Slashdot Mirror


UK Parliament Domain Without Registrar

asobala writes "According to this story at The Register, the UK parliament is using the domain www.parliament.uk. It's a top-level domain because it was registered before August 1996, before Nominet handled .uk domains. But since there is no registrar, they can't prove that they own it."

13 of 266 comments (clear)

  1. Interesting Dilema by AndrewM1 · · Score: -1, Troll

    --Begin News Story-- This was copied and pasted from the news story that the article linked to. I take no Credit. The dream of e-government has hit a brick wall because, incredibly, Parliament's Internet domain - www.parliament.uk - doesn't actually exist. The anomaly has come to light after Parliament's Publications and Archive arm attempted to make way for e-purchases. You are able to view recent Parliament reports online for free but if you wish to purchase a printed version of a report or copies of old legislation, you have to send a cheque to Parliament. The publications arm applied for an SSL certificate from leading supplier Thwate to provide a route for secure online transactions. Unfortunately, Thwate has insisted that it be provided with proof that Parliament actually owns parliament.uk. And no one is able to give it. UK domain registrar Nominet runs most .uk domains but not parliament.uk, which was registered before Nominet existed. Equally, UKERNA - which was the precursor to Nominet and still runs the government and academic domains .gov.uk and .ac.uk - confirmed that it didn't look after parliament.uk. In fact, no one runs parliament.uk and it doesn't officially exist. The extensive domain, which contains all official information regarding MPs, the House of Commons, House of Lords, UK legislation and just about everything else about the running of the United Kingdom, lives in the shadowlands of the Internet. The domain itself is one of a very rare breed registered before 1 August 1996, before Nominet existed and when plain .uk addresses were still available. In fact, just 13 .uk Internet domains now officially exist, of which only six are still accessible (libraries and nuclear fusion research labs). Then there are the second-level domain names like .co.uk, .govt.uk. There are 11 of these. Six are run by Nominet, two by UKERNA, nhs.uk by the National Health Service, .police.uk by the police and .mod.uk by the Ministry of Defence. Parliament.uk exists in no man's land. Surely this can be easily sorted out though? Well, no. Nominet has no control over the domain and a court case last year actually decided that there was no contract between Nominet and the registrants of domain names registered by the "Naming Committee" - the loose assortment of tech-heads that existed prior to Nominet. It also has nothing to do with IANA or ICANN - the people behind the global domain names like .com and .org - because the UK domain system is strictly autonomous to it. The .uk names that do still exist don't pay anything for their domains and have permanent control over them. However, they can't transfer them and no one can buy them. Nominet would like them to register with it but it has no powers to make them and if they do, they would have to pay regular renewal fees. Nominet is also about as likely to want to charge Parliament for its domain as it is the MoD or itself for its nic.uk domains. So what can Parliament do about its predicament? It is extremely unlikely that it will want to hand over the running of the domain to anyone else, but then there is no strict way of proving its owns the domain either. A Nominet spokeswoman told us Nominet is "in contact" with Parliament and will confirm to anyone that asks that Parliament owns parliament.uk but has no plans to do anything about the odd situation. Parliament will no doubt take months to get back to our queries and presumably just as long to assure Thawte that it is who it says it is. In the meantime, online sales of government publications are on the back burner. --End News Story-- So... Parliament's website dosen't exist... Interesting. Or just plain weird, depending on how you look at it. I wonder what Parliament is going to do. Register a New domain,maybe? But what about all the people who have the old page bookmarked? Weird. Andrew.

  2. Re:.uk by levik · · Score: 0, Troll
    I always knew they were a bunch of unruly wankers. But now it turns out they're cybersquatters as well!

    Blimey!

    --
    Ñ'
  3. tee hee! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    another slashdotting joke!

    you guys are too funny!

    choke on a cock!

  4. Re:dude by Drummer_Dan · · Score: -1, Troll

    The UK has helped the US ever since the revolutionary war. We might all be nazis if the UK didn't help us.

    --
    -- When all else fails, read the instructions --
  5. Re:Innocent till proven guilty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    Innocent until proven guilty? You do realize that is a foreign idea to most British and other Europeans, don't you?

  6. Re:dude by The+Mgt · · Score: -1, Troll

    Ha, you deluded fool, you are all Nazis.

  7. Re:Innocent till proven guilty by ajuda · · Score: 0, Troll

    An anonymous coward wrote:
    Innocent till proven guilty they cant prove they own it because they dont have to, its up to others to prove they don't own it or are not entitled to it simple

    My understanding is that, in the UK, people are guilty until proven innocent. If that's true, then Margret Thatcher stole the domain england.uk! I demand it back.

  8. Re:.co.uk - GB not UK by cscx · · Score: -1, Troll

    "It's shite being Scottish. We're the lowest of the low. The scum of the fuckin' earth. Most people hate the English. I don't. They're just wankers. We, on the other hand, are colonised by wankers."

    I think that just sums it up

  9. Re:LINUX R0X0RZ!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Kevin has been free for some time, dumb nuts.

  10. Re:no, somebody else owns it. duh. by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 0, Troll

    Um, you might want to go their before you assume that that's a government site.

    --
    "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
  11. Re:Innocent till proven guilty by eht · · Score: 0, Troll

    actually in england, i believe it's guilty until proven innocent

  12. Re:Innocent till proven guilty by ForestGrump · · Score: 0, Troll

    wait, then that means government becomes GOD over the people. its no longer a parliment for the people, but a parliment for itself...and they just tax the people to death. (um..glad to be an american..)

    --
    Is it true that more people vote for the winner of American Idol, than vote for the president? -Ali G.
  13. Re:.uk by jericho4.0 · · Score: 0, Troll
    Haha! Silly troll! You posted a totally inapropriate comment and got modded 'troll'!!Hahahahaha!!! What!? Funny!?I don't think so!!! Someone modded you 'troll', and that's what groupthink says you are. Hahahah! Stupid troll.

    What!? Offtopic!? What do you mean? Ahhhhh!!! Noooooo!!!!!!

    --
    "A language that doesn't affect the way you think about programming, is not worth knowing" - Alan Perlis