Slashdot Mirror


Perens Backs Down from DMCA Violation

liquidsin writes "According to this article by Dan Gillmor, Bruce Perens has backed out of his plan to demonstrate how to modify a DVD player to break region coding (and openly violate the DMCA as well) due to pressure from his employer, Hewlett Packard. I wish HP had given him their blessing on this, but I guess they have to worry about shareholders first..." See our previous story for Perens' plans.

9 of 352 comments (clear)

  1. HOWTO: Civil Disobedience by krog · · Score: 5, Funny

    so, let me get this straight. he intended to explain DVD region circumvention in order to publicly disobey an authority.... then an authority said "don't do that". so he won't.

    just wanted to grab some headlines, i guess...

    1. Re:HOWTO: Civil Disobedience by Arandir · · Score: 4, Funny

      Without knowing what HP told him, we'll never know.

      It could have been something as simple as "you know, our legal insurance doesn't cover willful, premeditated, and pre-announced violations of the law. If you get arrested you'll have to pay for your own defense. But don't worry, when you get out in ten years your old job will still be waiting for you..."

      --
      A Government Is a Body of People, Usually Notably Ungoverned
    2. Re:HOWTO: Civil Disobedience by unitron · · Score: 3, Funny

      So instead go up there with a small tape recorder rigged to throw a puff of smoke and a tape with Carly saying "Should you or any of your team be captured of killed, the board of directors will disavow any knowledge of your actions.".

      --

      I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.

  2. In other news... by warmcat · · Score: 5, Funny

    Mr Perens now able to walk without wheelbarrow; confirms HP has his nuts in a very large jar.

  3. In other news... by Zelet · · Score: 2, Funny

    In other news today, the Bush administration finally got the bill it has been seeking. Under current law, any contributor (as long as they are incorporated) of $200,000 or more to a government leader such as a Senator or President may get unconditional control of the U.S. military for 3 months. Supreme Commander, the High and Holy Hollings has announced that Commander Gates has paid for a millennia of U.S. Military control with Peter Pan and Mickey Mouse as Generals. Gates gave the honorary title to S.C.H.H. Hollings for his efforts in passing a bill that would allow MicroDisney to raise and use an elite paramilitary unit to raid and kill evil software/IP pirates with no fear of prosecution or oversight. Not surprisingly, there was little upheaval to this bill. One lady was quoted as saying, "Well, I don't pirate." The software pirates themselves had little comment considering that they were dead.

    Bush, after receiving his check quickly cashed it only to find that there were insufficient funds for payment and realized that the check was actually made in an EZ-Bake oven. Bush, upon complaining to the Supreme Court was found to be a software pirate and killed. The Supreme Court, coincidentally, was also found to be software pirates and killed also.

    Under new leadership the United States of America is now called the U.S.A. Inc. and Subsidiaries.

    In unrelated news, a software glitch at Offutt Air Force Base and Space Command launch a small nuclear attack on China killing 900 million and wounding 150 million more. Gates responded with the offhand remark, "shit happens, don't pirate."

    --
    ...And when they came for me, there was no one left to speak out for me." - Martin Niemoeller (1892-1984)
  4. Or maybe... by Alsee · · Score: 4, Funny

    XXAA vs Hewlett Packard the Honorable Judge Halfaclu presiding

    Judge Halfaclu: Call your first witness.
    Lawyer: I call Bruce Perens. Mr. Perens, did you have a discussion with Hewlett Packard regarding a possible DMCA violation?
    Bruce Perens: Yes. They told me not to do it.
    Lawyer: And what did you say?
    Bruce Perens: I said "OK", I won't do it.
    Lawyer: And then what happened?
    Bruce Perens: I changed my mind and did it anyway.
    Lawyer: Against Hewlett Packard's specific request?
    Bruce Perens: Yes.
    Lawyer: So Hewlett Packard didn't know?
    Bruce Perens: No.
    Lawyer: And even if they had known, was there any way they could have prevented it?
    Bruce Perens: "Any way"? Ummm, well I guess they could have hit me with a baseball bat and locked me in a dungeon.
    (laughter)
    Lawyer: I mean was there any legal way they could have prevented it?
    Bruce Perens: Umm, none that I know of... but, ahhh, I am not a laywer. Some of my friends are laywers though.
    Lawyer: Thank you. No further questions
    Judge Halfaclu: CASE DISSMISSED AGAINST HEWLETT PACKARD. Prosecution may procede against the defendant Bruce Perens.

    -

    --
    - - You can't take something off the Internet! That's like trying to take pee out of a swimming pool.
  5. Re:I don't get it? by acceleriter · · Score: 2, Funny

    I think they're called Compaquard Bell now.

    --

    CEE5210S The signal SIGHUP was received.

  6. Mr Perens, I have a solution for you. by A_Non_Moose · · Score: 4, Funny

    Give your presentation as per advised by your employer, which is the smart thing to do.

    Also, make your original presentation available on a CD-rom and attach a EULA to it reading:

    "By agreeing to this EULA you will not hold HP, Bruce Perens or any attendees of this conference, personally, legally, ethically, morally, physically, mentally, emotionally or any other *lly for that matter.
    If you are a member of the RIAA, MPAA, ABA, law enforcement (genus homo sapien or canine), political or judicial in nature, you hereby agree to stop breeding, kill any offspring and other kin you may have and then stop breathing should you have any need, want, desire, thought, inkling or idea to do or be the initiator, participant, party to or of any kind of lawsuit, harassment, annoyance or flatulance against Bruce Perens and HP.
    Failure to comply with the above and you will pay the legal fees of the prosecution, defense, judge, jury, state in which you file, donate to the EFF no less than the senator from Disney has been bribed...err...funded per day and sing "I'm a Lumberjack" every hour until the trial (which should not happen in the first place, but you had to be a dick about it) proceedes and co-council will have to say 'bork, bork, bork' every 20th word".


    Not only will you challenge the BS that is the DMCA but the EULA as well...because if the above EULA is valid and legally binding, well, somebody needs to lay off the crackpipe, get a sense of humor and be beaten by a clue stick before they can even approach the DMCA violation that they agreed to not to do anything about....and you just know it'll have to be submitted in original form, heh!!

    Feel free to add more asinine stuff and legalese up the arse with HP's lawyers... and find one with a mean streak who enjoys fscking with other lawyers.

    Now, if you will excuse me, I'm going to rip AC/DC's song "Big Balls" to MP3....JUST BECAUSE I CAN.....muaahahahahahahaha.

    .

    --
    Have you read the moderator guidelines? Well, have you, PUNK? (and I want a Karma: Gnarly option)
  7. Re:where is Bruce today? by Bruce+Perens · · Score: 3, Funny
    OK. I thought you expected me to have slashdot attached at the hip :-)

    Bruce