Slashdot Mirror


Scientists Think They've Discovered Lava Tubes Leading To the Moon's Polar Ice (sciencealert.com)

schwit1 quotes ScienceAlert: Small pits in a large crater on the Moon's North Pole could be "skylights" leading down to an underground network of lava tubes -- tubes holding hidden water on Earth's nearest neighbour, according to new research. There's no lava in them now of course, though that's originally how the tubes formed in the Moon's fiery past. But they could indicate easy access to a water source if we ever decide to develop a Moon base sometime in the future.

Despite the Moon's dry and dusty appearance, scientists think it contains a lot of water trapped as frozen ice. What these new observations carried out by NASA's Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) show is that it might be much more accessible than we thought... Scientists have long been thinking about how to extract the ice reserves we think are up there -- solar power was originally out of the question, as it's the freezing shadowed areas of the Moon that have preserved the ice in the first place. Not only would natural skylights like these provide easier access to the underground ice, it would also mean solar power would be back on the table as an idea.

59 comments

  1. Jules Vernes next blockbuster by maroberts · · Score: 2

    Journey to the Centre of the Moon

    --

    Donte Alistair Anderson Roberts - hi son!
    Karma: Chameleon

    1. Re:Jules Vernes next blockbuster by nospam007 · · Score: 2

      "Journey to the Centre of the Moon" ...through a series of tubes.

    2. Re:Jules Vernes next blockbuster by PolygamousRanchKid+ · · Score: 1

      I saw the other movie, and know what is really at the other end of this "series of tube": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

      Of course, I could be wrong, and the skylights could lead to these lovely critters: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

      So . . . future wannabe Moon astronauts will hope for the first, but might get stuck with the second.

      Elon Musk seems to have good luck with everything, so maybe he'll have the courage to go first.

      --
      Schroedinger's Brexit: The UK is both in and out of the EU at the same time!
    3. Re:Jules Vernes next blockbuster by Picodon · · Score: 1

      "Journey to the Centre of the Moon" ...through a series of tubes.

      Does this mean that the Moon already has Internet, then?

    4. Re:Jules Vernes next blockbuster by kelemvor4 · · Score: 1

      "Journey to the Centre of the Moon" ...through a series of tubes.

      There have been tubes through the center of alien worlds since the NYC subway opened years ago.

    5. Re:Jules Vernes next blockbuster by megalomaniacs4u · · Score: 2

      Actually HG Wells' First Men In the Moon got there already. Also see the 60s film adaptation which tied in the Apollo and the recent BBC remake.

  2. Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Do we have the technology to send "flying" drones that could stay low to the surface/land/enter tunnels autonomously on the moon and report the findings back? With no atmosphere, obviously they would have to be propelled by thrusters and I don't know how realistic it is for a small craft to carry the fuel.

    If that is not feasible, would it be more feasible to send surface rovers that have the ability to "jump" long distances? (and send a lot of them) It seems with the moon being only a couple days away from earth, we could very quickly get answers to a lot of questions.

    1. Re: Probes by K.+S.+Kyosuke · · Score: 3, Insightful

      With no atmosphere, obviously they would have to be propelled by thrusters

      Well, there's also this ancient thing called "a rope"...

      --
      Ezekiel 23:20
    2. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Creimer posted an on topic comment. Please do the same.

    3. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Creimer posted a link to his digital diarrhea. I commented on that topic. Please remove your link, person who totally isn't Christopher Dale Reimer at 1919 Fruitdale.

    4. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why do creimertards behave so badly on holiday weekends?

    5. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh hi Chris. Why did you behave so badly for a decade?

    6. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why did the creimertards wait until the 11th year to complain about the last decade?

    7. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      creimer doesn't set the rules at Slashdot. What we are doing is not against the TOS. Complain to the management. Bitching about it as AC in the comments does nothing, Chris.

    8. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Whether anyone complained or not is orthogonal to the fact that you misbehaved for a decade, Jigglypuff.

      How someone with no teeth can manage to eat himself into morbid obesity is fascinating.

    9. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Here is the story of creimy the mountain and his royalties!

      The story of creimy the mountain explained:
      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

      Listen to the audio version here:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?...

      "Creimy The Mountain"

      includes quotes from Pomp and Circumstance March No. 1 in D major (Edward Elgar), Johnny's Theme (Paul Anka), Off We Go Into The Wild Blue Yonder (Crawford), O Mein Papa (Paul Burkhard), Over The Rainbow (Harburg/Arlen), Star-Spangled Banner (Smith/Key), Suite: Judy Blue Eyes (Stephen Stills)

      One, two, three

      CREIMY the Mountain
      CREIMY the Mountain
      A regular picturesque
      Postcardy mountain
      Residing between lovely
      Rosamond and Gorman
      With his stunning wife ETHELL, A tree! A tree!

      CREIMY was a mountain ETHELL was a tree Growing off of his shoulder

      CREIMY was a mountain
      (CREIMY was a mountain!)
      ETHELL was a tree Growing off of his shoulder
      (ETHELL was a tree growing off of his shoulder)
      (hey, hey hey!)

      Creimy had two big
      Caves for eyes,
      With a cliff for a jaw
      That would go up 'n down,
      And whenever it did,
      He'd puff out some dust,
      And hack up a boulder (HACK!) Hack up a boulder (HACK! HACK!)
      Hack up a boulder (HACK! HACK! HACK!) Up a boulder

      Now, one day, now I believe it was on a Tuesday, a man in a checkered double-knit suit drove up in a large El Dorado Cadillac, leased from BOB SPREEN

      ("Where the freeways meet in Downey!")

      And he laid a HUGE, BULGING ENVELOPE right at the corner of CREIMY THE MOUNTAIN, that was right where his 'foot' was supposed to be.

      Now, CREIMY THE MOUNTAIN, he couldn't believe it! All those postcards he'd posed for, for ALL OF THOSE YEARS, and finally, now, AT LAST, his Royalties!

      Royalties! Royalties Royalties! Royalty check is in, honey!

      Yes, CREIMY THE MOUNTAIN was RICH! Yes, and his eyeball-caves, they widened in amazement, and his jaw (which was a cliff), well it dropped thirty feet!

      A bunch of dust puffed out! Rocks and boulders hacked up, (hack! hack!) crushing 'The LINCOLN'!

      I gave him the money He acted real funny He hocked up a rock and It TOTALLED my car!

      Oh, do you Know any trucks Might be bound for THE VALLEY?
      I don't wanna stand here All night in this bar (Dear Lord)

      I don't wanna stand here All night in this bar (No shit!)

      I don't wanna stand here All night in this bar!

      By two o'clock, when the bars are already closed down, CREIMY had broken 'THE BIG NEWS' to ETHELL. And with dust and boulders everywhere, CREIMY, choked with excitement, announced

      "ETHELL, we're going on a VACATION!"

      Yes, and they WERE going on a vacation! (Oh, and ETHELL, ETHELL, ETHELL, like every little woman, she of course was very excited! She creaked a little bit, and some old birds flew off of her.) CREIMY told ETHELL they were going to Yes! They were going to NEW YORK!

      "ETHELL, we're going to New York!"

      But first they were gonna stop in LAS VEGAS

      It's off to LAS VEGAS to check out the lounges Pull a few handles,
      And drink a few beers, (Oh, ETHELL!)

      ETHELL, my darling, you know that I love you!
      I'm glad we could have a Vacation this year! (Oh, NEET-O!)

      Glad we could have a Vacation this year!

      They left that night, crunchin' across the Mojave Desert their voices echoing through the canyons of your minds (POO-AAH!)

      "ETHELL, wanna get a cuppa cawfee?"

      (Howard Johnson's! Howard Johnson's!
      Howard Johnson's! Howard Johnson's!)

      "Ahhh! there's a HOWARD JOHNSONS! Wanna eat some CLAMS?"

      The first noteworhty piece of real estate they destroyed was EDWARDS AIR FORCE BASE

      And TO THIS VERY DAY, 'Wing Nuts' and Data Reduction Clerks alike, speak in reverent whispers about that fateful night when TEST STAND #1 and THE ROCKET SLED ITSELF (We have ignition!) got LUNCHED! I said LUNCHED! (Lunched!) By a FAM

    10. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Creimer post on topic comments. Creimertards shitstorm like crazy. Which one do think the Slashdot community finds more irritating than Irritable Bowel Syndrome?

    11. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Creimer post on topic comments."

      Ah ha! You're getting rattled again Chris! Your crammar is coming back!

      "Which one do think the Slashdot community"

      Hee hee, look at the irritated fat man! See how his giant cheeks flush red! See how his chins jiggle and his toothless mouth drools!

    12. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Look at the stupid creimertard! Still thinks every AC is Chris. LMAO!

    13. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I guess if the Slashdot community appreciated you they would mod you up or even ask that the rules of moderation be changed. Perhaps out of sympathy they would look around you Youtube channel?

      However, you are stuck at -1, everybody thinks you're a shitstain who deserves to be moderated to the point that most Slashdotters won't see your posts, and your latest video only has SIX views. LOLOLOLOLOL

      You're always going to be that guy who blogs about marrying children and describes their shit in great detail and is just generally a weird stupid pervert who in real life nobody would want anything to do with.

    14. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...and after the crammar, the typical lame Chris lame comeback, complete with the LMAO or ROFL at the end. No one else uses that anymore, just you.

      Chris, you are as easy to pick out of a crowd as Denis Rodman in North Korea.

      For one thing, you always deflect when cornered, like a cockroach. A 400 pound cockroach is a nightmare, but I've seen Damnation Alley so I'm used to it.

      For another, you have a very, very lame sense of humor, and repetition is one of your favorite techniques. This fits in with your child-like personality.

      You're as easy to spot as the sweat stain you leave on a plastic seat in summer.

    15. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I guess if the Slashdot community appreciated you they would mod you up

      Creimer has been up modded a dozen times over the last several weeks and has been breaking out of posting one or twice a day. This is why the creimertards are shitstorming a shithole on Slashdot. Creimer is gaining respectability.

    16. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If you think "respectability" comes from a few mouse clicks from strangers, you're hopeless beyond redemption.

      You'll always be at -1 from now on, Chris.

    17. Re: Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This copypasta sucks :(

    18. Re:Probes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How many of these mod-ups are from one of your many sockpuppets?

      Anyway, who cares about up-votes? That's not a sign of "respectability." People can vote your post "+1 Insightful" and not know/care anything about you one way or the other. If they saw you in real life they would still think you are a fat old weirdo taking videos of fountains.

  3. Flash Gordon! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So wow, now we can send men and equipment up there to live in a moon base, right? For what purpose I do not know, but we seem determined to spend all kinds of ridiculous money on going to the moon and mars for very little in return. It would seem that the money would be better spent on robotic missions. Look at the comparatively small amount of money that has been spent on robotic missions and see how much actual science has been done as compared to the ridiculously expensive manned missions. What a joke.

  4. Re: Simple question by K.+S.+Kyosuke · · Score: 2

    Because in a few years, that senile joke will be dead, but the lava tubes will be there for eons to come?

    --
    Ezekiel 23:20
  5. Re: Simple question by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes, we should ignore all future development, exploration, science, and technology... Because Trump said a bad word...

    You are a fucking imbecile.

  6. Re:Simple question by hey! · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Well, it makes lunar habitation feasible in the relatively nearer future.

    Consider this analogous question: did the discovery of the cancer gene BRCA1 affect anyone at all? To your way of thinking, no, because it didn't immediately cure anyone's cancer. It only affected the lives of a very small number of cancer scientists by pointing them down promising avenues of research.

    --
    Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
  7. Libertarian paradise. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is the libertarian paradise we have all waited for since Saint Rand blew Saint Heinlein and gave birth to our movement! I say all we libertarians should immediately board SpaceX ships and make our way to these lava tubes to spend eternity in a free market paradise of lunian proportions!

  8. Re: Simple question by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    AGREED. Russian KGB OPERATIVE TRUMP must be removed and replaced with Hillary/Oprah.

  9. Re: Simple question by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Cancel all science. This guy doesn't like the president.

  10. Swiss Cheese by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Small holes? That proves that the moon is made of Swiss cheese.

  11. I can just see the Chelsey Bonestell... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    painting in my mind. Guys in silver space suits standing on the ice in a huge cavern. They've gone partway down the lava tube but the large opening to the surface is very much visible. Through it you can just see the tip of the very aerodynamic spacecraft and perhaps a half-earth in the sky.

    His paintings at the planetarium in Chicago made me seriously consider a career in art theft.

    1. Re: I can just see the Chelsey Bonestell... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh yeah!!! Exactly what went through my head, too!!

      Last year I found a book of prints of many of his paintings, very nice quality prints. The book was $170 and totally worth it.

    2. Re: I can just see the Chelsey Bonestell... by mnemotronic · · Score: 1
      --
      The Russians have won. They have made the world a cesspool of distrust, greed, fear and hate.
  12. There's *Ice* In Them Thar.. by BlueStrat · · Score: 3, Informative

    Lunar ice-miner twenty-forty-niner!

    In space and/or on an airless rock, water is far more valuable than gold.

    This lunar ice deep in lava tubes on the moon was predicted back in 1966 in the science fiction novel "The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress" by Robert A. Heinlein.

    Of course in Heinlein's story, the Moon was a penal colony. Considering the authoritarian direction most nations seem to be drifting towards, maybe this is another Heinlein "prediction" that will come to pass.

    "This Court sentences you to life in the Alcatraz-II lunar penal colony."

    Strat

    --
    Progressivism (aka US 'Liberalism'): Ideas so good they need a police/surveillance-state to enforce.
    1. Re:There's *Ice* In Them Thar.. by KeensMustard · · Score: 1

      In space and/or on an airless rock, water is far more valuable than gold.

      But to be fair, neither substance is valuable in space, unless you are engaged in some sort of automated manufacturing which requires gold or water (the latter being perhaps more commonly required in significant quantities for manufacturing).

      This lunar ice deep in lava tubes on the moon was predicted back in 1966 in the science fiction novel "The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress" by Robert A. Heinlein.

      What Heinlein didn't predict (and perhaps could not have done so) was the advancement in robotics that ruled the presence of humans on the moon already obsolete.

      Of course in Heinlein's story, the Moon was a penal colony. Considering the authoritarian direction most nations seem to be drifting towards, maybe this is another Heinlein "prediction" that will come to pass.

      Authoritarian nations generally seem to exploit those prisoners for their labour, rather than stick them somewhere where their labour would have not value.

    2. Re:There's *Ice* In Them Thar.. by BlueStrat · · Score: 1

      But to be fair, neither substance is valuable in space, unless you are engaged in some sort of automated manufacturing which requires gold or water

      Wrong, as water == fuel for rockets/thrusters, shielding against radiation & micrometeorites and more. That's not even considering providing oxygen and drinking water to any humans.

      What Heinlein didn't predict (and perhaps could not have done so) was the advancement in robotics that ruled the presence of humans on the moon already obsolete.

      Robots can "do things" usually much better than humans. What they cannot do is *experience* things for humans.

      Besides, at some point in the future humans will have to colonize places off of the Earth. Robots will be helpful in preparing such places.

      Authoritarian nations generally seem to exploit those prisoners for their labour, rather than stick them somewhere where their labour would have not value.

      Apparently you have not read the story. The entire point of the penal colony was to grow rice and ship it to a starving, overpopulated Earth using a system of giant electromagnetic rail guns to shoot containers into the ocean. (which later in the story they turn into a strategic weapon)

      Strat

      --
      Progressivism (aka US 'Liberalism'): Ideas so good they need a police/surveillance-state to enforce.
  13. If they do discover 'frozen ice' on the Moon, by ThaumaTechnician · · Score: 1

    we can call it a 'free gift'.

  14. Redundant by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Frozen ice". What is frozen ice?

  15. Re: Simple question by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    I don't like Trump either, but I've chosen to go on living my life. I feel sorry for the people with so much wrong in their life they've latched on to Trump as their ultimate scapegoat. "If only Trump is out of office, then my life will turn around!" To paraphrase Trump...how very sad.

  16. Lava Tube by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I know I've discovered my lava tube.

  17. Re:Simple Answer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    To keep you thinking you live on a sphere moving through the heavens.

    You think it is coincidence the Sun is 400 times bigger than the moon, and 400 times farther away so we can have solar eclipse?

    You think it is coincidence the human female and the moon both have a 28 day cycle?

    You think it obvious and inevitable that we have a moon with only one visible side?

    Watch the Lunar eclipse Jan 30/31, 2018, and your eyes will be opened.

  18. Tintin was right! by AJWM · · Score: 4, Interesting
    So Tintin (or rather Hergé) got it right in Explorers on the Moon when Tintin discovers ice in a lunar cave. ;)

    http://en.tintin.com/images/ti...

    --
    -- Alastair
  19. Re: Simple question by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    You know what friend, I can tie it all together. In order to fix politics we need healthier ways for us all to communicate. That means replacing Facebook with a more nuanced variety of platforms to have discussions. All the tech in the next 20 years, Facebook or none, will require exponentially more satellites to circle the planet and move our data. The one thing that you cannot affordable carry to space to keep sattelites going but we do it anyway, is hydrogen and oxygen as propellant. The prospect of mining water ice to electrolyze into hydrogen and oxygen propellant, all outside the costly gravity well of earths surface, is a serious and not theoretical next step in industrial development.

  20. At least they're not going crazy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    And screaming "there may be life on the moon!"

  21. Nice. But to be really useful by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Someone'll have to find a good supply of barley up there, too.

  22. Hard vacuum by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If the moon's a hard vacuum wouldn't any ice exposed to space sublimate away?

  23. Re: Simple question by mnemotronic · · Score: 1

    It's kinda sad. OW is (I hope) smart enough to know to not run. The DNC is so discombobulated after their shoe-in lost, and so desperate for anyone with a pulse that they'll float a 2020 rumor for a rich TV star with no military or political experience. Maybe the pulse will become optional and they'll nominate Barbara Jordan. Or go full-throttle down the rich entertainer track and try Barbara Streisand, with Wayne Newton as VP.

    --
    The Russians have won. They have made the world a cesspool of distrust, greed, fear and hate.
  24. And now for something completely different by mnemotronic · · Score: 1


    And now for something completely different .... Working in a Lava Tube, sung to the melody of Devo - Working In a Coal Mine

    Workin' in a lava tube
    Goin' down, down, down
    Lookin' for the water fall
    Oops, about to slip down
    Workin' lunar lava tubes
    Goin' down down, down
    Look out for the icy stuff
    Oops, about to slip down

    Five o'clock in the morning
    That last tube sure was a dud
    This one lookin' no better
    How long before I get some bud?

    Daddies workin' in a lava tube
    Goin' down, down, down
    Lookin' for the water fall
    Oops, about to slip down
    Workin' lunar lava tubes
    Goin' down down, down
    Look out for the icy stuff
    Oops, about to slip down

    'Course I paid in Bitcoin
    Haulin' ice ain't no fun
    But when Saturday come round
    No beer, no xbox, no fun

    I'm just workin' in a lava tube
    Goin' down, down, down
    Lookin' for the water fall
    Oops, about to slip down
    Workin' ....



    thank you.

    --
    The Russians have won. They have made the world a cesspool of distrust, greed, fear and hate.
  25. Re: Simple question by Applehu+Akbar · · Score: 1

    I cant find any specific Constitutional reason why Jordan couldn’t get the nomination, so long as the VP could handle the State of the union address. It’s probable that even if elected people wouldn’t notice for at least a while because lobbyists do all the talking for today’s pols anyway.

  26. Caves also block radiation... by Ranbot · · Score: 1

    A prime location for a lunar [or martian] base would be inside a cave thick enough overhead to block dangerous radiation and recoverable ice/water inside.

    Discovering lunar caves/lava tubes is not really news though... From 2016: https://www.space.com/32795-mo...
    These are just more caves found closer to the lunar pole and hypothesizes there MIGHT be water/ice inside.