A Skeptical Look At The Multiverse

sjanich writes "The NY Times has a short, interesting article on multiverse theory. The author, Paul Davies, writes: 'This idea of multiple universes, or multiple realities, has been around in philosophical circles for centuries. The scientific justification for it, however, is new.' It is quite an interesting read. The author is a Physicist and pretty good science writer." Davies is not kind to the multiverse theory.

Comments

The Multiverse FAQ

[Anonymous Coward]

http://www.hedweb.com/everett/everett.htm

How ridiculous,

[rritterson]

Everywhere he says life could not exist in any other universal properties and constants should be modified to state "life as we know it."

quote:
Life would probably be impossible with more (or less) than three dimensions to work with, so our seeing three is then no surprise. Similar arguments apply to other supposedly fixed properties of the cosmos, such as the strengths of the fundamental forces or the masses of the various subatomic particles.

Why exactly is life impossible with more than 3 dimensions? He subscribes to the fundenmental flaw that all science fiction writers subscribe to: all alien life forms breath, walk on legs, and "see" through eyes. Sure, it's hard to change a human actor on a movie screen by too much, but the world of books and pages ought to be able to create something better.

I also agree with the other post that says, paraphrased, if we live in a giant simulation, does that make existance different? If you can't get out of, or control the simulation, what difference does it make? I, for one, am not worried about hyperintelligence alien giants looking at me showered naked, and the like.

Along those same lines, if we can eventually create computer simulations with sentiant beings, why can we not create a universe with different parameters and force life to exist within it?
Lastly, if we can't get out of this universe into another one, what difference does it make? And if we somehow break the barrier and jump universes, the link between them makes them one universe with localized properties doesn't it?