Slashdot Mirror


'Bombe' Replica Code-Breaking WW2 Computer Was Used To Decipher Message Scrambled By An Enigma Machine (bbc.com)

An anonymous reader quotes a report from the BBC: Computer historians have staged a re-enactment of World War Two code-cracking at Bletchley Park. A replica code-breaking computer called a Bombe was used to decipher a message scrambled by an Enigma machine. Held at the National Museum of Computing (TNMOC), the event honored Polish help with wartime code-cracking. Enigma machines were used extensively by the German army and navy during World War Two. This prompted a massive effort by the Allies to crack the complex method they employed to scramble messages. That effort was co-ordinated via Bletchley Park and resulted in the creation of the Bombe, said Paul Kellar who helps to keep a replica machine running at the museum. Renowned mathematician Alan Turing was instrumental in the creation of the original Bombe.

For its re-enactment, TNMOC recruited a team of 12 and used a replica Bombe that, until recently, had been on display at the Bletchley Park museum next door. The electro-mechanical Bombe was designed to discover which settings the German Enigma operators used to scramble their messages. As with World War Two messages, the TNMOC team began with a hint or educated guess about the content of the message, known as a "crib," which was used to set up the Bombe. The machine then cranked through the millions of possible combinations until it came to a "good stop," said Mr Kellar. This indicated that the Bombe had found key portions of the settings used to turn readable German into gobbledygook. After that, said Mr Kellar, it was just a matter of time before the 12-strong team cracked the message.

37 comments

  1. funny story by religionofpeas · · Score: 4, Interesting

    During WW2, the Ministry of Defence searched everywhere for cryptogramists (experts in code breaking), but accidentally hired a cryptogamist (expert in algae and other spore-distributing plants), Geoffrey Tandy, whose expertise turned out to be useful in restoring a water logged codebook.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...

    1. Re:funny story by Dutch+Gun · · Score: 2

      If you're interested in stories related to codebreaking, Code Girls is a pretty entertaining and informative read. I've read lots of war-related accounts and biographies, but this one had a different flavor, being about war-related work on the homefront, and about codebreaking women, who were not given much if any credit for the work they did in this or other fields during the war.

      --
      Irony: Agile development has too much intertia to be abandoned now.
  2. For added authenticity by skoskav · · Score: 2, Insightful

    At the end of the day, one of the team members who was a homosexual was given a cyanide pill.

    1. Re:For added authenticity by gnasher719 · · Score: 2

      At the end of the day, one of the team members who was a homosexual was given a cyanide pill.

      At the end of the day, one of team members who was gay and forced to undergo "treatment" took a cyanide pill.

    2. Re:For added authenticity by hackertourist · · Score: 1

      During WW2, homosexuality seems to have been mostly ignored. Turing's arrest and conviction wasn't until 1952, and had nothing to do with his life at Bletchley. So why dredge this up every time there's a story about Bletchley Park?

    3. Re: For added authenticity by Sultan+Of+Smut · · Score: 2

      Because his government hired him to help save the country which he did. That government then forced Turing to kill himself. They saw his earlier work as a separate issue too. Now save your breath if you were going to reply with taking issue with my use of the word "forced". It's too early in the morning for the "no one forced him to do it" rhetoric.

    4. Re: For added authenticity by hackertourist · · Score: 1

      By that reasoning, you'd have to bring up mistreatment of gay people in just about every story that is about human history of up until a few decades ago. Why the selective outrage in Bletchley Park stories?

    5. Re:For added authenticity by skoskav · · Score: 1

      I haven't brought it up before. I thought the absurd scenario I described would draw a chuckle from satirizing old-timey thinking.

      You know, comedy.

    6. Re: For added authenticity by Sultan+Of+Smut · · Score: 1

      I was staying on topic and to avoid following you and the strawman down the yellow brick road. Why did you comment on this anyway? The actions by the government of the day are very much a part of this story. Does it bother you that much? If it never happened then we wouldn't be talking about it. But it did. See how easy it is? If you don't act like a barbarian you don't get laughed at.

    7. Re: For added authenticity by Darinbob · · Score: 1

      He probably was never forced to do this. The two prevailing theories are either suicide or accidental poisoning. An early biographer strongly suggested suicide, but there were others not necessarily prone to apologizing for the government who pointed to evidence suggesting an accident. We probably won't know for sure, but forced poisoning or encouraging he poison himself is a bit of a stretch.

    8. Re:For added authenticity by rtb61 · · Score: 1

      How about they were forced too use the name of the exercise in US customs and then immediately spent an extended period of time in a holding facility where they get to spend special time customs and hoses and insertions or what ever the crazy fuck they get into.

      Using the word bombe no matter how you spell it is a bad idea. Like would it be a criminal offence to ring up the military and warn them there is a bomb on that large attack carrier floating in their harbour. I mean there are a whole bunch of bombs on board, so it would not be a lie and anything they did would be their choice and the bomb threat is entirely theirs to themselves.

      --
      Chaos - everything, everywhere, everywhen
  3. Poland Developed the Bombe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    The Bombe was originally built by Polish crypt analysts using data given to them by the French. It was able to get the daily key used by the enigma machine, of the time, fairly quickly. When Poland was in danger of falling to the invading Nazi forces they sent a bombe and the results of their work to France and England. I assume they then destroyed any evidence of their accomplishment before the Nazis arrived. England, in the form of Alan Turing et al, then used this accomplishment to eventually develop a new machine that could extract the daily key from the newer, improved enigma machine.

    The name Bombe came from the shape of the Polish machine. It looked like a type of French dessert called a "Bombe"

    1. Re:Poland Developed the Bombe by NikeHerc · · Score: 1

      The Bombe was originally built by Polish crypt analysts using data given to them by the French.

      What data? My reading says the bombe was a strictly Polish design with no input from French or Brits.

      --
      Circle the wagons and fire inward. Entropy increases without bounds.
    2. Re:Poland Developed the Bombe by hackertourist · · Score: 3, Informative

      using data given to them by the French

      AIU it was the other way round. The Polish team developed the codebreaking method using their own resources (notably, they were able to reconstruct the rotor wiring just by analyzing coded messages). They approached the French because they wanted to share their knowledge before the country was overrun. Also, changes made by the Germans meant the problem had become more complex and vastly more machines and personnel were needed to break the new codes with any regularity - resources the Polish cypher bureau didn't have.

    3. Re:Poland Developed the Bombe by Dutch+Gun · · Score: 2

      If I recall correctly, there were several phases in the bombe design. The original Polish codebreaking efforts, including their bombe, relied on some principles that turned out in the long run to be fragile and unsustainable. That was where Turing came in. He redesigned a British bombe on more general principles, and as such, was able to continue breaking messages when the Polish method stopped working due to changes in the encryption systems.

      The Polish definitely got the ball rolling, but Turing made many key breakthroughs, and the Americans helped later with their manufacturing prowess, which was required when a four-rotor Enigma was introduced that required much faster machines, and more of them. So, all three countries created their own bombe designs, and contributed to the codebreaking effort in their own capacity.

      I'm assuming what was demonstrated at Bletchley was one of the original British Turing-designed three-rotor-capable bombes, but the article didn't make that completely clear.

      --
      Irony: Agile development has too much intertia to be abandoned now.
    4. Re:Poland Developed the Bombe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Gustave Bertrand was the French Colonel who purchased Enigma secrets from a German code clerk. He provided them to the English & Polish, but it was the Polish that actually used that information to break the Enigma via the Bombe. Once Poland was going to be overrun, they provided the Bombes to the English & French, who used them to break the Enigma code at Bletchley park.

  4. Bombes in Washington by jmcharry · · Score: 4, Informative

    What is seldom mentioned is that the British sent the design for the Bombe to the US where hundreds were built and did the bulk of the decrypting work. This is nicely presented at the NSA museum at Ft. Meade, which also has several Enigma machines, including a pre-war commercial version, and a section of a Bombe on display.

    1. Re:Bombes in Washington by hackertourist · · Score: 2

      I recently saw a documentary that referred to this as an early version of cloud computing: Bletchley Park sent intercepted messages and menus (Bombe settings) to the US via telegraph cables, where they were run and the results returned.

  5. Cosmology vs Cosmetology by Roger+W+Moore · · Score: 2

    There is a similar story about the cosmologist Werner Israel who appeared on a television show. Unfortunately, the interviewer had prepared lots of questions about lipstick, eyeshadow etc. because she thought he was an expert in cosmetology.

  6. From Airplane! A bu-? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Not a bu-, a Bombe!

  7. Amazing place by hackertourist · · Score: 2

    It's quite remarkable these people were able to build a working replica, when all Bombes were destroyed after WW2 and its design kept secret. All they had to go on was people's recollections and the odd bit smuggled out here and there.
    And then they went and did the same for the Colossus.

    1. Re:Amazing place by spaceyhackerlady · · Score: 1

      A lot of the information was classified until the 1990s. Many of the people involved never got the credit they deserved.

      Some of it was declassified later, like very careful statistical analysis that suggested the most likely rotors in use.

  8. Gobbledygook by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Gobbledygook" sounds like a new name for a new cipher suite :)

  9. sorry by nospam007 · · Score: 1

    It was easy 70 years ago because there was always a 'Heil Hitler' at the end of each message, so it must be much easier today.

    1. Re:sorry by NikeHerc · · Score: 1

      It was easy 70 years ago because there was always a 'Heil Hitler' at the end of each message, so it must be much easier today.

      I realize you're trying to be funny, but you are also wrong; there was no 'Heil Hitler' at the end of each message. I would encourage you, however, to read up on "cillies," "nothing to report," weather station messages, "gardening," and other crib-based decryptions.

      --
      Circle the wagons and fire inward. Entropy increases without bounds.
    2. Re: sorry by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Heil hitler was actually also one of the common terms along with weather. Nothing to rePort and of course c.I.l.l.y. the movie simplifies this all to heal hitler

  10. So basically... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...this decrypter is the Bombe!

  11. Bad idea. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You should never set a bombe in a crib. The explosion will almost certainly wake the baby.

  12. Polish cryptologists (Rejewski) broke enigma first by rrx · · Score: 1

    They achieved it before the war and constructed the first prototype of the bomb. Alan Turing gained this groundbreaking knowledge from them during his visit in Warsaw (just before the outbreak of war). He implemented the acquired solution using British technical resources and significantly reduced the computation time. https://www.warhistoryonline.c...