Whither OpenAL?

delYsid asks: "About a year ago, Slashdot had a story about the OpenAL project by Loki and Creative. There was much hype around it. But if you check their website now, the last changelog entry appears to be from December of 1999! Does anyone know of a good (preferable platform independent) library for 3D audio? The only answer I get when I ask professionals in this field is DirectX. I'd love to have my app under Linux instead of having to move to Win again. Any pointer or hints about the current status of OpenAL? Are there any alternatives?" Update: 09/18 15:33 PM GMT by C :Corrected the link which referred to Slashdot's previous story on OpenAL.

I forwarded this question on to Loki, and here's the response from Scott Draeker, president of Loki Games:

As you can imagine, everyone is pretty busy right now, especially as we had some folks out on vacation the last couple of weeks. So I'm sorry about the slow response.

In answer to your question, work on OpenAL continues. Creative has already added EAX and hardware acceleration to the Mac and Windows versions, and are working on adding both to the Linux implementation as well. Work is also continuing on an OS X port as well as other OSes. OpenAL continues to be the sound API which Loki uses in all of its products, and many other companies are either using or evaluating OpenAL for their products as well.

Hope that helps.

So there you have it, straight from the source. Development is progressing, although it's likely to be a bit slow at present. Here's hoping we'll hear more updates on the progress of OpenAL, over the next 6 months. Thanks a bunch for taking the time to answer, Scott!

Comments

mailing list is active

[jas79]

check the archives of the maillinglist.[http://www.openal.org/ml/openal/]

it seems te be active

It is still in development

[michaelsimms]

I am not quite sure where you get the idea it isnt in development. The ftp site has a new tarball as of two days ago.

hardware

[Jacek Poplawski]

I think you can't have 3D audio library without advanced sound device drivers. And AFAIR emu10k1 driver supports effects like delay/flanger/gain, but do not support 3D sound. Main problem is - nobody need advanced sound drivers.
Most of people just need to listen mp3 (it's similiar to word processors - most people need only .doc import/export). The only way to fix that is to create more 3D games for Linux.
So download SDL then get some info from OpenGL site and gamedev then start coding! :-)

Why OpenAL sucks

[Snocone]

The inimitable Ian Ollmann (who brings up Mac implementation issues on the mac-sound-dev list often) has an interesting piece on why OpenAL sucks here. For the link-shy:

http://maccentral.macworld.com/storyforum/forums /2 001/07/02/music/?read=55

The relevant portions read

Two things are holding such people back from making more substantial contributions to OpenAL. First of all it is not entirely clear to me that the API is all that well designed. Modelling it after OpenGL was probably a mistake. In addition, there are certain fundamental assumptions put into the API that assume preemptive multitasking for some things to work well, most notably spooling file play. There was no thought put into using it for anything other than 3D sound effects for games. So, for example if you attempt to write a MOD player using OpenAL to hopefully be able to take advantage of their SoundFont technology and EAX in your MOD player's core and reverb functionalities, you are pretty much out of luck. OpenAL's source queues lack the functionality required for doing proper timing of various effects that you would need in order to pull it off.

The other problem is that the designers of OpenAL dont want to fix these problems, or let 3rd party developers do it for them. I have argued passionately for months for API improvements such as queue completion callbacks, defered object deletion and a more extensible API to make the library more generally useful for applications and operating systems other than 3D games on linux. I have been unable to convince them to make even the smallest changes to the spec. So, really until we can get some more flexibility and input into the API design, it is somewhat unrealistic to expect me or any other third party, including Apple, to be able to do much for OpenAL.