Slashdot Mirror


Second Life Opens Public Beta

thehossman writes "A friend of mine works for Linden Lab, and for the past few months he's been hyping their upcoming product: Second Life. I've just been nodding my head, and ignoring him, but last week he logged in and gave me a mini-tour of the VR world (and some things their alpha-testers have helped create) and I was blown away. Now they've announced their public beta, and if you've got a machine that can handle it, I highly advise you to check it out." This is another of the lifestyle-focused massively multiplayer titles that seem to have very big (venture capital?) budgets backing them - can they succeed?

42 comments

  1. credit card number? by kLaNk · · Score: 4, Insightful

    They require a credit card number to sign up for an open beta? That seems a bit extreme if you ask me. There are other ways of making sure that your users are unique without requiring everybody to trust you with your credit card number!

    1. Re:credit card number? by smoondog · · Score: 1

      I guess we now know what the '???' means:

      1. Develop game website
      2. ????
      3. Profit!

      (gotta say, it looks pretty cool, tho)

      -Sean

    2. Re:credit card number? by Achoi77 · · Score: 1
      There are other ways of making sure that your users are unique without requiring everybody to trust you with your credit card number

      Yeah, stuff like:

      Phone Numbers
      Email Address
      Home Address
      Social Security Number...

      Crap. Can't win

    3. Re:credit card number? by complete+loony · · Score: 1

      When the game goes live they'll probably roll over all free beta accounts automatically, and if you don't cancel your subscriptions within the x day period ... This reminds me of the behaviour of many web sites, "Sign up for a free X day trial"

      --
      09F91102 no, 455FE104 nope, F190A1E8 uh-uh, 7A5F8A09 that's not it, C87294CE no. Ah! 452F6E403CDF10714E41DFAA257D313F.
  2. Credit card?! by christian.lair · · Score: 1

    You need to give them a credit card to apply for the beta?! I had done some reading and thought I'd give it a try. Started filling out the form, when I came to the credit card part....Ctrl+W

    1. Re:Credit card?! by sweetooth · · Score: 1

      I was a little dubious about the first portion. Why do they need my address and phone number for a beta test? I figured that wasn't that big of a deal, they are verifying that I am who I say I am. Then I see the credit card portion and I closed the window. I'm sorry, but I'm not giving anyone my credit card unless they are charging me a predetermined fee that I agree to. I'm certainly not going to give a company my credit card number for a beta test.

    2. Re:Credit card?! by DaPhoenix · · Score: 0

      Same with me man. Same with me. I thought OH Cool! Another beta to try.

      I am in 'There' but I stopped playing once i found out that there was no way to make money in the game and that you had to pay real world $$ to get in game bucks just to buy crap like a tee-shirt...

      And even if you design a tee-shirt yourself, to submit it for resale in game you must pay the developers to put it in the game! I put all the time in making a tee-shirt, modeling it to their specs, and then i have to pay to use it in game! WTF!

      These guys need a better business model.

      --
      -- -=innocent ramblings from the mind of an insomniatic programmer=-
    3. Re:Credit card?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      Heh, I'm a current member of their beta program (you might say), and if you go to the links section, you'll notice links to both the EFF and Slashdot. You might also notice that Linden Lab just announced that Mitch Kapor, one of the founders of the EFF, was named as Chairman of their Board of Directors...

      It really sucks, but there's really no way to do anonymous age verification of users, which is the primary reason for requiring credit card numbers on the beta application. Given the choice between requiring credit card numbers and dealing with COPA(Children's Online Protection Act)... well, you're sort of between a rock and a hard place.

    4. Re:Credit card?! by Visceral+Monkey · · Score: 0

      Ditto, I tried it out for a few days then found out the expect me to spend REAL cash to buy shit or even make my own. A business plan straight out of 1999. Idiots.

      --
      *Fortitudo, aequitas, fidelitas.*
    5. Re:Credit card?! by amaprotu · · Score: 2, Informative

      Dude you be playing the wrong game. SL currently does not deal with real money at all.

      When it does it will be of the flat montly fee to play type thing other 'standard' MMOGs use.

      There is no RL $ -> SL $ thing going on. That's Planet Entropia. Not SL.

      The credit card is for age verification and is not charged or, to my knowledge, kept. They have a very nice privacy policy and from the 4+ months I have been beta testing it they have done very well by it.

    6. Re:Credit card?! by amaprotu · · Score: 3, Informative

      You don't pay RW $$.

      So much misconception. Here is an overview of the economics of SL.

      SL is a virtual world where the real limited resource is server sersources (cpu cycles, memory, bandwith etc.). So they create in game money and tie it to those resources.

      They use the standard US/Canadian/AU $ sign for their money. You want to upload a texture it costs $ ... in game/fake money. Same to upload a sound.

      It also costs money to build stuff - in game/fake money. At no point is it Real World money.

      There is a set pool of money, some things are taxed and that money goes into the pool. Buying land costs money but you can always sell it to get all your money back. 'Rezing primitives' costs money, but you can get it back by deleting them. AND IN BOTH CASES IT IS LINDEN $, SECOND LIFE $, NOT REAL $.

      Real money doesn't enter the equation. The credit card is only for age verification.

      Please take the time to learn what you are talking about before spouting to the world absolute nonsense. Thanks

    7. Re:Credit card?! by sweetooth · · Score: 1

      It's not a matter of who they are or why they are doing it. It is a personal preference. I don't give out my credit card for age verification. I only give out my credit card information when making a purchase.

    8. Re:Credit card?! by Dave2+Wickham · · Score: 1

      He's talking about "There"... and damn you for making me post and lose mod ability for this story, I wanted to mod the parent back up :P.

  3. Trademark infringement in this world? by smoondog · · Score: 1

    Ahh, this world isn't real because they don't yet have trademark infringement. (or at least until MLB sees it) Is it fair use if I own an officially licensed shirt?

    -Sean

  4. Second Life? by orkysoft · · Score: 2, Funny

    Some of us are still busy to get their first life! And what about cats?

    Insensitive clods.

    --

    I suffer from attention surplus disorder.
    1. Re:Second Life? by RevAaron · · Score: 1

      Heh... My being too busy in my first life is the exact reason I didn't sign up to play around with this beta test. ;)

      --

      Working toward a usable PDA environment in the spirit of Newton OS: Dynapad
  5. Second Life... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Second Life, for those with no life. Finally all you slashdorks can get girly friends!!

  6. Looks good... by psyco484 · · Score: 1

    But I'm going to leave it at looking good. I'm not going to trust someone to take my credit card number to make sure I'm a unique person. They have an email address, they have a home address, they have a phone number, why oh why do they need a credit card number? As legit as I'm sure this is, it sure seems a little shady. I guess they probably won't be swimming in beta applications though, maybe that's the real goal.

  7. Second Life, First Girlfriend? Last Job? by Nathan+Ramella · · Score: 4, Interesting
    Why is it nobody has harnessed the MMORPG model to get humans to do something useful. Like parsing, culling data or inputting data to get 'money' in the game.
    If somebody would just come up with the right setup, they could get the 'Matrix' harness developed to use people as the engine for their business model.

    Marketing people could test new music out in Virtual 'Bars' to see what people like, You could capture all the conversations and find out who's drinking coke and who's drinking pepsi..

    And the instant gratification as you talk to someone in a virtual bar and a passer-by auspiciously mentions that the new poster on the wall can be purchased online at the following URL..
    -n

    --
    http://www.remix.net/
    1. Re:Second Life, First Girlfriend? Last Job? by JackMonkey · · Score: 1

      Online games are one of the last sanctuaries where we can socialize and have fun without being bombarded by the corporate advertising machine. I, for one, don't like thinking of myself as a potential score for the ad-peddling media cartels.

      The first time I see a McDonald's sign in this game, I'm bailing and going back to Minesweeper. :-p

  8. Free lifestyle-focused massively multiplayer games by lowtekneq · · Score: 1

    Does anyone know of any "games" in this genre that are open source and free? Imagine having something like this as open as the web, with a scripting (or ofcourse we could all learn cg/openGL/etc, but i don't that would go over to well) languages to let people make objects. I guess I've been reading Snowcrash a bit to much though.

    --
    Carpe meam simiam!
  9. Re:Free lifestyle-focused massively multiplayer ga by RevAaron · · Score: 1

    So you mean like a MUD/MOO, but graphical? Heck, by the looks of it, the actual graphics elements wouldn't even have to be very complex. MUDs and MOOs have been doing what you propose for ages, but without the visual element that seems to important to people, especially Americans.

    --

    Working toward a usable PDA environment in the spirit of Newton OS: Dynapad
  10. Age Verification by amaprotu · · Score: 2, Informative

    The minimum age for this stage of the Alpha/Beta is 18. This is because the measures to keep under age people out of the Mature areas are not yet in place. And thus.... credit card.

    You are not charged, and to my knowledge after signing up your card information is ditched.

  11. Re:Looks good... but CC required? by NetFusion · · Score: 1
    I agree, Such privacy intrusions so early is a real turn off.

    Earth to Second Life.

    Wake up to the real world. You must build trust and confidence in your service with your new users before you can request such sensitve details from them. With zero track record there isn't much to set you apart from the barrage of scam artist websites out there in the users mind.

    First impressions are important part of the user experience. Screw it up and many people will never give you a second look much less life.

  12. Linden _Lab_ by replicate · · Score: 1

    If you're not finding much on "Linden Labs", it's because the company name is "Linden Lab". Yes, even among the beta testers, everyone calls it Linden Labs. Yes, it's a source of much confusion.

    For the record, the company URL is lindenlab.com.

  13. Last Ninja 4 by Per+Wigren · · Score: 1

    Ok, not the same genre of game, but the game I've really been waiting for is The Last Ninja 4! What's really cool about it is that the developers have been very active in Last Ninja fan-forums, asking fans of the classic Last Ninja 1-3 games questions how they should do this or that to keep the wonderful feeling of the old games. It's been in development since 1999 and the current planned releasedate is set to "end of 2003". Their attitude is also "if it doesn't have the same state-of-the-art gameplay and atmosphere (compared to today's games) as The Last Ninja 1 when it was released in 1986, we won't release it."

    --
    My other account has a 3-digit UID.
  14. Grreat Game by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I am a beta tester on SecondLife. I have been using it for quite some time. I don't know about the credit card part, but I think it had to do with many people abusing the ability to get x number of accounts and abuse the system. I for one have not given them any credit card information, but I am playing. I would seriously consider giving this try if you are skeptical of its 'clone-ness' to other games. I find it interesting at the least, after being driven away by subscription based MMO games. The possibilities are virtually endless with waht you can make and design in this environment.

  15. Re:Free lifestyle-focused massively multiplayer ga by Negatyfus · · Score: 2, Interesting

    What about Planeshift? It's a MMORPG in a fantasy setting and uses the CrystalSpace 3D engine.

  16. Is this an Internet Explorer-only site? by PaddyM · · Score: 0, Troll

    Mozilla and w3m have no luck with that link. Thanks linden labs and slashdot for supporting the Microsoft monopoly's network effects.

    1. Re:Is this an Internet Explorer-only site? by Bander · · Score: 1

      The Second Life site works fine with my mozilla-based Firebird (cough) browser. What version of Mozilla are you using?

      -- Bander

    2. Re:Is this an Internet Explorer-only site? by metamatic · · Score: 1

      Doesn't work with Mozilla 1.4a on Windows.

      --
      GCHQ Quantum Insert installed. If only our tongues were made of glass, how much more careful we would be when we speak
    3. Re:Is this an Internet Explorer-only site? by Bander · · Score: 1

      Strange. It works fine with the Firebird nightly build from 2003-04-29 running under WindowsXP... I can't check on Firebird under Linux until I get home, but I'm guessing it will work fine there too.

      -- Bander

    4. Re:Is this an Internet Explorer-only site? by PhrackCreak · · Score: 1

      The site is not IE only. I have browsed the linde sites with moz win32 and linux, as well as galeon.

      Also, the application back end is runs on linux.

      --
      - You don't know how to maintain a station wagon either!
  17. Most of us gave our credit card for Sims Online... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    But I do not know this company..

    EA was a big name.. I have no idea who these guys are.

  18. im gonna try and steal your idea. but by Unknown+Poltroon · · Score: 1

    Im very, very lazy, so it probably wont happen.

    --
    All Troll + "offtopic" mods are meta moderated as "Unfair", because you abused the system.
  19. In-game modeling/scripting by JackMonkey · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I've been playing the beta for about a week now, and I'm blown away by the possibilities for this game.

    Everyone has the ability to 3-D model objects and then script them to do whatever they want in-game. There are a bunch of pre-manufactured objects for you to play with, but you are free to build anything you can dream up. I've already seen guns, planes, pool tables, slot machines, skyscrapers, log cabins...it's really amazing how in-depth this world has already become.

  20. Noise, Noise, Noise by Chris+Canfield · · Score: 2, Interesting

    The fun of Second life, and the major problem with it, is the freedom of creation. You build and script objects in the world, from simple benches to mansions to Soccer Balls to Casinos. The problem arises that the world has all of the beauty and serenity of a graffiti wall. My little house by the hill is surrounded by a dilapidated building consisting of four walls and a triangle, a TIE FIGHTER on a launchpad, a pole-shaped thingie extending several miles into the sky, and a floating billboard for a skin modelling company, among others. There is no stretch of land anywhere unclaimed, and there is very, very little that isn't loud, gawdy, attention-grabbing, poorly made, or some combination of the above.

    Unfortunately, this is exactly the sort of thing I'm attempting to get away from: I live in a loud, attention-grabbing city, and would suspect that most people do too. The gameworld doesn't have the cultural feel of a city, with densely-packed space and open culture, but rather a suburbia with every parcel of land claimed and all of it wasted. But it has the dirty, technological, noisy feel of a city. Very few people bother to plant trees on their land, or go through any other sort of beautification with the surrounding environment. Even the people themselves can look like anything, from tiny little dwarves to pasty-white goth vampires to robby the robot.

    It's not necessarily lunacy, but it *is* disconcerting. Without an external area that people go to fight in, ala everquest, there is just no large open space within which one can be alone, or free, or communal. You can hardly sit down without paying attention to who owns the bench. Everything is owned, everything is shouting for attention, and everything looks different than everything else. The old-west themed area is refreshing, following the pre-concieved notions of design and function allows for a user to rest peacefully in a cute little town and recover sanity, but other than that area the game is a big aesthetic mess.

    I wish the Second Life people much luck and much success... But, in addition to a tremendous server upgrade and continents more worth of land, they need to deal with issues such as how to regulate freedom such that the activities of one person do not create a form of aesthetic pollution that makes things less enjoyable for their other paying customers. Perhaps pre-set texture sets for given areas? Or single-purpose areas? We will have to see.

    BTW, I gave credit card details, and haven't been charged. They do that to prevent people from signing up multiple times, giving the free sign-up currency and the weekly in-game stipend to the primay character.

    --
    This Sig is a mnemonic device designed to allow you to recognize this author in the future.
    1. Re:Noise, Noise, Noise by anonymous+loser · · Score: 1

      I haven't played the game, but your description along with the description on the website reminds me quite a bit of the Metaverse in Snow Crash. Sounds like what people really need is to set aside some virtual space and build a few safe havens that everyone can enjoy in serenity, like public parks in the real world. That, and a Black Sun.

  21. Re:Free lifestyle-focused massively multiplayer ga by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    3D multiuser chat and recreational environments were all the rage (for a small group of fanatics!) back in the mid-late nineties. Companies like Worlds Inc., OZ Interactive, and others developed 3D virtual communities where you could chill as an avatar and interact with others via chat and crude gestures and behaviors. However, only ActiveWorlds, originally developed by Worlds Inc., provided a way for users to own land, build their own structures and add customized scripted behaviors to avatars and objects. It is still around - http://www.activeworlds.com/

    These were the precursors to what Linden Lab is attempting. My question is why did such smart and successful entrepreneurs like Kapor and Rosedale invest in a project with such a weak business case? Where is the killer app here? Do they know about all of those failed 3D virtual community projects from the 90s? Why do they think theirs will succeed?