Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Taming the Web

Posted by michael on from the cisco-the-lion-tamer dept.

Thomas writes: "A story on Technology Review outlines the closer-to-reality-than-you-think fact that Internet regulations are right around the corner. It points out three false hopes held by web 'libertarians.' 1. the web is too international to control. 2. the net is too interconnected to fence in. 3. the net is full of hackers that are impossible to control. This is a good read." Bingo.

1 of 365 comments (clear)

  1. Did you even read the article's arguments? by Artifice_Eternity · · Score: 5, Interesting
    The internet has been around for more than two decades, during which time it has managed to elude being regulated in any meaningful way, anywhere in the world.

    That's an unsupportable generalization. Plenty of individuals and groups have seen their online activities regulated - Napster, Yahoo! France, and any site ever kicked off an ISP due to outside legal pressure.

    The internet stretches across national boundaries. For regulation to be successfully carried out, an international body would need to be involved.

    Ever hear of the Hague Convention? It was in the article. International agreements on intellectual property, copyright, etc. are growing day by day, as the economy is globalized and more information moves around the world.

    Now that we have web servers in space, even international bodies will be powerless to censor the internet.

    The US is embarking on wholesale weaponization of space. I disagree with it, but satellite-killing satellites - built by the US or someone else - will become a reality sooner or later.

    The skills of hackers and crackers will summarily overcome any attempts by government to lock-down the internet. If hackers can infiltrate the most secure military computers of the greatest nation on earth, how will the US, but more especially, the rest of the world, ever regulate the internet?

    This is about the only variable that I don't think can be controlled. Human ingenuity is pretty amazing. But the hurdles to an open Internet are going to get higher and higher (you didn't mention hardware-based content management, featured prominently in the article), and only an elite few may end up being able to circumvent them.