Making A Videowall

Ur@eus writes "Zeeshan Ali Khattak has made a videowall using Red Hat Linux, GStreamer and commodity hardware. The solution was made based on the need to create a flexible and cheap solution for use in Pakistani Schools and Universities using commodity hardware. To find out how this was done and some more details, and of course some cool pictures, check out the Video Whale project homepage."

Comments

Re:Wouldn't four quadheads be more usefull

[Quixote]

But what about the bandwidth issues? Will the PCI bus handle 16 video streams flowing through it (e.g. a movie, as the wall in the article shows) ?

Cost-effective ?

[tmark]

the need to create a flexible and cheap solution for use in Pakistani Schools and Universities using commodity hardware

I just can't believe this is cost-effective for more than a 4-screen display. With quality video projectors costing less than $2-3000 USD, this solution doesn't save much money, and is far less convenient in terms of portability - how would you even move around an 8x8 grid of monitors -, which would seem to be key for application in schools and universities. Also, the whole array is visually distracting due to the breaks between the monitors.

Sometimes people get distracted by technology and forget about the constraints of the problem to be solved.

A creative solution to the problem of...

[Spurious Growth]

No Funding! I think the point that people are missing here is that the project does not have a budget. There is no money to spend on a video projector. The entire system relies on hardware which is, on a regular basis, serving an entirely different purpose. This solution allows them to create a large display when it is necessary, out of components at hand. Almost any computer lab can generate a 4' x 5' display on demand.

Also, what is the effective resolution of such a screen? It sounds remarkably similar to the IBM ultra high resolution LCD we heard about a while back.

Spurious

Once again, did anyone read

[JWhitlock]

...or just look at the pictures. As the author states:

I rather quick realized that the only extra component we needed in Gstreamer was one that that did the cropping for us. At the same time I also saw that my knowledge about multimedia and GStreamer was not good enough to allow me to write this element. So I tried asking my friend Wim Taymans if he would be willing to take on the task of writing such a plugin. He was kind enough to do that not only because of my need, but also because he saw it as another nice feature of Gstreamer that would be needed by many others.

So, they know that cropping is a problem. But that's just software (and maybe a bit of hardware, with those huge borders). But that isn't their biggest hardware problem.

It turned out however that our biggest problem was finding PCI video cards in Pakistan whose XFree86 drivers could do XVideo, this in a situation when its hard to even find PCI video cards at all in the market. Solving this problem of lacking parts took us 3 months and at one point we even considered abondoning the project. We still need more cards because we do not have more than these 16 s3virge/DX cards. If any of the cards stop functioning, we are out of business.

This isn't the U.S. - it's Pakistan. They can't go to eBay and find a 4-head card, or even pick and chose cards (or even monitors) based on requirements. They have to use what they can find, and I for one am impressed. How many of you would give up if it took three months to just find the hardware?

This is a great engineering story, of folks working with what they have, and a great Free Software story - they could have tried some pirated copy of commerical software, but instead they decided to use open source components, stretching what is possible. Could it have been done with a projector? Sure, if one was availible. But now the state of multi-monitor free software has been advanced a little, which may benefit you or me some day.

I hope that there were some other people who saw how cool this was, who are contacting the authors with useful suggestions about removing the shells and mounting the tubes closer together, that are looking at the GStreamer source and thinking about how to add cropping, and how to make cropping easy, and hopefully a few people that are thinking about donating equipment, and realizing how lucky they are to live in a world where you can order a projector from Amazon and have it delivered in days.