Fizzer Worm Uninstalling Itself
boredMDer writes "According to a recent update on the Dshield.org mailing list, apparently the Fizzer Task Force has gained control of the Geocities webpage from which Fizzer updates itself. From an IRC-Security mailing list: 'We have also postted a Fizzer cleaner to the actual URL that the bot downloads its updates from, as a self extracting and running executable.' The Fizzer-uninstaller posted there creates the file '%WinDir%\uninstall.pky', which then causes Fizzer to remove all of its registry keys. Looks like the Fizzer worm will soon come to an end."
...now control the update page...
At what point does the vigalante hacking become acceptable when fighting against Something Bad?
If this worm updated itself from a random group of computers that it had infected (say for exmple, yours), would you mind if they took control of your computer if it meant stopping the worm?
Why isn't the geocities site saying it's 'bandwith exceeded' or something?
It would have been smarter for the worm to verify a signature on the code it downloads
Even better, it should not go to a hardcoded URL. This makes it too easy for the enemy to take over a vulnerable web page and attack the worm operation.
The worm should download its code via. P2P, maybe IRC, or maybe even Freenet. Especially Freenet. This way, the more the worm updates are requested, the more they replicate.
Maybe the worms could even try to keep track of each other, forming their own network, in a very low-key, low bandwidth, gnutella kind of way.
Finally, you had better not be shown to have the private key when the bad guys come knocking.
The price of freedom is eternal litigation.
An look at ethical issues involved in "hacking-back" was written by a cow-orker of mine. It looks at different ethical systems and how they might be applied here.
It's called "Crossing the Line: Ethics for the Security Professional"
And it could be argued that people who let viruses like this onto their machines have no training, are incompetant, and need to have experts solve their problems for them.
Let's try another analogy then:
Let's say that you are just an average person going in to get a flu-shot at the doctor.
The flu vaccine wasn't manufactured correctly and has a small amount of contamination that causes people to become slightly feverish. It's not fatal, but it's uncomfortable.
The health authorities, rather than trying to re-vaccinate everyone effected, put the cure (100% safe and effective) into the public water system to help everyone as quickly as possible, prevent the spread of the problem, etc.
How do you feel?
"Nothing strengthens authority so much as silence." - Charles de Gaulle