Slashdot Mirror


Nissan Won't Build Its Own Electric Car Batteries Anymore (cnet.com)

An anonymous reader shares a report: Balancing every single task by oneself, instead of getting some help, can break a person down in record time. That's likely why Nissan has decided to step away from manufacturing batteries for its electric vehicles. Nissan announced on Tuesday that it would sell its battery-manufacturing subsidiary, Automotive Energy Supply Corporation (AESC), to the Chinese investment firm GSR Capital. "This is a win-win for AESC and Nissan. It enables AESC to utilize GSR's wide networks and proactive investment to expand its customer base and further increase its competitiveness," said Hiroto Saikawa, president and CEO of Nissan, in a statement. "In turn, this will further enhance Nissan's EV competitiveness. AESC will remain a very important partner for Nissan as we deepen our focus on designing and producing market-leading electric vehicles."

132 comments

  1. this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by WindBourne · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Seriously, they control their own future and have the ability to drop costs relative to others.
    OTOH, companies like Nissan, GM, Ford, etc that do NOT build their own plants will not be able to compete against Germans (who are late to the game, but getting there), the Chinese (who will learn how to properly make cars, but at this time, only a fool would buy), and Tesla.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    1. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      To some degree, it is also a HUGE risk that Chinese government sponsored industry will undercut prices and take the entire market like they have with steel, solar panels, etc...

      The increased trade between Japan and China is a direct result of the abandonment of the TPP and foreshadows the unabated growth of China as America decides to withdraw from trade deals and pick at bellybutton lint instead of competing and controlling world markets.

    2. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Remember the days when monocultures and monopolies were frowned on around here. Yeah, those were good times. Now we have people who can't scream "TESLA!!!!!1111!!!!" loud enough.

    3. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

      These type of batteries are going to be a low margin commodity.

      In the meantime, Tesla is burning through cash for its operations. It just issued bonds that being rated in the low Bs.

      It has two more years to get market share and after that, the big boys are coming in at full strength.

      Tesla's future is hardly a guaranteed success. But, Tesla's stock doesn't trade on fundamentals: just pie-in-the-sky dreams. Dreams created by Elon's publicist. It's amazing how techies who can be so skeptical and rational throw it all away when it comes to the cult of Musk.

      It's exactly how religious people think - hence the use of the word cult.

    4. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm gonna just assume that you are new around here is you think that ridiculous stock valuations are only applied to Musk and not to the entire technology sector for the past 20 years.

      You same foreboding was smeared liberally to Apple, Level3 and any number of other tech firms that have continued to be leaders in their fields.

      Golf claps to Musk for figuring out how to get his hands on capital, whether or not he turns it into lasting revenue streams remains to be seen.

    5. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Gilgaron · · Score: 2

      Although if they build the 'best' battery, they can still say in the small margin battery business even if they stop making cars. It's like a Husqvarna mower with a Honda engine, except it'll be "Ford e-Peen, Powered by Tesla!" on the advert.

    6. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You same foreboding was smeared liberally to Apple, Level3 and any number of other tech firms that have continued to be leaders in their fields.

      Survivor bias. That same foreboding was "smeared liberally" on hundreds or even thousands of companies, and you only remember the names of a handful.

    7. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, Apple was almost driven into the ground by the Coca-cola salesman and the Rockwell retiree who tried to apply normal management techniques.
      Apple was only saved by the return of Jobs and the acquisition of NeXt technology.

      Tesla has to hang it hat on Musk remaining at the helm. Naysayers like yourself are only trying to drag the company down to pay out on their shorts

      Like I said, we have all seen this movie before, you are not bringing anything new to the table.

    8. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Because Tesla understands that battery costs are the key to competitive electric cars. The only way to control that is to build them, not outsource manufacturing to a third party hungry for extra margins. Auto companies still manufacture their own engines for this very reason.

    9. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 1

      Remember the days when monocultures and monopolies were frowned on around here.... Now we have people who can't scream "TESLA!!!!!1111!!!!" loud enough.

      Exactly. With Tesla's market share nearing 0.01%, we definitely need to be concerned about their monopoly power.

    10. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Tesla has a tiny share of the vehicle market, but a much bigger share of the battery market.

    11. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by tburkhol · · Score: 1

      Vertical integration is not monoculture or monopoly. Monoculture would be if Nissan, GM, Ford, etc all started buying Tesla batteries.

    12. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It would be great if the major manufacturers were producing some kind of non-fossil fuel based model. However decades of history have shown that they have little to no interest in making them, building the ones they do play with to the spottiest quality possible and even when one of these Eco-boxes does garner a following they recall them and feed them into car crushers. The only reason why many of them are clamoring to make EVs/Hybrids now is BECAUSE of Tesla.

    13. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Rei · · Score: 3, Informative

      There's no risk with this purchase. Nissan's battery "technology" in the Leaf is terrible. Among the worst in the industry, if not the worst in the industry. It's just passively cooled prismatic cells wired together in a giant "suitcase". The average degradation on them is terrible.

      --
      He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
    14. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sure, and the old DEC Alpha designs were gathering dust before China reworked them, fabbed them and then built the worlds largest supercomputer with them...

      Looking at China as a cheap manufacturer is relying on 'old ways' that do not apply any more

      Nissan is giving them a product and a market, expect innovation to follow

      This reminds of that famous quote:
      "They couldn't hit an elephant at this distance."
      General John Sedgwick (September 13, 1813 – May 9, 1864)
      Killed by a Confederate sharp-shooter at the Battle of Spotsylvania Court House.

    15. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by DontBeAMoran · · Score: 1

      Now we have people who can't scream "TESLA!" loud enough.

      You could always use that. For everything else, there's MasterCard.

      --
      #DeleteFacebook
    16. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Rei · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Annual US car production is under 4 million units. Tesla Model 3 production is scheduled to hit 500k next year. That's what people are investing in Tesla for. Because this is a big, big thing.

      And that's just one year. So far Tesla has gotten a nearly 2 year waiting list without any advertising at all, without anyone being able to test drive it (or even know all the specs for most of that time), and with Tesla trying to anti-sell it to try to drive buyers to S and X instead (which they can actually get cash from today, rather than two years in the future). With advertising Tesla expects to raise the 500k to 700k (this will involve moving S and X motor production to gigafactory to free up space at Fremont). A couple years from now they'll also be introducing the Model Y crossover (crossovers being more popular than sedans). They also have a major electric semi truck project in progress, and are developing the Supercharger V3 to support it. After the Y and semi they're discussed a new Roadster, a pickup, and a lower-cost sedan.

      Nobody is putting money into Tesla because of their current sales. They're putting money into Tesla because of how much pent-up demand there is for its vehicles - whether you happen to be part of that demand or not. Said investment money is to let them tool to convert demand into sales and thus profits. Talking about figures related to Tesla's current market share are just silly when they're in the middle of building a plant to increase the US's total car production by 28%.

      --
      He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
    17. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by DontBeAMoran · · Score: 1

      See also: Apple and their A-series CPU+GPU. Anyone want to bet they have A10-whatever Mac prototypes in their labs? They went from 68000 to PowerPC to Intel, another transition doesn't seem far-fetched.

      --
      #DeleteFacebook
    18. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by DontBeAMoran · · Score: 1

      Last time I checked they had at least 2170% of the market. Then again, maybe I'm not using that number correctly...

      --
      #DeleteFacebook
    19. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by BasilBrush · · Score: 1

      Probably a bit unfair comparing just US production. Tesla produce all their cars for worldwide distribution in the US. The larger US manufacturers have factories dotted around the world.

    20. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by BasilBrush · · Score: 1

      And for the same reason slashdot hive mind's hatred of Apple is irrational. They too have vertically integrated products, but there's plenty of competition.

    21. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Mr+D+from+63 · · Score: 1

      Tesla is making a big bet that they can stay ahead or at least even on the battery technology front. If a competitor comes out with a newer/cheaper/better battery solution, Telsa is stuck with what they are investing huge sums into. They can overcome some of that by managing their own margins, but if something were to drag the battery part of their business down, it could drag heavily on the car business (and other Telsa businesses). Its a strategy that can pay off big or be painful.

    22. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why only a fool would buy Chinese EV? I'm pretty sure they will be the cheapest.

    23. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by AmiMoJo · · Score: 5, Informative

      Nonsense. I have owned two Leafs, the batteries are great. Very low degradation even under extreme conditions - taxi companies doing multiple rapid charges every day and a 100% charge overnight, for 200,000 miles. They actually removed the "long life mode" 80% charge option from newer models because it was pointless, the 100% charge having no real effect on the battery pack.

      They are passively cooled, but that's fine for the Leaf. You only need active cooling if you want to charge at >50kW or for longer periods than a 30kWh pack needs, or if you are drawing more energy than the Leaf does even brodering it. Again, taxi firms running the cars hard, charging them hard, demonstrates this.

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
    24. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Rei · · Score: 1

      Very low degradation even under extreme conditions

      Great for you, but it's a well known problem that many people have experienced. There's a reason that pretty much everyone else is climate controlling their packs. Tesla degradation isn't anywhere nearly so fast (click "charts")

      --
      He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
    25. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Tesla aren't even ahead at the moment. They are just very effective at generating hype and buzz.

    26. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It would be great if the major manufacturers were producing some kind of non-fossil fuel based model.
       
      A number of them do.
       
        However decades of history have shown that they have little to no interest in making them, building the ones they do play with to the spottiest quality possible and even when one of these Eco-boxes does garner a following they recall them and feed them into car crushers.
       
      Aside from the near-two-decade old example of the Ford EV1, can you cite a case of this?
       
        The only reason why many of them are clamoring to make EVs/Hybrids now is BECAUSE of Tesla.
       
      Oh, so "I was here first" (an argument normally made of adolescents arguing with their siblings) is now a reason why we should wink at monocultures and monopolies? Wow. Just wow.
       
      Is this kind of shit-for-brains nonsense really what you have to bring to the table?

    27. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by thegarbz · · Score: 1

      Many things can seem great while still being the worst in the industry. Just because the Leaf works well for you and a bunch of taxis doesn't mean it works for an even wider audience and doesn't mean that there aren't better options available.

    28. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Crosshair84 · · Score: 1

      Tesla is a good 60 plus years behind other auto makers in production tech.

      Tesla makes one model per production line. The standard for other auto makers is eight. Meaning if one model bombs, the company is just fine if the other seven keep the line busy. Tesla can't even manage two.

      Munsk is an amateur when it comes to building physical things ecenomically. Nobody copies him and for good reason.

    29. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      Where do you live?
      The battery life of the leaf depends on where you live.
      In Denver, the leaf is SO-SO. North of here, the leaf appears to do pretty good. OTOH, down in pueblo Colorado, they constantly burn out early and then go cheap (5K).
      The leaf battery, along with the HVAC on it, actually DOES sux.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    30. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Tesla Model 3 production is scheduled to hit 500k next year.

      And everyone knows that is totally unrealistic.

      That's what people are investing in Tesla for.

      People are investing in Tesla because it is a bubble stock and bubble stocks can make you a lot of money if you sell before the bubble bursts.

    31. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Your in england, you dont get extreme conditions.

      this fucking summer in UK is pretty much the same as spring and autumn wet and grey, UK temp rarly varies more than 20C

    32. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by rtb61 · · Score: 1

      What to do with old battery plant when new battery technology comes out that the old battery plant can not produce. We are pulling out of battery manufacture and want to sell our old plant, because of 'cue business psychobabble'. Then, we have had a change of heart because of 'cue business psychobabble' and will build a new battery plant using the new battery technology. That is the problem with battery technology, a jump in efficiency and longevity absolutely slaughters old technology, just puts it right out of business. Tricky decision as to when to lock yourself into a particular technology.

      --
      Chaos - everything, everywhere, everywhen
    33. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It has two more years to get market share and after that, the big boys are coming in at full strength.

      Actually, they aren't. The big boys are going to start in two years. They won't be coming in at full strength until at couple of years after that, if nothing else then because the battery manufacturing capacity isn't going to be there for them.

    34. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by aaarrrgggh · · Score: 1

      Agree; I don't know how much they are putting into fundemental research, but I have to imagine they are restricted in chemistry. This provides significant long-term risk for them.

      That said, they are doing the right things by finding multiple markets for the batteries fast which should lower costs, and arguably more importantly an existing model isn't just going to jump onto a new battery overnight, so there is some inherent logic to focusing on improving one chemistry.

      If China starts dumping batteries it will hurt Tesla-- but in scale it might not be material. If they need $5B in capital investment over the next 5 years that could be a bigger existential concern.

    35. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      Not really. Lithium is required for high density batteries. In fact, the high energy density come from Li-air batteries. It is impossible to build a battery with higher energy density. As such, as long as batteries are used, similar plant technique will be used. As to the other elements, they would simply be recycled and used in other products. The only thing that will boot batteries, is capacitors, and they do not have high enough energy density. Yet.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    36. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      Which, other than Tesla and Nissan, all none Chinese car makers are buying from LG, which is expensive.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    37. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      Lol. Your are the first individual that I have seen make that accusation. The fact that he bought the premier robotic manufacturing company probably makes you way wrong.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    38. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      Not only cheapest but most dangerous. Even now , they are seeing Chinese cars catch fire as they move to a more energy dense formula.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    39. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Trogre · · Score: 1

      It is impossible to build a battery with higher energy density.

      That seems like a rather implausible claim, or a very narrow definition of "battery".

      --
      "Nine times out of ten, starting a fire is not the best way to solve the problem." - my wife
    40. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Rei · · Score: 1

      Indeed, it's one of the most modern car production factories on Earth. Including using some of the largest robots on Earth. All of Tesla's car production is done at the same place, using the same systems. Model S and X share a common platform; 3 and Y will also share a common platform.

      Tesla has really pushed the boundaries on automation on car production. They show the robot that installs the seats on the Wired video, and how it has to contort to get the seats into position. The Model 3 allows even more internal work by robots by having the big glass window, which gets installed last, so there's a giant gap for robots to reach inside. Model Y is taking automation to the point that robots will even be installing the entire wiring harness. Normally that's unthinkable because it's a complicated tangle that winds its way through every corner of the car, but Tesla has been putting a huge effort into simplifying it.

      --
      He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
    41. Re:this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Rei · · Score: 1

      First off, it was the GM EV1; Ford's EV of that era was the Ranger EV. Secondly, almost all of the major manufacturers terminated their leases and brought back their vehicles for destruction. A few models however were saved due to protests from their owners, with the companies changing their minds and allowing the owners to buy them (the Toyota RAV4 EV being the most notable example). GM became so famous for it in that the EV1 was the most beloved of that generation of EVs, and how GM staunchly ignored their owners protests (to the point that two actresses, Alexandra Paul and Colette Divine, were arrested trying to block the haulers) and crushed them anyway. However, GM was not the only company to do that - for example, Ford recalled all of their Ranger EVs.

      The real PR disaster for GM was their success - despite lacking high-level support, they had actually made a good EV, unlike the cheapo conversions made by other manufacturers. Despite the loss of the EV1, some of the people who had designed its drivetrain (for the GM Impact, its predecessor) had started a new company, AC Propulsion, developing similar technology. This culminated in them making the AC Propulsion tzero, a very innovative EV kit car that could do 0-60 in 4,1 seconds, which was simply unheard of at the time. They also developed a lot of neat accessories, like the Long Ranger, a range-extending trailer with self-steering so it was as easy to back up as not having a trailer at all. Martin Eberhard, being fascinated by the tzero, funded its conversion to lithium ion, making it even faster and with a much longer range. Failing to convince ACP to mass produce the tzero, he (along with Marc Tarpenning) founded Tesla Motors with the intent of doing it himself, started searching for investors, and borrowed the tzero for three months. One of the first people to drive it was Musk, who fell in love with it. Musk again tried to get ACP to make more tzeros, even in small numbers (offering large sums for it), but again ACP declined. So Tesla decided to pursue their own strategy of building their own drivetrain (based on the same tech behind ACPs) and build it into Lotus Elise shells. This became the Tesla Roadster, and the rest is history.

      It's entirely GM's fault that Tesla exists today. And also, I'll never understand ACP. They invented so much neat stuff yet never pursued anything important, only ever pursuing dumb conversions that were obviously never going to be profitable. They'd be billionaires today if they had agreed to join forces with Tesla.

      A postscript to the EV1 story: they're not actually all gone. A number were given to universities, although they were first deactivated and the universities had to agree to strict conditions to never make them roadworthy again. There is only one non-deactivated EV1 remaining, and it's in the Smithsonian.

      --
      He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
    42. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      Actually, several weeks ago, must said that Y would be based on 3, so there is some doubt about whether wires will be roboticly installed.
      Of course, the normal approach at any good company with good ppl, is do the right thing and ask for forgiveness rather than permission and have to do the wrong thing. :)

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    43. Re: this is why Tesla is going to be HUGE quickly by Rei · · Score: 1

      Indeed. Lithium is hardly the most energy-dense substance in existence. It has lots of desirable properties, but it's not the be-all end-all.

      Actually, sodium-air batteries would be even better. Still much more energy dense than li-ion (although not as much as li-air), but sodium is dirt cheap. Lithium isn't super-expensive, but sodium.... I mean, it's the cation in salt, it's bloody everywhere. And can be reduced to metal for a final price similar to that of aluminum.

      --
      He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  2. Offshoring to China by Tailhook · · Score: 1

    Nissan's battery factories are in Japan; Zama and Sagamihara Kanagawa. They'll be shutting those for GSR's Chinese factories.

    --
    Maw! Fire up the karma burner!
    1. Re: Offshoring to China by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There's a Nissan battery plant in Smyrna, TN, which is included in the deal.

  3. Sell It All to the Chinese by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe we should just get it over with and surrender to the Chinese. They're going to own us all eventually anyway. It's amazing what you can do with the slave labor of 1.2 billion people at your disposal.

    1. Re:Sell It All to the Chinese by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      That is kind of a mid-20th century view of China and it is woefully inaccurate.

      China's growth has fueled a rapidly growing middle-class that wants consumer goods, particularly American goods (i.e. they LOVE Buick cars for some reason)

      I would suggest some Mandarin language classes if you are really concerned. You may even get a western-guys-in-ties job although those are probably on the down-growth side right now.

    2. Re:Sell It All to the Chinese by LynnwoodRooster · · Score: 1

      More people learn English today in China, than live in the UK. English is required for all middle and high school students, has been for the last 10 years or so. Mandarin skills are still very helpful, but in a business situation they are rapidly fading as a requirement or even a big bonus.

      --
      Browsing at +1 - no ACs, I ignore their posts. So refreshing!
  4. Could not Compete by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Nissan did the Tesla strategy before Tesla did; namely in order to build a mass-market EV (Leaf) they need to control their own supply chain and partnered with NEC to form AESC to build their own batteries. In the beginning they were market leaders (example: Nissan+NEC Leaf was MUCH better then the Mitsubishi+Toshiba iMiev)

    What is interesting is GM+LG Chem and Tesla+Panasonic made better batteries cheaper then Nissan+NEC; the latest Leaf is evidence of that (2018 Leaf is expected to be 160 miles of range whereas the BoltEV is 238 miles of range both within the same price range, size and weight).

    So Nissan is jumping ship and going to LG Chem. Now what will be fascinating is both Hyundai, GM and Nissan will be competing for LG Chem Cells.

    The other wildcard is Samgsung+BMW; so far their cells have not been competitive; I'm curious if they'll step up or bow out like NEC did.

    1. Re:Could not Compete by Topwiz · · Score: 2

      The problem with the Leaf is that it looks like it was made ugly on purpose.

    2. Re:Could not Compete by Smidge204 · · Score: 1

      It's more accurate to say that the battery pack has no active thermal management and is fairly poor in capacity to begin with compared to what's now available.

      Nissan was not able to evolve their battery fast enough to keep pace with the technology and ended up taking it in the neck.
      =Smidge=

    3. Re:Could not Compete by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And don't forget the Tesla model 3 does 220 and 310 miles depending on which battery you buy.

      Leaf's 160 miles look bad compared to all the other main designs out there.

    4. Re:Could not Compete by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      The main problem was range - 75 miles doesn't cut it for the early models. 107 is getting there. It needs to be 150+.

    5. Re:Could not Compete by Rei · · Score: 1

      And that's its range when new. Leaf battery degradation is commonly severe, since it's passively cooled.

      --
      He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
    6. Re:Could not Compete by BasilBrush · · Score: 1

      And Hyundai is already suffering from lack of batteries from LG Chem. Their Ioniq has been far more popular than they predicted. They could raise production to deal with that, except that they haven't pre-ordered enough batteries from LG Chem, and LG Chem has other bigger customers, so won't/can't increase production for Hyundai.

    7. Re:Could not Compete by BasilBrush · · Score: 1

      They have a new model being launched next month. That will undoubtedly be 150+. But they need 200+ now.

  5. Grossly false analogy. by Nutria · · Score: 1

    Balancing every single task by oneself, instead of getting some help, can break a person down in record time.

    Nissan is a large company, with lots of people.

    This is either selling assets to pay down debt, or upper management thinking that they can't be competitive as battery manufacturers.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
    1. Re:Grossly false analogy. by the_skywise · · Score: 1

      Hear hear. Although I'm thinking selling to China (I'm assuming they still have some sort of ownership stake) probably helps them dodge environmental laws.

    2. Re:Grossly false analogy. by Nutria · · Score: 1

      probably helps them dodge environmental laws.

      Which drive up prices.

      --
      "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
    3. Re:Grossly false analogy. by ckatko · · Score: 1

      How will Nissan survive both ENGINEERING and MARKETING their cars?!

      Those are two different skills!

    4. Re:Grossly false analogy. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Bingo.

  6. Batteries are nice but let's get real by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

    Tesla's next vehicle will be coal powered according to multiple sources. Clean American coal is the future, not lithium.

  7. Adios Nissan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    There are pros and cons to outsourcing. But if there's one thing that's asymptotic to pure truth, it's never ever outsource your core competency.

    In the case of EVs, your core competencies are Battery Design and EV Drivetrain.

    Outsourcing half your core competency right as the market starts to pick up and get competitive sure seems like surefire way to be left behind.

    1. Re:Adios Nissan by hipp5 · · Score: 1

      In the case of EVs, your core competencies are Battery Design and EV Drivetrain.

      Not necessarily. Nissan's core competency is designing and building cars: regulatory compliance, supply chain management, marketing, etc. In fact, they likely have very little (comparatively) competency in battery and EV drivetrain design and production.

    2. Re:Adios Nissan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And it's not like we have seen Chinese companies learn outside tech and then compete directly with the companies they learnt the tech from.

    3. Re:Adios Nissan by DarkOx · · Score: 1

      There is still lots of room to be a good coach builder that drops a car on top of a mostly 3rd party chassis/battery/power train.

      Plenty of auto maker do this to in the ICE powered space. The thing it it usually moves you off into the boutique market space. The majors don't do it that way because there are big advantages in integrated manufacturing.

      You get some design flexibility because you don't have to work round the constraints of someone else's chassis/equipment

      You avoid a lot of overhead, much cheaper to shift something car sized from one assembly line to the next for than to incur all kinds of shipping and handling.

      So I think you will see the majors pretty much go for building these components themselves. You can't deliver a mass market vehicle in the ICE world if you have outsourced these things. I don't see it playing out differently in the electric market, once the electric market becomes mass market.

      So either Nissan is content to move into the boutique space or does not really believe in the electric car, having tried it now for a decade+.

      --
      Repeal the 17th Amendment TODAY! Also Please Read http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html
    4. Re:Adios Nissan by aaarrrgggh · · Score: 1

      Arguably the opposite could be true: auto manufacturers today are primarily about service and marketing; slapping a cabin on a slightly value-added chassis makes sense for their model.

      I could also see highly mass-marketed "skateboards" becoming the foundation (heh) of the auto industry-- it lends itself to more customization and is consistent with today's "platform" model.

  8. Nissan A Person? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Balancing every single task by oneself, instead of getting some help, can break a person down in record time. "

    Good thing Nissan is not a person. Seriously you are comparing apples to monkeys here.

  9. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by hipp5 · · Score: 1

    Have YOU ever used an electric car? Because everyone I've talked to who has, has said they're never going back to an ICE car.

  10. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by tmshort · · Score: 2

    My wife has a LEAF and a short enough commute to work and activities that the car works for her. I have a Volt that I primarily drive in EV mode. We both have Level 2 chargers at home and at work; but the LEAF has a 6.6kW charger, and can accept Level 3 CHAdeMo fast charging. So the double-sized LEAF battery can completely charge in the same time (or less) as the Volt. I know of a city dweller who has a Volt, and they charge it when they go grocery shopping.

    So personal circumstances do matter.

    The issues you bring up are certainly impediments, but an EV with with a decent battery and range extender (like the Volt or BMW i3) I think is the way things will progress. The battery needs to be bigger (at least 100 miles cold range) and the ICE needs to be able to charge the battery while running, not just maintain the charge. It also needs a highway mode that will choose EV or ICE depending on efficiency at speed. So take a Prius Prime, Volt, i3, mish-mash them together.

  11. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    Interesting that you don't drive an EV.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  12. Soon Nissan will outsource the whole car. by ArhcAngel · · Score: 1

    So Nissan gets their engines from Mazda and Cummins and now they'll get their batteries from someone else as well.

    --
    "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it." - K
    1. Re: Soon Nissan will outsource the whole car. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nissan buys quite a few engines from Renault. Buying engines or other major parts from another car maker is quite common. A company can't specialise in everything and sometimes it doesn't add up to build something in small numbers when it can be bought as well.

  13. Gov't Gave ELON Half his Net Worth by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Elon Musk continues to take billions in taxpayer subsidies through his various "green" shell companies, and we're worried that a company that isn't a battery manufacturer wants to get its batteries from a company that IS a battery manufacturer?

    http://thehill.com/blogs/pundi...

  14. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 1

    Interesting that you don't drive an EV.

    I drive an EV, and would not go back to an ICE.

    Advantages:
    I save time and money by not going to gas stations.
    My garage doesn't stink.
    The maintenance is much less.
    It is fun to drive.
    I have nerd-cred.

    Disadvantages:
    I have to stop for 20 minutes every few hours on long trips.
    But this far outweighed by the many many times that I don't have to go to gas stations.

  15. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Rei · · Score: 3, Informative

    Also worth noting that Tesla has the highest owner satisfaction rating in the industry, with 91% saying would buy again (the next closest being Porsche at 84%)

    Tesla only makes electric cars. So, read into that what you will.

    --
    He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  16. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Let me get this straight. It takes 10x longer to recharge your electric car than it takes to fill a car with gas. And you have to recharge your electric car 4x to 5x more often than a car needs to be filled with gas. Yet somehow you think you're 'saving time'?!

  17. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 1

    you have to recharge your electric car 4x to 5x more often than a car needs to be filled with gas. Yet somehow you think you're 'saving time'?!

    Yes. It charges overnight in my garage, or in my parking space at work, while I go about my life. I don't have to sit and wait while it charges. I just park, plug in, and walk away.

  18. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Rei · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Let me get this straight. When you need to stop for gas - say, when you realize "Oh, I need to stop for gas on the way home", you get home only two minutes (20 / 2) later than you otherwise would? Yeah, sure.

    EV drivers in their normal everyday lives never stop and think "Oh, I need to stop for gas on the way home" because they start every day with a full tank. The time to connect your vehicle at home is basically insignificant (not that you have to charge every day if for some reason you don't want to).

    I don't even know what your "4x to 5x" is supposed to mean. A Model 3 has a range from 220 to 310 miles, depending on which variant one gets. Do you think your average car has a range of 880 to 1550 miles? Heck, the only reason that gasoline vehicles have the range they do is to avoid the inconvenience of having to randomly detour from your everyday life to go to a dirty gas station and breathe carcinogenic (literally) fumes while standing outside fueling your vehicle, regardless of the weather. There's no point to 400+ miles range otherwise; it's not safe to drive for such long periods on the highway without stopping, your attention to the road wanes.

    --
    He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  19. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Interesting that you don't drive an EV.

    I drive an EV, and would not go back to an ICE.

    Advantages:
    I save time and money by not going to gas stations.
    My garage doesn't stink. ....

    My garage doesn't stink either despite having two ICE cars in it. You probably had a dead possum or something back in there somewhere.

  20. Exploding electric cars by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Great. So Nissan will be using shitty Chinese-made batteries. Expect to see lots of news stories about Nissan EVs exploding in fireballs for no reason while sitting in traffic.

    1. Re: Exploding electric cars by Crosshair84 · · Score: 1

      I had to buy an aftermarket brand battery for my phone on Amazon because all the "OEM" batteries were obviously fakes.

  21. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    or in my parking space at work

    Where is that? (I can't imagine it being a red state.)

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  22. Seriously? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Open your ICE hood/bonnet. What does the radiator say? Denso. What does the AC compressor say? Denso.

    It pretty does not matter what car you purchase today. The parts overlap significantly. Companies that crank out more parts volume can do it for lower cost.

    To lower the battery cost, manufacturers need volume. Right now, there is not enough volume for one manufacturer to make the venture profitable. The price point has been getting lower over the years though.

    1. Re: Seriously? by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      Huh. The fact that Tesla/panasonic already produces 20-25% of worlds li-ion batteries kind of makes them a volume manufacturer.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  23. Beautiful, Pretty, Cute by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My Leaf gets more compliments than my Porsche. The difference is who I get them from. Almost all of the Leaf complements come from women, while the Porsche complements come from men.

    It is simply a matter of taste.

  24. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 1

    Where is that?

    San Jose, California.

    (I can't imagine it being a red state.)

    Texas has more charging stations than any other state but California.

  25. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Wait... what?
    >>And you have to recharge your electric car 4x to 5x more often than a car needs to be filled with gas
    You have a car with a 1000 mile range on a tank of gas?

  26. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by mattack2 · · Score: 1

    The maintenance is much less.

    So so so so so so so much less.

    I even had a battery problem that was fixed under warranty, and that was a hassle.. but nowhere near as much a hassle as going to the gas station all the time, getting oil changes on schedule, getting it smogged every 2 years, etc..

  27. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by mattack2 · · Score: 1

    EV drivers in their normal everyday lives never stop and think "Oh, I need to stop for gas on the way home" because they start every day with a full tank. The time to connect your vehicle at home is basically insignificant (not that you have to charge every day if for some reason you don't want to).

    I don't want to since I can charge at work.. but even then, I only do it a couple of times a week at most (when I need to), and I have one of the lowest range cars.

  28. re: Tesla and "cult following" by King_TJ · · Score: 1

    Tesla reminds me a lot of Apple..... Knew exactly how to generate a "buzz" around their products, while actually doing a pretty good job of doing R&D to make cool (but expensive) things people want to own.

    Apple users are often accused of being religious zealots too.

    The thing is though? The "big boys" of automotive have a big disadvantage. They're heavily invested in internal combustion engines, unlike Tesla. Almost all of them are still trying to manufacture traditional vehicles while simultaneously switching some of them to electric. They aren't always building cars from the ground up, designed to only be electric. They're shoe-horning batteries and motors into cars that were originally designed for gasoline engines (like the Kia Soul).

    Chevy seems like they have a better chance than the others, but they've been building electric cars (at least sporadically) since the 90's with the EV-1. And even with 2 of them on sale right now -- sales are sluggish and people are unexcited by them. I have low confidence they can compete head-to-head with Tesla because they lack imagination.

  29. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Shanghai Bill that old paid shill. We meet again.

  30. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Tesla sells to fanboys almost exclusively. Of course they have a high customer satisfaction rating.

  31. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    San Jose, California

    I'm not surprised.

    Texas has more charging stations than any other state but California.

    1) A guy as smart as you should know that's a damned meaningless statement: if the state with the third most chargers has 10 charging stations, then your statement would be true by Texas only having 11 charging stations.

    2) Texas is becoming blue.

    3) Are those charging stations in (far left) Austin and (really rich) northern Dallas suburbs, or out in hot, dusty Lubbock?

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  32. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by makomk · · Score: 1

    Pretty much. Current Tesla owners are surprisingly willing to put up with problems like having to return their cars for repair multiple times. It's not clear that the general public will be quite so kind to them.

  33. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by hipp5 · · Score: 1

    Interesting that you don't drive an EV.

    I don't drive an EV because I don't have a car. But if/when my life situation changes such that I need a car, it will be electric.

  34. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    Unless you move to where charging stations aren't as ubiquitous as in San Jose.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  35. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    A Model 3 has a range from 220 to 310 miles

    A Model 3 doesn't have the range for a long weekend at the quaint rural B&B two hours away (plus driving to all the little shops your wife wants to visit in the "nearby" town).

    a dirty gas station and breathe carcinogenic (literally) fumes while standing outside fueling your vehicle

    Not in the US in the (at least) past 15 years.

    regardless of the weather.

    In some very small town gas stations (where you wouldn't find an EV charging station anyway), but certainly not at 98% of gas stations in the US in the past 30 years.

    There's no point to 400+ miles range otherwise; it's not safe to drive for such long periods

    Fine: you find a Motel 6 off the Interstate and check in for the night. Good luck charging your EV over night.

    Same with visiting distant friends/relatives: it would be grossly impolite to plug your car into someone else's power outlet.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  36. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    there are more than 900 stations in Texas spread all over (map does not include RV parks).
    we have a Tesla that we charge overnight on a simple 120V since my wife only goes about 60 miles /day
    when we take long trips we use the Tesla SCs, which make life easy.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  37. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    We do visit relatives that are 180 miles away, and when we do, we DO charge up at their house though it is because they volunteer it. After all, it is only about $2 which is less than the food or drink that we bring there.

    And probably about 1/4 to 1/3 of hotels in America offer an EV charger that is either free or you pay a couple of bucks for.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  38. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Rei · · Score: 1

    A Model 3 doesn't have the range for a long weekend at the quaint rural B&B two hours away

    Where are you getting that from? (also helpful: name the B&B and starting location)

    Not in the US in the (at least) past 15 years.

    How did gasoline manage to become non-carcinogenic (and neurotoxic, and a whole range of other toxicity effects) in the past 15 years?

    In some very small town gas stations (where you wouldn't find an EV charging station anyway), but certainly not at 98% of gas stations in the US in the past 30 years.

    Weather has ceased to exist in the US except in small towns? Or are you saying that US pumps connect themselves to your car on their own like a snake, as well as paying for you with EZ-pass?

    Fine: you find a Motel 6 off the Interstate and check in for the night. Good luck charging your EV over night.

    Lol. Which Motel 6? This one? How about this one? This one maybe? Or perhaps this one? Maybe you meant this one? Or this one? Nah, must have been this one.. No, wait, this one! No, this one! Last guess, this one? Wait, wait a second! How many guesses do I get?

    EV charging is now very common at hotels. And even if a place doesn't officially offer it, 9 times out of 10, if you call and ask, you get a "yes".

    Same with visiting distant friends/relatives: it would be grossly impolite to plug your car into someone else's power outlet.

    Right. Let me get this straight. "Welcome to my home. Thanks for driving five hours to see me! Come on in! Have a bite to eat! Walk on this carpet that I just cleaned! Feel at home! But don't you DARE use 80 cents an hour of electricity, or I'll cut you! No, you have to go plug in at one of the numerous superchargers on the way and have to suffer through half an hour to 80% full while you eat lunch. Muahaha, I've foiled your evil EV-driving plans with my penny-pinching make-you-eat-lunch-during-a-road-trip plot!"

    --
    He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  39. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    There appear to be only 20 SCs in Texas, including one in all of Houston, and one on the 240 mile drive from Houston to Dallas. As soon as you finish the drive, your first thought will be to hunt for a charging station.

    And there are zero in vast swaths of the state.

    In my state, there are six, the closest being 40 miles away. It'll be decades before there's an EV station in the where sisters live (at least 10 miles from the nearest small town).

    And RV parks... is that electricity usage unmetered? (I bet it currently is, and they'll be mighty pissed when people start pulling in and -- effectively -- run a string of sixty 100W light bulbs for 10 hours.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  40. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    How did gasoline manage to become non-carcinogenic (and neurotoxic, and a whole range of other toxicity effects) in the past 15 years?

    Little rubber collars on pump nozzles kept the gas in. Five years ago the rule mandating them was eliminated, because most cars have built-in fume traps. url:http://www.cnn.com/2012/05/10/politics/epa-gas-pump-handles/index.html> It was 70% back then, and I bet it's higher now.

    Weather has ceased to exist in the US except in small towns? Or are you saying that US pumps connect themselves to your car on their own like a snake, as well as paying for you with EZ-pass?

    Are there no awnings over the gas pumps in NY/NJ/PA (or wherever you are that E-ZPass is used)?

    EV charging is now very common at hotels. And even if a place doesn't officially offer it, 9 times out of 10, if you call and ask, you get a "yes".

    Interesting. I looked at one (https://www.plugshare.com/?location=63496#) and you've got to pay $20. That's a decent price for a tank of gas, but you should be morally outraged at the markup charged, since electricity is so cheap.

    But don't you DARE use 80 cents an hour of electricity, or I'll cut you!

    That's a serious math fail.

    The average cost of electricity in the US is 14.2 cents/kWh. After a long trip, the tank is pretty depleted. In this case, 50 kWh (of a max 60kWh) seems a reasonable requirement to "tank up". That turns out to be $7.10.

    Still not much, but (1) it adds up if the visitors are there for a few days, and (2) not everyone has lots of cash to spare.

    you have to go plug in at one of the numerous superchargers on the way

    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. I've looked at the Tesla Supercharger map, and the closest one to me is 35 miles.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  41. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    At the national average of 14.2 cents/kWh, a 50kw charge (the "tank" is usually pretty empty after a long trip) is $7.10.

    Not a lot, but it adds up, and is more than your estimate.

    (Fans always underestimate costs and overestimate availability.)

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  42. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    national average is ~.11 with Colorado being .10. Pueblo, co is around .16/kwh, but they switched to time based so they pay .08/kwh in middle of night.
    In addition, we stop at c.springs and charge for free at Tesla SC site. So it is typically 40-50 kwh that we add at .08, or $3.20-$4.00, which again, they do not care about.
    Sadly, astroturfers always way overestimate.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  43. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    The MS has been defect free for some time ( until recently when musk pushes for quarterly). Yes, the MAX has more then their fair share of issues. And if Tesla produces M3 with MS quality, they will do great. Otoh, if done at MX level, well, they will have customer issues.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  44. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Rei · · Score: 1

    Little rubber collars on pump nozzles kept the gas in. Five years ago the rule mandating them was eliminated, because most cars have built-in fume traps. url:http://www.cnn.com/2012/05/10/politics/epa-gas-pump-handles/index.html> It was 70% back then, and I bet it's higher now.

    You know those drips of gasoline when you pull the hose out? Drips on your fueling port, on the ground, on the pump? What do you think happens to them?

    Yes, they vaporize. Fume traps on modern cars do not make gas stations vapour free.

    Are there no awnings over the gas pumps [wikimedia.org] in NY/NJ/PA (or wherever you are that E-ZPass is used)?

    I'm using US terms. I live in Iceland. I have however lived previously in the US.

    and you've got to pay $20. That's a decent price for a tank of gas, but you should be morally outraged at the markup charged, since electricity is so cheap.

    Meh, business is business. It really doesn't matter because long distance trips are so infrequent for people. It's your everyday life that really matters. Besides, if you don't like what one charger charges, you can just pick another.

    But don't you DARE use 80 cents an hour of electricity, or I'll cut you!

    That's a serious math fail.

    The average cost of electricity in the US is 14.2 cents/kWh. After a long trip, the tank is pretty depleted. In this case, 50 kWh (of a max 60kWh) seems a reasonable requirement to "tank up". That turns out to be $7.10.

    Someone failed to notice the words "an hour". :) I'm assuming charging at 120V 10A on midwestern or southern electricity, since that was my experience in the US. Add 50% for charging from a 15A, or 100% for 20A (somewhat risky for throwing a breaker, even from a bathroom). I'm presuming that you're not showing up and asking someone to disconnect their drier (240V/30A) or oven (240V/50A) for you. ;) I'm also presuming that they don't have a charging cable (aka, don't own an EV). But feel free to make your own assumptions.

    Electricity is cheap. You do whatever you do when you visit a friend or family member and would cause them an expense (aka, going out to eat, going to the movies, travling together and incurring gas bills, etc) - either the whole "Oh, let me pay for that" "Oh no no, I've got it", "Please, let me pay..." routine, or the "pay for something else / bring a gift" routine.

    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. I've looked at the Tesla Supercharger map, and the closest one to me is 35 miles.

    And? You realize that the range on a Model 3 is 220 to 310 miles, right? Again: you stop on the way there or back, just like you do with gas stations. It's really not a tricky concept.

    --
    He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  45. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    Dueling government statistics!
    At the bottom of https://www.bls.gov/regions/west/news-release/averageenergyprices_losangeles.htm

    Table 1. Average prices for gasoline, electricity, and utility (piped) gas, Los Angeles-Riverside-Orange County and the United States, June 2016-June 2017, not seasonally adjusted

    In June 2017, the "Electricity per kWh" cost for "United States" was $0.142.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  46. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by hipp5 · · Score: 1

    Unless you move to where charging stations aren't as ubiquitous as in San Jose.

    I don't live in San Jose, I live in Canada. And they're not ubiquitous here (except Ontario and Quebec). But I would still get an electric, because most charging is done at home and what is available for charging infrastructure is enough for those times I would need it.

  47. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    you stop on the way there or back, just like you do with gas stations. It's really not a tricky concept.

    And when that one SC station happens to be in the opposite direction from where I want to go...? Or it's a long drive and tacking another 30 minutes, and tacking on another 30 minutes is a non-starter?

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  48. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    and what is available for charging infrastructure is enough for those times I would need it.

    I'm as dubious of that as I am of there ever being a Year of the Linux Desktop.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  49. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by hipp5 · · Score: 1

    and what is available for charging infrastructure is enough for those times I would need it.

    I'm as dubious of that as I am of there ever being a Year of the Linux Desktop.

    So you know my own city better than me? Why in the world would I lie about what I need? Why in the world would I buy an electric car if it didn't suit my needs? I get it, you don't think they work for you. But that doesn't mean they don't work for everyone.

  50. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    I'm dubious that you can foresee more than your immediate needs. Unexpected life-altering events happen regularly to young people.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  51. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by hipp5 · · Score: 1

    I'm dubious that you can foresee more than your immediate needs. Unexpected life-altering events happen regularly to young people.

    Are you actually serious? Could you actually be more arrogant? I'm not young. Even if I was, I (or anyone else) don't need your paternalistic advice.

  52. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    I'm not giving you advice; I'm expressing my opinion.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  53. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Rei · · Score: 1

    And when that one SC station happens to be in the opposite direction from where I want to go...?

    The vehicle has a 220-310 mile range. Wait for one that's en route. They're not that far apart.

    --
    He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  54. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    You need to look at the Texas SC map. It's 306 miles from Dallas to Shamrock. Do you really want to cut things that close? And there are zero SC stations in southern NM.

    But, you say, people have to stop and eat, and it's dangerous to drive that long without stopping for rest.

    To that I day... team driving. My family and I do that quite often: pack water and supposedly healthy snacks, hop on the Interstate and hit the gas. Every 3-4 hours stop 10 minutes for bathroom, gasoline, and to switch drivers.

    You can get damned far across the country in one day doing that, especially after the kids hit age 17.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  55. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    Wow. So many things wrong. First off, SCs we're never meant to be primary source of electricity. House plugs are. SCs are meant for in between end points of long distant driving. IOW, u charge at your original and then end point using much lower current and price electricity. If 100% of our vehicle s are EVs, and something like 85% of our vehicles charge at night time, it will actually lower total cost of electricity. These cars that charge in.daytime will in the end cost society with a higher electricity costs.

    as to RV parks, Some of them simply charge by the hour and that solves that issue.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  56. Re:Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by hipp5 · · Score: 1

    No, you are making a series of incredibly wrong assumptions about me, and then suggesting you know better about my life situation than I do. You know nothing about my job, my relationship status, my income, my city, the type of building I live in, the size of my family, my travel needs, the stability of my situation, my age, or anything beyond the fact that I have no car, I am planning on an electric car, and I live in Canada. Yet somehow, you feel like you have a better handle on what I need than I do. Call it opinion if you want, but I'm calling it a very arrogant opinion.

  57. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Rei · · Score: 1

    Okay, finally we have some data - you're going from Dallas to Shamrock (and I presume NM also?). Where in Dallas? If you're starting on the south side or in town, stop at the Arlington supercharger; from the north, the Denton supercharger. There are four more opening up in Dallas this year . Even if you tried you couldn't get an M3 before they opened; the waiting list is two years long (there will be 2018 superchargers (not on the map) opening before someone who placed an order today got their car). Same story with the Wichita Falls supercharger - all of the gray ones on the map open this year (they've been flipping to red one by one - also, some that are still grey on the map are actually already functional, to varying degrees). Wichita Falls is 120 miles from the Arlington supercharger, 100 from Denton. From there it's 110 miles to the Childress supercharger, and from there, 55 to Shamrock. Also en route (at present): 18 non-Tesla chargers outside of Dallas, and many hundreds in Dallas, including over a dozen CHAdeMO/CCS (~50kW).

    As for southern NM, I don't know what you're talking about. Truth or Consequences is already operational. Deming and Soccoro will be operational by the end of this year. And of course across the border the El Paso charger is operational.

      If you want me to be more specific, you need to be more specific as to what routes you're talking about.

    --
    He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  58. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    IOW, u charge at your original and then end point using much lower current and price electricity.

    And you blindly ignored my point that many people drive long distances where they can't stop overnight to charge, and there's no SC around. For example, tag-team driving across southern Texas to southern AZ.

    Not to mention that heat and cold negatively impact battery performance.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  59. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    Where in Dallas? If you're starting on the south side or in town, stop at the Arlington supercharger; from the north, the Denton supercharger.

    But you're supposed to charge up all night at home, so why in the world would you drive the short distance from home to the SC station and then juice up again? That makes no sense.

    There needs to be a SC station between Dallas and Shamrock.

    As for southern NM, I don't know what you're talking about.

    I googled "Tesla supercharger new mexico" and saw none in the entire southern half of the state. A similar search for Texas doesn't show one in El Paso.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  60. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    Southern Taxes to Az, by end of 2017 though knowing Tesla, it is really be end of 2018. Still....
    Still, this is no different than when I was a kid and in the 70s, esp on Sundays, we had to consider where gas stations where to drive from Illinois to Mich, or Illinois to California. Yet, by mid 80s, it was a none issue.
    Same way with EVs, and no doubt Tesla will be the first. What is interesting is that their next SC that should be coming out now, will allow for 5-10 minute charges.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  61. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    Eventually charging stations will get as ubiquitous as gas stations.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  62. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Rei · · Score: 1

    But you're supposed to charge up all night at home

    You're the one who imposed the "no supercharging at the person's house" requirement (which doesn't match reality, FYI). I'm just meeting your impositions.

    so why in the world would you drive the short distance from home to the SC station and then juice up again?

    On the way. Hence Arlington if you're coming from the south and Denton if you're coming from the north.

    There needs to be a SC station between Dallas and Shamrock.

    By the time anyone in Texas gets a M3, there will be two. There's already one.

    I googled "Tesla supercharger new mexico" and saw none in the entire southern half of the state

    Okay, now we're seeing the problem. I'm pretty sure you're looking at "screenshots" of the supercharger map taken from random points in the past, not any of the live maps. It's important to always check the most current data; the network has been growing at a crazy rate.

    This is Tesla's live supercharger map. Red means already fully operational. Grey means either currently unoperational or under construction; all under construction stations are scheduled to be finished by the end of this year (and the total number of stations tripled by the end of next year over what they are today).

    Beyond superchargers (that map also has an option to show Tesla-branded destination chargers), there's exponentially more chargers over at Plugshare, of varying speeds. Note that you have to zoom in before they appear. Plugshare does not show any that are under construction. Superchargers are of course fastest, but they're going to be rivaled very soon by VW's network, which is targeting speeds even faster than the current generation of superchargers (but not as powerful as Tesla's new V3 supercharger, which is still under wraps). Current V2 superchargers are 145kW per charger (usually 4-8 chargers per station), max 120kW per vehicle, up to two vehicles connected to a charger at once (but with supercharger density maintained such that having to share a charger is rare - if it ever ceases to be rare that's a trigger to build more superchargers in an area). Volkswagen's network is going to be a mix of 150kW and 350kW chargers. When asked if Tesla's V3 would be 350kW, Musk responded by calling 350kW a "children's toy". ;)

    --
    He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  63. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Rei · · Score: 1

    In case you're curious, it's rare that most supercharger stations not in big cities will ever need 4 chargers at this point in time, with the number of EVs on the road. It's one of the things that to me continually demonstrates how Tesla understands the market while others' don't. If you just build a single charger somewhere, and someone gets there, and it's taken or broken.... then what? Bad luck, right? But Tesla makes sure that there's always multiple chargers at every site (constantly monitored), on different circuits, to prevent this. And V3 chargers are going to be battery buffered.

    Another example (IMHO) of why I like Tesla is the quality of their engineering. Check the difference between a Tesla supercharger connector (right) vs. a socket for a CHAdeMO connector that delivers less than 40% as much power (left). They're constantly thinking of human factors. Likewise, the reason why they went with such high powers in the first place while everyone else was ignoring it. Companies like Nissan, etc look at EVs like a hair shirt for hippies. "So what if it takes a long time to charge on trips, they'll wait for it so they can save the planet, and think it's fine because they save so much time when not on trips." Same reason that they underpower the motors in their cars. Tesla's goal isn't hippies; their goal is the world.

    --
    He's really very... gentle... and fuzzy. We're becoming fast friends.
  64. Re: Electric cars going the way of 3D TV and RoR by Nutria · · Score: 1

    You're the one who imposed the "no supercharging at the person's house" requirement

    I think one of us changed subjects along the way, and the other didn't see that.

    Otherwise, this was a helpful post.

    --
    "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1