Honestly, which one would you prefer to play as? I know I will enjoy Zelda: TWW a lot more with this more believable design. It's hard to feel emotionally attached to chibi one.
It has nothing to do with cel-shading itself, it's all about art direction which most people didn't like.
Slashdot Mirror
Chibi style vs More believable style:i nkdesign.jpg
http://homepage.mac.com/adambetts/forums/abetterl
Honestly, which one would you prefer to play as? I know I will enjoy Zelda: TWW a lot more with this more believable design. It's hard to feel emotionally attached to chibi one.
It has nothing to do with cel-shading itself, it's all about art direction which most people didn't like.