Ah, yes, the THREE BIG LIES of Wikipedia admins about Wikipedia Review.
Let's try some facts, shall we?
Lie #1: "Wikipediareview has made a policy of harassing editors and admins"
Harassing? No. Calling them to account for antisocial behavior, lies, GFDL violations, and point-of-view pushing on an allegedly neutral wiki? Yes.
Lie #2: "the users coordinated attacks where they call people at their houses late at night"
There are still no real-world examples of this. Only stories that members of the this-is-not-a-cabal tell each other to assure themselves of the pure evil of WR.
Lie #3: "and call their employers to complain about them to get them fired."
Other than the "Ryan" "Jordan" mess, yes, one WR user tried this. That user was banned from the site.
And bonus Lie #4, the always-fun comparison to Nazis. Quite frankly, the Wikipedia Uber Alles mindset is far more reminicent of the Nazis than anything WR has ever done. And if you don't think so, just watch some of the key admins. It can be... insightful. And frightening.
Slashdot Mirror
Ah, yes, the THREE BIG LIES of Wikipedia admins about Wikipedia Review.
Let's try some facts, shall we?
Lie #1: "Wikipediareview has made a policy of harassing editors and admins"
Harassing? No. Calling them to account for antisocial behavior, lies, GFDL violations, and point-of-view pushing on an allegedly neutral wiki? Yes.
Lie #2: "the users coordinated attacks where they call people at their houses late at night"
There are still no real-world examples of this. Only stories that members of the this-is-not-a-cabal tell each other to assure themselves of the pure evil of WR.
Lie #3: "and call their employers to complain about them to get them fired."
Other than the "Ryan" "Jordan" mess, yes, one WR user tried this. That user was banned from the site.
And bonus Lie #4, the always-fun comparison to Nazis. Quite frankly, the Wikipedia Uber Alles mindset is far more reminicent of the Nazis than anything WR has ever done. And if you don't think so, just watch some of the key admins. It can be... insightful. And frightening.