Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Review: Creative Labs Video Blaster - Digital VCR

Posted by michael on from the not-quite-ready-for-prime-time dept.

An anonymous reader sent in a review of Creative's Digital VCR, a TV tuner card supposedly offering functionality similar to a Tivo or ReplayTV dedicated box. From the review, it seems like there are still a few bugs to be worked out.

"Two weeks ago, I dropped by my Local Frys Electronics to pick up the Creative Labs Video Blaster Digital VCR. I picked up the card for the lovely price of $99. I felt at the time that the days of a PVR was upon me. I hooked it up into my modest system and got started right away. My modest system includes:

  • Pentium III 1Ghz System
  • 512 MB of PC-133 SDRAM
  • 1 40 GB 7200 WD Drive, on ATA-66
  • 1 60 GB 7200 Maxtor Drive, on ATA-100
  • ATI Radeon VE
  • LG 24x CD Burner, on ATA-66
  • Running Windows XP Pro
My Maxtor Drive was a new purchase that was going to be dedicated to my Digital VCR Experience, hence my marooning the drive on my onboard HighPoint HPT370 controller card. The installation of the card was a snap, and the drivers were quick and painless.

Now, at home, I don't subscribe to any digital video services: I get pretty good reception over an old-fashioned antenna. I primarily wanted the card so I could capture my tape collection of Enterprise episodes to MPEG-2, so I could burn VCDs for my DVD player. I also wanted to begin my trek down the PVR road, and eventually do away with VHS forever.

I spent an evening a couple of days ago, playing with settings on screen-size, capture quality and file sizes. One thing I noticed quite quickly is that the Digital VCR system does not encode directly to MPEG-2. Creative sets up many segment files on your system, each in 32mb blocks, to store your recorded shows and timeshifting buffer. It is essentially a filesystem on top of a filesystem. In order to get the MPEG-2 files out of the Digital VCR, you use a 'File Converter' that they provide in the Creative Menu. The results of this setup is that when you setup the system, you specify how long you want to record (19 hours in my case) and it takes up the appropriate harddrive space (45 GB in my case) for use for future recording. The tool works pretty well overall, even going so far as to create new MPG files every 650 MB. The problem with this is that its possible that your recording could be sliced mid-sentence in your show. The other problem though, didn't occur until last night.

I recorded the episode of Enterprise last night, as well as I had some previous shows of 'Friends' in my 'Saved Shows' menu. After watching the episode again, I pulled up the file convert tool to convert Enterprise to MPG, and flipped onto Live TV, so I could watch the news. Then, the unspeakable happened. Digital VCR froze. I tried to kill it from the Task Manager (which worked perfectly well), but to no avail. There was no killing this app at all. This crash spread like a bad flu across the rest of my system and I was forced to hard reboot. Returning to Windows, I brought up the convert tool to start again, this time not to make the mistake of watching television at the same time. There was only one problem: All of the shows recorded in the last 2 days were wiped out. No data on disk, nothing.

In the end, there were very few positive points that I would give to the Digital VCR product: it just doesn't seem ready for primetime. All in all, the issues I found were as follows:

  • Jerky on startup
  • Processor Intensive during playing (I'd recommend at least a 1.5 Ghz)
  • Menu System is slow
  • No Linux Drivers
  • Instability in proprietary filesystem
  • Mpeg Splitting (what about 700mb CDRs or DVDS)
In the end, I'd give this product a 2.5 out of a possible 5 score. The unit has a lot of potential, but it seems far from it. Dedicated PVR equipment seems a much better choice, even if pricey."

4 of 277 comments (clear)

  1. FP! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Forker the Porker!

  2. OKC Federal Building Bombed!!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Oh my god there was just a massive explosion that practically destroyed the Alfred P. Murrah federal building in Oklahoma City. Details are sketchy, but apparently a truck bomb was used. Officials suspect that Arab terrorists may be involved. Please report any suspicious activity to your local police.

  3. Re:Respect by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    the SB live is NOT PCI compliant and will throw noise on your PCI bus to further make your computer unstable... at least more unstable than running a Microsoft Operating system.. (3.11 was actually nice... too bad XP cant be as nice as 3.11)

    Dont buy creative anything anymore... they suck.

  4. Re:Doesnt the ATI AIW do this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    your best bet for archival of tv shows and playback is Nuppelvideo + mplaye r+ a hollywood+ card + a BT878 tuner card. I get better than VHS, can convert from a nuv file to a mpeg2 easily... (ok mpegtools is a royal bitch to compile after you download 98 different libs and fight with the compiles... but you can get it to work in about 4 hours of fighting) Slap all of this in a DCT/Allwell Metallic6086N2 and you have something that even LOOKS like a tivo clone.

    You made all those numbers up. You're a fucking phony fraud felchering fucker. My AI455 + keyboard + kodiak chew+ vice grip pliers + VHS porn said so. It even looks like fucking shit.