Slashdot Mirror


MPlayer Licence Trouble With A Twist

protonman writes "A hefty flame war has broken loose on the debian-devel mailinglist about (amongst other things) the legality of mplayer. The interesting part in this conflict is that unlike in previous alledged GPL violations, the culprit is not the unwillingness to provide the source, but the prohibition of the distribution of binaries, thereby violating section 6 of the GPL: 'You may not impose any further restrictions on the recipients' exercise of the rights granted herein.' Read also the blurb on the MPlayer homepage."

11 of 455 comments (clear)

  1. 3rd post! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    This is the thr0d ps1t!

    Share and enjoy!

  2. Re:The simple fact.. by grasshoppers · · Score: -1, Troll

    most people are perfectly content ignoring license issues, as long as the software does what they want it to do. Most people don't care about licensing. Copying free software, copying closed software, it's all the same.

    Don't you think you've caused enough problems lately, Mr. Gabucino... er... Anonymous Coward?!! First debian-devel, then -legal, now /.?!

    In the name of all that is holy and good, when will the persecution of innocents on dialup stop?!

  3. preview by Joe+the+Lesser · · Score: 1, Troll

    Flame War: The Return of Mplayer
    This movie will star Alan Alda and Bruce Willis as top lawyers. The role of 'mplayer' will be played by Chris Kattan.

    --
    "I only speak the truth"
    Karma: null(Mostly affected by an unassigned variable)
  4. Wow. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    You linux people need to get a clue. I mean my god. I think Linux is a good idea and all, but you guys just don't have a clue about how to get people to switch to linux if you can distribute binaries for the thing.

    You guys need to get your shit together. If you want linux to be sucessful then a binary from a PC has to run on a MAC running linux and vice versa. That means the software has to be written in something like a Java like language. Sure it'll be slower, but that's the only way linux will ever dethrone windows. If anyone could run any executable on any machine that would be a huge benefit.

    So you guys need to come up with some kind of graphical language that will work cross platform.

    I mean jeeze you don't even have binaries which will run on most x86 machines right? I mean wtf?

  5. Re:Question The Legality of George W. Bush by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll


    you stupid fucking hippie liberal tree-licking dog-fucking piece of crap, go back to canada or germany or whatever the fuck country your came from and contrinue to live in peace under the umbrella of free Unister State protection, you left coast cunt. I'd like to smash your nuts with my boot heel and then split your sack open and feed your testicle butter to your dog which you probably don't "own" but you're a "pet gaurdian" you stupid cum spot. The only thing worse than a gay nigger faggot is a gay nigger faggot with a computer and internet connection, we shouldn't have taught you people how to read because now you think you have something to say. Go stick needles in your arm and blame it on your parents or society or global warming but FUCK don't take personal responsability holy shit can't do that! Please suck the soft mushy fecal matter right outta my anus and down your throat, trust me it will taste better than the nuke Sadam is going to drop on your house because you want to give him another and another and another chance, fucking California peice of shit.

  6. Re:The simple fact.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll



    No, you're missing the real point, which is that we have a perfectly good music player - MS Media Player. And it runs on WINDOWS no some piece of shit OS written by a bunch of doped out hippies too busy sucking each other's schlongs than to worry about security. Nothing like letting everyone in the fucking world see what you have "under the hood" to keep them our, cripes just but your passcodes on the 'net.

  7. What a clusterfuck by NineNine · · Score: 0, Troll

    This kind of childish shit is what keeps OSS in the dark ages. Why in the hell would I want to deal with a mess like that just to play some media files? I'd happily pay for Windows just not to have to deal with this childish garbage. My time is worth more than a Windows license or two.

  8. Re:We need Debian by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    ust look at the current SCO issues and be grateful for all Debian do to avoid problems like this.

    Bzzzzzzzzzzt! Wrong! Thanks for playing.

    SCO's alleged patents on the init process are so basic that and Linux distro is on shaky legal ground; SCO has Debian over the same barrel as every other distro. Debian-legal didn't see that coming, and now we know why! They were too busy squabbling over a video player. Tell me again what Debian's lawyers are good for?

  9. Re:The simple fact.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll



    I can relate. I recently slammed my schlong into your mom's poop chute, on the same day 20 other guys did the same thing. She didn't seem to mind having 20 different loads of nad nectar left in her rectum.

  10. Re:The Mplayer team by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    FUCK YOU.

    You dont know one thing about us. FUCK YOU AND YOUR MOTHER AND YOUR SHITTY DOG. YOU STUPID PEOPLE! IF YOU DONT LIKE mplayer then dont fucking cvs update it you cunt geezers.

    Just look at your own pathetic project ziel your stupid gnome goes no where how can you possibly even compare to mplayer you retarded shit eater.

    Next time you want to flame mplayer, come over to my country we know what to do with people like you.

  11. Congratulations! by Fagnuttius · · Score: -1, Troll

    Congratulations! Per your sig, you are now deemed a "faggot!"

    More information can be found at this link.

    Have a good day packing ass, fag.