However, the link to the tarball being a 404 is a dead giveaway:(
My little April Fools rant...
by
mindriot
·
· Score: 1, Interesting
I'd just like to review the 'jokes' so far... call it Flamebait, if you want to, but it just annoys me and I have to say it...
RFC 3514
This one was nice. Obvious, but nice... as usual, the RFC people are doing a good job. Too bad Slashdot ruined it with the first April Fools dupe...
Gentoo on RPM
Well, good idea of the Gentoo people, but waaay too obvious... imho a good AF joke is one you believe to be true for at least a couple of minutes until you've looked at it very closely. But OK, this was only number 2, so it was still nice... now AF story bloat yet.
Whitespace programming language
Hm. As has been pointed out, it's not new... and even more obvious than the previous one (and pretty much boring too). I think then CPAN people know how to really make a good AF joke...
Microsoft + Security
Hey... better at least. Nicely combining a true story with a joke story... though the joke was not very believable either. Also, it's number four already, and we're only half-way through the day...
The Register's story
OK. By itself, not all that bad... but not too overwhelming either. And, on Slashdot, we're now at Number 5 and counting.
The dupe.
OK, increasingly stupid... but then again, maybe the best joke today on Slashdot:)
Enlightenment 1.0
Aawwww, come on. Enough. It hurts. And again, blunt joke. Latency between reading and noting the joke:.01 ms. Including the dupe, we're at seven now... and the day is still not over. I think I'll stop reloading the web site until I'm sure April 1 is over in all time zones...
Can you/. editors pleease try to come up with a single good hoax and dump the rest? That would be nice.
</rant>
Basic Rule for April Fools jokes
by
jd
·
· Score: 2, Interesting
They don't have to be realistic (take the BBC's Spaghetti Harvest prank, which still ranks No. 1 of all pranks, for all its age), but they do need to be convincing enough to hook the victims, and diverting enough that they'll want to stay hooked.
I think geeks need to improve in this department, somewhat. The Spaghetti Harvest was a work of sheer creative brilliance, despite the simplicity of the sketch and the simplicity of the props.
These are the kinds of pranks that work well, and are remembered. So simple, it's "got to be true", without assuming that the audience is as simple as the prank.
I'll give this year's attempts a 3/5 for effort, 4/5 for volume, and 2/5 for the "got to be true" factor. Hey, that's not a bad score, but it does show that this is an area that needs practice.
-- It's a small world and it smells funny; I'd buy another if it wasn't for the money; Take back what I paid (SoM)
However, the link to the tarball being a 404 is a dead giveaway :(
I'd just like to review the 'jokes' so far... call it Flamebait, if you want to, but it just annoys me and I have to say it...
This one was nice. Obvious, but nice... as usual, the RFC people are doing a good job. Too bad Slashdot ruined it with the first April Fools dupe...
Well, good idea of the Gentoo people, but waaay too obvious... imho a good AF joke is one you believe to be true for at least a couple of minutes until you've looked at it very closely. But OK, this was only number 2, so it was still nice... now AF story bloat yet.
Hm. As has been pointed out, it's not new... and even more obvious than the previous one (and pretty much boring too). I think then CPAN people know how to really make a good AF joke...
Hey... better at least. Nicely combining a true story with a joke story... though the joke was not very believable either. Also, it's number four already, and we're only half-way through the day...
OK. By itself, not all that bad... but not too overwhelming either. And, on Slashdot, we're now at Number 5 and counting.
OK, increasingly stupid... but then again, maybe the best joke today on Slashdot
Aawwww, come on. Enough. It hurts. And again, blunt joke. Latency between reading and noting the joke:
For some quality 4-1 jokes, see here (German), the above-mentioned cpan.org, or even the Freshmeat one which isn't so bad. This ain't so bad either. Kuro5hin points to this interesting link.
Can you /. editors pleease try to come up with a single good hoax and dump the rest? That would be nice.
</rant>I think geeks need to improve in this department, somewhat. The Spaghetti Harvest was a work of sheer creative brilliance, despite the simplicity of the sketch and the simplicity of the props.
These are the kinds of pranks that work well, and are remembered. So simple, it's "got to be true", without assuming that the audience is as simple as the prank.
I'll give this year's attempts a 3/5 for effort, 4/5 for volume, and 2/5 for the "got to be true" factor. Hey, that's not a bad score, but it does show that this is an area that needs practice.
It's a small world and it smells funny; I'd buy another if it wasn't for the money; Take back what I paid (SoM)