Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Kazaa Is Legal, Dutch Appeals Court Rules

Posted by Hemos on from the wish-i-could-read-dutch dept.

Killjoy_b writes " First, the courts in the Netherlands rule against Kazaa, in a higher appeal, the courts rule in favour of Kazaa saying "The software itself doesn't commit any illegal acts, it's the users that could do that, therefore the software is legal" Read the Dutch article on Webwereld I like the way this turned out :)" Another Dutch reader wrote with this: " The Judge ruled that even if the users violated copyright, Kazaa did not. Important in the ruling were the facts that Kazaa does not rely on a central server, and that it is not bound to music or video files alone. According to Webwereld (in Dutch) Kazaa is pondering if they should sue back for lost damages. After the first court ruling against Kazaa, they were forced to sell part of their business, for supposedly a too low prize. " And despite the the fact that both Taco and I are from Holland, MI, no, neither of us can speak/read Dutch - so don't ask us to translate. Update: 03/28 14:39 GMT by M : Reuters has an English summary.

3 of 390 comments (clear)

  1. Yeah, but .... by wazzzup · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    this is the Netherlands where they smile on drug use and prostitution. Not that there's anything wrong with that.

  2. Back damages? by truesaer · · Score: 1, Flamebait
    Maybe KaZaA should have not folded like sissies...this case has been relatively short. That ruling that it was illegal was only a few months ago.


    For that matter, they have seriously fucked up their network. The new Morpheus that uses Gnutella sucks, and the fast track network has lost a huge portion of its file base.


    Kazaa has been nothing but trouble for p2p software, maybe they should be sued by morpheus for damages....

  3. Re:Amazing. by xZAQx · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    I use guns because I'm in impressionable 16 yr old. I played WAY too much DOOM when I was younger, and now I play all sorts of "shoot-em-ups". I own a complete arsenal and one day I will kill you all!
    Mwahaha.

    Seriously, guns are legal. They will stay that way.
    Making guns illegal does nothing. Last time I checked, murder was illegal, doing (insert drug of choice here) was illegal, rape was illegal, and yet these things continue to go on EVERY DAY OF MY NATURAL LIFE.

    Illegalization stops nothing, except keeping guns out of the hands of LAW-ABIDING CITIZENS.

    Criminals don't care about laws, hence the name "CRIMINAL"

    --

    We dance to all the wrong songs.
    --Refused.