Slashdot Mirror


How To Delete Your Data From Google's 'My Activity' (vortex.com)

Last summer Google revealed personalized data dashboards for every Google account, letting users edit (or delete) items from their search history as well as their viewing history on YouTube. Now Slashdot reader Lauren Weinstein writes: Since posting "The Google Page That Google Haters Don't Want You to Know About" last week, I've received a bunch of messages from readers asking for help using Google's "My Activity" page to control, inspect, and/or delete their data on Google. The My Activity portal is quite comprehensive and can be used in many different ways, but to get you started I'll briefly outline how to use My Activity to delete activity data.
CNET points out you can also access the slightly-creepier "Google Maps location history" by clicking the menu icon in the upper left corner and selecting "Other Google activity." But Weinstein writes, "I have no problems with Google collecting the kinds of data that provide their advanced services, so long as I can choose when that data is collected, and I can inspect and delete it on demand. The google.com/myactivity portal provides those abilities and a lot more."

44 comments

  1. How deleted are the data? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    How deleted are the data? Are they removed from any and all backups? Are they deleted by any and all third parties the data may have been bought by or shared? Are the corresponding data removed from all 'anonymized' data dumps?

    1. Re:How deleted are the data? by fahrbot-bot · · Score: 2

      How deleted are the data? ...

      Your data is just moved to the hidden account Google keeps about you (and everyone else, even those w/o Google accounts) where it exists forever - you know, like Facebook does.

      --
      It must have been something you assimilated. . . .
    2. Re:How deleted are the data? by Mitreya · · Score: 1

      How deleted are the data?

      Deleted from your view only. As most databases, it will only flag records as "deleted", but not overwrite it.

      Are they deleted by any and all third parties the data may have been bought by or shared?

      That's a brilliant idea. Every deleted item is shared with HiddenAlphabet division and then purged from the main Google server.

    3. Re:How deleted are the data? by bagofbeans · · Score: 1

      Essentially when one deletes tracking data, they just go on a blacklist for viewing permissions for that data subset.

      Also, when a second party logs your activity, they own that data not you, despite the data being about you, because they created the data. You didn't.

    4. Re:How deleted are the data? by WarJolt · · Score: 2

      The aggregated data google uses to tell stories about trends will always contain your data. Also anonymized data is easy to deanonymize. By deleting your location data you are only preventing yourself and presumably any lawyer that might subpoena your personal records from accessing the data.

    5. Re:How deleted are the data? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The aggregated data is data such as "X people clicked on link Y in this hour" which is not, in general, easily deanonymized. Lower-traffic websites are aggregated at lower granularity for this reason.

    6. Re:How deleted are the data? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Google doesn't sell data; it's one of their most valuable assets. Data at rest is all encrypted, so only the (well audited) keys need to be destroyed, rather than hunting down backups and caches and massive re-writes.

    7. Re:How deleted are the data? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's all fine, except Google announced a few months ago that it would be mining "anonymous" data in order to identify specific individuals. You might recall that, in 2007, to gain government approval for its acquisition of DoubleClick, Google promised not to de-anonymize the data collected. But the company has since changed its mind.

      Furthermore, Google is too wealthy and has too much at stake not to have hired lawyers to figure out how to tell people they can delete their history, while the company--in the worst case for itself--still legally retains virtually all of the data "anonymized" but then de-anonymizes it.

    8. Re:How deleted are the data? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      google is known to 'never' delete "anything". so deleted it may be from YOUR view.. it isn't from their end, nor from others they contract access to (feds, et al)

    9. Re:How deleted are the data? by marcansoft · · Score: 1

      Deleted from your view only. As most databases, it will only flag records as "deleted", but not overwrite it.

      Oh, then the anonymization and deletion pipelines I kept running while I worked for Google were all a ruse?

      Seriously, this deceitful cynicism is getting old.

    10. Re:How deleted are the data? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It is never deleted. Likewise for all the social media sites, even after you delete your account. Everything is just flagged as "deleted". You can see this for yourself in the data dumps google, FB, twitter, Apple et al give to law enforcement agencies.

    11. Re:How deleted are the data? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      At least they give the warm fuzzy appearance that you can delete your data. Slashdot doesn't even pretend. It's why I no longer log in to my (very low UID) account on the increasingly rare occasions I come here. Not missing much, though. Until earlier this year, I hadn't found any links worth clicking for well over two years, and had almost entirely ceased even coming to Slashdot.

      https://slashdot.org/faq#accounts3

      How can I delete my account?

      You can't. But don't sweat it; the unused accounts don't hurt anything.

    12. Re:How deleted are the data? by ArmoredDragon · · Score: 1

      Also, when a second party logs your activity, they own that data not you, despite the data being about you, because they created the data. You didn't.

      And why would they have any opportunity to do that? Contrary to popular belief, even if Google was pure evil, it would make all of about zero economic sense for them to make your data available to third parties. Google is an ad company, if they were to give that kind of information out, all it would do is help somebody else compete in their primary market.

  2. Provides help only to those who understand well. by Futurepower(R) · · Score: 3, Insightful

    "I have no problems with Google collecting the kinds of data that provide their advanced services, so long as I can choose when that data is collected, and I can inspect and delete it on demand. The google.com/myactivity portal provides those abilities and a lot more."

    Most people, however, won't know that opportunity exists. So, only technically-knowledgeable people get the benefit.

    In fact, Google is collecting HUGE amounts of data. Anyone who uses the NoScript and Disconnect add-ons can see that Google services are used by many, many web sites.

  3. Honored ? How? by redelm · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Non-routine deleted data is often the most interesting data of all.

    Furthermore, most databases do not actually delete records, just flag them as "DELETED". Such records might be actually deleted/overwritten when a "Compaction" run is performed to recover space into larger blocks--if ever, might just recover LRU. How do we know what Google implements even if it not DELETED==INTERESTING?

  4. "Deleted" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Yes yes, Google will definitely delete the data. Of course.

    (no they won't, they will just flag it as deleted)

  5. Deletion? On Google? by aglider · · Score: 2

    Maybe you're talking about the feeling of deletion. Nothing will ever be deleted on Google. Be assured.

    --
    Sent as ripples into the electromagnetic field. No single photon has been harmed in the process.
  6. Dashboard, Rephrased by tinkerton · · Score: 1

    Last summer Google revealed personalized data dashboards for every Google account, letting users edit (or delete) items from their search history as well as their viewing history on YouTube.

    Last summer Google introduced a dashboard forcing users of Google to a weekly complicated routine involving 20 mouseclicks and installation of an app that they can only avoid by staying logged in to their Google account. Users who do not want to go through this weekly routine are banned from using google.

    Google wants to improve this dashboard in order to enhance the harassment of people who are not logged in.

    1. Re:Dashboard, Rephrased by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      WTF are you talking about? I've never had a Google account, and I've never seen any of this. There's no visible difference for users without an account.

  7. No Account by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    But, I don't have a google account. How do I delete the data they've surely collected anyway?

    1. Re:No Account by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Don't worry; your data is 100% as deleted as that of the account holders who go through this process.

  8. "delete" (wink wink) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No, seriously, Google actually deletes that data. Pinky promise!

  9. Re:Honored ? How? by Mitreya · · Score: 1

    Furthermore, most databases do not actually delete records, just flag them as "DELETED". Such records might be actually deleted/overwritten when a "Compaction" run is

    And, even more, HBase (which is modeled after Google's BigTable) keeps everything stored with older timestamps, even if you overwrite the old record.
    This feature gives you the cool ability to query "as of TimeX" (i.e. what the answer would have been yesterday). So you likely only deleting your data for the "current" queries, but not for the past ones.

  10. Re:Can Idelete my apps? by richy+freeway · · Score: 1

    You can do it from the Play Store on your Android device. Go to "My Apps and Games" then "Library".

  11. Re:Honored ? How? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    That's why there are strict policies requiring periodic compactions for anything holding user data. (Disclaimer: yes, I work for Google.)

  12. Except it's never really deleted by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You honestly think anything is ever really deleted

  13. Lauren Weinstein needs to fuck off elsewhere by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Slashdot is not your own personal promotion platform. Get the fuck out of here, Bennett Haselton 2.0, we don't want you here.

  14. Run from Google by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I did this last week interestingly enough. The amount of data that Google collects will blow you away, especially the location stuff. I've purged everything from my account, even though it wasn't much data, save for some random emails. I've switched over to protonmail. I also disabled all the Google apps on my phone and removed the associated Google account from it. Only drawback is the play store won't work now. Oh well, I have all the apps I need. I only use it for texting, chess, and posting memes on a certain website that likes green frogs.

  15. Google is privacy hazard by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I have stopped using Google which needs any login. I got burnt few years ago. I had been using Google chat for long time and whenever I felt the conversation was confidential, I will go to "chat" folder and delete specific conversation. Few years later, I moved from iPhone to Google Nexus. I had just setup phone using my gmail id and my wife was looking through my phone. Since I had deleted anything confidential, I gave the phone to her. Apparently all the private conversion that I had with my parents, siblings and others (no affair was involved) was all there. Now, these conversation were not at accessible in browser and appeared in Google Hangout app. When I contacted Google support, they told me, I have to mark the conversation off record before beginning the conversation and there is no way to delete conversation without deleting the whole chat history. Few months later, I sold my Nexus and moved to iPhone. I have stopped using gmail and all other Google accounts.

    I still use google apps anonymously. Google Search, youtube, maps are still my primary app, but no more Google accounts and for the same reasons, I don't trust Chrome browser. I only use Chrome browser for compatibility testing of my software on my company machine (no chrome on my personal machines).

  16. Good luck getting rid of WatchMojo by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    First thing I did when it came out was purge any hint that I had ever viewed a WatchMojo video.

    WatchMojo: server 500 error
    Watch: server 500 error

    Anything else: Okay!

    Yeah. It literally cannot search for the word "watch". Good going Google.

  17. Google should just say what they really mean: by TheOuterLinux · · Score: 1

    "Would YOU like to no longer see your data on your account page?" Of course they still keep it and anything up until opting out will continue to be used regardless; it's too late. Anything uploaded to the Internet never completely goes away. Imagine deleting a file from your computer. Unless you wipe that file 30 times with zeros before deleting, some information can still be recovered. That's just your typical computer. Now, picture a company like Google and their data recovery tools, especially when creating files on their platforms (google docs, maps, etc.). Google turns your data into Borg. Better yet, it's figuratively shoved into a pod and uploaded to the Matrix (archives) while it's bots feed (crawl) off it.

  18. Re:Provides help only to those who understand well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Google services are used by many, many web sites.

    That's the understatement of the month.

    Virtually every significant site on the internet uses some google trackers. Furthermore, many sites requiring account creation no longer provide any way to do so that does not involve Google.

    If you do not use google you are rapidly becoming a second class internet citizen.

  19. Delete Google ads tracking/infecting/slowing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    APK Hosts File Engine 9.0++ SR-7 32/64-bit https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&source=hp&biw=&bih=&q=%22APK+Hosts+File+Engine%22+and+%22start64%22&btnG=Google+Search&gbv=1/

    Ads/script & malware rob speed/security/privacy

    Hosts add speed (via hardcodes/adblocks), security (vs. bad sites/malware/poisoned dns), reliability (vs. dns down), & anonymity (vs. dns requestlogs/trackers).

    Less power/cpu/ram + IO use vs. DNS/routers/addons/antivirus + less security bugs/complexity & faster vs. addons/routers/remote dns!

    Avoids DNSChangers in routers/IP settings & dns redirects (99.999% of ISP DNS != patched vs. it) + lightens DNS load & resolves faster from local system RAM!

    * Via what u NATIVELY have in the IP stack in FASTER kernelmode!

    APK

    P.S. - Safe https://www.virustotal.com/en/file/e01211ca36aa02e923f20adee0a3c4f5d5187dc65bdf1c997b3da3c2b0745425/analysis/1433430542/

    1. Re:Delete Google ads tracking/infecting/slowing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I suck big juicy cocks!

      APK

      P.S. - And I love it!

  20. Re:Honored ? How? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What about backups? And that other copy?

  21. It's not Google Maps, it's Google Fit by Zanadou · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Actually, it's not Google Maps that that's the most creepy when it comes to location tracking: it's Google Fit.

    After using the Google Takeout service the other day I noticed Fit does a LOT more fine-tuned location tracking than Maps, and I don't think there's an easy option to delete all of Fit's location data. Deleting all of Maps's location history does not affect Fit's location history.

    Yeah, I guess that's the whole point of fitness tracking, but it's still creepy.

  22. The Delete Activity Button by SmaryJerry · · Score: 1

    The article goes to length at a round about way to manage to delete your activity but you can just click the Delete Activity button on the left and select all time or any time period.

  23. easy way... by scatbomb · · Score: 2

    STOP USING GOOGLE. They're evil, screw 'em. Already switched to their competitors for everything.

  24. Wrong & IMPERSONATING me? LOL! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    See subject impersonator stooge - you WISH I did but sorry: Find yourself another dish weirdo freak - I'm "not on the menu"!

    * It must totally TOTALLY BLOW to be "someone like you" PROJECTING your own TWISTED freakishness while impersonating me!

    APK

    P.S.=> I just Thank merciful God I didn't waste my life & time being a loser like you - you WISH you were me (but you KNOW you never CAN be - you're a waste of life & YOU know it)... apk

  25. Re:Provides help only to those who understand well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Including this one.

  26. Re:Can Idelete my apps? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Have you considered trying COWS? ...moo

  27. Data access for recurring revenue by bagofbeans · · Score: 1

    Data hoarders sell searches on their data sets, not the data set itself.

  28. Re:Honored ? How? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes, backups are also compacted/deleted. It's part of the policies.