Closed Gnutella System to Prevent Bandwidth Hogs

prostoalex writes: "Salon.com is running a story on Gnutella developers contemplating the creation of a closed or authorization-only system to prevent bandwidth hogging. Turns out, numerous applications, including Xolox and QTraxMax employ quering algorithms that are capable of bringing the network traffic to a halt. While it gets better download speeds for the users of the aforementioned applications, the damage to network traffic as a whole is substantial."

Comments

Get rid of pop culture vultures!

[Glowing Fish]

The biggest problem with gnutella is not technical. It is that gnutella was invented so that true hardcore underground people such as myself could complete our collection of harcore underground things, such as the entire run of Evangelion. However, gnutella is cluttered with people only interested in Brittney Spears. Here is an idea I first proposed on everything2 for making gnutella less crowded.

Gnutella is one of the best things to come out of Sedona, AZ since the hordes of Alien Invaders who passed through the vortex. At leat for those of us who have DSL or better, Gnutella is the best way to complete our collection of Evangelion episodes, obscure hip hop mp3s and fets.com sets.

The problem with gnutella though, is that it is crowded, and according to my estimates, about 75% of this crowding is due to people looking either for mp3s of that damn song that plays on the radio every half hour and\or nude pictures of celebrities. Often to compound matters, these people are looking for nude pictures of that one celebrity that sings that damn song they play on the radio every half hour.

If we have a tool that allows us to download obscure 90 minute long epic techno ballads from the Slovak Republic, why are we allowing people to use it to listen to music that they can hear by turning on MTV?

The answer is because we don't know how to stop them. But I have a possible solution for our problem. All it requires is for about 100 or so people to put a file in a shared directory called "Brittneyspearsbarebreasts.jpg" or something along those lines. But instead of said picture actually being of Miss Spears beare breats, why not make it something else...such as possibly goatse.cx?

After seeing this picture one too many times (which will probably be the first time), many people will cease to use gnutella as a vehicle for their pop culture stupidities.

In other news

[dirtsurfer]

The userbase of Xolox and QTraxMax doubled today...

Never mind Gnutella, this just in....

[Anonymous Coward]

The S&P 500 and the FBI's most wanted lists are going to be merged.

Gene Kan, YES!

[gripdamage]

Finally the time has come for that guy with the Gene Kan comments to be on-topic! But he's nowhere to be found.

In case it's not clear, I'm trying to be funny.

Re:OT: Re:A few thoughts on P2P

[UncleFluffy]

When someone points a gun at you, it isn't anarchy any more, so none of your examples apply.

Where's the party?

[Mirk]

This is simple. The solution to the problem of quality of service is just to invite your close, trusted friends onto your Gnutella network and not let the plebs out there know about it.

[pause]

Now if only I could find out where those elitist bastards are hiding! :-)