Slashdot Mirror


Google Play Services Supplants Android As Google's "Platform"

exomondo writes "Google has a plan to circumvent the problem of fragmentation of its Android operating system across the installed base by using its proprietary, closed-source Google Play Services. Play Services is a privileged service that runs on Android and provides the sort of functionality to applications that would generally be seen in operating system updates like cloud backup, remote wipe, push messaging, etc... This service can be updated silently and independently of the operating system and runs on almost every version of Android out there allowing Google to add functionality to Android devices without having to go through the OEMs so having an up-to-date version of Android is looking like less of a necessity." It might be worth noting that Google originally rejected copyleft in favor of permissive licensing in the name of giving OEMs and carriers more control over Android on their devices.

182 comments

  1. Sand Carriers by cosm · · Score: 5, Funny

    It might be worth noting that Google originally rejected copyleft in favor of permissive licensing in the name of giving OEM sand carriers more control over Android on their devices.

    And thus /. hath bestowed upon us a new name for companies peddling crappy hardware.

    --
    'We are trying to prove ourselves wrong as quickly as possible, because only in that way can we find progress.' RPF
    1. Re:Sand Carriers by SJHillman · · Score: 5, Funny

      Sand carriers always ride single file to hide their numbers

    2. Re:Sand Carriers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Walk without rhythm, it won't attract the worm

    3. Re:Sand Carriers by rossdee · · Score: 2

      Nope, its Star Wars - they don't have droids in Dune (remember they had the Butlerian Jihad)

      Back to the topic...

      I don't use the Google Play store - I don't have an account with Google

      I get Apps from the Amazon App store - I do have an account with AMazon, and have for umpteen years.

    4. Re:Sand Carriers by evilviper · · Score: 1

      However warning must be heeded. While they do startle easily, they usually come back, and in greater numbers.

      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    5. Re:Sand Carriers by BrokenHalo · · Score: 1

      What are these sand carriers and how can I get my hands on one?

      I have one in my yard. It's called a wheelbarrow. So far, I've found it a bit awkward to manage my apps, but you never know...

    6. Re:Sand Carriers by FatdogHaiku · · Score: 2

      Walk without rhythm, it won't attract the worm

      Christopher Walken even has an instructional video courtesy of Fatboy Slim:
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQ7z57qrZU8

      --
      You have the right to remain sentient. If you give up the right to remain sentient, you will be elected to public office
    7. Re:Sand Carriers by mwvdlee · · Score: 1

      Guess it gives new meaning to the term "shovelware".

      --
      Slashdot social media options: AIM, ICQ, Yahoo, Jabber and Mobile Text. Why no MySpace?
    8. Re:Sand Carriers by gravis777 · · Score: 2

      This is not the Android you are looking for.

    9. Re:Sand Carriers by ArcadeMan · · Score: 1

      Oh yeah it's gonna sound fantastic!

    10. Re:Sand Carriers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ironically since it's dance, he's actually walking with extended rhythm

    11. Re:Sand Carriers by nobaloney · · Score: 1

      OEM sand carriers

      And thus /. hath bestowed upon us a new name for companies peddling crappy hardware.

      Did you not see the movie Dune?

  2. Sand Carriers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

    What are these sand carriers and how can I get my hands on one? Is it something from Dune?

  3. DroidWall by Mr.+Slippery · · Score: 2

    Fortunately, I keep "Google Play Services" cut off from the net via Droidwall. That should keep Google from fscking with the software on my phone without my review and permission.

    *My* computer. *My* choice about whether to apply a software change.

    --
    Tom Swiss | the infamous tms | my blog
    You cannot wash away blood with blood
    1. Re:DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      DroidWall is dead as shit, and didn't work on my N4 on JB 4.3.

      Android Firewall is a fork, free, no ads, and works good.
      https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jtschohl.androidfirewall&hl=en

    2. Re:DroidWall by cool_arrow · · Score: 1

      Lots of software installed via Play wont like that and refuse to run.

    3. Re:DroidWall by ArhcAngel · · Score: 3, Funny

      I just use Airplane Mode. Nothing gets past that!

      --
      "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it." - K
    4. Re:DroidWall by BrokenHalo · · Score: 1

      I've never used Droidwall, but you can block Google with just a few entries in your /etc/hosts file (just like on any other Linux box) just as easily, and without having to run any other services.

    5. Re:DroidWall by Unknown+Lamer · · Score: 3, Informative

      F-Droid has a pretty good catalog nowadays. I've eliminated everything proprietary from my phone life except for Google Maps and those pesky hardware drivers. Osmand is pretty close to replacing Maps too... navigation basically works (even offline, although I've yet to try using it for more than echoing routes I already know) but POI searching is hit and miss (e.g. when searching for my bank it says the closest location is 17mi away, when there's one about 3mi away). It's actually nicer in a number of ways: maps and POI data can be stored offline (I have my entire state stored, what's 400M when you've got a 16G SD card?), you can record GPX routes (without eating tons of battery even), navigation can be simulated, it has a handy elevation and distance tool (great for biking), ...

      --

      HAL 7000, fewer features than the HAL 9000, but just as homicidal!
    6. Re:DroidWall by Mr.+Slippery · · Score: 1

      DroidWall is dead as shit, and didn't work on my N4 on JB 4.3.

      Can't speak for shiny new phones. It works on my Epic 4G running Gingerbread. I'll keep Android FW in mind when I upgrade, though.

      --
      Tom Swiss | the infamous tms | my blog
      You cannot wash away blood with blood
    7. Re:DroidWall by noh8rz10 · · Score: 1

      HOSTS FILES FTW!!!!!

    8. Re:DroidWall by Threni · · Score: 1

      Uhh.. apart from all data sent and received over WiFi.

    9. Re:DroidWall by Omestes · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I really don't get all the hate on this service. It is better than the alternative; devices that are never updated because carriers and manufacturers would rather you go out and buy more hardware every year. This happened to my Droid (Verizon) and Transformer (ASUS), after a single update, they never received even a modicum of support again.

      Oh no, Android is slightly more useful, at the cost of carriers and manufactures... must be a terrible plot.

      I understand wanting control, but sadly mobile devices have moved way beyond that. You can't control your hardware nor, really, your software. They aren't desktop computers... Sadly. I would kill for upgradable mobile devices, so I don't have to toss them every year. I find disposable hardware to be a bit vulgar. Then add in the fact, that sans rooting (if possible) that your device will never, ever, see an upgrade. So to get more functions, and security, you need to go shell out $300+ for a new device. If you're not on a contract, then you might just be screwed.

      I'm also happy that Google recognizes, finally, fragmentation.

      --
      A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government. -edward abbey
    10. Re:DroidWall by gmhowell · · Score: 2

      HOSTS FILES FTW!!!!!

      We finally know what account apk logs in under.

      --
      Jesus was all right but his disciples were thick and ordinary. -John Lennon
    11. Re:DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Osmand [osmand.net] is pretty close to replacing Maps too...

      Osmand is proprietary. Trying downloading more than 10 maps (or updates!). - essential for somebody who travels. They are not upfront about this and that makes them dishonest.

    12. Re:DroidWall by ameen.ross · · Score: 1

      Osmand isn't proprietary. It does contain DRM however, which I agree is quite annoying.

      --
      $(echo cm0gLXJmIC8= | base64 --decode)
    13. Re:DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      DroidWall works perfectly on my N4 w/ stock 4.3. Are you sure you're rooted properly?

    14. Re:DroidWall by 3.5+stripes · · Score: 1

      Airplane mode shuts down ALL communication, NFC, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and of course the radio that talks to the cell towers.

      --


      He tried to kill me with a forklift!
    15. Re:DroidWall by Ash-Fox · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Fortunately, I keep "Google Play Services" cut off from the net via Droidwall.

      Droidwall requires root access. This is not usable for the majority and therefore I feel that this should not be considered helpful advice but instead, 'gloating'.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    16. Re:DroidWall by AikonMGB · · Score: 1

      You can turn on Wi-Fi and Bluetooth while in airplane mode if you so choose (possibly NFC as well, but I haven't tried).

    17. Re: DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I definitely am sure I'm rooted proper. SuperSU via TWRP. Pretty foolproof...

    18. Re:DroidWall by gstoddart · · Score: 1

      Uhh.. apart from all data sent and received over WiFi.

      Do you actually know what airplane mode does?

      It disables all communications, cellular and wireless -- when it's in airplane mode, there should be zero emissions from it.

      Any device which didn't do that would be in violation of FCC rules.

      I play most games in airplane mode to block their ads and crap. In fact, when I first download something, I put the device into airplane mode and confirm it doesn't require a network connection. Any game which can't be played offline, I uninstall right away.

      --
      Lost at C:>. Found at C.
    19. Re:DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Osmand is pretty close to replacing Maps too

      I like the OSM stuff too, but for navigation (especially with the new Waze integration) it's not even close.

    20. Re:DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Your phone has the power of a desktop computer. You CAN and should have 100% of something that can and IS used as evidence against you as being under your control in a court of law. Or in car analogies, if some illegal immigrant with calves the size of cantalopes brings 75 pounds of marijuana in your car and you drive him into the US you're still responsible for the drugs. Same as that you're still responsible for what's on your phone.

    21. Re:DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Or if you don't have a Google account, and don't want to use the Google apps, you can disable "Google Play Services with no ill effect.

    22. Re:DroidWall by noh8rz10 · · Score: 1

      It is obviously your a fucker. Have a laugh, man, or take the $10,000 challenge.

    23. Re:DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Southwest airlines (likely other carriers too) allows you to access the Internet via 802.11(g|n). I've pinged the access point from a phone that was in airplane mode, so airplane mode is strictly the GSM/CDMA/LTE/other cell protocol radio.

    24. Re:DroidWall by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      OsmAnd is open source under the GPL. How is that proprietary? Go to GitHub and grab the source code if you need it.

    25. Re:DroidWall by Threni · · Score: 1

      No, it doesn't. I always use Wifi abroad when I want to surf but not make/receive any calls.

    26. Re:DroidWall by Threni · · Score: 1

      > Do you actually know what airplane mode does?

      Yes. Apparently you don't. You turn airplane mode on, then turn wifi on (which doesn't disable airplane mode).

      > Any device which didn't do that would be in violation of FCC rules.

      I live in the UK, and my phone was made by a Korean company, and I on holiday in Thailand, so I'm not really bothered about the FCC.

    27. Re:DroidWall by Unknown+Lamer · · Score: 1

      That's why you use the Osmand~ build by the community (which is in f-droid of course) which removes all of those restrictions. Of course, I probably should send them ten bucks to fight the good fight.

      --

      HAL 7000, fewer features than the HAL 9000, but just as homicidal!
  4. Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacturers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    The manufacturers and carriers have ZERO interest in supporting devices after the ink is dried on the contract. The manufacturers want to be apple and sell a new phone every time the O/S gets even the most basic of incremental improvements to functionality. The carriers are right there with a fresh contract extension and a kriss bladed knife ready to seal the deal in blood.

    The rooting community is the only group actively supporting devices. Google on the other hand has almost zero stake in contracts or hardware sales. Their profitability is tied to the services and ad revenue which comes with loyal devotion to their brand's ecosystem. The same brand that the carriers and manufacturers are more than happy to piss and shit on with their stupid & unwanted modifications from the stock Google release.

    Samsung is the only manufacturer that doesn't have their head up their ass which is why the Galaxy S is on version 4 instead of these retarded Beta releases from every other manufacturer which get aborted as a brand out of shame and distrust like Diebold/Blackwater/Xe/Academi.

    HTC is currently the only brand I'm willing to buy because unlike Samsung, they have figured out that locked boot-loaders are bad for business.

  5. Play Services is the "Value Add" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    After the raw OS, Google needs to have something unique/proprietary to offer users. That's all the google play interconnected stuff... The Google-specific stuff is... in the Gapps. It makes sense... that's where Google's ecosystem integrates with the OS.

    Nearly everything that can be moved out of the main OS has been.

    That's not exactly true-- try running a Cyanogenmod build sometime without Gapps. It still works well-- just as you'd expect, you don't have the Google-related things, but there is a non-branded browser, and it's still a very usable device. But yeah, you don't get the benefits (or risks, depending on your POV) of using Google's services.

    Still, it's an interesting theory that the OS work is basically done now so new feature work is going to be piled over google services/gapps. I suspect it's a bit overstated as I'd think there is plenty of platform/OS-level and basic framework improvements still to do. Many of the UI advances in the Google services have been built in tandem with corresponding framework development (though much of it is backported all the way to v4),

    1. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      That's not exactly true-- try running a Cyanogenmod build sometime without Gapps. It still works well-- just as you'd expect, you don't have the Google-related things, but there is a non-branded browser, and it's still a very usable device.

      and what happens when developers start taking advantage of new features from Play Services? Android itself will stagnate and the only viable way for consumers to go will be Google's proprietary, closed Android distribution. Sure the underlying OS is open much like Darwin is on OSX but all the real useful bits that make it what it is are in a closed source layer.

    2. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by taxman_10m · · Score: 1

      I just did that in fact. I'm not sure what I'm missing out on by having not installed Gapps. No Google+?

    3. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by alostpacket · · Score: 1

      The biggest one is Maps the v2 (Android) Google Maps API is part of Google Play services. (What 3rd party devs use).

      Anyways, there is a picture in TFA that covers the Google services & apps you would lose without Google Play Services (i.e. almost all of them).

      I think you would also lose any games/paid apps that use the Play store licensing (LVL).

      --
      PocketPermissions Android Permission Guide
    4. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by MikeBabcock · · Score: 1

      Honestly, I'd miss the Play Store and G+ ... However all my E-mail is done with K-9 and navigation with Waze (which is soon to be Google I understand).

      --
      - Michael T. Babcock (Yes, I blog)
    5. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by AmiMoJo · · Score: 0

      As well as being a technically elegant solution I think they probably have Microsoft's experience at the back of their minds. When MS tried to make the browser and media player a core part of the OS they got bollocked by various governments, but on Android every component is easily replaceable.

      I'm surprised Apple gets away with it, but apparent they have the president of the US on their side at the moment.

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
    6. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by Nerdfest · · Score: 1

      K-9 is a fantastic mail client, especially since it support encryption. It would be nice to see a few more people using it.

    7. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by Desler · · Score: 1

      Does Apple hold a monopoly on mobile device operating systems? No, you say? Well there is your answer.

    8. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      LuckyPatcher

    9. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      , especially since it support encryption.

      Sadly, neither S/MIME nor certificate-based mail server authentication is supported.

    10. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You can install Maps and the Maps API libraries (manually) without the rest of Play. It does bitch at you to install the rest of Play at first, though (it's easily disabled).

    11. Re:Play Services is the "Value Add" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      To add to the other gripe, it doesn't support PGP/MIME (it can't even read it), so it's not really very useful...

  6. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    HTC is currently the only brand I'm willing to buy because unlike Samsung, they have figured out that locked boot-loaders are bad for business.

    Yeah HTC's profits are plunging while Samsung's are soaring, locked boot loaders are *so* bad for business.

  7. Copyleft got left in the name of progress by Droidweb · · Score: 1

    It might be worth noting that Google originally rejected copyleft in favor of permissive licensing in the name of giving OEM sand carriers more control over Android on their devices.

    They did, but that practice of benevolence was quickly up once the time from code release to users adoption became astronomical, causing pitchforks and branding irons labled 'fragmentation' to bought out by every fanboy and 'industry expert'. Something had to be done.

    Besides, Android as a pure OS is still freely available so that hackers and researchers can continue peacefully using the software. As for this new play services app, I'm a little concerned about what possible exploitable backdoors this might enable. Infect a phone with a modified play services .apk and it seems like you have the Android version of a rootkit.

    1. Re:Copyleft got left in the name of progress by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Don't install it?

      On my GNex, I actually had to go install the Remote Wipe / Phone Finder Play Services application.

      Even if it was installed... just disable it?

  8. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

    A good chess player can still win against a weak opponent despite letting them take their queen. That doesn't mean that playing without a queen is a good strategic decision.

  9. Instead of focusing on a typo.. by hairyfeet · · Score: 1

    Which just for the record probably means he is on the latest Chromium branch or one of those based on Chromium as i have noticed the "weird spacing error" thing since the last update, and instead focus on this great news?

    As someone who owns an Android pre-paid (finally got out from under that contract, praise the FSM) this is great news but I have a few reservations...does this mean they'll be forcing updates to ICS on devices that can't run it well? Will they just abandon all but the latest and greatest? or will they do like I hope they would and take all those 2.x and 3.x devices and update to the last release in that branch?

    Because looking around when i was shopping for my phone it amazed me how many Gingerbread (most 2.3.X based phones) there are being made and sold and moreover...how fricking well they run! When I was first looking at Android a couple years back it was when the market was crapflooded with 1.x devices and I have to say they ran like absolute dogshit. They were slow, buggy as all get out, the screen response was pathetic, they were just total shit, but these Gingerbread based phones? They are snappy, great battery life, plenty of apps for it,decent touchscreens, etc. While the 1.x devices i'm sure soured some on Android based on how shitty they were the 2.x devices are a nice experience all around.

    So while its nice that Google will be able to do an end run around the OEMs, which i have noticed really don't give a rat's ass about support once they have sold you the phone I do hope Google doesn't "pull a MSFT" and drop all support and access to Google Play for those using older devices. I live in a rural state where many are working poor and they just can't afford to go out and spend $300+ on a phone and the contracts are legalized assrape so all those $50-$100 Android 2.x phones give the working poor the chance to enjoy what many of us have enjoyed for ages, the ability to have the Internet in their pocket.

    --
    ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
    1. Re:Instead of focusing on a typo.. by alostpacket · · Score: 1

      Gingerbread phones run Google Play Services* pretty well.

      That's kind of the point, they can push out updates to say the Maps API and let devs use those APIs on older phones.

      --
      PocketPermissions Android Permission Guide
    2. Re:Instead of focusing on a typo.. by hairyfeet · · Score: 1

      Yes they do NOW but that was the point I was trying to make, will Google allow that into the future? After all I'm sure if they had their way all phones and tablets would be ICS, just one version to support means less cost and the new devices have more memory and more powerful CPUs so they can do more with a new 4.x phone than they can a 2.x phone.

      Of course whether more equals better is up for interpretation as I have seen one of those 2.x phones easily beat a 4.x Samsung, even though the LG Slider 2.x had half the memory and was a single core to the Samung's dual. The reason why was simple, less bloat and a slimmer OS with Gingerbread than with ICS.

      So while I hope Google does keep supporting 2.x I would feel a LOT better about TFA if we got some sort of assurance from Google. I have a couple of relatives including my oldest on 2.x phones and it would not be fun to have to file 13 all those phones and tablets which work just fine because Google decides to stop supporting 2.x through Google Play.

      --
      ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
    3. Re:Instead of focusing on a typo.. by spacepimp · · Score: 1

      The more devices using Google search/services/ads makes money for Google. They don't make more money by having you buy a new phone. It is in Googles best interest to have as many people accessing their services as possible. Cutting off a user base only hurts their bottom line. Try that with MS or Apple and the numbers never work out the same for the consumer.

  10. The FreeBSD way by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So Google is following the FreeBSD way by keeping the base system separated from the userland? This allows upgrading user-facing programs and APIs even when the base OS is in "stable" mode. In this case, anything after Gingerbread is considered "stable" and everything else can be updated by the Google Play service.

    Very well done. Now let's see you do this on Enterprise Linux 6 by porting a recent version of Google Chrome.

  11. Re:Posting by king+neckbeard · · Score: 2

    Grammer Nazism is a staple of geeks.

    --
    This is my signature. There are many like it, but this one is mine.
  12. When I get a new phone... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I first go to google play and download all of the updated versions of the software I use...

    Then I root the device, backup all of the downloaded apks and install a clean operating system.. Something WITHOUT gapps.

    Then I side load all of the applications I downloaded.

    You would be amazed how much better the device works when all of that CRAP isn't running in the background eating resources and using bandwidth.

     

    1. Re:When I get a new phone... by m.alessandrini · · Score: 1

      But then you cannot download any new application when it comes to your mind?

    2. Re:When I get a new phone... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I usually write my own applications... Weather, Music player, Backup, File Sync, Book Reader... The list goes on... I really don't need to be tracked so I can download some ad / nag supported application. I still remember the glory days of windows mobile (free / share ware). Those were good days.. Before google / Apple got into the mix.

  13. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Desler · · Score: 5, Informative

    The manufacturers want to be apple and sell a new phone every time the O/S gets even the most basic of incremental improvements to functionality.

    How exactly is that being like Apple other than in your invented version of reality? The iPhone 4 was discontinued October of 2011 and is slated to also get iOS 7 coming out later this year. The 3GS got discontinued in September of last year it still received iOS updates to 6.1.3 from last March. The 3G was discontinued in June 2010 yet continued receiving iOS updates until November of 2010. And the original iPhone was discontinued July 2008 and still received iOS updates until February of 2010.

  14. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Desler · · Score: 1

    And, yes, the iPhone 4 and 4S will not get all features of iOS 7 but they are still getting a large portion of it along with the security fixes.

  15. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by niftymitch · · Score: 2

    .....

    Samsung is the only manufacturer that doesn't have their head up their

    Well they are not keeping up. I have wonderful phone from Samsung
    and the base OS is locked at old and musty. Worse the graphics code
    does not take advantage of the graphics hardware as it should.

    One of the critical buggers in phone land is the big system lump upgrade.
    The Android team apparently elected to structure things to exclude modest updates
    and fail to establish a path for trusted updates.

    But this stuff is all new. A couple turns of the crank and good things are possible.

    --
    Truth is stranger than fiction, but it is because Fiction is obliged to stick to possibilities; Truth isn't. Mark Twain.
  16. Cell phone companies not so much by rsilvergun · · Score: 1

    they'd like you to keep your phone, thank you very much. Even at $600 bucks some of them still have a subsidy.

    --
    Hi! I make Firefox Plug-ins. Check 'em out @ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-mp3-podcaster/
  17. Google Play breaks my phone with every update by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Every time Google Play Store and Google Play Services update they install as a removable update in the non-system area of my phone. The phone's memory is small - just a few hundred 185MB of user space available and I have it jam packed with apps. So every time I get an update I go from having 25MB or more to having under 12MB. The Android operating system does not like this. On my wife's phone I've had this cause a reboot cycle - I had to reset the phone to get out of it.

    To make matters worse a bug (or feature - don't know if it was intended) means that updated versions of Google Play Store have not honoured the preferences for application update of user applications. So even though I've set the thing to never update, I on two occasions upon establishing a wireless connection I have had a bunch of apps update themselves with newer larger versions quicker than I could notice and shut down the phone. The end result once again is a phone with too little user memory to run. I've heard this has happened for others when not using wireless and that it has resulted in expensive data downloads.

    I HATE not having control of my phone. I HATE idiotic updates that break it. I HATE Android. There's just nothing better out there. Give me back control!!!

    1. Re:Google Play breaks my phone with every update by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The problem isn't with the service updating itself, it's with you only having 185MB of total space. Throw that ancient piece of shit away.

    2. Re:Google Play breaks my phone with every update by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I HATE not having control of my phone.

      Then choose an open phone, oh but you just want all the benefits that closed systems offer you because the open ones are shit.

      Give me back control!!!

      No. You arent entitled to anything. Go an contribute something to making the experience on open phones better instead of being an entitlist dipshit.

    3. Re:Google Play breaks my phone with every update by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Buy an SD card and get over yourself.

    4. Re:Google Play breaks my phone with every update by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Install Titanium Backup and push the updates to the system partition. Also, remove any crap you don't want. You have an ancient phone: either get a new one, or learn how to keep it up to date.

  18. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    HTC is currently the only brand I'm willing to buy because unlike Samsung, they have figured out that locked boot-loaders are bad for business.

    It is one thing or another with these vendors.

    I would have an HTC one right now but the friggen battery can't be changed and I refuse to be at the mercy of battery gods/planned obsolesence.

    You can get a cool new device with lots of features except the loader is locked, or it is unlocked and does not support US LTE frequencies or the battery is non-removable or it does not have SD slot.

    I won't even consider a device where cyanogen can't be installed and google play is totally out of the question.

  19. So then... by FuzzNugget · · Score: 1

    Settings > Apps > Google Play Services > Disable

    1. Re:So then... by alostpacket · · Score: 1

      This is not a good idea, you'll end up breaking a lot of apps if you do this. Disabling Google Services would also disable the ability for 3rd party apps to make use of the many, many APIs it contains (where are very useful for app devs).

      FTA:

      Right now Play Services handles the Google Maps API, Google Account syncing, remote wipe, push messages, the Play Games back end, and many other duties. If you ever question the power of Google Play Services, try disabling it. Nearly every Google App on your device will break.

      --
      PocketPermissions Android Permission Guide
    2. Re:So then... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I see what they did there.

      They're right: Google Play Services handles all that. They provide the APIs.

      Google Play Games is an optional download: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.play.games&hl=en
      Maps is also a separate download.

      Google Play Device Manager also requires you to enable the factory reset on the phone before you're able to do it. Try it, and you'll see that you need to enable it on phone first.

    3. Re:So then... by pentadecagon · · Score: 1

      This affects only Google APIs. So if you disable the Google-Service, any apps talking to Google-Services won't work anymore. Big surprise.

    4. Re:So then... by FuzzNugget · · Score: 1

      I use Osmand (gmaps still works fine, BTW), like hell I give Google all my data, remote wipe won't work in any case because I have no data on my plan, I use Aquamail instead Gmail and I rarely play games.

      I've disabled Google Play Services and there are no problems because I don't expect mommy Google to do everything for me.

  20. Who wants an NSA phone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Fuck Google.

    1. Re:Who wants an NSA phone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Fuck you.

    2. Re:Who wants an NSA phone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      When Google spies on me and my fellow citizens they use Linux so that makes it cool!

    3. Re:Who wants an NSA phone? by spacepimp · · Score: 1

      Name a phone OS that you think is not being used to spy on you by the NSA? They are spying on everyone. At least you can use Cyanogenmod and use an open source version of the OS.

    4. Re:Who wants an NSA phone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      NSA doesn't care what OS your phone uses, they just call up your carrier and ask them who you've been talking to.

  21. Issues by currently_awake · · Score: 1

    here are a few problems: The NSA can now install software on your phone, world wide. If you don't pay Google a monthly fee all your apps and data gets lost in the cloud. They can read all your data, remotely, and give you targeted adds. You can only buy apps from them, unless they let you. Always on the network DRM.

    1. Re:Issues by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Except that the Google Play Remote Wipe/Find My Phone services are NOT installed by default. You'd have to go out and install the thing. I had to do this with my Galaxy Nexus.

      Not to mention that you can choose any of the other Where's My Droid applications that have precisely the same (some with more) functionality.

      Nice FUD article.

    2. Re:Issues by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Considering Google has pretty much admitted to unconditional cooperation with the NSA I think it's pretty safe to assume that the "Play" applications superuser privileges are within the NSAs grasp on any device running it and connected to a network.

      I'm not faulting Google BTW, I would do the same thing if someone held a gun to my head. The government is the one breaking the social contract here.

    3. Re:Issues by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Cyanogenmod, motherfucker, do you speak it?

    4. Re: Issues by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Breaking my phone is not the answer motherfucker.

    5. Re: Issues by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Posting this from cyanogenmod, motherfucker.

    6. Re: Issues by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Calm down, bitches. I seriously doubt either of you have ever fucked a mother.

    7. Re: Issues by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I agree. If you don't know what you are doing, you should stay with stock.

      Personally, I run Cyanogenmod on all of the Android devices because I understand how to flash a ROM.

    8. Re:Issues by petman · · Score: 1

      There are three Android devices in my house. My Samsung Galaxy S2, my wife's Sony Xperia and a Galaxy Tab 2. Everyone of those had the Android Device Manager function installed automatically. I could immediately use the Locate Phone function without having to perform any manual installation/update. Only the Wipe Device function requires manual configuration on the phone.

  22. One thing they can't fix: realtime audio by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That will still need proper OS-level support, and vendor/hardware specific upgrades, to fix.
    I like Android, but the VM layer philosophy just isn't suited to realtime audio apps. I'd be excited to see apps as bulletproof and useful as the Mackie iPad-mixer setups bands are now using in live settings, on Android tablets.

    1. Re:One thing they can't fix: realtime audio by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You may think you know what you're talking about, but you really don't. In fact you made a very ignorant comment. The issue isn't the VM, it's Linux and 4.3 has done a lot to address the issue. I encourage you to view the Google 2013 I/O presentation on low latency audio to further correct your ignorant views.

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d3kfEeMZ65c

    2. Re:One thing they can't fix: realtime audio by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I encourage you to check it in real life and not how google presents it on a stage, in front if the press and audience.

  23. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by jrumney · · Score: 2

    The iPhone 4 was discontinued October of 2011...

    The 8GB iPhone 4 is still in production (rumored to be replaced at the bottom end soon by the iPhone 5C). Only the 16GB and 32GB versions were discontinued to make way for the 4S. Apple has consistently released major OS upgrades only for models that are current on the day of the announcement (including models that are discontinued as of that same date due to simultaneous new product announcements). Ask any iPhone 3G user that upgraded to iOS 5 whether they think this is a good or bad thing.

  24. Can you download and modify Google Play? by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    I can see the utility in google being able to push out new services and frameworks via Google Play.

    However it seems like the danger as far as Android being a more open system, is that now you can't change or examine Google Play yourself.

    I did try googling for Google Play source, but it seems the sort of thing Google would not likely provide source for... they may very well for embedded frameworks it pushes out I suppose, but then how would you load modified versions?

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  25. What Happens When Google Play Services is Buggy? by echusarcana · · Score: 4, Informative

    A quick check on XDA Developers suggests that many ROMs are having problems with Google Play Services right now: excessive battery usage, high data usage. It is hard to tell because the simple monitoring tools don't break down what this mysterious piece of software is doing. It might be some subtle version incompatibility.
    So what happens when a monolithic chunk of software has a *really* bad release? Putting all your eggs in one basket is a serious risk.

  26. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    https://discussions.apple.com/thread/4335148?start=0&tstart=0

    "The manufacturers want to be apple and sell a new phone every time there is the most basic of incremental improvements to functionality."

    FTFY

    I can't tell the difference between an iPhone 3G and an iPhone 5 was my point. Cue the Galaxy SIII commercials. I'm sure to your discerning eye the differences are obvious and well worth the purchase price. I'm glad you're happy. I'm sure by version 8 you'll get shit like facial recognition unlock and eye tracking. Personally, I'll be sipping on cutting edge in Google-land. You can probably find it on Apple Maps if you drive to Hawaii first.

  27. Why I dont have a smartphone by WOOFYGOOFY · · Score: 1

    Pushing updates means your phone or apps break, just one day for no apparent reason. It's why I don't have a smartphone. My SOs sucks so bad we had to buy her a tablet just so she could use her apps and read her books.

    My dumbphone is good enough . I look forward to Ubuntu tablets and phones.

    1. Re:Why I dont have a smartphone by jbeaupre · · Score: 1

      My SOs sucks so bad we had to buy her a tablet

      Has her sucking improved?

      (sorry, couldn't resist)

      --
      The world is made by those who show up for the job.
    2. Re:Why I dont have a smartphone by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You can turn off auto-update.

  28. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by petman · · Score: 2

    HTC is currently the only brand I'm willing to buy because unlike Samsung, they have figured out that locked boot-loaders are bad for business.

    Non-carrier branded Samsung phones don't have locked bootloaders.

  29. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Don't forget to include the differences between the Galaxy S1/2/3 and an S4 is:
    Infrared blaster
    NFC support / S Beam / Android Beam
    Visa PayWave compatible (yes, you can use it as a credit card)
    One touch pairing (BT, wifi)
    Group Play / Media sharing
    S Health support
    Hand-side detection (you swipe the side of your hand over the screen to take a screenshot and not some arcane key combination)
    Air Gesture (you don't actually have to touch the screen, for when your hands are dirty and whatever you want to do isn't supported by voice commands)
    Burst fire camera

    My Sony RX100 / Playmemories transfers images and engages the remote viewfinder between camera and phone with one touch.

    Meanwhile, iUsers have to:
    0) If you haven't installed PlayMemories, go to the store. Search for playmemories, hit install.
    1) If you're already connected to an access point, hit settings, hit wifi, hit disconnect (however you do it).
    2) If you haven't set up the wifi access point on your phone yet, you'll have to do that. Hit Settings, hit wifi, hit the entry after doing #3
    3) On camera, hit menu, scroll to Transfer page, hit "Transfer to Smartphone"
    4) If you did step 2, enter the randomly generated password without making a mistake.
    5) Hit home, scroll to where ever you put the PlayMemories app. Click on it.
    6) DONE!

    For me: ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-hyqmWX3aLc )
    1) If I haven't installed PlayMemories, just touch the phone and camera together. It opens the Play Store to the Playmemories app. One button to press: Hit install.
    2-5) Touch the two devices together.
    6) DONE!

    OMG SO EASY...

  30. Open by sydneyfong · · Score: 3, Insightful

    the definition of open: "mkdir android ; cd android ; repo init -u git://android.git.kernel.org/platform/manifest.git ; repo sync ; make"

    --
    Don't quote me on this.
    1. Re:Open by 21mhz · · Score: 1

      A good one-liner. Now honestly, have you ever tried to build and run that on a hardware of your choice?

      --
      My exception safety is -fno-exceptions.
    2. Re:Open by Jah-Wren+Ryel · · Score: 1

      OP was quoting Andy Rubin at Google explaining why android is "open" and ios is not. The point being that 3 years later, Andrdoid doesn't really qualify as open by Google's own definition.

      Google is slowly morphing into just another proprietary software corp - my feeling is that it is because of management changes where the new guys think that because google is now the biggest fish in the pond that there really isn't any point in trying to make the pond bigger, they probably feel threatened by the chance of enabling competitors.

      --
      When information is power, privacy is freedom.
    3. Re:Open by Desler · · Score: 1

      Google has always been a proprietary software company. They only open source the few bits and pieces that aren't directly moneitizable. All of their money-making software has never had its source released (search engine and Adwords/Adsense).

  31. Re:What Happens When Google Play Services is Buggy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Exactly this doesn't fix any of the users issues. It only helps Google. The carrier, manufacturer, and google will still be adding in programs the user doesn't want or need on their phone. More control of the OS is desperately needed for the users. Especially where it is tied to performance and battery life

  32. Re:What Happens When Google Play Services is Buggy by alostpacket · · Score: 2

    I do think there were some bugs to be worked out because they patched the app signature stuff, but the reality is that those ROMs are not getting Google Play from Google, nor do they officially support them.

    http://wiki.cyanogenmod.org/w/Gapps

    Incidentally, on any given day any quick check of XDA will show ROMs with a wide variety of bugs. Many of the ROMs on XDA are put together by hobbists who have figured out how to build AOSP from source. Many are quite talented and experienced but do not have a staff of QA testers, nor the inside knowledge of closed source driver APIs. So many bugs on custom ROMs revolve around the hardware driver issue. The hardware driver stuff is the bigger concern (IMHO)

    Granted, it would be nice for customers to have an official way to obtain Google Play (as they do for many other gapps)

    --
    PocketPermissions Android Permission Guide
  33. If not YouTube by tepples · · Score: 2

    I don't use the Google Play store - I don't have an account with Google

    For people who choose not to have an account with Google, what alternative to YouTube have you found useful?

    1. Re:If not YouTube by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      what alternative to YouTube have you found useful?

      Vimeo

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    2. Re:If not YouTube by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...which drags along 18 billion third party cookies with it. No 3p cookies, no video, no thanks.

    3. Re:If not YouTube by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      ...which drags along 18 billion third party cookies with it. No 3p cookies, no video, no thanks.

      It's okay, my harddrive was made in after the 90s, where we can afford to store tiny amounts of text without a concern for space usage.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    4. Re:If not YouTube by tepples · · Score: 1

      As an alternative to YouTube, Vimeo happens not to be useful for me because it bans videos related to video games. As I understand its terms of use, a video uploaded by someone other than the game's developer is considered an upload of someone else's work, and a video uploaded by the developer is considered a commercial promotion of the depicted game.

    5. Re:If not YouTube by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Then use the Vimeo Android app. You can get it on Amazon.

    6. Re:If not YouTube by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You have an Android phone or tablet with a hard drive? Which one is it?

    7. Re:If not YouTube by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      My Android phone has a 64GB SDHC card, as well as 16GB internal storage.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    8. Re:If not YouTube by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      You'd probably prefer ustream, twitchtv, justin.tv, livestream, blog tv then.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
  34. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by alostpacket · · Score: 2

    He didn't say anything about how Apple supports their devices, just that manufacturers and carriers want to sell devices as much as Apple does. He then notes that but they want to do it without having to upgrade the older ones. I think you're being a bit defensive there bud. The only misconception of reality here is in what you think he said. Apple's support of older devices is great. Google's is getting much better, especially given the logistical challenges of Android. (This is the whole point of the article). It's other manufacturers and carriers that are terrible.

    --
    PocketPermissions Android Permission Guide
  35. Games on F-Droid by tepples · · Score: 2

    F-Droid has a pretty good catalog nowadays. I've eliminated everything proprietary from my phone life except for Google Maps and those pesky hardware drivers.

    Has the community figured out a business model for funding development of a video game for distribution under a license for free software and free cultural works? Or do you just choose not to play video games more complex than Solitaire?

    1. Re:Games on F-Droid by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      Has the community figured out a business model for funding development of a video game for distribution under a license for free software and free cultural works?

      Yes, the community has figured out how to do 'Kickstarter' campaigns.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    2. Re:Games on F-Droid by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Look at Battle for Wesnoth or Nikki and the Robots for examples of commercial free software but not necessarily free culture.

  36. iPod touch 4 by tepples · · Score: 2

    The iPhone 4 was discontinued October of 2011 and is slated to also get iOS 7 coming out later this year.

    The fourth-generation iPod touch was discontinued a year later, in October 2012, and isn't getting iOS 7. This means that for example, someone who bought an iPod touch a year ago won't be able to use a game controller, as game controller support is new in iOS 7.

    1. Re:iPod touch 4 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is, unfortunately, an issue with the minimum RAM target of iOS7. iOS7 includes a set of minimum standards that programs targeted for it will have available, which includes at least 512 MB of RAM. The iPOD touch 4G only has 256MB of RAM. The iPhond 4, which has similar hardware, but has 512 MB of RAM, will be able to get iOS 7. This is unfortunate and sad, but, given that each iOS main version is considered a development platform target instead of the hardware, I can see why this was neccessary. I'm more upset that apple decided to cut the corner on the iPOD touch 4G and half the RAM in it as compared to the similar iPhone 4.

    2. Re:iPod touch 4 by tepples · · Score: 1

      Then let me rephrase: Why isn't controller support backported to iOS 6? Why should reading a controller need 512 MiB of RAM? My NES has 2 KiB of RAM and 16 KiB of ROM (not counting video memory) and it reads the controller.

  37. Pay to the order of by tepples · · Score: 1

    I'm not sure what I'm missing out on by having not installed Gapps.

    If your bank makes its check/cheque deposit application for Android available only on Google Play Store, not on Amazon or direct APK download, you'll have to take the bus to the ATM to deposit a payment that you receive from a relative.

    1. Re:Pay to the order of by taxman_10m · · Score: 1

      i don't understand then. Over the weekend i did cyanogenmod w/out google apps, but i have the play store on my phone right now.

    2. Re:Pay to the order of by Andy+Dodd · · Score: 1

      This is not possible, unless you just reflashed CM over an existing install that had gapps - CM has a built in backup system that lets addon packages create a backup script which will be used by the CM installer. The most well known user of this feature is gapps - so it gets backed up and reinstalled any time you flash a CM update.

      --
      retrorocket.o not found, launch anyway?
  38. Open-source? Meh by chickybrick · · Score: 5, Insightful

    "Of course it's an open-source OS! But we moved all the important parts to a closed-source mega-app which can give itself permission to do anything it wants."

    Having said that, I'm not sure I want to start bashing Google too much. People complain about fragmentation and feature exclusion, but complain again when Google introduces a work-around to deal with slow vendor updates. Damned both ways, and if there was a simple, easy solution that did not entirely lock down the OS, it would have pushed out already.

    1. Re:Open-source? Meh by m.alessandrini · · Score: 1

      Indeed. It all depends on where they put the line between essential OS services and google's extra services.

    2. Re:Open-source? Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They would have the best of both worlds if they do the end run around the OEMs *AND* make it an open. They are getting ire because they are not doing the latter. (BTW, whatever happened to the "do no evil" motto? We never hear about that these days and their behavior seems to suggest we never will again.)

    3. Re:Open-source? Meh by knarf · · Score: 1

      You don't actually need those Google services to run whatever you want on your device. It is easy and painless togo without, either by using one of the ccompeting 'app stores' or by foregoing on the app store concept altogether and installing whatever you want manually - as I've done since day 1 on android. So yes, android is open source and can be used like any other open source system.

      --
      --frank[at]unternet.org
    4. Re:Open-source? Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If they really want to force vendors to give Google control of updates to certain parts of the phone they could just insist on that being in the contracts like Apple does. If they wanted to do it by putting OS features in this goofy God program instead, they would have put the God program under the Apache license just like Android. Certainly anything that provides APIs to non-Google applications should be considered part of the OS and under Apache license.

      However if the goal is to increase their control and shut out free software and competitors, then they would make their God program just comprehensive enough to become essential (provides important APIs to third party applications, mission accomplished!) and make it proprietary. And that's exactly what they did.

    5. Re:Open-source? Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, let's just make life harder for ourselves by managing everything manually (no stores, manual software updates, no Google apps due to unavailable dependencies, etc).

      Are you just trying to do things the hard way to improve your geek cred? Cos a true geek knows how to use tech to make life easier for themselves, not harder. Besides, going without seems rather dull and sterile in this world (plus you'll be seen as a weirdo for trying to be so different for no obvious, tangible gain).

    6. Re:Open-source? Meh by chickybrick · · Score: 1

      The core Google apps for Android have always been closed source, which is why they aren't (supposed to be, anyway) distributed along with custom ROMs and you have to download them as a separate package. Since they tie in so closely with this God program, presumably said God application has to also be closed-source to prevent exposing anything (APIs, whatever) the apps utilize.

      It would be nice if the core apps were open-source, but when the cards are down it shows that the open-source ideology only exists for Google when it's convenient, and not as a complete philosophy to be strictly followed.

  39. Re:What Happens When Google Play Services is Buggy by AmiMoJo · · Score: 1

    Updates are not mandatory, and you can easily install old versions of Google apps. I am currently running the last V6.x issue of Maps, for example, because the new V7.x ones don't have the navigation without destination feature I use every day.

    --
    const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
    SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
  40. Changes on a daily basis ?? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    And since they own it and update it any time they feel like it might it be used to :

    Install/uninstall Spyware when they feel like it ??

    Applications that use it be locked out unless the App seller come across with some CASH at any time Google chooses??

    Seriously -- parts of the OS or App services that change constantly without the users permission ... great way to make it an even bigger moving target for developers.

  41. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Pi1grim · · Score: 1

    Visa PayWave is based on NFC, so, basically any phone with it will work, same for "one touch pairing".
    "Burst fire" for cam is purely software feature.
    Take a look at Nexus 4, then back at your G4, then again at Nexus 4, then look at the price of Nexus 4, then at the price of your G4, then go in the corner and wheep. On the way there you might buy an aftermarket Qi charging coil for your G4.

  42. Re:Posting by Wootery · · Score: 1

    Grammer

    I like to think I'm not normally a Grammar Nazi, but that made me twitch.

  43. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Nerdfest · · Score: 2

    HTC also didn't really "figure it out". About 40000 people posted complaints on their FaceBook page.

  44. Ask and ye shall receive by Skythe · · Score: 1

    Your answer to "fragmentation" is here

  45. Thanks, device manufacturers, by Thry · · Score: 3, Insightful

    All your laziness has led to proprietary, closed-source services being dropped on the phone to cover your asses.

  46. Am I the only one? by gravis777 · · Score: 3

    Going through the comments, it seems as if I am the only person who seems to think this is a good thing. I got a name-brand phone, but its on a discount carrier. Surprisingly, Cyanogen does not have a fork for my phone (apparently, even though this phone is the most popular Samsung Galaxy my carrier carries, it is still not popular enough for a Cyanogen Mod ROM). My phone is stuck on 2.3.6, meaning that I can't use TWC app on it. I don't think my provider has EVER pushed out an OTA update for any of their phones. My old phone was on 2.0, but luckily there was a Cyanogen Mod for it (actually, it was not an official release, had to dig through forums to find people working on it), and was able to get it to 2.3

    My tablett is worse - it is made by an off-name brand chinese company (actually considering wiping it next year and giving it to a friend and picking up a Nexus), and it is only that they released a VERY SIMILAR tablet with a newer OS on it that I was able to get the thing to update to 4.1, otherwise I would still be stuck on 2.1. However, because the phone is rooted, I cannot view Ultraviolet content on it. (Stupid, really, as Netflix works just fine)

    So to get updated features, I have to root my device, mess with half a dozen ROMs before finding one that works, go back into the Cyanogen Mod settings (if there is a Cyanogen Mod ROM, otherwise whatever ROM you are using) and punch in my carrier details, hoping my data and texts still work, and run the risk of possibly bricking my device.

    Now Google is talking about pushing out updates through the Play Store? What a brilliant idea! Give people new features without them having to Root their phones or install custom ROMs. This will also mean for app developers that more devices will have newer features, allowing special features of your app to run on more devices. This sounds like a VERY good thing.

    If you don't like it, block the updates. But for the rest of us, this sounds like a great idea, and I can't wait for Google to push out thier first new updates, and hope this means better app support on my devices.

  47. Solution: CM10.1 w/o GAPPS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I've been running CM 10.1 without GAPPS and I love not having Google controlling my phone remotely.

  48. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Desler · · Score: 2

    I can't tell the difference between an iPhone 3G and an iPhone 5 was my point.

    Are you legally blind? Different case design and materials, larger screen, higher resolution screen, faster CPU/GPU, etc. You're being intentional dense.

  49. google updates make my phone useless by a2wflc · · Score: 1

    I have a low-end phone. It came with a number of google apps that "work" (google play music/books/mags, youtube, google+). When I set "automatically update" it gives me new versions that eat up the battery, run in the background when I don't want, or fail to update because they are too big. I can't disable the new apps unless I uninstall back to the original and I can't uninstall the original but only disable it. So I have to update manually and only get the apps I want to update.

  50. Typical Tupe666 comment by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Google OPEN! Made in USA! Google! GOOGLE! SERGEY! MOTOROLA!

    Apple! China! Evil! Closed source! Walled garden! Sheeple! Google!

  51. Re: Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufactur by GrahamJ · · Score: 1

    Apple doesn't do what you claim. They release major OS versions along with new hardware but they do release point updates in between. Major versions generally work as far back as four hardware generations and all devices can be updated as soon as updates are released. It is by far the best update situation in the industry.

  52. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Andy+Dodd · · Score: 1

    "which is why the Galaxy S is on version 4" - bullshit. The original Aries family deadended at Gingerbread, despite the fact that they were nearly identical spec-wise to the Nexus S which made it as far as 4.0 or 4.1 (I can't remember if crespo got 4.1 or if it EOLed when 4.2 was released...)

    This is despite the fact that the community had 4.0 running within a few weeks, has released 4.1 and 4.2 for that device, and even 4.3 seems to be coming along OK so far.

    --
    retrorocket.o not found, launch anyway?
  53. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Andy+Dodd · · Score: 1

    Right now, as much as I dislike Samsung, I have to give them credit with respect to bootloader locking. Verizon devices were the ONLY bootloader-locked Samsungs until the Galaxy S4, when AT&T was added to the list. Note that pretty much all HTCs on these carriers have been locked down too. (The One on AT&T is strange, I think HTC intentionally "made a mistake" by whitelisting these devices.)

    --
    retrorocket.o not found, launch anyway?
  54. Closed & proprietary you say by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Jobs laughs

    1. Re:Closed & proprietary you say by spacepimp · · Score: 1

      Stupid comment is stupid, and nobody laughed.

  55. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by gstoddart · · Score: 1

    Ask any iPhone 3G user that upgraded to iOS 5 whether they think this is a good or bad thing.

    Or anybody with an original iPad ... iOS 5.5 is a crashy pile of junk, and I wish I could roll back to an older version, but sadly 'wiping' the device just deletes everything but doesn't affect the version of the OS.

    To me, two years was far too short of a time to support the device given what I paid for it -- so my iPad has largely been relegated to a corner and my Nexus 7 gets used in its place.

    The only thing I miss is support for Digital Copies I got with DVDs/Blu Rays that I bought, because I have quite a few of them. If Apple would just put iTunes out for Android, I'd be set, but somehow I doubt they'll do that.

    --
    Lost at C:>. Found at C.
  56. Re:Anything that bypasses the carriers/manufacture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'm fairly certain you don't understand the difference between the artificial world of chess and the very real world of business, in which there are no queens, and Samsung is soundly whupping up on HTC's ass.

  57. There is no iOS 5.5 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There is no iOS 5.5, the last version of iOS 5 was 5.1.1.

  58. Re:Posting by ConceptJunkie · · Score: 1

    Come to the Dark Side... we have "whom".

    --
    You are in a maze of twisty little passages, all alike.
  59. Android and Google Play or or iOS and iTunes? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Honestly both iOS and Android have something to offer.
    For the "I just want it to work, when I email, (use the phone, text, tweet, keep my calendar) and not to have to think about it. iOS is your friend. plan on paying Cupertino and to a lesser extent you wireless service provider your unending high rent rental.
    For those (ahem geeks) who don't mind paying that some of that rental fee in mental sweat (learning), you can use Android, CM and potentially Linux if Ubuntu or FoxOS plays their cards right. Which of course requires Opensource hardware (drivers) and the Opensouce coders. Then you get back the ability to use 'your' hardware as you see fit; Where you largely own the keys to your closed garden. Of course this isn't possible without Google staying committed to hardware where you can boot the OS which you prefer.
    I've been in the iOS world, but with the possibility of Linux running my smart phone, which is a practical non-starter for an iOS device? Google and Android get's my next upgrade.

  60. Re:Posting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That doesn't make you a Grammar Nazi. That makes you a Spelling Nazi.

  61. Kickstarter is region coded by tepples · · Score: 1

    Would you name some notable Free video games that were funded through Kickstarter, so that I and other developers who are first-time users of Kickstarter can understand how this tool was used successfully in the past and in this way figure out how best to use this tool? And what's the best way to approach establishing a US, UK, or Canadian subsidiary in order to qualify under KS's guidelines?

    1. Re:Kickstarter is region coded by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      Would you name some notable Free video games that were funded through Kickstarter

      Trick question! Despite knowing many games, I can't even think of one I'd consider notable from this year. AAA titles like Bioshock: Infinite in my opinion aren't even notable.

      I and other developers who are first-time users of Kickstarter can understand how this tool was used successfully in the past and in this way figure out how best to use this tool?

      You may wish to look at examples of other open source projects using kickstarter, such as openphoto while also looking at how the bigger funding kickstarters managed to acquire large resources/funding (such as with Star Citizen). To be frank, I do not see how the subject of an opensource license or free game blocks you here.

      And what's the best way to approach establishing a US, UK, or Canadian subsidiary in order to qualify under KS's guidelines?

      It cost me £15 to register a limited company in the UK and it was fairly trivial to figure out using Google. I'm not giving advice on what to do here, I just don't really understand what stops you from finding this out on your own.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    2. Re:Kickstarter is region coded by tepples · · Score: 1

      Trick question! Despite knowing many games, I can't even think of one I'd consider notable from this year. AAA titles like Bioshock: Infinite in my opinion aren't even notable.

      By notable, I was referring to a video game that "has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of" the game's developer or publisher. For example, a major online encyclopedia's article about BioShock Infinite cites over 200 sources. I was assuming that if I could find an open source game that had been covered by the news media, I could read the coverage and look for what went right.

      You may wish to look at examples of other open source projects using kickstarter

      The article "Crowdfunding Video Games" by JD Alois claims that a successful campaign starts by "Leveraging strong social network ties". So how would one go about getting those "strong social network ties" in the first place?

      To be frank, I do not see how the subject of an opensource license or free game blocks you here.

      The mentality I anticipate is "Why pledge now, if I can just download the game as free software later?"

      It cost me £15 to register a limited company in the UK

      Plus however much it costs to staff the UK mailing address and handle accounting for this UK limited company.

    3. Re:Kickstarter is region coded by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      The article "Crowdfunding Video Games" by JD Alois claims that a successful campaign starts by "Leveraging strong social network ties". So how would one go about getting those "strong social network ties" in the first place?

      My project (also FOSS) did it through our links in the Second life combat community through being an already pre-existing and active participating group in the community. This probably doesn't help you since it's specific to our project. If there was a universal formula and method, everyone would be doing it. In reality, you will likely have to custom tailor your plans for your situation, fanbase (if any) etc. I don't see how being an opensource project prevents you from doing this - It didn't stop mine.

      The mentality I anticipate is "Why pledge now, if I can just download the game as free software later?"

      If you looked at other projects, they generally offer those who pledge some unique type of opportunities such as special characters, badges, early access, etc.

      Plus however much it costs to staff the UK mailing address and handle accounting for this UK limited company.

      I used my home address and did it myself (seriously, it's not hard), but there are many agencies out there that will handle this for you - Maybe you should ask them for a quote?

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
  62. Re:Posting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Spelling is part of grammar, you Stupid Nazi. I apologize for offending your Nazi self with these anti-stupid statements. I expect that you'll point out the lack of stupidity therein.

  63. Incentive to go to Ubuntu by JohnFen · · Score: 1

    This move by Google may be the best thing to happen to Ubuntu's OS. I know that, personally, Ubuntu's offering hasn't interested me at all -- but if Google really wants to go this direction, I'll have little choice but to go with Ubuntu.

  64. Re:Posting by Wootery · · Score: 1

    Tempting.... tempting...

  65. google + root access = by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    bad news for android owners.

  66. Apps hidden behind the anti-feature curtain by tepples · · Score: 1

    F-Droid has a pretty good catalog nowadays. I've eliminated everything proprietary from my phone life

    Look at [these games] for examples of commercial free software but not necessarily free culture.

    Reliance on proprietary data appears to mean that the developer has to list anti-features. For example, an application distributed as free software that relies on non-free assets would need the NonFreeAdd anti-feature. The F-Droid client defaults to hiding all apps with anti-features. How many people set it to show apps with anti-features?

    1. Re:Apps hidden behind the anti-feature curtain by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    2. Re:Apps hidden behind the anti-feature curtain by tepples · · Score: 1

      I saw it the first time.

  67. Note: "hosts file guy"? No, "Lord of hosts" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://developers.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=4162427&cid=44754641 = "better" (than yours on the 'point' you made), "young lad", lol! Try to see MY point there though (not a toy but can't let him *think* that, with 1 liners). "Touche", my boy...

    APK

  68. I put on my robe and tinfoil hat by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What I find interesting is that three months ago, when the PRISM news started and people were all paranoid of anything the NSA did (including writing code for Android), one of the arguments against NSA bugs in Android was "yes but Android is all open source, anyone can review the code and check there are no bugs there". While that may be true in itself (and I'm not suspicious of the NSA contributions to Android itself, much like I'm not paranoid of SELinux), if the NSA or other intelligence services did want to hide bugs in everyone's phone, Google Play Services would be the perfect place to do so. Closed source, system level, granted pretty much every Android permission, can grant itself new permissions without user consent... I could be being paranoid here, and I'm not saying Google Play Services is definitely bugged. But this does clearly show that the argument "there can't be any NSA bugs in Android because it's open source" is false, since while the base system is open source, almost all Android devices have this closed source, system level, highly powerful binary blob.

  69. You marvelled @ my magnificance... apk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No doubt: Seeing as it struck you "speechless" there... not to worry - it's a common result of those attempting to 'troll me' being schooled (as you were, easily).

    * "You know it, I know it - now? Anyone/Everyone else reading will too...

    (Hard results, facts, truth, & "better technology" always does the job!)

    APK

    P.S.=> It's not easy, being 'world-class', like me (@ being unable to silence trolls such as yourself)... apk

  70. Re:You marvelled @ my magnificEnce... apk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Sorry - had to do typo correction before grammar/spelling nazis do! See my subject-line for correct spelling of "Magnificence"...

    APK

  71. Google Play is dangerous by allo · · Score: 1

    Play updates itself, in the background and without asking the user. Even when you configured, that you need to confirm updates, the play store updates itself silently in the background.
    You may lose features of old versions, get annoying new features, but the worst is, Google is part of prism, and can execute any new code on your phone, anytime they want.

    F-Droid is cool, but missing the commercial apps.

    Amazon appstore could be an option, because it needs to use the android "install APK" Function with a confimation dialog, while google play can not only update itself, but even other apps without showing this dialog.

    Maybe ROMs like cyanogen should alter Android, such that the play store has the same restrictions as other apps.