Slashdot Mirror


User: swillden

swillden's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
18,006
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 18,006

  1. Re:Crushed Freedoms on James Watson's Nobel Prize Goes On Auction This Week · · Score: 2

    And yet no one silenced Watson.

    Except all those venues that cancelled his sold-out lectures, his forced retirement, and the fact he's being forced into giving up his Nobel (according to the first link in the summary)...

    People deciding not to pay to listen to you is far from the same thing as people silencing you.

    Free speech means that you cannot be prevented from speaking your mind (within some limits, which Watson did not cross), but it in no way obligates people to listen to you, much less to pay you for the privilege of listening to you.

  2. Re:Of Course It Was on James Watson's Nobel Prize Goes On Auction This Week · · Score: 1

    There is [google.co.uk] scientific evidence that genetic variation within "races" is greater than the variation between the median genetic profiles of "races".

    so you're saying "yes"

    Well, assuming you don't know what "variation" and "median" mean, sure, why not call that a "yes"?

    I can only assume from your response that you're a member of one of those "inferior" races, since if you were a member of the superior race you would recognize your own stupidity. Is there a racial analogue of the Dunning-Kruger effect... the stupidest races consider themselves the most competent?

  3. Re:US Centric? on Is a "Wikipedia For News" Feasible? · · Score: 2

    My experience is that, regardless of country, the reporting of any news of which I have firsthand knowledge is wrong in all sorts of ways. Usually they get the gist right, but that's about it... and they don't always get that much right. I remind myself regularly that this cannot be an artifact related to my personal knowledge, but that all news reporting must be flawed.

    Just take everything with a grain of salt. Or a pound.

  4. Re:This is clearly futile... on Google Told To Expand Right To Be Forgotten · · Score: 1

    The point is that the page rank algorithm just reflects the consensus of other sites on the web. If you don't like that consensus, you should take it up with all of those sources.

  5. Re:Wow... on Debian Forked Over Systemd · · Score: 1

    Shudup boy, this is for your own good.

    Boy? LOL.

  6. Re:Why not UselessDebian? on Debian Forked Over Systemd · · Score: 1

    I'm an admin. I don't want to be excited about startup managers. If I get excited by init, it means something is broken.

    Yes, the lack of detailed status information about init-managed process is something that is broken in traditional init systems, so it's fine to get excited by the fact that systemd fixes this brokenness.

  7. Re:Nevada, not Utah on Shale: Good For Gas, Oil...and Nuclear Waste Disposal? · · Score: 1

    Facts don't matter, but what does matter is the chance to spread fact less based hype and pass it off as some type accepted fact. Rather, just smoke from an anti nuke agenda driven organization.

    Given the recent discovery that water is much more of an issue than originally thought for the tough rock at Yucca Mountain

    Heh. Well, if your goal is to spread fact-less hype, you should be careful not to include blindingly obvious errors in your summary. As soon as I hit "Utah" in the summary, I stopped reading.

  8. Re:Wow... on Debian Forked Over Systemd · · Score: 1

    I Don't Want SystemD.

    FTFY. I've been quite impressed with it.

  9. Re:Wow... on Debian Forked Over Systemd · · Score: 1

    systemd is modular, that is in the list of debunked myths.

    Yes, it is. However, the Debian guys who looked hard at it felt that it was going to be difficult to separate reliance on the login and network and volume management components which the DEs are building from the system startup component.

  10. Re:This is clearly futile... on Google Told To Expand Right To Be Forgotten · · Score: 1

    Google certainly doesn't have heuristics that try to pick out negative stories and highlight them.

    Of coursen not, and I never said it has. However, it is the page rank algorithm that results in this selection, so Google is not entirely uninvolved.

    I disagree, the page rank algorithm is content-agnostic. It just reflects aggregate interest in content. Your problem is with the sources, not the index.

  11. Nevada, not Utah on Shale: Good For Gas, Oil...and Nuclear Waste Disposal? · · Score: 4, Informative

    Not that it makes much difference, but the Yucca Mountain site is in Nevada, not Utah.

  12. Re:Wow... on Debian Forked Over Systemd · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I think it's fair to say that this fork is far more significant.

    I think this fork will be fairly insignificant, and, further, that it will increasingly run into problems as desktops and other packages depend more and more on systemd components (that trend was one of the major factors in the Debian decision to adopt it).

    I actually wish the Devuan guys all the best; I'd love to see another solid server-focused distro (server focus may help them avoid the issues with DEs). But I'm really glad to hear about this fork because the systemd debate has been a huge distraction to Debian. Hopefully this will finally put it to bed as all of the systemd opponents leave Debian for Devuan. I think that will be a net win for Debian because most of the vocal opponents don't contribute much code anyway.

    Personally, the more I learn about systemd, the more I like the ideas behind it, and both code and documentation seem to be of high quality (documentation in particular is much better than is typical of open source projects). I'll be sticking with Debian.

  13. Re:This is clearly futile... on Google Told To Expand Right To Be Forgotten · · Score: 1

    I may not have been clear enough.

    The news websites in question may all have put up all the information, including - in my example - your acquittal.

    But due to the way Google page rank works, only the "arrest for child porn" headlines show up on the first 20 pages for your name.

    That is a problem of Google's making, not of the news sites.

    Nonsense. The reason Google ranks the arrest headlines higher is because there are a lot more of them, and they're more heavily linked. The news sites find the acquittal boring and either don't report it or bury it, so it shows up lower in the search rankings. Google certainly doesn't have heuristics that try to pick out negative stories and highlight them.

  14. Re:This is clearly futile... on Google Told To Expand Right To Be Forgotten · · Score: 1

    The Internet is full of half-truths and outright lies. Search engines do not deliver results based on the truth value of sites, but on popularity, page ranking and such.

    That has nothing to do with this. If someone has put lies about you up on a news site, you can and should be able to get that information taken down at the source. In fact, dealing with defamatory writing is something we figured out how to do long ago. It's called "libel" and there are all sorts of laws around it.

    The "right to be forgotten" isn't about taking down false or misleading information. It's about suppressing accurate but unpleasant truth.

  15. Re:BLUE ray on Jackie Chan Discs Help Boost Solar Panel Efficiency · · Score: 1

    removed the top plastic layer, exposing the recording medium beneath; cast a mold of the quasi-random pattern; and then used the mold to create a photovoltaic cell with the same pattern

    So you use your expensive photo lithography equipment to create a master, make as many molds from that as you like, and then create the photovoltaic cells from those. The mass production of BD-ROM discs is irrelevant, it just makes your master cheap, but when you're making 10,000s of cells the cost of the master is unimportant.

    Sure, but the cost is very relevant when you're doing research. This Blu-Ray disc experiment demonstrates that the theoretical work done previously will probably work as well as the theory predicts.

  16. Re:In Finland on Ask Slashdot: Why Is the Power Grid So Crummy In So Many Places? · · Score: 1

    Especially for side to side movements.

    The AC gave the more authoritative answer, but for a more intuitive one spend some time playing with blocks of jello.

  17. Re:In Finland on Ask Slashdot: Why Is the Power Grid So Crummy In So Many Places? · · Score: 2

    Unfortunately the resonance frequency of buildings is not affected by hight but by the length and the width of the building.

    Not for side-to-side movements.

  18. Re:Of course not! on 2014 Hour of Code: Do Ends Justify Disney Product Placement Means? · · Score: 1

    Did you miss the second sentence?

  19. What's amazing... on Google Chrome Will Block All NPAPI Plugins By Default In January · · Score: 1

    What's amazing is that this 1996-era hack for extending the functionality of the Netscape browser, in a rather kludgy and unsafe way, still exists at all in 2014. I took a class at the Netscape office in Mountain View in 1997 to learn how to write NPAPI plugins and thought then that it was an ugly hack that deserved to go way soon, though I was glad it existed to solve my immediate problems. Not only did it not go away (though MS removed NPAPI support for IE a long time ago), nearly all major browsers today still support it.

    Good for Google for deprecating this crap. Firefox (which is to some degree a descendant of Netscape) has also been reducing its support, per the WP article.

  20. Re:I don't think hydrogen makes sense on Multiple Manufacturers Push Hydrogen Fuel Cell Cars, But Can They Catch Tesla? · · Score: 1

    But don't ignore other advantages of hydrocarbon fuels simply because you don't like the idea of spewing carbon into the atmosphere.

    FWIW, I don't worry over much about carbon. My EV purchase was based on purely economic analysis. Having driven an EV for a while, what I really dislike about gas burners is the noise and the smell. This isn't an environmental concern, or not a global environmental concern, anyway. It's about the environment of my garage.

  21. Re:I don't think hydrogen makes sense on Multiple Manufacturers Push Hydrogen Fuel Cell Cars, But Can They Catch Tesla? · · Score: 1

    Easy! I stand corrected. :-)

  22. Re:I don't think hydrogen makes sense on Multiple Manufacturers Push Hydrogen Fuel Cell Cars, But Can They Catch Tesla? · · Score: 1

    I suppose. I generally want to stop every few hours for an hour or so anyway.

  23. Re:132 stations is not "blanketing the US" on Multiple Manufacturers Push Hydrogen Fuel Cell Cars, But Can They Catch Tesla? · · Score: 2

    When they get the number of stations into the tens of thousands then I'll concede the point.

    I don't think the number needs to be anywhere near that high. Not remotely.

    Don't make the mistake of thinking of supercharger stations as analogous to your average neighborhood gas station. They're nothing like that. Supercharger stations are only needed for long-distance travel. They're analogous to the big travel centers you find along the interstates and other highways which carry significant amounts of long-distance traffic, and the numbers required are similar to those of travel centers. If there's one every hundred miles or so along every long-distance travel corridor (which in the US is mostly just the interstates, though there are a few areas with long-distance highways) then coverage will be complete.

    With electric vehicles, 95+% of charging is done at places where vehicles spend lots of time parked, primarily homes and workplaces. Such charging doesn't need to be particularly fast. Fast charging only matters when you're driving distances beyond the range of your battery.

    You mention North Dakota, for example. Move the slider on that map to 2015 and you'll see they plan to put three superchargers there. That will cover the long-distance travel across ND, and most long-distance travel within ND. Add another supercharger on highway 2, midway between Grand Forks and Minot and you'll have covered nearly all of the rest. Add four of five more and you'll be able to get to any destination in the state without worry.

  24. Re:Corn Subsidies on How the World's Agricultural Boom Has Changed CO2 Cycles · · Score: 1

    Throw away Malthus - you have to give up the theory of evolution.

    Darwin cites Malthus repeatedly in his books and for very good reason: without Malthus, there can't BE evolution.

    Randomly-driven evolution, no. But we aren't very far from being able to deliberately evolve ourselves, to achieve specific purposes.

    There's a good argument, though, that deliberate, directed evolution is also evolution by variation and selection... it's just that the variation and selection is carried out in brains and in computers rather than in genotypes and phenotypes. In fact, there's a good argument that all knowledge creation is via variation and selection, including all knowledge created by humans, though there we call the process speculation and criticism and much of it happens internally so that truly bad ideas never get uttered or written.

    So, no need to abandon the theory of evolution.

  25. Re:Corn Subsidies on How the World's Agricultural Boom Has Changed CO2 Cycles · · Score: 2

    No convincing needed, its happening naturally and just a question of when the peak is Total fertility rate 1950–1955 : 4.95 2010–2015 : 2.36 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T...

    Yes and no. What you say is true, and further it appears we've already reached and passed the maximum number of children born per year, in absolute terms. But the population is still growing because the world population is youth-heavy. Assuming we stay on the current trend of gradually declining births and assuming we don't start living longer than 100 years in large numbers, this means the world population will stop growing at about 10B, then start a very slow decline, but that will be far above the levels Spy Hunter thinks we should reach.

    I don't think I'd want to live in Spy Hunter's world, though. I certainly wouldn't want to live the "hunter-gatherer lifestyle", which was fully Hobbesian (nasty, brutish and short). In some senses perhaps those people were "healthier" than we are today, but they experienced a lot more pain and died a lot sooner. I suppose Spy Hunter is theorizing some world in which we eat like hunter-gatherers but live in a technological civilization, but that seems like a silly approach when we can, instead, continue our research into human biochemistry to understand exactly what humans need (with much more precision than "eat like hunter-gatherers", who almost certainly never got an ideal diet) and into food production, until we can create food that is healthy (ideally so), safe and flavorful.