Slashdot Mirror
BBC Hails "fair" Microsoft XP SP1
Richard Bown writes "Continuing their current trend of only giving you half the story the BBC have
this article on how fair and equitable Microsoft are these days. No mention of EULA changes."
← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)
And, for anybody who is using XP, they say that the software (like IE, Media Player, etc) is hidden. But if I double-click on an HTML file, does it come up in IE anyways? Or does it say "File type not recognized"?
</Karma Whoring>
Comment removed based on user account deletion
The word is that there are two widely circulated keys in particular that are targeted. Not sure if SP1 will disable those systems or if it will just refuse to install
Schnapple
You can put in a new serial number on a running system. Do a quick search on deja and you'll find it.
The main problem with this article is that BBC makes it sound as if there was already a final settlement in the anti-trust case. Nowhere in the entire article do they point out that there is only a proposed settlement, and that Microsoft's actions are being taken to try and forestall more restrictive penalties by the government. And, finally, the method used for "hiding" the MS software doesn't help much for those who don't want to use them because the other software manufacturers have to write their software to take advantage of the changes. Of course none have done it yet, so you actually cannot change your default browser to Netscape right now, no matter what MS says.
None of that is MS bashing. This is. MS is a monopoly. They know they are a monopoly. People like Steve Ballmer within the executive circle of MS have no intention of letting go of their monopoly. Unless Judge Kollar-Kotelly takes very restrictive and punitive measures against MS they will just continue to do this, again and again. The obvious solution, one which would actually benefit the country economically, is to first penalize the company for it's actions, and then, after the penalty phase, split the company into at least two parts, perhaps three, with each new company restricted in a fashion that will help to prevent future monopolistic behavior. The first time I bought MS Office (Office 95 Pro) its cost was 10% of the cost of a reasonable PC ($200 vs. $2,000). Now the cost of MS Office is $499 (Office XP Pro). A reasonable PC is about $1,000 (office automation, web surfing, etc. not a gaming machine). Not only is Office XP not 250% better than Office 95, it's not even 100% better. I refuse to use Office anymore. Unfortunately at work I have to, since it is our company standard. That may change, according to some rumblings I'm hearing. In the meantime I will never again spend any of my own money on MS products.
In my universe I'm perfectly normal, it's not my fault you don't live in my universe.
nope, he'd just have to use a generator with a valid license key to produce a valid product key and edit about 5 registry entries replace the old ID with the new product key and reboot, then tryu again, it might break windows update, but it should allow the service pack, worked for the betas anyway.
Software Freedom Day!.
It won't install on a copy with the infamous FCKGW-... key from the Devil's Own release, released months before XP went retail. They also disabled another one, which is pretty unknown and not at all as wide spread it seems.
:-)
Some are saying that MS disabled all serials for the "Corporate Edition" starting with F and P.
What happens if installing on SP1 with the FCKGW key then?
You'll get a message similar to "this key is pirated -- blabla -- you need to immediately obtain a legal key". Then I recall your copy of XP needs activation and you get this timer before it's *completely* deactivated and you're *forced* to phone MS to use the crap.
Needless to say, there are ways to change a key before installing SP1 without uninstalling XP.
Also, there are a key generator (yes, that "Blue List keygen") available for XP that generates keys not detected as illegal by SP1.
So, in the end, not much has been changed in the warez scene from this. Integrated Windows XP SP1 Corp Ed. ISO's with working serials are already floating around.
Beware: In C++, your friends can see your privates!
As you used Windows Update, it almost certainly worked out what components you require, and downloaded only those. The 133meg file size would be for the whole thing, including updates for components that you don't have installed and/or don't come with your version of XP (i.e. Home vs. Pro, language/locale, etc).
If you look around on the Microsoft site, you'll find that there's a "network install" (or similar) version of the service pack, that's the entire thing in one file. It's designed for sites that may have a variety of different configurations installed, so they can essentially mirror it locally. 133meg sounds about right for that sort of service pack (the Windows 2000 ones have generally been around the 100+meg mark).
Cheers,
Tim
It's official. Most of you are morons.
Do you honestly belive 133 megs is just for that? Or do you not relase it's a SERVICE PACK, which means it services flaws, mistakes, etc in old software. It's a glorifed patch!
I think the issue here is the way the changes are portrayed.
/. reader - if they can't see it, how do they tell the difference? If the BBC says it's an improvement, surely it must be?
;)
When I RTFA, it seemed to suggest that Microsoft has made major concessions to the world's anti-monopoly bodies by removing a few icons from the desktop and start menu, and that MS is now a much nicer company, having given in to the little people.
The problem there is that most people assume that if the icon's not there, neither is the program. Not everyone's as tech-savvy as the average
Mainstream media educates the public, and it'd be good to get mainstream media to understand the issues and technology involved (don't forget, the writers at the BBC are professional _writers_, not coders).
If you think this 'change' has been misrepresented to Joe Public, mail the BBC and let them know what's up. You can't fault them for not knowing everything, but you can let them know where _you_ think they've got it wrong.
btw, please be nice - this bunch are usually good enough to have a real person reply to your comments. Show a little respect for people doing something right
Warning: May contain nuts
You do understand that there's a difference between a company that gets a monopoly because it simply has a better product, and a company that gets a monopoly because of unfair business practices? "Monopoly" doesn't automatically equal "anticompetetive." Besides, if everyone uses Linux all of a sudden, who has the monopoly? Red Hat? Gentoo? Mandrake? Slackware? Debian? Linus Torvalds himself?
"Destroy science and religion. Science would re-emerge exactly the same; but not religion." - Penn Jillette, paraphrased
The item could have gone into more detail but what it does say is pretty straight-down-the-line factual and is not "half the story" as the poster claimed. Sure, there's no mention of EULA changes but, since they're not legally binding anyway who gives a toss? It's only a small piece, not the history of Windows!
TWW
"Encyclopedia" is to "Wikipedia" what "Library" is to "Some people at a bus stop"
SUPPLEMENTAL END USER LICENSE AGREEMENT
.NET .NET Framework to any third party
IMPORTANT: READ CAREFULLY - This
Supplemental End User License Agreement
("Supplemental EULA") is a legal agreement
between you (either an individual or a single
entity) and Microsoft Corporation ("Microsoft") for the Microsoft
software that accompanies this Supplemental EULA, which
includes computer software and may include associated media,
printed materials, "online" or electronic documentation,
and Internet-based services (the "OS Components").
The OS Components are provided to update, supplement,
or replace existing functionality of the applicable
Microsoft software for which the OS Components
are designed (any such software referred to here as "OS
Software"). An amendment or addendum to this
Supplemental EULA may accompany the OS Components.
YOU AGREE TO BE BOUND BY THE TERMS OF THE
APPLICABLE OS SOFTWARE END USER LICENSE
AGREEMENT ("OS SOFTWARE EULA") AND THIS
SUPPLEMENTAL EULA BY INSTALLING, COPYING, OR
OTHERWISE USING THE OS COMPONENTS. IF YOU DO
NOT AGREE, DO NOT INSTALL, COPY, OR USE THE
OS COMPONENTS.
IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A VALIDLY LICENSED COPY OF
THE APPLICABLE OS SOFTWARE, YOU ARE NOT
AUTHORIZED TO INSTALL, COPY OR OTHERWISE USE
THE OS COMPONENTS AND YOU HAVE NO RIGHTS
UNDER THIS SUPPLEMENTAL EULA.
General.
* Microsoft grants you a license to use the OS Components
under the terms and conditions of the OS Software EULA
(which are hereby incorporated by reference except as
set forth below), the terms and conditions set forth in
this Supplemental EULA, and the terms and conditions of
any additional end user license agreement that may
accompany the individual OS Components (each an
"Individual EULA"), provided that you comply with all
such terms and conditions. To the extent that there is
a conflict among any of these terms and conditions
applicable to the OS Components, the following hierarchy
shall apply: 1) the terms and conditions of the
Individual EULA; 2) the terms and conditions in this
Supplemental EULA; and 3) the terms and conditions of the
applicable OS Software EULA.
* The OS Components are protected by copyright and other
intellectual property laws and treaties. Microsoft or its
suppliers own the title, copyright, and other intellectual
property rights in the OS Components. Microsoft reserves
all rights not expressly granted to you in this Supplemental
EULA. The OS Components are licensed, not sold.
* Capitalized terms used in this Supplemental EULA and not
otherwise defined herein shall have the meanings assigned to
them in the applicable OS Software EULA.
Additional Rights and Limitations.
* You may reproduce, install and use one copy of the OS
Components on each of your computers that is running a
validly licensed copy of the applicable OS Software,
provided that you use each such additional copy of the OS
Components in accordance with the terms and conditions of
this Supplemental EULA.
* Solely for the purpose of preventing unlicensed use of the
applicable OS Software, the OS Components will include
installation on your computer of technological measures that
are designed to prevent unlicensed use, and Microsoft may
use this technology to confirm that you have a licensed copy
of the OS Software. The update of these technological
measures only occurs through the installation of these OS
Components. The OS Components will not install on
unlicensed copies of the OS Software. If you are not using
a licensed copy of the OS Software, you are not allowed to
install the OS Components or future OS Software updates.
Microsoft will not collect any personally identifiable
information from your computer during this process.
* The OS Components may include the Microsoft
Framework. You may not disclose the results of any
benchmark test of the
without Microsoft's prior written approval.
* Solely with respect to the OS Components, if the licensor of
the applicable OS Software was an entity other than
Microsoft, then for the purposes of this Supplemental EULA
Microsoft is the licensor with respect to such OS Components
in lieu of the "Manufacturer" or other entity. Manufacturer
or such other entity has no obligation under this
Supplemental EULA to provide support for such OS
Components. With respect to the existing functionality
contained in the applicable OS Software that is not updated,
supplemented, or replaced by the OS Components, the OS
Software EULA provided by the Manufacturer or other
licensing entity shall remain in full force and effect as
to that OS Software.
IF THE APPLICABLE OS SOFTWARE WAS LICENSED TO
YOU BY MICROSOFT OR ANY OF ITS WHOLLY OWNED
SUBSIDIARIES, THE LIMITED WARRANTY (IF ANY)
INCLUDED IN THE APPLICABLE OS SOFTWARE EULA
APPLIES TO THE OS COMPONENTS, PROVIDED THAT
THE OS COMPONENTS HAVE BEEN LICENSED BY YOU
WITHIN THE TERM OF THE LIMITED WARRANTY IN
THE APPLICABLE OS SOFTWARE EULA. HOWEVER,
THIS SUPPLEMENTAL EULA DOES NOT EXTEND THE
TIME PERIOD FOR WHICH THE LIMITED WARRANTY IS
PROVIDED.
IF THE APPLICABLE OS SOFTWARE WAS LICENSED TO
YOU BY AN ENTITY OTHER THAN MICROSOFT OR ANY
OF ITS WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARIES, MICROSOFT
DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES WITH RESPECT TO THE
OS COMPONENTS AS FOLLOWS:
DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTIES. TO THE MAXIMUM
EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, MICROSOFT
AND ITS SUPPLIERS PROVIDE TO YOU THE OS
COMPONENTS, AND SUPPORT SERVICES (IF ANY) AS
IS AND WITH ALL FAULTS; AND MICROSOFT AND ITS
SUPPLIERS HEREBY DISCLAIM ALL OTHER
WARRANTIES AND CONDITIONS, WHETHER EXPRESS,
IMPLIED OR STATUTORY, INCLUDING, BUT NOT
LIMITED TO, ANY (IF ANY) IMPLIED WARRANTIES,
DUTIES OR CONDITIONS OF MERCHANTABILITY, OF
FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, OF
RELIABILITY OR AVAILABILITY, OF ACCURACY OR
COMPLETENESS OF RESPONSES, OF RESULTS, OF
WORKMANLIKE EFFORT, OF LACK OF VIRUSES, AND
OF LACK OF NEGLIGENCE, ALL WITH REGARD TO THE
OS COMPONENTS, AND THE PROVISION OF OR
FAILURE TO PROVIDE SUPPORT OR OTHER SERVICES,
INFORMATION, SOFTWARE, AND RELATED CONTENT
THROUGH THE OS COMPONENTS OR OTHERWISE
ARISING OUT OF THE USE OF THE OS COMPONENTS.
ALSO, THERE IS NO WARRANTY OR CONDITION OF
TITLE, QUIET ENJOYMENT, QUIET POSSESSION,
CORRESPONDENCE TO DESCRIPTION OR NON
-INFRINGEMENT WITH REGARD TO THE OS
COMPONENTS.
EXCLUSION OF INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL AND
CERTAIN OTHER DAMAGES. TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT
PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, IN NO EVENT
SHALL MICROSOFT OR ITS SUPPLIERS BE LIABLE
FOR ANY SPECIAL, INCIDENTAL, PUNITIVE,
INDIRECT, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES
WHATSOEVER (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO,
DAMAGES FOR LOSS OF PROFITS OR CONFIDENTIAL
OR OTHER INFORMATION, FOR BUSINESS
INTERRUPTION, FOR PERSONAL INJURY, FOR LOSS
OF PRIVACY, FOR FAILURE TO MEET ANY DUTY
INCLUDING OF GOOD FAITH OR OF REASONABLE
CARE, NEGLIGENCE, AND ANY OTHER PECUNIARY
OR OTHER LOSS WHATSOEVER) ARISING OUT OF OR
IN ANY WAY RELATED TO THE USE OF OR
INABILITY TO USE THE OS COMPONENTS,
THE PROVISION OF OR FAILURE TO PROVIDE
SUPPORT OR OTHER SERVICES, INFORMATION,
SOFTWARE, AND RELATED CONTENT THROUGH THE OS
COMPONENTS OR OTHERWISE ARISING OUT OF THE
USE OF THE OS COMPONENTS, OR OTHERWISE UNDER
OR IN CONNECTION WITH ANY PROVISION OF THIS
SUPPLEMENTAL EULA, EVEN IN THE EVENT OF THE
FAULT, TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE),
MISREPRESENTATION, STRICT OR PRODUCT
LIABILITY, BREACH OF CONTRACT OR BREACH OF
WARRANTY OF MICROSOFT OR ANY SUPPLIER, AND
EVEN IF MICROSOFT OR ANY SUPPLIER HAS BEEN
ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILTY OF SUCH DAMAGES.
LIMITATION OF LIABILITY AND REMEDIES.
NOTWITHSTANDING ANY DAMAGES THAT YOU MIGHT
INCUR FOR ANY REASON WHATSOEVER (INCLUDING,
WITHOUT LIMITATION, ALL DAMAGES REFERENCED
ABOVE AND ALL DIRECT OR GENERAL DAMAGES IN
CONTRACT OR ANYTHING ELSE), THE ENTIRE
LIABILITY OF MICROSOFT AND ANY OF ITS
SUPPLIERS UNDER ANY PROVISION OF THIS
SUPPLEMENTAL EULA AND YOUR EXCLUSIVE REMEDY
FOR ALL OF THE FOREGOING SHALL BE LIMITED TO
THE GREATER OF THE ACTUAL DAMAGES YOU INCUR
IN REASONABLE RELIANCE ON THE SOFTWARE UP TO
THE AMOUNT ACTUALLY PAID BY YOU FOR THE OS
COMPONENTS OR U.S.$5.00. THE FOREGOING
LIMITATIONS, EXCLUSIONS AND DISCLAIMERS SHALL
APPLY TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY
APPLICABLE LAW, EVEN IF ANY REMEDY FAILS ITS
ESSENTIAL PURPOSE.