Slashdot Mirror
Even Flash Can Get Viruses
Mechel Conrad writes: "Heise Online(German) writes about a Virus called SWF/LFM-926.
It consists of a Macromedia Flash movie and seems to be the first of its kind.
It uses Flash's scripting language in order to open a debug terminal creating and executing a file called V.COM, which infests other .SWF Files.
Although the virus is not very dangerous and not widespread yet, it suggests clear security holes in Flash." The translation of the Heise article is quite readable, too. Update: 01/08 22:47 GMT by T : bdavenport adds: "this report on Yahoo lists a new Shockwave virus as low grade due to the need of manual downloading. infoworld is reporting that McAfee has upgraded to high risk after several Fortune 500 firms have reported it in the wild, arriving as an email attachment."
Why is it that almost every system out there can get a virus? I'm under the opinion that it is the OS's fault, *nix, windows included.
The reason anything can get a virus is because programs still have direct control over the IP ( instruction pointer ). This is a fatal flaw found in most OS's. Programs should be ran inside of a VM with tight security. Of course performance calls for some apps, especially servers to be ran in compiled code, but this should not be the default. If such an app needs to be installed or run the OS should prompt the user warning them of such activity.
Another flaw is the fact that we are still using a basic file system. Whether it's fat32, ntfs, or ext2 it is still just placing a byte stream on a disk, managing the name, where it starts and where it ends. Lets evolve a little. The file system should be more like a database. It should be able attach any number of properties to a file. It should be able to manage security at any level, and it should be able to isolate files from process to process.
Imagine if when a program installs it has access to it's portion of the file system and that is it. It couldn't see the rest if it wanted to. Installed programs could get quotas. They sure as hell wouldn't be able to start overwriting executables all over the place.
You could argue that good user level security could solve these problems, but it's obviously not enough since so many viruses simply find away around it.
I could go on and on about how OS's treat applications wrong. But the main point is that they treat them like friends when they are really strangers. The answer is to take control away from the app, and put it back in the OS. Perl and Java are a good start ( since they are both interrupted in a way), but obviously more work needs to be done.