Slashdot Mirror


WinXP Keygen Foils Product Activation

Bill Gates' Friend's Brother's Roommate writes: "The Register has a story on a working key generator that produces 25 valid Windows XP Product Activation Keys in a few hours. As author John Lettice summarizes, 'So the question as regards keymaking software is whether or not Microsoft has any way to differentiate between generated keys and the ones it has issued itself. If not, this generation of WPA is now surely toast.'"

9 of 461 comments (clear)

  1. Weird by glh · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Don't they have some kind of database with all the keys in it.. (after all, a lot of games out there such as anything newer by blizzard works that way)!

    1. Re:Weird by govtcheez · · Score: 4, Interesting

      > Quite smart, really.

      Except that every Blizzard game I've ever played would be just peachy if a reg-code of all 3's was typed in. Seriously.

    2. Re:Weird by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

      a good method that i've never seen used for key generation is to not use a "Working/Not Working" states, but instead, have the key actually disable/enable certain parts to the game. It would make finding a valid key even harder. You might think you have a valid one, but get to level 3, and the game suddenly dumps you out unexpectedly. It wouldn't be foolproof as far as stopping piracy, but it might hamper it a little i suppose.

  2. 25 keys in one night with one PC by J.D.+Hogg · · Score: 5, Interesting

    That means you probably could get 25000 keys in one hour if distributed.net was setup to do that. Even DES is harder to crack. That should tell you something about the extent of Microsoft's understanding of security issues if they can't even protect their own bread and butter correctly.

  3. Well they won't accept their license agreement... by Nailer · · Score: 5, Interesting

    By allowing me to decline their license and give me the refund they promise if I do so, I don't see why I should accept it and activate periodically.

    ncftp -u xpkey -p xpkey -P 6473 24.22.15.128

  4. Don't ruin MY key by innate · · Score: 4, Interesting

    What if someone using this keygen generates my key that has already been activated? It will look to Microsoft like the key-in-question is being installed on a different computer with different hardware. Then the next time I go to re-install XP my legitimate key won't work.

    --
    No, I don't want to explore the Recycle Bin.
  5. Re:Can we say Service Pack 1? by HMC+CS+Major · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Uh, they havent started doing that with win2k, win98, winme, or any of their other products, why would they start with xp ?

    The only thing even vaguely close is the ms office update that refuses to install if its running with a known bad serial number, but that doesnt disable anything.

    My theory is that the damage is already done. Messing up the OS isnt going to make the person buy a real copy, it'll just make the person reinstall the same insecure pile of crap they installed in the first place, and then ms will get blamed again because stupid people dont know how to secure their illegal boxes. It's in Microsoft's best interest to let people with stolen versions update their OS, so if nothing else, they dont have software pirates spreading things like Nimda.

  6. So what? by The_Shadows · · Score: 5, Interesting

    It was cracked. Big deal. Everyone is saying "Now we can use this and won't have to register it with MS!" or "They probably have an archive of keys and can see the fakes, who will then be arrested!"

    No. Here's what I say: So what?
    Great, it's cracked. You know what? The number of people who will wind up using the crack is probably insignificant to MS.

    Newsflash! There have been anti-activaition cracks from day one with more efficiency than this. How about the cracks that allow you to never register? How about buying a version of XP Pro that doesn't require activation (Corporate(expensive) or Academic)? How about pirating one? I looked on hotline the day of XP's release and there were already several servers claiming to have the Corporate Version of XP Pro.

    To top this all off, how many people will really use this? I'll give you a hint: proportionately few. The vast majority of people who will upgrade to XP either don't know or care that there is a hack, or are businesses that have to have legitimate software (activation and all). Well, I suppose they don't have to, but most businesses consider it a good idea.

    So that's my thoughts. It's cracked. It's a great feat and all, but the number of illegal copies of XP isn't going to suddenly, dramatically surge.

  7. Your point is? by sethamin · · Score: 4, Interesting
    This makes no difference to MS whatsoever. The whole point of WPA is not to stop dedicated and knowledagble computer users from finding or using valid keys; it is to stop Mom and Pop from installing someone else's version of Windows. If you told your Mom, "oh, you have to use this little keygen program to get the key", then she'd be a whole hell of a lot less likely to pirate it than if you just said "Use the installation code on the back of the jewel case".

    Good god, who here ever thought WPA was going to stop the pirating of MS software?
    *prolonged awkward silence*
    Yeah, that's what I thought.