Slashdot Mirror


SSSCA Hearing

larsoncc writes: "According to this article on CNET, a Senate Bill will likely force the issue of adding copy protection to hardware. They are giving the industry 12 to 18 months to come up with a voluntary solution to the "problem" of copies, and if not... Well, you just have to read the article. Insane." Wired also has a story. The IP list published two interesting documents: an account of the hearing by an attendee, and a letter from Intel published immediately after the hearing. Read the letter carefully - note that the disagreement between the tech industry and Hollywood is not over whether or not copy protection will be implemented into every electronic device, but only whether or not this should be written into law. If the SSSCA isn't passed, Intel (and others) get a lot of leverage over Hollywood. If it is, Intel's leverage disappears. But since both sides want to build copy protection into everything, they only differ over the process, we're in trouble either way.

4 of 761 comments (clear)

  1. So basically by TheGreenLantern · · Score: 4, Funny

    I have 12-18 months to buy as much non-protected digital media/hardware as I can? I guess this is one way to stimulate the economy.

    --

    It hurts when I pee.
  2. New law by stinkydog · · Score: 5, Funny

    Congress is considering a law to mandate that all digital content be rendered on puch cards with "Do Not Copy" printed on them.

    The MPAA applauded them move. "Now that digital movies weigh 300lbs casual piracy will be elimiated and we can safely distribute films without concern of terrorists." Blockbuster announed that all new members will receive a free pallet jack.

    Chinese peasents who have been hoarding illegal CDR technology in their villages were gleefull. "Perhaps Lik-Sang will buy this @#$%% for paper to cdr converters for hackers". The I-Pod Mafia could not be reach for comment.

    SD

    --
    âoeWho knew something as harmless as willful ignorance could end up having real consequences?â
  3. Wow, lets make laws for everything! by MongooseCN · · Score: 4, Funny

    Industry: We can't make anything to prevent copying of media.
    Politicians: Well then, we'll just make a law that says you have to make something to prevent copying. That will solve the problem.

    Later on...

    NASA: We can't make a spaceship that travels faster than the speed of light, it's against the laws of physics!
    Politicians: Well then, we'll just make a law that says you have to make a spaceship that travels faster than the speed of light. That will fix the laws of physics.

  4. This seems so Dilbertian... by Jason+Levine · · Score: 4, Funny

    Just replace the IT industry with Dilbert, the MPAA folks with marketing weasels, and the congressmen with Pointy-Haired Bosses. To sum up the hearings, this is how it went:

    Marketing Weasels: "This online piracy is hurting sales. The solution is obvious: Make all computers unable to copy anything."

    PHB: "Yup. That sounds right, take care of it Dilbert."

    Dilbert: "That's impossible. All computers copy. It's part of their basic operation. You might as well tell me to design a perpetual motion machine."

    PHB: "I don't understand what you're saying. Logically, anything I don't understand isn't important. You have 12 to 18 months to make all the computers in the world unable to copy. Oh, and the marketing weasels get to decide on the specs. Don't worry, they rarely change their minds more than twice a day."

    --
    My sci-fi novel, Ghost Thief, is now available from Amazon.com.