Posted by
chrisd
on from the it's-water-helen-water dept.
davster writes "I was just checking out the Linux 2.5changeset and noticed that Linus has just merged ALSA into his tree. Its about time."CD: Looks like Jaroslav Kysela did the merge work, but Linus obviously allowed it to happen. I'm a happy Alsa user so this looks like a good thing.
Re:How cross-platform is ALSA?
by
paulbd
·
· Score: 5, Interesting
there are Mac/PPC drivers in the tree already, and some of the PCI-based cards have been tested under Linux on the Alpha.
Re:Can we dump aRts and esd now?
by
Error27
·
· Score: 5, Interesting
>> The Linux sound situation is really retarded.
Correct.
There was an interesting discussion on the alsa-devel list in January about "Alsa and the future of sound on Linux." Paul Davis the author of jackit.sf.net wrote some pretty convincing emails that a call back system is better than the popular Linux way with read/write like a file.
Jackit is designed for high end audio but it's really similar to Apple's CoreAudio. The problem is that most Linux developers don't want to mess around with callbacks and multi-threaded programming. And quite frankly most sound applications don't require such a high level of quality.
A good thing to do would be to change aRts to write to jack. That way you could use jack for the high end and aRts for basic mp3s etc.
Slashdot Mirror
there are Mac/PPC drivers in the tree already, and some of the PCI-based cards have been tested under Linux on the Alpha.
Correct.
There was an interesting discussion on the alsa-devel list in January about "Alsa and the future of sound on Linux." Paul Davis the author of jackit.sf.net wrote some pretty convincing emails that a call back system is better than the popular Linux way with read/write like a file.
Jackit is designed for high end audio but it's really similar to Apple's CoreAudio. The problem is that most Linux developers don't want to mess around with callbacks and multi-threaded programming. And quite frankly most sound applications don't require such a high level of quality.
A good thing to do would be to change aRts to write to jack. That way you could use jack for the high end and aRts for basic mp3s etc.
Unfortunately jack is not finished yet.