Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

An X-Client Wrapper for Microsoft Windows?

Posted by Cliff on from the a-worthwhile-thing-that-would-be-hard-to-implement dept.

S asks: "In my opinion, one of X11's most underrated features is the ability to export the display of an [X] application to an X-Server that can be physically separated from the application's host (use a remote display). I have used this countless times to dramatically increase my ability to 'get stuff done' from a distance. Recently I discovered Cygwin's ability to run XFree86 in rootless mode (startx -- -rootless) where there is no main X root window, and imported displays get their own 'native-looking' window on the Microsoft Windows platform. This also has saved me much headache when working from a Windows machine to do Linux-type things. My question is: Is there some way to export the display of Microsoft Windows windows to a remote X-Server? I'm not talking VNC/RFB here, and terminal services (via rdesktop) ALMOST fits the bill, but I don't want a root window. I want to simply export the display of (say... photoshop) to my X workstation. Googling is not an easy task; 'windows' is too much of a generic term to get usable results. What I have found, however, suggests Wine as a buffer between native Windows GUI calls and the X protocol, but offers no actual solution. Does anyone know of software that allows allows Windows to export the display of its windows to an X server (ie, an X-Client wrapper for Windows)?"

3 of 62 comments (clear)

  1. Tightvnc: desktop sharing by jeorgen · · Score: 5, Informative
    If you want to get a window on Linux with one single Windows application in it, the screen sharing application tightvnc has a beta (se bottom of page) where you can e.g. share just one window instead of the whole screen. they've named it partial desktop sharing

    /jeorgen

  2. Not yet possible, but XOpenWin wants to be this by khanyisa · · Score: 5, Informative
    No, there are no real X-Clients for Windows currently - I wrote that message you linked to. Like others have suggested, you can use either VNC or RFB to accomplish similar ends.

    There would be amazing advantages to doing it differently though - for more discussion on this see XOpenWin

    although nothing has yet been accomplished through this project. The key things to do which would make this possible are:

    • separate out the Wine GDI and x11drv dlls (see this message)
    • port these dlls to cygwin
    • persuade windows to use them in place of the normal gdi
    If anyone is really interested in that solution, it will take time and effort, but is definitely possible. Join the mailing lists!
  3. Re:Citrix by scrybe_treo · · Score: 5, Informative

    To expand on this, Citrix Metaframe runs on a windows 2000 Application Terminal Server. This adds a lot of manageability and the ICA protocol. You can access applications in "seemless" mode with the modern unix clients. While it is extremely cool and works very well it's not a solution for a single user but more for a department or enterprise level. This is mostly due to cost. Something like 2000+ dollars for the product, 300+ dollars for each connection licence, and 85 bucks for every pre-windows2000 client. Given the potential benefits it is well worth the price if you can avoid having 2 pc's on each desk.

    Disclamer: I am a CCEA and CCI working for a citrix implementer (http://www.vector.com) but it is a blast!!!

    Disclamer Disclamer: I just typed this whole message on my treo300 and I'm just starting to have an attack of "nintendo thumbs"