Slashdot Mirror


Cooler Master's Latest High-End Case Reviewed

Hubert writes "Cooler Master, pioneer of the aluminum cases, overhauled one of their most popular models, and released something enthusiasts should consider when shopping for a new case." Cooler Master has also come out with some cases which might meet the often-expressed demand for PC enclosures which would look at home in an A/V rack. Pricey, though.

97 comments

  1. Strange policies... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    The linked page has this little gem written on it...

    ! note: all the specification subject should be changed without prior notice !

    They should?

  2. typo heaven by DrSkwid · · Score: 5, Funny

    ! note: all the specification subject should be changed without prior notice !

    it's really a matchbox

    An ulimate multinedia PC in intel website

    I just can't get by without my daily dose of ulimate multinedia

    --
    There are places where the networks are not touching,and there are places where they are-Boeing's Lori Gunter
    1. Re:typo heaven by MeanMF · · Score: 4, Funny

      ! note: all the specification subject should be changed without prior notice !

      Also note, somebody set us up the power supply!

    2. Re:typo heaven by qslack · · Score: 1

      All your case are belong to us?

  3. ARTICLE SPACE FOR SALE by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    If you have a product you cannot sell, ask Slashdot advertising department. We can and do provide high response rates and publish your advertisement hidden as science or hardware news.

    1. Re:ARTICLE SPACE FOR SALE by AntiNorm · · Score: 2, Informative

      If you have a product you cannot sell, ask Slashdot advertising department. We can and do provide high response rates and publish your advertisement hidden as science or hardware news.

      They do.

      --

      I pledge allegiance to the flag...
      of the Corporate States of America...
    2. Re:ARTICLE SPACE FOR SALE by ender81b · · Score: 1

      Happen to look at the date on that article stud? That would april 1st, also known as april fools day. Looks like they got you...

  4. Now that by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That, is my kind of cast. Simple, standard, aluminum, cold, and cool lookin'. It's expensive, but worth it. When I get a new PC in the coming months I'll definitely be looking for a coolermaster.

    1. Re:Now that by chunkwhite86 · · Score: 1

      What for? And what were the "enthusiasts" supposed to take note of from the article?

      I have a lian li PC60usb and it works great. The price was decent, and I don't know what the author of the article was smoking when he said it's too cramped inside. FWIW I have a *watercooled* Dual athlon with SCSI raid array (& FULL length 64 bit pci scsi raid card), DVD, CDR and I'm using ALL the pci slots. And it fits fine in a pc60.

      I think the author of the article was just biased against lian-li for some reason. who knows.

      --
      I'd rather be a conservative nutjob than a liberal with no nuts and no job.
  5. Boring by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So what if you can have a goatse sized hole and red lights on your pc to make it look one thousand three hundred and thirty seven. I dont care, Im sticking to my white box, the only decoration is an amd case badge and that is it.

    Most of the time your box is shoved under the desk while you look at the screen.

    mod this as -1 if you want, but its very hard to find generic whiteboxes for sale these days.

  6. No offense but.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...that's it? It's a steel case with a hole cut in the side and something that looks like a steel fly-swatter pad stuck over it... and not even a big hole at that. TigerDirect has much better cases for like.. $50. Am I missing something?

    1. Re:No offense but.. by elkto · · Score: 0

      Which one? The CoolMaster case looks like a piece of stereo gear, which is handy in some environments. I went to TigerDirect and cannot see anything, save one server rackmount case, that is designed to sit horizontally. Thanks....

  7. Re:OT reply but I couldn't resist by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    WinXP and KDE are also pretty much at a Win95/98ish stage in competitive feature/integration terms.

  8. Designer Feet by wideBlueSkies · · Score: 5, Funny

    >>Taking a cue from home audio equipment, there's a nice gold trim around the 4 feet on the bottom of the case. I do question the colour choice though, as being a silver case, a silver trim would be a better colour match for the rest of the case.

    Yeah, one should care about how the case's feet look when they're beneath their desk retreiving a dropped pen, or reseating a network cable.

    "Mmm. Where's my pen? It's sure dusty down here, oh there's the potato chip I dropped last week. Whoa! check out the feet on the Cooler Master! Nice. Too bad they're not silver though"

    --
    Huh?
    1. Re:Designer Feet by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You don't put stuff this beautiful under a desk. Cooler Master cases are made to be seen.

  9. can't.....see.....link..... by Phybersyk0 · · Score: 3, Funny

    It seems their webserver is running cold enough to stop electrons dead in their tracks....

    1. Re:can't.....see.....link..... by gl4ss · · Score: 2

      yeah could somebody post a link to some picture of that thing somewhere on the web?

      it would be nice to know what people are bashing.. otherwise this could be just 'ask slashdot, what do you want to say about fancy cases'..

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
  10. WinBLOWS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I Heard Microsoft is going to make... coolers... trust me... they will blow you away...

    Whoopa@tmf.nl

  11. back to the future ? by beanerspace · · Score: 2

    it's sleek, it's sexy, I want one

    that said, it does make me wonder how far away we are from having to hire plumbers to help install water-cooled towers ... just like they did back in the day with the old Crays.

  12. even more expensive because micro-ATX only by eagl · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Those AV styled cases are even more expensive due to the fact that you'd have to buy new hardware to fit inside it. My multimedia box next to my TV is ready to go into a new, nicer looking case, except that it uses a full ATX motherboard. I'm willing to spend some coin on a new case, but I'm not willing to change the hardware configuration from a known-good setup just to fit into a new case. If I'm going to do that, I might as well buy a prebuilt or bare-bones setup like those nice little shuttle mini systems.

    1. Re:even more expensive because micro-ATX only by pcardoso · · Score: 2, Informative

      or you can also make your own case!

      I just did that to a computer of mine to plug into the tv and watch DVDs, DIVX and play snes/genesis games. I built a cube out of transparent plexiglass. You can watch it here. This is not something you can easily mix with other AV gear, of course :)

    2. Re:even more expensive because micro-ATX only by mcspock · · Score: 2, Informative

      I have the 610 case. It's an early adopter product. It's good construction, and it's worth $200, but they missed a bunch of details.

      Getting a micro-atx mainboard is no big deal. I bought an ASUS A7N266-VM board for $70 at newegg. Athlon XP 1700+ is about $55, and a stick of 512mb mushkin was $130, so all in all, getting new components was reasonable compared to the $205 for the case (at trendetronics.com).

      Back to the case itself, the things they missed are:

      1) Window for IR receiver

      2) Removable drive bracket; it'd be nice to mount all my drives in a bracket then screw that down to the chassis

      3) Quiet case fan; the 60mm cooler-master fan it came with was a tad loud. i bought a vantec stealth and that was ok, but nothing magical.

      4) Cable routing. Finding a way to run the front usb connectors around the entire case to the internal USB jacks was...interesting. right now i think i have them going under the motherboard

      I researched HTPC cases for months before buying this one; there was basically this, a case available in germany only, and another case that was $500 (but looked oh-so-cool). All in all it was worth it; it matches my stereo equipment, it's quiet (now), and gives me a PC that doesn't look anything like a PC.

      --
      -- Patience is a virtue, but impatience is an art.
    3. Re:even more expensive because micro-ATX only by skeedlelee · · Score: 2

      Howz the door on the -610? From the image of it that I saw, it looks to have a similar door to the -600 case. Got a -600 case and the door is a pain in the ass! If you (as I do) try to open an optical drive while the door thing is closed it crashes. On the plus side the door is transparent which might have made for a solution to your IR receiver issue.

    4. Re:even more expensive because micro-ATX only by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I built a cube out of transparent plexiglass.

      You know, that sounded a lot cooler than it looked...

    5. Re:even more expensive because micro-ATX only by mcspock · · Score: 1

      I haven't tried that yet actually. The doors are closed by a push-latch at the top and have those slow-swivel gears on the sides (words...escaping...mind). Usually if i am doing something with the CD drive i just leave the top door open, i'm guessing that the drive wouldn't be able to force it open at all.

      I'm planning on getting a slot loading cd drive at some point; i dont know if that would handle things differently (since there is no tray state? who knows)

      --
      -- Patience is a virtue, but impatience is an art.
  13. Excellent Seller by eviljolly · · Score: 3, Informative

    I ordered a rounded SCSI cable from these guys a few weeks ago. It took about a week and a half to get her, but that's very acceptable considering it was right around the holidays. I think most of that was UPS's fault anyways. These guys are very professional and they answered all my questions promptly and shipped my item the next day. Man I feel like I'm leaving feedback on ebay now.

    1. Re:Excellent Seller by alexburke · · Score: 2

      Man I feel like I'm leaving feedback on ebay now.

      Perhaps, but you seem to be missing what is unfortunately considered by many to be a required component of a feedback comment:

      AAAAA+++++++!!!!!!!

    2. Re:Excellent Seller by DAldredge · · Score: 2

      Rounded SCSI cable? What in the hell for? Why don't you just get some electric fence wire to use while you are at it.

      Spend a fortune on SCSI then use out of spec cables because they are 'KOOL'...

      Someone please shoot me.

    3. Re:Excellent Seller by eviljolly · · Score: 1

      How are those cables out of spec? I didn't buy them because they looked cool either, I bought them because the normal 5 device cable clogs up airflow in my case and literally raises the temp about 10 degrees (Fahrenheit...and yes I know most of the world uses Metric...you don't have to remind me). I ran benchmarks and noticed no difference between the 2 cables just to make sure. I actually gained a few points on the rounded cables, but nothing signifigant. Perhaps if I had all 30 devices on my 39160 card then these cables might make a difference, but I'm only connecting one device, so does it really even matter? They do make rounded cables that work equally as well as high end ribbon cables, but those will run you a little extra just as the flat ones would. If I was going to be connecting 30 devices I wouldn't bother paying for scsi anyways, I'd go with a fibre channel array.

  14. Re:OT reply but I couldn't resist by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    well I tend to compare KDE with Windows but I would never compare GNOME with one Windows version available.

  15. Re:OT reply but I couldn't resist by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    hahaha hahaha hahaha hahaha hahaha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha hahaha hahaha hahaha hahaha ha nevar! Amiga will come back, I just know it!

  16. Not at the moment :-( by Anonymous+Brave+Guy · · Score: 1, Flamebait
    It took about a week and a half to get her, but that's very acceptable considering it was right around the holidays. I think most of that was UPS's fault anyways.

    Well, this time it'll be Slashdot's. Doesn't anyone ever think to mirror the article before taking out a small company's web site? Knowingly taking out a commercial site like that ought to be illegal.

    --
    If you disagree, post your argument. (-1, Overrated) isn't your personal censorship tool for views you don't like.
  17. Aluminum drive bays... by httpamphibio.us · · Score: 2

    The aluminum looks all sleek and cool, yeah... but what about when you install a bunch of nasty beige devices into it? Isn't that just going to look super super tacky? Is there an easy (ie. w/o disassembling each component) way to make it all match up?

    --
    sig.
    1. Re:Aluminum drive bays... by Osty · · Score: 3, Interesting

      The faceplates on most components are very easily removed. Add to that a can of spray paint in a matching color for your case, and there's no longer a problem. Be sure to mask off the holes for status lights, though.

    2. Re:Aluminum drive bays... by steeleye_brad · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Lian Li makes some aluminum stick-on things for various brands of drives (optical and floppy). Fairly cheap, around 5-7 dollars each. I've seen them at many places online, and at CompUSA. You could also probably make your own out of a piece of aluminum, or thin steel even.

      You could also try painting your drives, but that involves a lot more effort.

    3. Re:Aluminum drive bays... by dhuff · · Score: 1

      There are color-matched components available at places like Directron. For instance, at Directron they have links to all their components in both black and silver right on the front page - DVD and CR-RW drives, stick on bezels for beige drives, both LCD & CRT monitors, all sorts of stuff :)

    4. Re:Aluminum drive bays... by skeedlelee · · Score: 5, Informative

      I am not a case modder but here are a few comments on that...

      The article actually mentions (if you got to it before the slashdotting) that CoolerMaster sells bezels that match. That would be useful for the mid-tower case.

      The desktop case (which looks like an AV component) doesn't need it because there is a very attractive door in front of the drive bays, making the whole thing look like a laserdisk player or a 7 disk CD changer or something. You only see the drives when the door is opened.

      This bears mentioning though because I helped someone get a computer that ended up coming with an ATC-600 (IIRC). This is a desktop with a transparent door in front of the drive bays. Very attractive case, actually had Mac people ooo-ing and aww-ing (unpromted even). The case is really solid, put a 19" CRT on top of it with no complaints (which ordinarily might be a stupid thing to do). The door is attractive and well built. Unfortunaely the door is also a completely stupid idea if you actually plan on using the computer. There are two optical drives on the front, not surprisingly you often want to get in and out of them fairly often. The door is on some sort of smooth opening device, which means it opens slowly. Frequently you'll eject a CD or DVD and the drive slides right into the stupid little door. You can try to frantically open the door as the drive comes out but it goes way too slowly.

      The result is that I tend to just leave the door open all the time when I'm using it, have almost brought myself to remove it (which looks pretty easy). I'm guessing that the new case has a similar problem with the door. If you're planning on using this in an AV system, be aware that this will be an issue (minor as it is, but these are rather expensive cases). The door is a liability and to some extent negates the 'don't need matching face plates' comment that started all this off in the first place.

    5. Re:Aluminum drive bays... by slriv · · Score: 1

      I understand what you mean, but how often are you swapping CD's/DVD's on your player???

      --
      All the worlds a stage, and I'm the guy running the lights...
  18. Get what you pay for.... by NetJunkie · · Score: 2

    I'm glad someone is finally doing nice looking AV rack cases. Yes, they cost more but they look nicer. All of my AV gear is in a normal cabinet and a minitower PC just doesn't fit this setup. For these "media center" PCs to take off they need to fit in with normal AV electronics.

    Maybe I'll look at building a media center PC now....

  19. Lian Li by Master+Bait · · Score: 2, Informative
    Pioneered aluminum cases before Coolermaster even began building cases. They remain superior in construction quality, but not necessarily in looks.

    --
    "Only in their dreams can men truly be free 'twas always thus, and always thus will be."
    --Tom Schulman
    1. Re:Lian Li by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, they didn't. CM made the first Al cases.

    2. Re:Lian Li by Toraz+Chryx · · Score: 2

      Get back to me when Lian Li make a case as nice as the Coolermaster ATC-710
      The guts of that one are the same as the Antec/Chieftec towers BTW... complete with (metal) clip-in drivebays for 3.5" devices and rails for the 5.25" bays.

  20. Not really new by core+plexus · · Score: 2
    Disclaimer: This is not a troll

    That said, it really just a variation of the same thing. I bought some nice, tall server towers, in black, for next to nothing at an auction, threw in all new gear, from power supply to extra fans, and everything in between. Total cost (because I installed Linux)- $500 each. I'll bet my rack of black boxes are more impressive than a pimp-puter with lights. Also, I don't give a rats ass what other people think about my setup. I have to admin it, and use it. An extra hole in the side and some lights do not improve my efficiency. Sure, I'd prefer a direct neural interlink, and a secondary interface like Romy (the AI on Andromeda), and a bioprocessor, and and...

    C'mon, people, lets see something like the pumkin 'puter, only smarter. I've got a project I'm working on, and no, it doesn't use wood. All these smart minds, and all we get are case mods. I want to see case RADS!

    "As of Monday, you will fear me,"

  21. For some reason people seem to be. . . by kfg · · Score: 5, Informative

    getting confused by the way the article has been posted.

    Please note that there are *two* cases linked to, one of which is a standard tower, and *one* of which is an AV style case.

    Please read the article carefully and follow both links if you expect your comments to make sense.

    KFG

  22. Another Slashdot OO by satsuke · · Score: 2

    This appears to be an attempt on slashdot to go directly to "OOO SHINY!" rather than something leading up to it, usually Homer related.

    (And a good link as I'm looking for a new case now anyway now that I have a kid to pass it down to)

  23. the a/v case by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    if anyone wants to get all touchy-feely with one, i've seen them at best buys and comp usas

    1. Re:the a/v case by Cyno01 · · Score: 1

      Your best buy has cases? Where do you live?

      --
      "Sic Semper Tyrannosaurus Rex."
    2. Re:the a/v case by _N0EL · · Score: 1

      Yep, I was at a CompUSA last weekend (downtown Chicago) and they had all kinds of cases there at the entrance. Like you said, good opportunity to see them up close.

      --

      "My mother works for Microsoft now. A whole other cult."

    3. Re:the a/v case by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      tempe, az

      bestbuys are in chandler, snobsdale, and mesa tho

  24. text if slashed so you can read before replying by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Please don't waste mod points on this


    Cooler Master ATC-201A SX2: Cooler Master, pioneer of the aluminum cases, overhauled one of their most popular models, and released something enthusiasts should consider when shopping for a new case.


    Date: January 6, 2003
    Catagory: Cases & Cooling
    Manufacturer: Cooler Master
    Written By: Hubert Wong
    Cooler Master ATC-201A Introduction External Features Internal Features Cooling Performance and Conclusion

    There was a time when many enthusiasts were content with buying a beige box. Overtime, mostly due to the popularity of LAN parties, enthusiasts would begin to customize their rig. In some cases, these modifications were functional, but in most cases, it was for aesthetic reasons. Everyone wants to stand out, and be it a fancy paint job, or a cool cutout in the side panel, everyone fought to be Waldo (read: standout in a sea of normality).

    Case manufacturers see this as a cash cow though, and today, more and more companies are springing up, offering their cases to compete for your wallet. These companies offer pre-modded cases, either with windows, or with blowholes.

    Getting further into this, aluminum cases were another market. Other than the physical benefits, they were sought after because they simply looked cool. Aluminum cases are becoming a dime a dozen these days. Once upon a time (read: 18 to 24 months ago), there were only a couple manufacturers, but now there are dozens. These cases can also be bought pre-modded, and even companies such as Lian-Li give their cases a little extra to catch the buyer's eye.

    It should seem fitting then, that the pioneer of aluminum cases, Cooler Master, went back to the drawing board, and improved upon one of their most popular models, the ATC-201, and end result is the ATC-201A-SX2. Make no mistake though, as they didn't just add an air duct and call it a day. There were some overhauls done, and this is one case you're going to want to check out.

    Specifications

    Material: All Aluminum Alloys


    Drive Bay: 5.25' Bays (exposed) x 4
    3.5' Bays (exposed) x 2
    3.5' Bays (hidden) x 4
    Slot Bracket: 7

    M/B Type: Standard ATX MB

    I/O Bracket: Standard ATX

    Power Supply: None

    Cooling: Dual 80mm x 80mm x 25 mm Fan attached front panel. -- Air flow in --
    One 80mm x 80mm x 25 mm Fan attached back panel.--Air flow out --
    One 80mm x 80mm x 25 mmFan attached top panel. --Air flow out --

    Weight: Case : 5Kg (12 lbs)

    Dimension: 497 mm x 196 mm x 452 mm

    The Cooler Master ATC-201A-SX2 ships in a fairly average sized box, just a little larger than the case itself. Everything is neatly packed, and there's enough folded cardboard and packing foam to keep things secure during shipping.

    There isn't much in the way of instructions, except for a small leaflet on installing a redundant PSU. I suppose anyone who purchases an aftermarket case; i.e., you build a PC yourself, won't miss the instructions too much. There are plenty of screws provided, though sadly, no extra thumbscrews, which we'll get into a little later.

    External Features


    As with most aluminum cases, the ATC-201A is light. At a mere 12lbs (case alone), you should have no problem lugging the rig from place to place. Like most of the aluminum cases on the market, you're on your own when it comes to the power supply. In most cases (no pun intended), stock power supplies aren't of the best quality, and I'll bet most of you have an aftermarket PSU anyways.


    There are 4 external 5.25" drive bays, and 2 external 3.5" drive bays. This should be enough expansion room for most users, as being a mid sized case, you do sacrifice the number of drive bays when compared to a full tower.


    Our Cooler Master, and from what I hear, most Cooler Masters, was missing one external 5.25" drive bay faceplate. I suppose the idea behind it is you'll have at least one optical drive to put in there, but for those of you who wish to stealth their CDROM drive, you'll have to resort to painting it instead, or picking up one of Cooler Master's aluminum bezels.

    The ATC-201 has a mesh grill (to allow for airflow for the fans), which will be a hit or miss for some people. Personally, I find it a nice aesthetic (and functional) feature, whereas there are people who prefer an untainted front panel. We will discuss why this vent placement is better than how most cases draw air later on in the review.

    The power button and reset button are nicely recessed on the right side. The power button is a little "squishy" for my tastes, but that's a minor complaint on my part. On the left of the vent are the USB 2.0 ports. Personally, I don't like the idea of USB ports that "show" on the front, so the spring door to cover the ports is nice. I'm not sure if it was our sample or if it'll be a common issue for all of the production 201As, but the spring door doesn't really lock in an open position. A couple of times, it just swung shut, bending the cable to my USB device. No damage was done, but you'll need to take some care with the door.

    Taking a cue from home audio equipment, there's a nice gold trim around the 4 feet on the bottom of the case. I do question the colour choice though, as being a silver case, a silver trim would be a better colour match for the rest of the case. The feet are fairly spongy, and do a pretty good job at keeping the case from slipping around.

    As with past Cooler Master cases, both side panels are removable. There are three thumbscrews on each side panel, and each panel has a small grip on the back to pull them off. The side panel on the left side has a pre-cut blow hole, which is referred to as the "Air Guide". The case is available without the Air Guide, but as our tests have shown, it works prety good. We'll talk more about this in the cooling features.

    One nice feature is the painted side panels (as well as the top panel). The paint is of car paint quality, though under a special garage light, we did notice a sort of "dusting" over the surface. This is unnoticable under normal light though, so I doubt anyone will bother wet-sanding it any further. As you can see above, the paint is very reflective, and will certainly impress people (who are into these things at least). At this moment, only metalic silver (4 coats) is available, but you can expect a high gloss black (6 coats), as well as an aluminum colour in the near future.

    Internal Features

    The interior is fairly spacious, and actually does not have the "crammed" feel I got when I was working with our Lian-Li PC65U. The hard drives and optical drives are held in place by screws. I would have personally preferred drive rails, but the screws do the job. The aluminum edges have been sanded down, to prevent scraping yourself, but there is still of an edge to them. I still managed to scuff myself a couple times, so don't just go charging in there when you're setting up your rig.

    Although I did not have any problem installing most of our components, we did stumble on an issue with the Vantec Nexus Fan Controller.

    Due to the fact that the screws on the Nexus are not flush with the unit, it simply will not fit. I ended up scratching up the inside drive bay pretty badly in the end. I'll probably will have to grind the crews off and do some soldering in the end.

    Although the interior is roomy, the inclusion of a pull out mobo tray can be a life saver. The tray should accomadate most ATX motherboards, and one nice thing I like about it is the use of traditional motherboard, screw-on standoffs. Earlier Cooler Masters, as well as Lian-Li, used clip-on standoffs. Although they look nice, a problem that arose was that they bent very easily, rendering them useless. Considering the amount of times that enthusiasts change mobos, this can be a problem if you've run out of these clip on standoffs.

    Another well thought out idea is the mobo tray support. A lot of motherboard trays are simply "L" shaped (tray and back panel), and if you pull it out with a large heatsink and motherboard installed, the weight will flex the mobo tray. This problem in particular is the case with our Lian-Li, though nothing has broken yet. Although the support bracket was always present with past Cooler Masters, as well as other cases, the bracket here is a lot stronger than those you'll normally find.

    Thumbscrews are present throughout the case, including those to secure the PCI cards. A nice touch, and once you've gotten used to thumbscrews, you can never go back to using Phillips screws to secure your peripherals.

    The wiring required to plug into the motherboard run from the right side of the case. The only reason I'm mentioning it is because if you're picky about aesthetics, you'll know that case wiring is something you'll want to keep out of the way as much as possible. The wires here are somewhat hidden behind the 3.5" bays, saving you some of the work in trying to hide them.

    A problem with a lot of aluminum cases (again, an issue with Lian-Li, as well as others from reviews I've read) is it can be troublesome installing power supplies that have more than one fan. Enermax immediately comes to mind, as their secondary fan grill is not flush with the PSU, as well as those PSUs with front mounted fans. In these cases, some modifications to the PSU, or removal of a fan grill during installation is required. Not so with the ATC-201A, as our enermax slipped right in without any problems.

    Cooling

    That's some fancy equipment they got there.

    Cooler Master originally got their recognition from their heatsinks, so it's natural that the R&D into heat dissapation carried over into their case design. The ATC in its name stands for Active Thermal Convective System. The name is exactly as it implies... the case acts as a giant heatsink. This theory comes from, in part, that the case is made of aluminum, which as we all (should) know, is decent at dissapating heat. The Active Thermal Convective System however, is a bit different, as it represents the design in the case's airflow, air pressure, air resistance, and ventilation. By default, the ATC-201A-SX1 comes with four 80mm fans, as well as the Air Guide, which is a 10cm hole and duct.


    Fan #1 is located in the top of the case. The fan is configured to exhaust air from the top, which in theory, should work pretty well. As hot air rises, the fan will accelerate the air flow out the top. Previously, Cooler Master cut into the top of the case to create the vents for the fan, but now there is a mesh screen, which should allow for more airflow out of the case. Like the front screen we'll be talking bout, there is a foam filter between the fan and screen. I have not figured out a way to remove it yet, so cleaning will be a bit of a chore.

    By removing the front mesh screen, we can see the filter Cooler Master has installed into it. Although it is removable, Cooler Master didn't exactly make it easy for us to clean. To get to the screen, you'll have to remove the front bezel, which is secured by six hex screws. The screen then requires the removal of four small Phillips screws, which will almost certainly drop unless you use a magnetic tipped screwdriver. The screen secures the filter itself by folding portions of it into the filter. An air gun is all that's needed to clean out dust particles, but I wish there was an easier method of removal.

    Fans #2 and #3, which are the two front fans, are configured as intake fans. Not only do they serve as intake fans, they also serve as hard drive coolers as well. Although the air will now be somewhat "warmed-up" by passing through the hard drives, I don't think it will affect temperatures all that much.

    The last fan, #4, is located in the back, next to where the CPU would be. This fan serves as an exhaust fan. Liek the changes to the top panel, you'll see that Cooler Master no longer uses ventilation holes stamped out of the metal, but rather, they use a traditional fan grill which will allow more air to pass through the back.

    An optional feature, the Air Guide is the most significant change in the ATC-201. Ducts are nothing new, but for those who don't know, the idea behind them is they assist in isolating the air around the CPU and to help keep the heat away from the rest of the PC. Dell has been using ducts for years, though they do it much differently. Unlike Dell, there is no fan built into the duct (they don't use fans on their CPU heatsinks).

    On the ATC-201A-SX2, there is another mesh screen built into the side (otherside is the Air Guide duct), with a nice acylic decoration around it. We'll see later on if the duct affects temperatures at all.

    By adding a PSU, you should have a minimum of 5 fans (perhaps 6 or even 7 depending on the PSU), where 3 fans exhaust air, and 2 are intake. In terms of noise, there is quite a bit of it, though a high speed CPU fan, such as a Delta, will still overpower the noise generated by the case fans.

    Cooling Performance

    Other than the aesthetics, an important aspect when shopping for a case, is the cooling performance. Contrary to popular belief, having a large tower with 10 fans blowing in every direction is not necessarily going to mean it's going to keep your components cool.

    Test Bed

    AMD Athlon 1700+ w/Swiftech MCX462+
    MSI KT3 Ultra2
    2 x 256MB Crucial PC2700
    2 x 80GB Maxtor 7200RPM
    PNY Verto GeForce 4 Ti4600
    Plextor 24/10/40 CDRW
    AOpen 1640 DVD
    Enermax 430W

    Comparison cases will be a Lian-Li PC65U, which is also a mid tower aluminum case, as well as a full tower, steel construction AOpen HX-08. All three cases are configured with their stock cooling for the initial tests. The second group of tests will be with all three cases with all their fans off (except on the power supply).

    I should note that for the first two tests, we have removed the Air Guide from the ATC-201A, and taped the side screen shut. The last test will be with the Air Guide enabled. Temperatures were read with the Vantec Multifunction Panel (which fit just fine btw), except for the CPU and system temperatures, which were gathered from MBM. Temperatures will be presented in Celcius, but you can grab a Celcius to Fahrenheit converter here. Temperature readings are taken at full load, with Prime95 and Folding@Home enabled.

    Both the Cooler Master and Lian-Li are the top performers of the three. Between the three, the AOpen seemed to be the noisiest, as I would guess that the larger case echo'd a little more. Hard drive cooling was led by the ATC-201A, as well as the video card and system cooling tests.

    Although the Lian-Li also has dual intake fans blowing directly over the hard drives, the way the hard drives were arranged (sideways), it was a tighter fit than the dual drives in the Cooler Master. Furthermore, there's a bit more obstruction on the Lian-Li, as the air filter is thicker, and the front vents are not as free flowing as the screen mesh on the ATC-201A.

    System cooling temperatures were drastically lower with the Cooler Master. This can probably be attributed to the top blowhole wicking away the rising hot air. To equalize the playing field, we'll no conduct tests with all the fans off (except on the power supply). All ventilation holes on all three cases will now be cardboarded, and taped off.

    By turning off the fans (and taping shut any ventilation, save for the power supply), we can get a better idea of how well each case handles heat. The AOpen does the worst, but not really as bad as I thought it would do. It's possible that being such a huge tower, there's just more air volume to heat up. The Lian-Li fairs much better, but like I said earlier, the interior is a bit more cramped when you load it up. The CDROM drives are very close to the PSU, and being a shorter case than the Cooler Master, wiring becomes more of an issue. The Cooler Master does the best, keeping temperatures just a bit lower than the Lian-Li. Now, let's see how things are when we enable the Air Guide.


    Testing the Cooler Master with the Air Guide enabled netted some interesting results. System temperatures actually increased slightly, but CPU temperatures did lower by a small margin. What is probably happening that the CPU fan is configured to draw air into the heatsink. The Air Guide is channeling cooler outside air into the heatsink. The reason we're not seeing a more drastic drop in temperatures though is because the Air Guide does not reach the motherboard, thus not cutting the heatsink off completely from the rest of the components. The increase in system temperatures is probably the result of the Air Guide obstructing some of the air flow to the rear vent, though I think this rise in temperature is worth the drop in CPU heat.

    I should note that these temperatures for the CPU were obtained by running our Smart Fan 2 at full speed. When we ran the fan at low speed, CPU temperatures were the same, regardless if the Air Guide was used or not. What is probably happening is that at low speed, the fan simply isn't drawing air in fast enough to matter if the air was being channeled or not.

    Installation Notes

    I have already mentioned the Vantec Fan Controller issues, but other than that, all our hard drives and optical drives had no problems. Our KT3 Ultra2 had no problems fitting, nor did the Air Guide "miss" our CPU/HSF. The problem with the Air Guide compatibility is if you use a dual CPU setup, a Slot-1 or A motherboard, or an ATX motherboard with an oddly placed CPU socket. For the most part, the majority of ATX motherboards should have no problems. One other heatsink that comes to mind as possibly having problems with the Air Guide is the Zalman CNPS3100-Plus, as the cooling fan may not allow for the Air Guide to fit.

    Final Words

    Cooler Master has taken everything that was good about their ATC-201, and carried it over into the the ATC-201A-SX2. This includes the sharp aesthetics, the thumbscrews, the removable motherboard tray, the slick paint job, and its ATC technology. What has been improved with the latest version is the stronger construction overall (thanks to thicker aluminum, though I wouldn't use the case as an ottoman), the Air Guide, and dropping the older ventilation cutouts with either grills or mesh screens instead.

    Complaints are minor, but there are a few things that did bother me. The foam filters used in the top and front ventilation screens are problematic to clean, as they don't lend themselves to easy de-installation. The USB door, though a nice touch, does not lock into place, possibly slamming shut if you're using it. I am not going to penalize the trouble with the Vantec Nexus Fan Controller woes, but be aware that peripherals with outside screws not flush with the unit will have problems installing. The edges in the interior could have been folded, or covered with some protective plastic to protect your hands would have been nice as well.

    I will flat out say that the Active Thermal Convective System does indeed work here, as our overall temperatures are in fact lower than they have been before. Whether fans are off or on, the case itself does wick away heat, though I would not quite go as far as turning off fans on your heatsinks. Our tests have shown, though not dramatically, that the Air Guide does indeed lower CPU temperatures slightly. I also find the side cutout a nice aesthetic feature, though you're free to remove the Air Guide and place an additional side fan in its place. All this cooling also does not come at the expense of your ears, as the stock fans, though noticable, are not deafening. Anyone used to 3-4 case fans probably won't notice a thing.

    You do pay a fair penny for a quality case, but it is cheaper than past models, and you get exactly what you pay for. I have seen nice aluminum cases, and I have seen ugly ones, but Cooler Master cases always catch my eye whenever they are on display. No doubt, it'll draw a remark or two if it's sitting on your desk.

    Pros: Beautiful, cool, removable motherboard tray, thumbscrews, quality construction and Air Guide.

    Cons: USB Door needs work, cleaning the air filters inconvenient, expensive (but worth it).

    Bottom line: Make no mistake... $178.00 is a lot to spend on something that sits under your desk, but a case like this deserves to sit on top of it. It's roomy, and acts like a heatsink for those $3000 PC parts inside. In terms of quality and R&D, it's pretty tough to top Cooler Master.

  25. Do you mind!?!?! by espresso_now · · Score: 3, Funny

    I'm trying to read the article and all you Slashdoters are making the web-site unresponsive. Could you please wait for me to finish? I was there first after all.

    --
    Of course, and I highly suspect it, I may be talking out of my ass. -oqti
    1. Re:Do you mind!?!?! by VampireByte · · Score: 1

      text is available under the first post if you want to read it.

      --

      Run and catch, run and catch, the lamb is caught in the blackberry patch.

  26. Here is a much nicer home theater case by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Click on the "See it" links for the silver and black
    versions. This case is also under the "DIGN" brand name.

    http://www.newegg.com/app/viewproduct.asp?DEPA=& su bmit=Go&description=d%2Dvine

  27. Coolermaster vs. HTML by Animats · · Score: 2

    Somebody tell CoolerMaster that "charset=big5" is for Japanese kana.

  28. Slashdot by Denver_80203 · · Score: 1

    Really is it so slow that now you are posting case reviews? BFD. I can go to a million sites for that.

  29. Welcome to the ... by SuperDuG · · Score: 2
    ... MUST HAVE TO BE COOL ON SLASHDOT ...

    Geeks throughout the world, in order to be loved and accepted by your fellow slashdot peers you MUST buy the following product.

    Businesses, please follow these simple steps.

    1.) Make something that involves a computer (nearly anything will do)

    2.) In your pitch make sure you include words that aren't usually associated with the target crowd:"Must Have", "Sleek", "Sexy", "Expensive", and of course "HandSized".

    3.) After that setup a sham of a fake website that looks like it's ran by an independent source, then give yourself great reviews.

    4.) Submit the story to slashdot.org and make it look like the product is obviously well known by menioning "older" and "outdated" products that every geek who is a geek SHOULD already know about, even though more tha 99% of the readers will have no idea what your company is even about.

    5.) When the story is published on slashdot, immediately take down the sham site and proceed to the article in question. Provide a personal insight as to how wonderful you think the company is, along with a shitty cut and paste job of the text from the page (make sure you paste text from frames close to each other to make it nearly impossible follow. (do this as what they call an "Anoynmous Coward"

    6.) Have someone with a "ScreenName" on the website submit a personal encounter with the company and how wonderful they were to them.

    7.) And then have someone mention how horrible it is that slashdot would waste a companies bandwidth like this thus making the consumers think they are helping you out by purchasing your product.

    8.) Cut a check to OSDN for 10% of the profit.

    9.) Repeat in 6 months with new product.

    --
    Ignore the "p2p is theft" trolls, they're just uninformed
  30. Re:I got a digital camera for Christmas I'll start by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You are an idiot. Viperlair posts some very interesting reviews and the writing is excellent, I can deal with just OK pics.

  31. Instead of this case... by Judg3 · · Score: 3, Informative

    Why not build a PC into your stereo? That's exactly the route I'm taking. A Mini-ITX motherboard for 100-200$ (Builtin everything), an old stereo to test it on from the Goodwill, a few other pieces and you have an all in one multi-media box.
    In fact, Im setting it up with a wireless NIC and will be able to use my IPAQ to control BrowseAMP to change mp3s anywhere in the house.
    Add to that an IR controller and the IR stuff for Winamp and it's an all-in-one solution for a lot less then one of these.

    Now, granted, it's not going to handle everything you throw at it, it's only an 800 to 933Mhz Via CPU, but it's all I need.
    They had a similar case like this on The Screensavers 2 days ago, and the case alone is 200$.
    Thats the price for everything in my setup, including the stereo.
    It's nothing special, as it's a test to see if ti works, but hell, I got the idea here at slashdot from another poster.

    --
    Looking for hardware (Currently need: Large Etch-a-Sketch) Have one? See my journal!
  32. Re:Hardware Ist Krieg by VampireByte · · Score: 1

    Why flamebait, there's a point here about the way things are on Slashdot lately? The worst one lately was this one two days ago. What nerd these days has over six grand to waste on something like that (really, since when is being a "nerd" equivalent to someone blowing money on overpriced eye candy)? Isn't a nerd someone who has a 1.3GHz CPU running in an old 286 machine or something like that?

    --

    Run and catch, run and catch, the lamb is caught in the blackberry patch.

  33. 5.25" bays... by jeffy210 · · Score: 2

    What I would like to see is a case like that with the 5.25" bay in the back, so I could mount the I/O bay back there and have most the A/V cables coming out the back like a real component solution. Other wise, things will look a little weird having everything running out the front.

    --
    ------
    "And may your days be long upon the earth."
    1. Re:5.25" bays... by slriv · · Score: 1

      What are you talking about???

      The 600 is basically a regular micro-ATX computer case with a custom fascia and kind of funky drive mounts. I love this case, by the way...

      atc600

      The only complaint I have with it are the fans... Too damn loud! Of course I have a 10K RPM scsi drive in the mix so that doesn't help either. Upgrading the fans to panaflo's or something similar, throwing in maybe that cool looking vantec Nexus controller:

      Vantec fan controller

      Get some fast EIDE 8MB quiet drives, and your system would almost be ready for the AV rack.

      --
      All the worlds a stage, and I'm the guy running the lights...
    2. Re:5.25" bays... by jeffy210 · · Score: 1

      I was refering to the 610. I would have liked to have seem them put a 5.25" bay on the back side of it (rather than in the front behind the panel), so I could mount something like a Live!Drive and run all the cables to it from the back, just like the rest of my components (DVD, VCR, etc.).

      --
      ------
      "And may your days be long upon the earth."
    3. Re:5.25" bays... by Sloppy · · Score: 1
      I don't understand. Why would you use a LiveDrive-like thingie in the back, instead of just using the usual motherboard and card connectors that are already back there? Isn't the whole point of LiveDrive-like panels, to have attractive front connectors in view? 4

      It seems to me that if you're going to have connectors in back, out of view, that you wouldn't have any desire for a LiveDrive.

      --
      As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
    4. Re:5.25" bays... by jeffy210 · · Score: 1

      The LiveDrive and such offers connectors that are not usually available on the back of a PCI card. Take for example the Toslink optical I/O. I haven't seen a PCI card that has an optical out on the card itself. By mounting a LiveDrive in the back, I could run an optical out for all my audio without it running through the front. Now if there were sound cards that have daughter cards for the connectors or have the connectors themselves on the PCI card then i'd be all for that. I just don't know of any.

      --
      ------
      "And may your days be long upon the earth."
    5. Re:5.25" bays... by Sloppy · · Score: 1

      Ah, I suspected I was "not getting" something. Thanks.

      --
      As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
  34. Re:Duh by Bastian · · Score: 2

    Incase anyone wasn't paying attention back when Slashdot decided to add subscription service, one of the things Slashdot is now doing is allowing advertisers to write advertisements disguised as articles and put them up with the rest of the articles.

    Either start paying the subscription fee or quit whining.

  35. Re:I got a digital camera for Christmas I'll start by packeteer · · Score: 2

    The pics arent the worst part. My main problems are with the methods used to test in most review sites. Remember the scientific method you learned back in school, thats what these people need to learn again. I dont know how much i can trust these numbers without a reliable method. Sure im glad at least i have SOME idea about performance of parts but there are many things to look into.

    There are a few things that bugged me the most on this site. For starters the graphs suck. The graphs need a label at the top so you know what they are measuring. You should be able to tell whether or not your looking at the "taped off vents" graph or the "all fans on" graph withoutm trying to guess which paragraph it is above so therefore it is... this one. Also on the graphs the X and Y axis' need to be labled. The X axis isn't so bad as its fairly easy to tell what they mean but for the Y? Come on its a few clicks in an spreadsheet program. When i see the results i see something like "46,45,45"... 45 what? seconds before it overheats? I will assume it means degrees celcius but is it above zero or above ambient room temp?

    Also the numbers are taken a bit too seriously. There are many places where errors could have skewed data but none of these are pointed out. The data for the "w/Air Guide" is a little odd. The reviewer goes on about 1 degree differances and tries to guess about why they might be there when im sure if a margin of error was obtained it would explain a little bit of change in data between tests.

    Also for numbers to be considered valid in a real controlled experiment you need to have at least 3 trials at minimum so you can get an average. I appreciate that someone out there is willing to spend time on this but if your going to do it at all why not spend a bit mroe tmie and do it right?

    --
    unzip; strip; touch; finger; mount; fsck; more; yes; unmount; sleep
  36. Re:the a/v case -- saw in CompUSA, too by timothy · · Score: 1

    I saw the A/V Cooler Master case at the CompUSA at Snowden Square in Columbia MD yesterday morning.

    One of those little shuttle cases is more appealing to me, though ... more transportable, for one thing. But I can see the fetish appeal of black, same-width stereo gear ;)

    timothy

    --
    jrnl: http://tinyurl.com/c2l8yr / foes: http://tinyurl.com/ckjno5
  37. Re:Duh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Happen to look at the date on that article wehn that was posted? That would be april 1st, also known as april fools day. Maybe you should do a better job of checking your facts

  38. Re:Duh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Then how do YOU explain the rise of the slashvertisements over the years? It certainly wasn't this bad 2 years ago. I think someone at VA Research^WLinux^WSoftware put CmdrTaco's balls to the grindstone and told him to get some fucking revenue going or his servers are going to be out on the street.

  39. A better choice: Lian Li by lma · · Score: 0
    That's twice in the past week Slashdot has posted reviews of sub-par choices in PC Hardware.

    I much prefer Lian Li cases. I have their PC-60USB and PC-62USB models. They have all the attributes expected of high-end cases: machined or rounded edges everywhere, thumbscrews, excellent airflow, lots of drive bays, etc. But they have nice touches like filters on the intake fans that can be easily removed for cleaning by unsnapping the front bezel. are a pleasure to work on. The dual front fans have a speed control, adjustable from the chassis front, that lets you set their speed to keep noise down. Combine that with noise limiting fans on the front and top exhaust ports, and you can make a nearly silent machine. The front also has 4 USB port connections behind a door that hinges back into the chassis when open. Its nice touches like that that make a big difference.

    Finally, in spite of having more space (3 external, 5 internal 3.5" bays vs. the 2 and 4 of the CoolerMaster), it fits all this into a total package about the same size. So check out Lian Li if you are in the market for an aluminum chassis.

  40. most annoying expression in the world by Clover_Kicker · · Score: 2

    Using a tired cliche like "make no mistake" - that's a paddlin'.

    Using a tired cliche like "make no mistake" twice in the same article - it's time to smash the author's keyboard, and maybe cut off his fingers, just to be sure.

  41. Who needs a case with "High Edges"? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I hope they're at least sanded or have trim covers to prevent cuts. Ouch!

  42. It's amazing by Zuperdominican · · Score: 3, Funny

    I have a 700 MHz celeron and when people look at the case they just shut up and think that this can blow theirs away. Even though their computers may be more powerful than mines.

    1. Re:It's amazing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have a Geo Metro, but when people look at the 4' tall spoiler on the back, the ground effects, and the 17" wheels that cost more than the car itself, people just shut up and think that this thing can blow theirs away, even though their cars (almost certianly) have more powerful engines.

  43. Other options by Daniel+Rutter · · Score: 2
    My chance to pile on, with links to my own recent fancy case reviews:

    AOpen H500W and A340, Chyang Fun CF-2029B, and FastWin FW-168A

    Codegen ATX-6061 and ATX-6063 (they look expensive, but they aren't)

    Lian Li PC-6087, PC-6089 and PC-6099 (Lian Li's versions of Cooler Master's swing-front boxes)

  44. more expensive, but worth it by asv108 · · Score: 2

    I've had an ATC 101 for over a year now. Coolermaster cases are very expensive, but the quality and performance is unbeatable. My ATC 101 runs at 30C with 100% CPU utilization sustained in a 78 degree room. No crazy mod either, just a standard ATC 101 case, with a standard coolermaster heatsink, and 2 superdrive coolers in the front. Here is a screenshot.

  45. Actually I think it looks a bit boring... by WolfWithoutAClause · · Score: 2
    Ok, call me picky, but I think they should anodise these cases black:

    a) it looks cooler

    b) black is a better thermal emitter so the case will actually be cooler!

    Also, I'm wondering whether a really nice case would use perspex instead of aluminum. I mean sure, aluminum is nice and light, but perspex is even lighter, and you can double wall it, and fill it with water from water cooling. The only problem with perspex is that it gives no electromagnetic shielding, but thin aluminum or copper mesh underneath would, done correctly, look cool, be transparent, and provide every bit as good protection. (Hint, ever wondered why they use mesh on the door of a microwave oven?)

    Plus you could keep fish in it ;-)

    --

    -WolfWithoutAClause

    "Gravity is only a theory, not a fact!"
    1. Re:Actually I think it looks a bit boring... by JohnFluxx · · Score: 2

      Hate to be dumb, and I don't quite remember the wavelength of the particular wavelengths that cause the electromagnetic interference, but given that visible light is under 1000nm = thousandth of a milimeter it would require a very thin mesh to block visible light. This is of course just for visible light, but are the frequencies that need sheilding too far off?

    2. Re:Actually I think it looks a bit boring... by WolfWithoutAClause · · Score: 2
      Yeah, the frequencies responsible for EM issues chiefly have wavelengths around 1cm or more.

      Visible light is, as you note, around 1000nm or so. Note the difference between nm (0.000,000,001m) and cm (0.01m)...

      Try googling first next time.

      --

      -WolfWithoutAClause

      "Gravity is only a theory, not a fact!"
  46. How pointless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What kind of crackhead would pay $178 for a computer case? What's the point of paying twice as much for a product that isn't any better than the standard fare? I think the hardware industry is being taken over by ricer mechanics.

  47. Everybody go to FATWALLET.COM by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    they have tons of people who find deals on electronics and post them to a forum. I got a 120GB HD for my XBOX for $100!

    Link for the lazy: www.fatwallet.com
    Link for the lazy: www.fatwallet.com
    Link for the lazy: www.fatwallet.com
    Link for the lazy: www.fatwallet.com
    Link for the lazy: www.fatwallet.com

  48. what the hell? by Anti_zeitgeist · · Score: 0

    News for nerds.....stuff that MATTERS!~! Keep this out of here.

    --
    If it wasn't for C, we would be stuck using BASI, PASAL and OBOL.
  49. Better article on Intel's site by itwerx · · Score: 1

    The article linked to above links in turn to a much better page on Intel's site. It's practically a howto on using this case to build a kick-ass (and quiet) multimedia pc for the living room.

  50. Enough with the case mods already! by Logopop · · Score: 1

    ...

  51. Last Post! by alpg · · Score: 0

    I was part of that strange race of people aptly described as spending
    their lives doing things they detest to make money they don't want to
    buy things they don't need to impress people they dislike.
    -- Emile Henry Gauvreay

    - this post brought to you by the Automated Last Post Generator...