Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

KDE & Gnome Usability Engineers Interviewed

Posted by Hemos on from the talking-with-the-men-with-the-plan dept.

Gentu writes "After the recent flamewar between the KDE and Gnome user camps, OSNews brings together the most influencial KDE and Gnome usability engineers to talk about how they will be able to overcome a number of obstacles in order to 'unify' KDE and Gnome in ways that could bring to the Unix desktop an easy to use, integrated and fully interoperated DE to better compete with the commercial alternatives. Waldo from SuSE and Havoc from Red Hat are taking part to the interview, and also Aaron, the head of KDE's usability."

2 of 372 comments (clear)

  1. Integration across the desktop by manyoso · · Score: 5, Interesting

    In general I found myself agreeing with Aaron
    's comments more than the others. The main problem I see with Havoc and Waldo and all the others pushing for more shared technologies across the desktop is the implementation technology. KDE is built from the ground up upon Qt/C++ and this is one of the major reasons for it's considerable success. I see no reason to change this winning strategy.

    Recently, we've been discussing the incorporation of Glib into KDE on the core development list. While I am not against this per se, I wonder whether the GNOME developers will ever allow the use of Qt/C++ in any shared technology. It seems to this day that Qt licensing is still a problem for GNOME. One of the greatest ironies in all of Free Software, IMHO.

    If Havoc and Waldo are serious about integration then this problem will have to be addressed in earnest. I do not want to see KDE come down a level in technology just so that GNOME apps can integrate into KDE. Better to improve the great applications we currently have in KDE then waste so much time focusing on some elusive merging of these two.

    Besides, choice is good and GNOME with KDE offer this. Where we can agree upon specs and closing superficial differences we should and that will help those who choose to use GNOME apps in KDE and vice versa. But please, let's not rearchitect KDE and strip it of Qt.

  2. one API. one look. by CreatorOfSmallTruths · · Score: 5, Interesting

    a unified look and feel to both Gnome and KDE will be great. I would even go further to suggest that someone should write a book in the lines of the M$ book of standards (its a book full of "thats how a window should look like" and "thats how a button should look like" etc.) for the linux environment.
    I know this is sort of a blasphemy, after all - linux is about tweaking, but nevertheless its quite irritating to use middle mouse to paste in one program, ctrl-v in the other and shift-insert in the third , without any way of deciding or even a way to know in advance.
    just my 2 cents...