Slashdot Mirror


Samsung Sales, Profits Dive on Note 7 Recall (pcworld.com)

Samsung's smartphone division struggled to breakeven between July and September as sales plunged due to the recall of its high-end Note 7. The smartphone giant said quarterly sales in its IT and Mobile Communications division were down 15 percent on the same period last year to 22.5 trillion Korean won (US$19.8 billion) while operating profit crashed 95 percent to 100 billion won. From a PCWorld report: Problems with the Note 7 starting hitting sales shortly after it went on sale in mid-August. By early September, reports that several units had caught on fire prompted Samsung to begin a costly recall and replacement program. When it became clear that the replacements had the same problem, Samsung pulled the phone for good. Perhaps remarkably, Samsung said it saw no significant effect during the quarter on sales of its two other high-end handsets, the Galaxy S7 and S7 Edge, but it conceded that "regaining consumer confidence" will be a key objective in the months ahead. And for the current quarter, which includes the key year-end sales period, Samsung said it expects profit in the smartphone divison to bounce back to normal levels due to solid sales of the two flagship phones and increasing sales of mid-level Galaxy A- and J-series handsets. "As for 2017, the company anticipates a turnaround with the launch of new flagship smartphones," it said in a statement. "Next year will also see expansion of Samsung Pay rollouts and cloud-related services as well as the introduction of artificial intelligence related offerings."

39 comments

  1. Wow! by frovingslosh · · Score: 4, Funny

    Their profits and sales dropped after a massive recall and their products and even their replacements bursting into flame? I did not see that coming!

    --
    I'm an American. I love this country and the freedoms that we used to have.
    1. Re:Wow! by tripleevenfall · · Score: 3, Funny

      I was hopeful they'd have a good quarter, but then again, I've been burned by Samsung before.

    2. Re:Wow! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Their profits and sales dropped after a massive recall and their products and even their replacements bursting into flame? I did not see that coming!

      Don't take it too bad. An entire company was Elopped because they didn't see this coming and they believed "Samsung would be well-placed [to] dominate, which would leave no room for anyone else". This would have been their chance to take back the lead. They might be able to use this to get back into the market, but I bet they are kicking themselves that they didn't go with Android when they had the chance originally.

    3. Re:Wow! by K.+S.+Kyosuke · · Score: 1

      It's a won-won situation! (They have two wons remaining.)

      --
      Ezekiel 23:20
    4. Re:Wow! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Democratic economists are predicting another recession if Trump gets elected but anyone with a clue knows it's due to massive recalls and broke ass shit coming from companies who embraced a "global economy" of 3rd world standards.

    5. Re: Wow! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm shocked!

  2. How is this news? by It's+the+tripnaut! · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Was anyone actually expecting better profit margins because of the recall?

    1. Re:How is this news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Was anyone actually expecting better profit margins because of the recall?

      Yes, I thought they would sell the recalled devices to the military.

    2. Re:How is this news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, I thought they would sell the recalled devices to the military.

      Unfortunately, due to a misunderstanding with their brand protection department the advertising video was blocked on the internet so they failed to capitalize on the great publicity they got.

    3. Re:How is this news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's a follow-up. Is there something wrong about that? Are follow-ups forbidden too?

    4. Re:How is this news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's very unlikely, but every so often a "New Coke" turns out to be a godsend.

      Short term they'll definitely have a hit. It remains to be seen how this affects them long-term. They have been relatively proactive and generous in handling this (as compared to the admittedly less impactful "you're holding it wrong" and "bendgate"). Fast forward 2 years and there is a small chance that they will emerge stronger than they entered.

      See Johnson and Johnson, and what happened with the Tylenol scare.

  3. My plan for a Samsung turnaround by JoeyRox · · Score: 4, Funny

    Their Sales VP needs to burn the midnight oil to come up with a plan that lights a fire under the sales team to return the company to the explosive sales growth they used to enjoy.

    1. Re:My plan for a Samsung turnaround by vux984 · · Score: 4, Funny

      Their Sales VP needs [...] to come up with a plan that lights a fire under the sales team

      Easy. Make the sales team sit on the recalled note 7s.

    2. Re:My plan for a Samsung turnaround by OneHundredAndTen · · Score: 1

      They'll need something like that rekindle their self-esteem. I don't think they are bursting with pride these days.

    3. Re:My plan for a Samsung turnaround by rtb61 · · Score: 1

      I hope it is not that idiot who decided they could save $5 per phone by eliminating user removable batteries and boost sales by killing future resale of used Samsung phones, that dude cost them billions and will likely to try to keep their job by trying to keep fixed batteries (I wonder how many decades it will take for the tiny savings in going from a user replaceable battery to a fixed battery compared to the losses created by doing that, if ever).

      --
      Chaos - everything, everywhere, everywhen
  4. They need a big success by Oswald+McWeany · · Score: 1

    They need a big success to life them up after the Note 7.

    They have a lot of respect and goodwill from other buyers. I know my wife won't buy any phone that isn't Samsung. (I had one Samsung phone I loved, but I shop around more personally- I'm not brand loyal about anything).

    Another mistake like this though would really hurt Samsung. One mistake and most buyers will forgive, a second big mistake and they could rapidly lose market share.

    --
    "That's the way to do it" - Punch
    1. Re: They need a big success by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've always used Samsung, but as far I'm concerned the second recall broke the camel's back. I orderd a Pixel and will never own a Samsung product again.

    2. Re:They need a big success by dgatwood · · Score: 1

      One mistake and most buyers will forgive, a second big mistake and they could rapidly lose market share.

      Fortunately for Samsung, most buyers have poor memory. I just about gave up on the Blu-Ray format because I had so much trouble with two of their players lasting only a year or so before they stopped reading discs reliably. When I replaced my refrigerator, I seriously considered the Samsung, because (IIRC) its reviews showed ridiculous numbers of people saying that they stopped keeping food cold because of control boards dying (repeatedly)... and a refrigerator is not something you can just toss in the trash can and replace.

      This is not to say that they don't also make some products that are good. Obviously they do, or nobody would buy their products. But IMO, it takes a lot more than one or two big mistakes for a company with that much name recognition to rapidly lose market share. Otherwise, it would have happened long ago. :-)

      --

      Check out my sci-fi/humor trilogy at PatriotsBooks.

    3. Re:They need a big success by thsths · · Score: 1

      I do wonder why people buy Samsung. I got a used one for cheap, and I admit that the hardware is very nice, but the software is just terrible, and also terribly out of date. It was a flagship phone, it cost an insane amount of money new, and it was only supported for just over a year from launch. I am pretty sure it was still being sold when it was already out of support.

      So clearly Samsung is not looking after the customer, that should be perfectly obvious from every single phone they make. Why do people still buy them?

  5. 2017 Forecast by hcs_$reboot · · Score: 1

    Samsung Sales, Profits Rise despite the 2016 Note 7 Recall

    --
    Slashdot, fix the reply notifications... You won't get away with it...
  6. Barely Profitable by VorpalRodent · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I'm not totally up on my corporate accounting / investment info, but this sounds to me like - after a massive recall, they're still operating at a (admittedly tiny) profit. I'm sorry, but if you can have your products explode on people and still be in the black you're doing pretty well.

    --
    Take it to the limit, everybody to the limit, come on, everybody fhqwhgads.
    1. Re:Barely Profitable by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      That's my take as well. A company the size of Samsung should have the reserves and inertia to survive an enormous loss, but it turns out that they don't have to, because even through this exceptional catastrophe they still turned a profit.

  7. Samsung is on the decline by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I tend to believe Samsung profits will continue to decline. Here are the biggest reasons I tend to believe...

    1. Global smartphone sales will slow - Most people will wait longer & longer to replace their phones.

    2. More competition - The Chinese competitors are close to catching up in quality...is there really a big difference in quality anymore? Google Pixel phones may one day supplant as the high-end Android phone of choice.

    3. Better technology - TSMC seems to be ahead of Samsung in terms of process technology. What will Samsung do when Apple, Qualcomm and nVidia all choose to use TSMC's 10 nm process? Samsung Foundry's profits will decline. Samsung Electronics (Exynos) mobile products will be slower and more power-hungry.

    4. Intel is slowly coming - 3D Xpoint will eventually take marketshare - Too bad Intel/Micron may delay the tech for another year....but it will eventually eat at Samsung's SSD profits.

    5. The exploding Note - Samsung must have lost a few customers/fans with their handling of the exploding Note 7.

    1. Re:Samsung is on the decline by unixisc · · Score: 1

      6. Unlike Apple, which is the only iOS phone vendor, Samsung makes Android phones, which every other smartphone vendor makes, and can therefore challenge Samsung on anywhere on the price/features spectrum

    2. Re:Samsung is on the decline by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      6. Global warming - always include global warming

  8. Obligatory by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Netcraft confirms it.

  9. Make a phone with a replaceable Battery by Mr.+Droopy+Drawers · · Score: 2

    I've sat out two upgrade cycles waiting on Samsung to come up with a viable replacement for the S5. I want a battery that can be replaced by mere mortals. It doesn't have to be as easy as the S5 to do so. But, it needs to be replaceable during its lifespan without sending it off to timbuktu.

    Seems to me the whole exploding phone business wouldn't have happened had they not been bowing down to the god of thinness. S5 is a great form factor. Why do you need it smaller?

    --

    To Copy from One is Plagiarism; To Copy from Many is Research.

    1. Re:Make a phone with a replaceable Battery by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The thinness thing is a red herring. Samsung is well aware that today's generation of devices will not need to be replaced for many, many years. Gluing in batteries ensures that users will need to throw away their perfectly good devices and buy a new one within a few years.

    2. Re:Make a phone with a replaceable Battery by thegarbz · · Score: 1

      I want a battery that can be replaced by mere mortals.

      Why? No seriously why? I'm interested in the use case, especially since longevity doesn't seem to come into it since you're so keen to replace the device.

    3. Re:Make a phone with a replaceable Battery by rasmusbr · · Score: 1

      I want a battery that can be replaced by mere mortals.

      Why? No seriously why? I'm interested in the use case, especially since longevity doesn't seem to come into it since you're so keen to replace the device.

      He could be planning on selling or gifting the phone after he's used it for a year himself. It's not an uncommon use case. Niche maybe, but not unheard of.

      There is probably a good niche out there for a high end phone with a user-replaceable battery, but I don't think Samsung is interested in it. They won't do it unless Apple does it and apple is never, ever even going to consider doing it. The wear and tear is pretty much the only thing that will keep Apple's customers upgrading their iPhones. A replaceable battery would probably cut Apple's future iPhone profits in half by allowing customers to keep their phones for twice as long.

    4. Re:Make a phone with a replaceable Battery by thegarbz · · Score: 1

      That is a market that disappears with trade-ins, and ignores the fact that there are people who will happily buy devices without replaceable batteries and replace them anyway / refurbish them.

      Plus about the only batteries I can still get for my S4 are non-genuine likely to explode in my face Alibaba specials, so I don't see this as being a major benefit unless manufacturers continue to support the removable batteries ... which they don't.

    5. Re:Make a phone with a replaceable Battery by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're not a market force to be reckoned with. Outside of the same dozen complainers on Slashdot I haven't heard anyone mention anything about replaceable batteries in eons. And every time I've seen a battery replaced in recent memory it hasn't helped the issue beyond normal battery depreciation that you'd expect for find for a phone that is x years old. The phones themselves are more defective than the batteries anymore.

  10. Suprised that their midlevel phones are selling... by iampiti · · Score: 1

    well. I've found the A and J series to be mediocre and expensive for what they are. Their 2 year old flagships for 300€ are not a bad deal in my opinion.

  11. It could be worse ... by gordguide · · Score: 1

    Just this morning I read a news report from South Korea (English media) that said 85% of buyers of the Note7 in South Korea have so far refused to turn in their phones. It seems likely that a similar sentiment, regardless of exactly what percentage, exists in other markets.

  12. Why would this surprise? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If one of your main new models is recalled I don't what else you would expect but lower sales? Apple isn't exactly going great either and they don't have any product recalls. It's come down to what happened with PC sales, iPad sales, and smartphone sales. They don't have leaps and bounds in product advances so people don't replace them as often. Heck, my Mother in Law still uses a iPad 2 and doesn't care in the least about a new one. Yes Samsung will have to write off a lot of this loss but I am sure another model is just around the corner. Of course they may miss out on holiday sales, but those could generally be muted by disposable income anyway. Nobody is predicting a great holiday sales season.

  13. Wont purchase another Samsung phone. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Rode a wave of timing related samsung upgrades. Note4, upgraded for a note5 due to no longer being offered thru my carriers insurance. Note5 broke, ended up with an s7 Edge due to N5 no longer being offered and the Note7s exploding, which i absolutely hate. Its a glass clad fucking nightmare. I dislike samsung and it soured me to android so much im jumping ship, off to be an iFag like all the rest of ya's.

  14. LG should... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    LG should spend millions just spamming the entire world: "Why LG? Because we don't glue batteries into our phones."

    "LG batteries are reliable. But even if they weren't, changing them is as simple as .

    "LG. May your device outlast its battery."

  15. Remember that U.S. companies get off lighter by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    it's on the agenda now to let the hammer fall heavily whenever there's a chance. This issue, and the recent Volkswagen emission problem, was blown up tremendously, and the U.S. sought for the most devastating consequences they could impair on the foreign competitors.

    Apple's Antenna-gate and Bend-gate was relatively quietly swept under the rug. And did you know that G.M. only paid about $45 million last time they had a serious recall after several people died due to them lying about faults in their vehicles? Cheap, compared to the $18 billion VW has to pay.

  16. I know that people are yelping about phones by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I know people are yelping about phones, but I'm typing this staring at a Samsung monitor, beside another Samsung monitor that is showing the news via a tv tuner card. And neither monitor has caused me a dead pixel in more than 5 years, and they use very little power and are very bright and colorful. And they were cheaper than any monitor I've ever used. And *NEITHER* has exploded or burst into flames!!! I know that North Korean leader Kim Jong-un was buying up Samsung note 7 phones and packing them into the nose of long range rockets, so each phone could explode, and a few dozen would create an explosion big enough to destroy half a city. Samsung makes things other than phones, and not all their phones explode or blow up (some might only accidentally catch fire due to the battery).