Slashdot Mirror
White LEDs for a Brighter World
deepfry writes "CBC radio today featured an interview with Dr. Dave Irvine-Halliday, an engineering professor at the University of Calgary, who's developed a home lighting system for the developing world using a combination of white LEDs, pedal generators and rechargable batteries. This type of "pico-power" can make a huge difference in the lives of villagers in rural areas where being connected to a power grid is not an option and probably never will be. Read about the Light Up the World project and make a donation."
"Read about the Light Up the World project and make a donation."
It ain't no joke, I'd like to buy the world a toke...
Ride a bike for 10 minutes, get a couple of hours worth of light so you can read and learn.
The Kruger Dunning explains most post on
Why limit something like this to the developing world? If the developed world used low-power, high-efficiency lighting, we'd dramatically reduce the consumption of energy and non-renewable resources. If these lights are cheap enough for the poorest on the planet to consider using them, there's no doubt that they'd save the industrialized nations amazing amounts of money, as well.
Frankly, I suspect we'd do more for the developing world by adopting this sort of thing for ourselves--which is not to say, of course, that we shouldn't encourage them to skip our wasteful ways in favor of the right way to do things.
b&
All but God can prove this sentence true.
One way to bring down the cost would be to sell them in the developed world. A finished product, that could screw into a standard light socket, but use 1/100th the power to provide the same light would sell well in the U.S.
Especially with all the noise about power shortages and rolling blackouts.
Selling them in the U.S. and the rest of the developed world would go a long way towards creating enough demand for serious mass production.
Learning HOW to think is more important than learning WHAT to think.
About a year ago, I got a kitsch keychain from a vendor who was trying to sell software to my company. We didn't purchase the software, but I have held onto that keychain.
Let me describe it. It's oval in shape, about 3cm long by about 2cm across and 1 cm thick. Inside the body of the keychain, which is clear vinyl, you can see the mechanism that makes it so neat, which is a small watch-type battery, a very small resistor, and one of the newer white LED's. The clear plastic vinyl is red, so when you squeze the thing, it's light is very slightly pink.
Now, here's the thing that makes me keep this around. This little piece of what I would othewise call 'crap' is brighter than my 'keychain-size' Mag Light! I can easily read by or do computer maintenance with this toy. If I had five or six of them, I could reasonably light a room for however long the batteries lasted.
White LED's are the wave of the future, IMHO. They're cheap in terms of production and electricity cost. I also understand that they're significantly easier on the environment than incandescent bulbs or flourescent tubes. Unless you overload it with current, which I understand is very difficult since many come with tiny regulators in the form of attached IC's, they don't burn out, making replacement costs plummet.
Make my next lightbulb a white LED
The next Slashdot story will be ready soon, but subscribers can beat the rush and slashdot the links early!
Because, while that bulb only consumes 0.1 W, it gives off as much light as a much brighter incandescant bulb. I didn't see figures in the article, but one would figure that it's better than what you get with flourescent lights.
I've replaced many of the lights in my apartment with compact flourescents. Typically, a CF bulb that outputs as many lumens as a 100 W incandescant bulb will only require 20 - 30 W. Reading a newspaper with a 20 W incandescant isn't practical, but the 20 W CF is more than bright enough.
b&
All but God can prove this sentence true.
uh, ok. $1 a piece for a .1 watt bulb. sounds great. Exactly how many would I have to gang to be able to read my newspaper?
Maybe not that many... Remember that the efficiency of a normal light bulb is very very bad, since most of its energy is dissipated as heat. I wouldn't be suprised if a 100W bulb only produced 1W of visible light.
Opus: the Swiss army knife of audio codec
You should stop being so paternalistic and conservative. The attitude of your response shows you romanticize poverty, and mistake powerlessness for aestheticism.
This was also featured on Talk of the Nation on NPR last week. It is worth a listen.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Oh bother.
Some people might be better off without lights or connection to a power grid.
So I suppose it never occurred to anyone that this might be of use in hospitals or clinics?
Does anyone realize how important low cost oil lamps were to families back during the industrial revolution. In those times, a worker would generally work all day until dark, and then after work, spend an hour or two of quality time with his/her family. How much quality would your time have if it was dark and you had no light source?
We all need to step back from our CRTs/LCDs for a second and realize that many places haven't even reached where the western world was 100 years ago!
"I have never let my schooling interfere with my education." - Mark Twain
I didn't take any courses from this prof, but some of my friends in school did.
What he is doing is kindof neat... He wants to equip poor villages (in places like Nepal) with electric lighting that better utilizes the minimal generating capacity they have.
I know you can get white LEDs as replacements for flashlights that will increase the battery life approximately 20x. For those Petzl headlamps a standard Duracell battery will give you about 6H of light with a standard bulb, but is rated at 100H with a superbright LED. And as far as I know the superbright gives you equivalent illumination - just at higher efficiency.
When I was in Nepal a few years ago, most rural villages would have power (all from hydroelectric) but it was unpredictable and unreliable. Also the generators were small and there were limits on how many bulbs each place could have. Replacing regular bulbs with white leds would save power - and make battery backups realistic.
Thats one way out of the dark.
m
Here's a quote from the Web Site:
I should point out that a single WLED provides sufficient light to easily read a book or to study with. My wife, who wholeheartedly assisted me in Nepal in 1999, has amassed ample field evidence to support this last statement. It is very significant to the developing world that these wee marvels of technology can effectively light an entire kitchen table area using less than one watt of electrical power and there are none of the attendant dreadful pollution and fire dangers associated with the use of kerosene lamps.
Please read more of the web site before commenting. /Don
What you do not realize, judging by your post, is that the average 20 mA white LED looks brighter than the average 40W 120V bulb. A single one makes an excellent flashlight. A few of them together make an awesome lightsource.
I can see it now: Some third world family of 12. Dad says to the 3rd kid "Okay, your the dumb one so the rest of us can learn. You get to spend the rest of your likfe riding the exercise bike while the rest of us learn to read."
Don't feel bad for the "dumb kid" though, he will go on to win international biking compititions, while the rest of the family trys to compete in the rat race with millions of other people.
Our village elders agree with you. I'd say more, but we're on a hunt for witches and evil spirits right now, and the others tend to get suspicious if I don't join in...
Lately democracy seems to be based on the skybox, the Happy Meal box, the X-box, and the idiot box.
I wouldn't be suprised if a 100W bulb only produced 1W of visible light.
It's usually around 3W. IIRC, flourescent runs around 25W.
"We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
I work in the lighting industry with conventional means of producing light (florescent, incandescent, etc) and have done some testing on LEDs. The most important thing to realize is that the light being produced is not a pure "white" light.
Typically the manufacturer will use a blue LED and coat the outside of the lens with a yellow broadband phosphor, which when the blue light is filtered through it, appears white. True white is extremely difficult (and expensive) to produce; it's still years away and it has to do with the ability of the diodes to produce certain wavelengths of light.
As far as efficiency, yes, LEDs are quite effecient at producing light at a given (low) wattage but they are still not as bright as conventional light sources. The rating of an LEDs efficiency is measured in lumens per watt; a bulb with a higher lumen per watt rating is more efficient than that of a lower one. At this point, red LEDs are the most efficient, which is why many applications that use LEDs (exit signs, car turn signals, etc) are red.
Manufacurers claim a 100,000 hour life span of LEDs. What most of them fail to mention is that to acheive this, the power supply that the LEDs are attached to has to be set at a low current. Low current means decreased brightness. If the current is increased past the manufacurers recommended setting, you will get higher brightess but the lifespan will be cut short severely. Not to mention the fact that many LED applications where companies are touting 100,000 hour lifetimes (approximately 10 years) haven't been around that long to confirm or deny it.
LEDs are not going away, however. It's not a question of if they go mainstream, it's when. And I have no problem with that, it's just that from what I have observed, the manufacurers are dispensing half-truths and outright lies about this stuff. People take it for gospel because big companies are developing the technology (GE and HP-funded Agilent come to mind) so they figure it must be true.
Whatever. It's reall not going to make that much difference in the long run. Just want people to know there's more behind it.
The neutrality of this sig is disputed.
a) Apparently you don't have access to common sense either. Criminals prefer dark alleys to well-lit streets. The "data" that you fail to cite is probably inconclusive, since there are a billion variables involved with comparing the crime trends in location A to the crime trends in location B.
b) Where are you getting this stuff? If we didn't have well-lit urban culture, we'd still think that the Earth is a flat disc a few miles in diameter, with a large mechanical sphere surrounding it. That's not exactly what I'd consider an appreciation for the vastness of the Universe.
c) People watching television probably learn more about the vastness of the Universe than you will staring at the night sky.
Stop puking up luddite FUD, please. You're making a mess.
using a combination of white LEDs, pedal generators and rechargable batteries.
Nothing innovative about this, the Professor was using pedal generators to power ALL KINDS OF THINGS while shipwrecked on Gilligan's Island back in the late 60s / early 70s.
I Heart Sorting Networks
Frankly, I suspect we'd do more for the developing world by adopting this sort of thing for ourselves
A quick Google search turns up The LED Light, and they have a collection of "bulbs" that fit into 120 Volt AC sockets (That would be them things in yer house, at least in the US)
Very expensive though - "36 LED bulb...comparable to a 30 watt incandescent bulb" costs $190.
Another site I've run into in the past is LEDTronics which looks more in line with the geek need for way too much information, and component-level purchasing. I can just see the mod case now...
You're right on.
.1 watt bulb of some new technology giving the same light output as a 100 watt incandescent tungsten filament bulb.
With as long as we've had "100 watt" and "60 watt" lightbulbs, people have gotten it into their heads that the wattage rating is a measure of the light output.
I would have to work out the physics to see if it's possible, but I don't immediately see any barrier to a
Oh well, no modding power for me this time :)
I partially solve this issue with the compact flourescents in my house by choosing lampshades with a warm characteristic like Japanese paper lanterns.
As most photographers follow, the "temperature" of the light is really what determines how "pretty" you consider it. Incandescent is way down the spectrum from flourescent. I don't really know where LED is, but I imagine it's closer to the latter than the former.
just my blog and pix
Some people do not want or have a need for the modern medicine that a hospital or clinic would provide.
I think that the "some people" that you refer to are in the minority.
I understand that 'some people' may not want modern medicine due to various reasons. Of course, 'some people' would prefer to die in agony from a burst appendix than get medical help. 'Some people' get a nice case of lockjaw from the tetanus infection they got from a cut. 'Some people' walk with a limp from that leg that they broke when they were six. 'Some people' just plain lose all their teeth by the time they are 35, presuming that they live that long.
But I'm sure 'most people' would rather have a hospital or clinic nearby. And, when it comes down to it, most people are pretty flexible about issues such as their personal beliefs conflicting with urgent medical treatment.
The fact of the matter is that it's our duty to provide opportunities for those who are less fortunate than us to improve themselves. That hosptial or clinic full of modern medicine has to be there on the off-chance that it might save a few lives and improve their quality of living. If pedal-powered LED lights gets it there, well I'm all for it.
If you can get a population that is healthy , they can get on with improving their situation. If they're so busy fighting to keep alive, well improvement takes a back seat.
This has turned into a bit of a rant. But having visited places where "upper class" living means having a toilet (which may be flushed with a bucket), it kinda stirs me up a bit.
You are in a twisty maze of processor lines, all alike.
There is a lot of hype here.
The measure of what it "looks" like should be how much light is reflected off an object at a given distance, not how bright the bulb itself looks. The latter is very misleading since the surface area of a typical LED is many times smaller than the surface area of a typical light bulb, so a LED can "look" much brighter compared with a 40W bulb even if the total light output is much less.
Use 'slashdot stuff' in the subject line in any email you send me if you want to get past the spam filter.
After hunting around for a reasonably-priced reading spotlight to mount in the minivan for my kids to read after dark, I couldn't find anything that was (1) bright and clear at low wattage (2) priced under $100US (3) small enough to hide in the trimwork. Then putzing around Radio Shack one day, I saw the rack of white LEDs, and decided to give them a whirl.
I bought 6 WLEDs for about $30, a couple 100-ohm resistors and 1K trimmer pots for current limiting and dimming, and went home. Half an hour and a few solder joints later, I had mounted the 6 LEDs shining thru holes in my overhead panel, pointed at my steering wheel area (hey, first I helped MYSELF, not the kids). I found that I could run three LEDs, with a voltage drop of about 3.5V each, in series with the fixed 100 ohm resistor and a trimmer pot. So two sets in parallel worked well. I couldn't wait until nighttime.
After dark, out to the van I went. Switch on - WOW.
First impression - the color was all wrong. Until I realized that I'm so used to yellow light that pure white was almost distracting. But the light was BRIGHT and very crisp. From about 18 inches from LEDs to reading material, with only 6 LEDs, I had more light than with the original dome light 20 inches away, and the color was perfect - I could enjoy reading material with photos, without straining to see the colors. The pool of light was about 15 inches across. The LEDs I used are rated at 30deg beam spread (to the point of half brightness) so that seemed about right for six lights pointed a bit apart from each other. Best of all, unlike a dome lamp, there was NO spillover light to the rest of the interior - with the light on I could still easily see out the front to drive. Don't try that for long with a glaring dome lamp.
One other thing was worth noting - there were faint yellow/blue bands in the pool of light, noticable only when looking at a large mostly blank page. This is probably due to the blue LED/yellow phosphor combination used to make white light.
The biggest problem was cost. At Radio Shack prices of $4.99 each, I couldn't affort enough LEDs to do the other five seating locations. But it was still far cheaper than a quality aircraft-style reading lamp, and just as bright. If I wanted more brightness, I can easily add more LEDs.
Check out this link - http://www.theledlight.com - for some really cool ideas, parts, kits, assembled lamps, all based on LED technology. Really cool, and a LOT cheaper for the bare LEDs than Radio Shack. About $2.50 or less each.
Soon I'm going to order some bulk WLEDs from them - and light up the rest of the vehicle interior.
--Brandon / Split Infinity Music
They're used quite extensively as backlights for industrial equipment, I know some of the newer Fluke multimeters use white LEDs to backlight the display for nighttime use. Also, Gameboy Advance has outboard white LEDs that you can plug in the link cable slot, and I'm pretty sure some geek case modder types have installed white LEDs in their GBA's.