.
it looks battle scarred, but it works perfectly. When he fills it up with too much garbage by clicking through all the advertisements, I press reset and everything is ok.
It's been a year in his abuse, and still going strong. I'm very satisfied, and since then have purchased the Asus Padfone, and am considering another Asus transformer for my wife.
Note: it's not in any protective case of any type.
-Ryan
polandr@gmail.com
the best handbags High Brand bags From JPN rakuten.com/auc-realbargain/ Guarantee 100% customer satisfactio Let's pick out your favorite items! 50mL amber serum vials www.ivpacks.com 50mL amber serum vials at wholesale Amber serum vial packaging supplies Replica handbags are gaining worldwide popularity in recent times. There are millions who wish to own a real designer bag but cannot afford to do so. This is because the original designer replica fendi handbags are very expensive. Thus, the replica or duplicate handbags have taken the world market of handbags completely by storm and are in great demand. The fashion industry has captured the global market completely. The global population is becoming more fashion conscious with every passing day. Globally reputed fashion designers are gaining more popularity and their products are recording high sales everywhere. This in turn is leading to even higher pricing of designer products and accessories and women's handbags are no exception. The solution to this has come in the form of replica or duplicate handbags. Duplicate designer handbags are of many types. For instance, these bags are available in different shapes, sizes and quality. They are available on sale in huge numbers both online as well as offline. They belong to a wide variety of very popular and reputed designers from different parts of the world. The replica designer handbags typically includes collections of Gucci, Balenciaga, Christian Dior, Prada, Marc Jacobs, Versace, Chanel, Mulberry, Miu Miu, Dolce & Gabbana, Chloe and many others. These handbags are also popularly known as "handbag knockoffs" since they are especially designed to resemble and feel almost like the original product. Replica handbags can be excellent for extravagant social events and gatherings such as formal balls, black-tie occasions, weddings, special dinners, banquets, proms and special ceremonies. These handbags can make one appear as striking as one would with the authentic bag itself. Locating and searching for designer replica replica hermes handbags is not very difficult. There are various sources available online and offline that offer these desiner miu miu handbags at very reasonable prices and are of good quality at the same time. There are also many popular stores and outlets that sell these duplicate designer handbags such as 'Handbags World' and 'Replica' to mention a few. With a fast growing fashion-oriented and competitive global population, fashion lovers are not content with possessing just a few duplicate designer handbags. Wholesale replica handbags are those duplicate designer handbags that are available at wholesale rates or very cheap discounts. They are available for sale online as well. Thus, they enable one to buy and possess many duplicate designer handbags at the same time. Thus, one can easily locate and purchase one's favorite and desired designer handbags by searching for the same replica handbags by doing some searching online for retailers and online fashion stores. All related and necessary information is widely available on the Internet. Shayne is an author of a popular Internet marketing company on the web. For further information the author recommends you to visit [http://www.fendihandbags.org.uk] cartier handbags balenciaga handbags