Slashdot Mirror


User: repapetilto

repapetilto's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
1,162
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 1,162

  1. Re:We voted for it on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    No, I am asking if it is the FDA's responsibility to investigate fraud.

  2. Re:Theory and Application on The Math Formula That Lead To the Financial Crash · · Score: 1

    Well, you could argue that any bank doing that would just eventually fail due to their policy of underestimating risks. The problem is that the bank gets to take down everyone around them as well. Why are banks so huge and powerful?

    Perhaps if banks were treated like normal businesses it wouldn't be such a big deal when they fail. Then again there is a 200 year history of special treatment (bank holidays, etc) so it would be a shock to the system to do that now.

  3. Re:No Really on The Math Formula That Lead To the Financial Crash · · Score: 1

    Is it that complicated? I thought the models just gave the traders an excuse to underestimate kurtosis risk.

  4. Re:Don't blame math on The Math Formula That Lead To the Financial Crash · · Score: 1

    This is a pretty good anaylsis. All these people saying "its the banks", "it's the governments", "its human greed" are not contributing anything worthwhile. Thanks.

  5. Wow look at all these trolls. on Bitcoin Mining Startup Gets $500k In Venture Capital · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It is becoming more and more obvious who is on which side of the bitcoin "debate". This thread honestly isn't even worth reading, everyone who knows what they are talking about is spending all their time explaining the most basic info to idiots. Admittedly there are a few lazy, but intelligent sounding posters mixed in, but this is mostly just troll FUD. 95% of normal people either think it is interesting or just don't care.

  6. Re:You Forgot the Part About the Money on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    I dunno. I just did a quick literature search and saw nothing about paleo-diets causing death in diabetics. This guy has been posting FUD about it throughout this thread.

  7. Re:Practicing nutrition? on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1
  8. Re:positive feedback loop on Massive Methane Release In the Arctic Region · · Score: 1

    Oh. I thought you were referring to "people in the street".

  9. Re:positive feedback loop on Massive Methane Release In the Arctic Region · · Score: 1

    Most people who "believe in" AGW are the same...

  10. Re:We voted for it on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    I highly doubt he properly analyzed the literature. You can cherry pick literature to say whatever you want. Doesn't make him wrong, but doesn't mean his theory has been tested either.

  11. Re:he was giving out business cards.... on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    Please cite the study on which you are basing your fear that paleo diets may be deadly to diabetics.
    Where does he advocate going ketotic?

  12. Re:all for a FAQ on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    1) What city built a roadway using some random guy's plans? Perhaps politicians should be licensed to make decisions.

    2 )The person getting a manicure can avoid the infection problem by being aware of, and demanding common sanitary practices.

    Really, these aren't real problems.

  13. Re:he was giving out business cards.... on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    Why would it be his fault that someone listened to him?

  14. Re:You Forgot the Part About the Money on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    Hmm, ok. Now try to think of ways to weasel that definition to mean whatever you want. Protest is a good one too.

    Well. The first problem with your definition is the WBC could still protest "body not present" (not sure what the real word for this is) funerals. So we would need to fix it to account for that.

  15. Re:We voted for it on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    One guys book isn't going to prove anything. At most there is a logical sounding narrative in there. I am not saying he is wrong, but you shouldn't act like the guy created some book of truth.

  16. Re:You Forgot the Part About the Money on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    How will you define funeral?

  17. Re:Practicing nutrition? on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    If you haven't noticed, doctor's don't really have a good way of dealing with most cancers either. I would personally choose to go to MDs because they're methods have a greater basis in evidence, but they are not perfect. Other's might believe taking medicine is a sin or something like that. I think that is dumb, but so be it... so is overmedication.

  18. Re:You Forgot the Part About the Money on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 3, Insightful

    From what I have seen of his recommendations they could easily cause hypoglycemia, a potentially fatal condition.

    Are you qualified to assess this?

  19. Re:We voted for it on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    Then he should be arrested/sued for defrauding people. I didn't see anything about that in the story.

  20. Re:good on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    unqualified

    This part doesn't matter. If lying is going on, that is the problem. Really, lying isn't even necessarily the problem either, it is being wrong. "Qualified" people lie and make mistakes as well.

    Perhaps you need someone to stamp qualified on a piece of paper in order to trust health advice (not saying this is stupid, it is a decent heuristic). What would be wrong with trusting membership in a trade union rather than the government?

  21. Re:he was giving out business cards.... on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    I asked a similar question elsewhere, but why should he need a license?

      If anything the license makes him more dangerous if he is a quack. He just needs to pass some test that is most likely BS and pay the government money, now he seems like a legit expert to people.

  22. Re:Why just OUR government? on The Crisis of Government-Funded Science · · Score: 1

    Well thanks for taking the time to think about it. I'm not sure what that means though.

  23. Re:good on North Carolina Threatens To Shut Down Nutrition Blogger · · Score: 1

    Why?

  24. Re:Why just OUR government? on The Crisis of Government-Funded Science · · Score: 1

    Yep, a joke. No one thinks there is value in basic research. There is no one willing to contribute to large scale projects unless forced by government to do so.

    Well, that's a strawman. But really, the US science budget is pretty miniscule.

    100 million people giving an average of $1500 a year would cover it. Obviously it wouldn't be normally distributed.

    How much would you voluntarily give? If not donating, what would convince you to invest?

  25. Re:Why just OUR government? on The Crisis of Government-Funded Science · · Score: 1

    So should we compare a single rich guy with all the worlds governments? Perhaps not.