Slashdot Mirror
Ghostscript Leaves GNU
commanderfoxtrot writes "Ghostscript 7.07 has been released. However, this is the last GNU release. They will continue to make releases under the GNU GPL, but because of disagreements over censorship of the AFPL releases and the development model in the GNU release their development process has become incompatible with the goals of the GNU project as interpreted by Richard Stallman."
Mmm, nothing like being slashdotted. I'll try to comment on some factual points, though.
There is no "Artifex Public License". There is the AFPL, or "Aladdin Free Public License," but we've never claimed this to be open-source, as it's not consistent with the Open Source Definition.
Our decision separate from the GNU name has no effect on the freedoms guaranteed to our users. We've always done a GPL release within a year of the AFPL release, and will continue to do so.
The text quoted above correctly describes the AFPL versions of Ghostscript - commercial distribution is not allowed. However, commercial Linux distributions do of course distribute the GPL version.
LILO boot: linux init=/usr/bin/emacs
> Stallman has done more harm to the Open Source movement than
;-)
> anyone else.
That's over the top. Granted, Stallman is an idealistic nutcase
with strange ideas and strange priorities, and he likes to shove
them down everyone's throat, but nevertheless he has actually
provided quite a bit of really useful stuff. He coordinated the
early development of some very important things: gcc (without
which we wouldn't have Linux *or* Free/Net/Open BSD in their
current forms) and a number of important filesystem tools, plus
of course Emacs, without which we would all die or (worse
have to use vim.
It's only recently, after the OSS movement gained some real
momentum in the form of lots of programmers writing code, that
RMS seems to have stopped contributing anything useful himself
and gone off into full-time-ideology mode. (Does he still write
code these days? HURD? What? Anything anyone *uses*?)
Still, even in full-time-ideology mode, he's mostly harmless.
Most folks pay more attention to other people (ESR for example),
and even the people who consider RMS as the big leader don't buy
his most inane ramblings. What harm has he done, other than
annoy people such as yourself who haven't learned to ignore him?
Yes, the GS departure is another example of how the Gnu project
is becomming irrelevant. But the Gnu project is becomming
irrelevant *mostly* because the open-source movement has gained
such momentum that it no longer needs the FSF as such. We depend
on certain Gnu software, but if the FSF evaporated tomorrow we'd
still have (and still be able to develop and improve) that
software. The FSF as an institution we no longer need, and the
reason we no longer need them is because (though RMS does not
realise it yet) they were successful.
The FSF gave people like Linus the tools they needed to create
free software. The internet gave them the ability to easily
share it. Linux attracted lots of developers and created a
critical momentum. Companies like RedHat and IBM gave the
movement enough credibility (in the eyes of suits) to force
everyone in the industry to take notice. The rest is details.
Cut that out, or I will ship you to Norilsk in a box.
You must call it GNU/Ghostscript...