Slashdot Mirror


War Hero Thwarted Nazi Heavy Water Production

Freshly Exhumed writes "Its doubtful you know the name of Einar Skinnarland, but his sabotage over several years repeatedly thwarted Nazi plans to exploit Norway's heavy water production capabilities for their atomic bomb research plans. Skinnerland recently passed away in Canada and his daring exploits are recounted here. Details of some of the raids on the production facilities can be found on pafko and Stephen's Study Room. So many 'what if?'s and suspicions have swirled around the Nazi atomic bomb program that this man's efforts seem crystal clear for a change."

8 of 333 comments (clear)

  1. Hitler's anti-semitism did him the most harm by asmithmd1 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Richard Rhodes' The Making of the Atomic Bomb shows clearly and ironically that Hitler drove many Jewish physicists out of Germany in the '30s including Einstein. If he would have let them keep there posts he almost certainly would have had the bomb before the US.

    1. Re:Hitler's anti-semitism did him the most harm by knobmaker · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Sometimes I think there are no more Einar Skinnarlands, at least not in America. On my cynical days, I think that if another Hitler came to power, no one would even attempt to stop him.

      Let's examine the evidence. Since Vietnam, our inconclusive proxy war with World Communism, we haven't exactly made a habit of fighting Good Wars. Take the last Gulf War, for example. We mobilized the troops to throw Saddam out of our Kuwaiti friends' oil fields. Bush Sr. liked to call it a battle for freedom and democracy, somehow failing to mention that Kuwaiti was the personal property of a few aristocratic Arabs and that there was no more democracy in Kuwait than in, say, General Motors. Sure Saddam is a monster, but he's a small-time monster. Mao was a bigtime monster, and his regime is still in power. They have weapons of mass destruction and it's doubtful they'd hesitate to use them if pressed. Why aren't we worried about the "Chinese threat," and their various crimes against humanity?

      Other actions during this time? Panama, Grenada, Haiti? Not serious. There are still thousands of drug-corrupted generals in Central and South America, there's still no democracy in Haiti, and Grenada is a bad joke. And consider Somalia, Bush Sr.'s lovely parting gift to Clinton. There we had a clearcut (if pointless) humanitarian mission, but when we took a few casualties it was Sayonara Somalia.

      Bosnia really wasn't our finest hour. We did bomb the Chinese, something we've never dared to do to them in China.

      What really disturbs me are the true horrors we neglected during the dying days of the Soviet. There were genocides in Uganda and Rwanda, and we didn't do anything. Millions died. It was far worse than anything Saddam has ever done.

      So I don't know. If The Ashcrofts and Poindexters have their way and we end up living in a nation where the trains run on time, will there be any Skinnermans or Schindlers among us? Or are those days, and those kinds of men gone forever?

  2. Hitler, and the bomb by Oriumpor · · Score: 5, Informative

    The japanese decided it was a bad idea to persue the atomic bomb (heavily) because of the shortage of deuterium. The germans and the french had the nice little plant, Norsk Hydro in Norway, to make enough of the stuff to have a burgeoning atomic program, fortunately there was enough sabotage that Hitler didn't get the bomb. Especially since he already had an excellent delivery system.

  3. Re:What matters is not who was going to get the bo by Henry+V+.009 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Maybe it matters a slight amount that the thing was used by a democratic nation to end a dreadful war launched against them rather than by the Nazis to achieve world domination in a war of their own making?

  4. Mentioned in "Between Silk and Cyanide" by Ted+Stoner · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Mr. Skinnarland was mentioned several times in Leo Marks book "Between Silk and Cyanide". One of the many heroes just recently getting their due.

    He trained in England with the SOE, crossing paths with Mr Marks who trained operatives in the use of codes.

    Marks died in the last year or two also.

  5. Makes me proud to be a 'wegian by WegianWarrior · · Score: 5, Informative
    Just a few links on the subject;
    http://www.pafko.com/trips/norway/n10/ - about the sabotage
    http://www.fas.org/nuke/intro/nuke/heavy.htm - about heavy water and it's use
    http://www.lawzone.com/half-nor/haukelid.htm - about Knut Haukelid; another of the heroes from Telemark
    http://www.390th.org/warstories/Rjukan.htm - about how the USAF tried and failed to knock out the heavy water plant

    I know, I gotta learn proper html

    --
    Everything in the world is controlled by a small, evil group to which, unfortunately, no one you know belongs.
  6. Re:Nazi's weren't even building an atomic bomb.... by idontgno · · Score: 5, Informative
    The Nazi's were never building a bomb, they didn't even think it was possible

    Not strictly true. The Nazis had a significant nuclear-weapons research program, using the intellectual powers of such notable physicists as Werner Heisenberg (of "Uncertainty Principle" fame). However, they were convinced that an exploding nuclear bomb was impractical, because Dr. Heisenberg had grossly mis-estimated the critical mass of uranium. Because of this, the most likely form of Nazi nuclear weapon was a subcritcal reactor-bomb which would "detonate" through a mechanism more like the Chornobyl meltdown than a runaway complete fission reaction.

    That said, the commando raids on the various plants supporting this reasearch definitely helped guarantee that Nazi Germany never attained nuclear weapons. We can be fairly grateful for that, I think.

    --
    Welcome to the Panopticon. Used to be a prison, now it's your home.
  7. Re:This is the guy who sank a ferry full of people by lommer · · Score: 5, Informative

    The ferry incident was merely an extension of this first effort. The ferry was carrying parts from the reactor and the remaining supply of heavy water back to germany to be used in further atomic research. He blew it up to stop that, and he was greatly saddened by the fact that there were several norweigans on board at the time.

    As well, Norway wasn't neutral, it was occupied by germany and as such was part of the Nazi war effort.