Slashdot Mirror


Micromax Remotely Installing Unwanted Apps and Showing Ads

jones_supa (887896) writes "Reports are coming in that users of certain devices by Indian phone manufacturer Micromax noticed apps being silently installed without their consent or permission. Uninstalling these apps won't help, as they will be automatically reinstalled. Alternatively, instead of downloading apps, the phone might litter the UI with stack of notifications which are advertisements for online stores and other apps. It turns out that the "System Update" application is responsible for all of this. When starting to tear down the application (which is actually called FWUpgrade.apk on the filesystem), the first thing you notice is that it's a third-party application. A Chinese company named Adups developed it as a replacement for the stock Google OTA service. The article shows the potential abilities of this app and how Micromax customers can work around the disruptive behavior."

50 comments

  1. Then don't buy their phones by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Problem solved.

    1. Re: Then don't buy their phones by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Tell that to the people who have already done it and Don't afford another sà soon.

    2. Re: Then don't buy their phones by alen · · Score: 2

      They don't have free phones where you live?

      USA FTW

    3. Re: Then don't buy their phones by unixisc · · Score: 2

      In India, they don't. Phones are always purchased separately, and the SIM is what is sold with the contract, and the installation is done at that point.

    4. Re: Then don't buy their phones by moronoxyd · · Score: 2

      You don't have free phones in the USA, either.
      You are just paying in installments rather than up front, and chances are you paying more in the end than if you bought the phone separately.

    5. Re: Then don't buy their phones by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Contracts are on the way out in the US. You pay by the month until you pay the full cost of the phone. It's the same either way.

    6. Re: Then don't buy their phones by kelemvor4 · · Score: 1

      They don't have free phones where you live?

      USA FTW

      Hello hefty cancellation fine (or collection agency/bad credit) in the USA. Free phones are kind of like free North Koreans.

    7. Re: Then don't buy their phones by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      chances are you paying more in the end than if you bought the phone separately.

      Well, we always knew that Apple users love anal. That just proves it.

    8. Re: Then don't buy their phones by Paradise+Pete · · Score: 1

      They don't have free phones where you live? USA FTW

      Either this is some attempt at ironic humor or you're fooling yourself. Which is it?

  2. Flawed by design . . . by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    just as Google knew it would be used.

    1. Re:Flawed by design . . . by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Totally not like Apple's iAd?

      http://advertising.apple.com/

      I know, because it has "i" in front makes it "trendy and OK"?

    2. Re:Flawed by design . . . by ClaraBow · · Score: 1

      Apple iAds don't install unwanted apps nor does it flood your phone with adverts! iAds are used by developers who chose to place adverts in their apps.

    3. Re:Flawed by design . . . by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      I know. the point the other guy was implying is google intended andoid to be a platform for ads. Apple had the same intention as that is one way to generate revenue.

    4. Re:Flawed by design . . . by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      False. The overwhelming majority of apples revenue is from hardware sales.

    5. Re:Flawed by design . . . by moronoxyd · · Score: 1

      Neither does Googles Android.
      RTFA, the culprit is a replacement app developed by a third party.

    6. Re:Flawed by design . . . by r1348 · · Score: 1

      I'm not entirely sure they can cherry-pick and replace single Google apps, they can of course use the Android stack without Google apps and services (that's what Amazon does).

    7. Re:Flawed by design . . . by thunderclap · · Score: 1

      Apple iAds don't install unwanted apps nor does it flood your phone with adverts! iAds are used by developers who chose to place adverts in their apps.

      Most of Apple's apps are unwanted.

    8. Re:Flawed by design . . . by Paradise+Pete · · Score: 1

      Apple sells ads in the same way that Google sells hardware. They both do it, but it's not a significant part of the business.

  3. It's not illegal, so they will do it by linebackn · · Score: 2

    Isn't this already the business model for most "apps" these days? The only thing surprising here is they aren't sugar coating it with pleasant sounding euphemisms.

    Yea, some of us used computers with only 4K of RAM and remember a day when this kind of shit would have been unthinkable even if it were possible.

    But it isn't expressly illegal, so expect more of this. Don't buy something that does this? Sure, enjoy that option while it lasts.

    1. Re: It's not illegal, so they will do it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      4k ?

      Noob, we started with 1k back in the day and learned how to make the most of it !

    2. Re:It's not illegal, so they will do it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      as an Indian I can tell you NOTHING is illegal if you have money (much less than what it would take in US for eqv effect). Problem is there is nothing precluding other manufacturers from doing the same! Believe me it does not takes much to introduce full user tracking in these smart devices. THIS is the reason why we need a fully opensourced android (& yes I know about cyno) incarnation that these devices can build on top of.

    3. Re:It's not illegal, so they will do it by unixisc · · Score: 1

      Cyano is there, Replicant is there... Problem you have is that in India, very few people will know how to set that up for end users. Those with that sort of expertise would probably already have pretty good jobs in the IT sector and wouldn't bother to have a service in fixing phone firmware that would typically pay pretty poorly

    4. Re:It's not illegal, so they will do it by tlhIngan · · Score: 3, Informative

      Isn't this already the business model for most "apps" these days?

      Only on Android.

      If you have an app, on iOS, you'll make more money selling it ad-free outright in the App Store. But on Android, you won't make much if you sell it outright - you're far better off putting ads in the app.

      Ad-based apps on Android generate far more money than ad-based apps on iOS. LIkewise, Ad-free paid apps on iOS generate far more money than paid apps on Android. (Usually because the Play Store isn't available everywhere, nor is Google Checkout/Wallet, so if you have a paid app, that pretty much eliminates your app from showing up in half the places Google Play is available).

      So no, raping customer information is NOT a standard business model. Especially since on iOS you can restrict access to your contacts, location/photos (which are a location proxy). Hell, you can't even track a user across apps easily anymore.

  4. i had a similar worry with a Logicom E350 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    i was proposed an ota update,in France at the end of 2014(november?), for a cheap android 4.2.2 device branded logicom E350, since i had some ads popping up at each action, and finally i discovered malwares as cube.apk , fake google search,
    i am not sure 100% they were brought by the update but i found a recovery folder containing a log with the cube.apk , fake google search, if i guess right, it's created by the ota, to flash the o.s . i may be wrong, but i've writen to Logicom commercial service, to warn them(in case of ota hijack or claim for explainations) without any reply since several months.
    i had to root my device, very painful when it's a cheap, not well known model/brand, i spent hours to find how to do that and to get rid of malwares with root , and risking to delete an essential system file(because you have to delete all the pieces else they will auto reinstall at the next reboot): so beware of cheap, exotics brands or models

  5. Wow ... by cascadingstylesheet · · Score: 1

    ... the only thing worse would be apps you don't want preinstalled, and no ability to uninstall them at all!

  6. Indians being unscrupulous...i'm shocked! Shocked! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Shocked i tells ya!

  7. This sounds familiar... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is not unlike what AT&T has been doing recently to its android customers.
    Every manditory system update (the ones that get pushed without warning when on wifi) has turned into a game of what app did they add and force active this time.

    Last time it was uber and a "you're in range of an affiliates wifi, you should sign up" bit of aware.

    1. Re:This sounds familiar... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sprint does it as well, only they don't only do it with the mandatory system updates, they actually have apps on the phone that can just remotely add other apps whenever they want. When you buy the phones they are in a generic non branded state, the phone then downloads all the "sprint apps" once it figures out it is on sprint and not say virgin mobile. That package contains all sorts of non first party apps, uber, the wifi affiliate thing, some games, some app stores, their "connection optimizer" that basically tries to get your phone on wifi constantly so they don't have to deal with your "unlimited data" traffic.

  8. So by Greyfox · · Score: 1

    Has anyone ported cyanogenmod to the phone yet? That's my default answer to the heaping helping of unwanted crap that always seem to get bundled with my phones.

    --

    I'm trying to teach myself to set people on fire with my mind... Is it hot in here?

    1. Re:So by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In India, anybody who's technical enough to know how to replace Android with cyanogenmod probably has a much higher profile job and wouldn't set up an inexpensive or free service replacing the OS: it would hardly pay for his meals

    2. Re:So by arvindsg · · Score: 1

      You both over estimate the salaries of Indian techies and underestimate the cheapness of Indians.

    3. Re:So by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      On the latter - cheapness of Indians, I didn't underestimate them. I know they are pretty cheap, so they're not going to fork out Rs 500 to get CM on their phones. They'd rather put up with the malware, as long as it's free. As far as salaries of Indian techies go, while they may be low (in terms of $$$, not Rs), they're certainly far higher than what they'd be if they tried setting up stores that would fix the OSs on smart phones.

  9. Samsung does this too... by buckfeta2014 · · Score: 2

    My phone is constantly downloading shit I don't want. Luckily for me I can freeze it all.

    --
    Buck Feta. You know what to do.
    1. Re:Samsung does this too... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I block the downloads with a little firewall app called Droidwall.

    2. Re:Samsung does this too... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not downloading, but I noticed this trend of unwanted and unremovable apps pretty common in India while I was there - and this was before even smartphones. I had an LG phone as well as a Motorola Yuva (while Motorola still had operations in that country) and they'd come preinstalled with a whole list of useless apps, plus wallpapers, which you couldn't even delete. It was a frustrating experience. With the smartphones - in case of Android, one could, if one knew how, replace it with cyanogenmod, assuming that the model is supported. Apple and Microsoft are much cleaner

    3. Re:Samsung does this too... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You shouldn't need a firewall in a well designed system...

    4. Re:Samsung does this too... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wait, Android has a 'feature' that allows unremovable third party apps?

      What the actual fuck?!?!?

      Who would buy a system with that sort of feature?

    5. Re:Samsung does this too... by unixisc · · Score: 1

      You always need a firewall to keep unwanted intruders out!

    6. Re: Samsung does this too... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Android being open means the carriers can do what they please to it.

  10. Sounds like Google by spacefight · · Score: 2, Insightful

    ...when they introduced Google Play Music etc. via regular Updates through the Play Store.

    1. Re:Sounds like Google by wiredlogic · · Score: 2, Informative

      Had to terminate that POS because it's ALWAYS RUNNING and chewing up RAM on my 1GiB phone. WTF Google?

      --
      I am becoming gerund, destroyer of verbs.
  11. Re:Indians being unscrupulous...i'm shocked! Shock by Tablizer · · Score: 1

    They learned well from their USA capitalist teachers.

  12. Re:Indians being unscrupulous...i'm shocked! Shock by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    They learned well from their USA capitalist teachers.

    More like the English East India Company.

  13. Samsung does this too... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My Samsung phone came littered with so much garbage that I can't uninstall, only "disable." Stuff that wants to sell me crap, stuff takes up CPU cycles and phones home like a chatty teenager. Nothing of interest to me.

  14. verizon plasters ads too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    on dumb feature flip phones no less. our newer basic verizon phones (we do not have any 'smart phones') have ads half the time we flip them open to make a call. so fucking annoying and no way to disable or opt out of them short of telling verizon to fuck off and switch to tmobile (which unfortunately isn't really an option because gsm has shitty or no coverage around here).

  15. stock android by jakesyl · · Score: 1

    Fuck them, just install stock android