Slashdot Mirror
Easy-To-Clean Membrane Separates Oil From Water
ckwu writes: A steel mesh with a novel self-cleaning coating can separate oil and water, easily lifting oil from an oil-water mixture and leaving the water behind. Unlike existing oil-water separation membranes, if the coated mesh gets contaminated with oil, it can be simply rinsed off with water and reused, without needing to be cleaned with detergents. The team was able to use the mesh to lift crude oil from a crude oil-seawater mixture, showcasing the feasibility of oil-spill cleanup. The membrane could also be used to treat oily wastewater and as a protective barrier in industrial sewer outlets to avoid oil discharge.
It separates oil from water because the oil sticks to the mesh and the water doesn't, but then you clean it with water???? Surely they don't expect us to believe this magic.
I bet a lot of people who have contaminated well water thanks to fracking are going to love this!
Okay oil sticks to mesh coated with a phosphorylcholine-based polymer membrane. Sounds not-cheap. Next you wash the oil build-up off with water. This happens because the polymer has an affinity for water. Next...what comes next? Where does the oil-water mixture go? Is it shipped to a facility that can properly treat it or are they simply moving the problem to another location?
Ok, sorry, but....
You catch oil in WATER with a mesh to separate out the oil from the WATER.
You then wash the mesh with WATER to remove the oil.
What am i missing oh sageous scientists and wannabe slashdottersists?
Lennart has announced he's implementing one of those filters to remove corruped binary logs.
US law requires that all oil collected by vacuum ships be brought to a processing facility, where 100% of all oil must be removed prior to the water being discharged.
During the Deepwater Horizon disaster, there were serious delays in the US accepting offers of help from the Netherlands and other nations. Most of them came with a price tag, but the Dutch offered three sets of Koseq Rigid Sweeping Arms for free. Because they were only 98% efficient, and they were initially refused.
However, common sense (and desperation) won out in the end, and we started accepting all the offers for free equipment that came in, including the Dutch offer.
Reference article
[End Of Line]
The coating lives water and repels oil. Pull it thru an oil-water mix and the water flows thru the holes but the oil doesn't.
Pull it out and it contains a puddle of oil. Rinse it with a little water and the oil comes right off, ready for reuse.
This isn't that uncommon in these types of filters. What is new is that this works dry. Other filters of this type have to be thoroughly wet before they work. This one is oleophobic when dry as well. So no fancy prep to get it to work.
Learning HOW to think is more important than learning WHAT to think.
Perhaps the temperature of the water? The pressure at which it is applied? There are ways.
When our name is on the back of your car, we're behind you all the way!
At best, you are off-topic, at worst a troll.
And you've given them the attention they desperately crave. Idiot.
See subject: It sounds like a GREAT thing that could be applied there.
* The reason I state this is, last I knew of @ least (not a big current events man on the environmental front here) it was STILL a big mess there with the oil spill.
See - I was in Mobile Alabama, Fairhope specifically, in 2002, & it's a beautiful place... it'd be a shame to know it's beyond recovery + the utter shame of destroying all that sealife that never did a damn thing to people having to die for no reason like that is a shame.
I've seen "jubilee" there (look it up) & it's like a gift from God, free fresh food from the sea (attributed to sudden oxygen loss iirc since the gulf is VERY shallow for miles into it, you can actually walk way, Way, WAY out into it down where I was learning about crabbing in cages from folks I stayed with)... again, a shame to mess such a wonderful natural phenomenon up, when this invention sounds like the ticket to fix it possibly.
APK
P.S.=> Someone "more in the know" fill me in &/or feel free to correct me if need be - I can stand to learn a new thing or learn it better as much as the next person does (thanks in advance)... apk
Fair call. In reality, I think that this was just the straw that broke the camel's back because I just have gotten so sick of seeing that kind of stuff in the comments, and I just kinda snapped.
If fracking contaminated well water with oil, I'm sure they would. Unfortunately, the claim is that fracking contaminates well water with fracking compounds used by the driller, not the oil. This does them no good at all.
Quite right... the water wells are seldom contaminated with oil. Salty production water, carcinogenic solvents, and as yet mystery fracking chemicals are much more common invaders of the fresh water table due to drilling activities.
Every well drilled for oil/gas exploitation travels through the water table to get to the energy reservoir. There is an industry practice of casing these wells with concrete to below where the water table ends, altruistically protecting the water table from the well.
Consider the millions of producing US wells alone: a fraction of a percent of casing failures would still be a huge number of well contaminations. Add the number of all wells drilled since Titusville in 1896, and factor in the likelihood that the older wells were less concerned with safety.
Happiness in intelligent people is the rarest thing I know.
Ernest Hemingway
What am i missing
Perhaps it takes a lot less wash water than the amount that is cleaned per cycle. Typical of many filtering systems.
Have gnu, will travel.
Can they make a few hundred square kilometers of this filter to clean up oil spills on the sea?
Yeah, won't someone think of saving all that potable seawater. Wait...what?
> if the coated mesh gets contaminated with oil
If I filter oil, the mesh gets oily. What's the reason for the 'if'?
It is something that aids in the cleanup of oil spills, so it will be banned on irrational ground in order to maximise the amount of damages they can extract from foreign oil companies, like they did with Deepwater Horizon.
As a mechanic, sometimes you drain the antifreeze to work on a car, but the pan you drain it into gets contaminated with oil and grit. So, you pour off the liquid into a large open faced pan and throw some clean rags on top. They absorb the oil, and since they're getting oily, they won't absorb the water/antifreeze mixture. I'd say this has been done since the '50's at least.
But they are getting oil out of this deal, and they love oil!
Wasn't this necessity already solved by a competition a few years back? There was an X-prize competition where several groups tested methods of removing oil from seawater. The winner by a large margin (industry standard was 1,100 gallons per minute, goal of competition was 2,500 gpm, they achieved almost twice that) was a simple concept of large rotating grooved disks of plastic, the oil would adhere to the plastic long enough to be scraped off and diverted to a holding tank. It removed far more oil than the competition required, was dirt cheap to build and simple to keep up and running.
http://www.npr.org/2011/10/19/141481055/revolutionary-oil-skimmer-nets-1-million-x-prize
Something for me to skim oil off of my soup with?