Bayesian Filter Testing?

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Posted by Cliff on Tuesday July 1, 2003 @10:09PM from the verifying-new-spam-fighting-techniques dept.

pu33y asks: "Since the publication of Paul Graham's A Plan For Spam, several programs that perform Bayesian filtering having become available, including CRM114 and Bogofilter. But missing is any serious testing to see how they perform in relation to themselves and to other, non-Bayesian filters.Searching Google has turned up nothing and when I asked Paul Graham, he was unaware of any such testing, as well. Can anyone point to any such testing or provide the results of their own personal experiences with Bayesian filters?"

12 of 127 comments (clear)

Min score:

Reason:

Sort:

Bayesian Filter Testing Data ec802661a08e483bda3fc by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 22:57 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

4f5ce14074291a2c1934fe921181ca705561cc398bbb52a7 e0 4d92abeff3080d27ec5d56333e689df1d16a5a0b4115934532 a60b94bdc73797e5c140bdd65f9d17db8733020ec2c3c3e762 672db97b667ffe08e7623a46843e73565ae1618f5b6397bb2d 04a32b954909e4356bd68793
Bayesian Filter Testing Data b305c4982512d2529ad05 by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 22:58 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

8640d7a945445a1efbe208c1017e5b415b88f3e86f89a892 d7 677fffad99c65f049d64bd087ad59d9e5320df965a4820ac17 d8a48126ac3ddd82489b35c0cd3274bde4156a827f7e5a5e54 5a0c8a4cc64a76b224c9f76c15289d2883e0bf93fd0df9b7bb 2859008c54e1d5d9522d16befee547a0966831d20f0253b883 7254bb5bffb1cbed6ed79589cf475923419d268dfb5138be32 3453af7d58fb7b246df77861106151e4da32b43aebe4c0ce91 73ba6e473d24d1e1aa6b3b977caff021b4
Bayesian Filter Testing Data 233e59fa6283938baff02 by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:00 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

c6ba5ff1fe5b19259f173e7972a12015397e1d1a9bcc4400 a9 f8754e1c1048b6ba7ca22b615f4f8a1743406d3550c93a4a2e 22a869a12c8411953d9c1ac682828ed6f70eea41393320aa4c febb279a242fc69c3781f9dd6a5cb24d335945e841f7660308 943d2350de0f14731a7abd7f20107e53de721e12455287303a 3e30ecd7a8cb529e4a5d48f11e4256e53c99172708ccf204c4 7df56b5469327e9005819221cc350ac177eee8204222855049 85fc4166d1b1e192f650ee2d807b54c943b18dd38638bf19ad 6f32345a0327a58bcff944ef77cf5a63e0255c2bd8ca870b73 398af676fbda475d5889a112c629b925687248f3cec028c975 94abb60635acf25209a3f94a59cb0bad1a297ae8164d58531c 85829c056175c3c27c7360e9fd49d88d063afbe92c7f028d0c 1f7e08eb16d37a42180158171d57e1cc8122b415c1f22f4c38 899f51f1ed3ce20120bbd9867d6c2fa26c1218f8a23d56c21f bea2
Bayesian Filter Testing Data 188934b799f9c866379dd by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:00 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

51d3cab6da2603ad816083eb371d13ad5fd55a4ffb1e6632 bc 31a01a9fa5b213c86af7db552f16a11c2e3308074154ac1b23 0c2ea27a320190a0fe0b002521d74d750f2655f9cf033bceb8 aba14f71aba6668ef0ca3092b1efab304fbf65e4e6
Bayesian Filter Testing Data 04d81fced5c98dd092723 by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:00 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

ec5ab2bab6fdb880337c5c92785f77dd4b663b62aeaf93c1 ec 07e7f73bf2543189dafaf4e16185424fa93241c009fa522c5a 6c94ba9dea2c9a656407e1b9bd8c8948986d77d8c218f03ebc ca19417d9289e1814dd872636fad8160139dc4766a
Bayesian Filter Testing Data 3a55002e105ec6b1177ab by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:01 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

92759f3b989bd57b544abacd6cf92d327df552440682aa17 5b 6ba97ff4522ad8
Bayesian Filter Testing Data c608f0780424e8d79ec47 by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:01 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

cc650618dcee9d88ceb45f6403016b0528b2255ba27e51d4 5a 2fe036ce5f473c4cee866e53cef6c818d1a7ed47d3215813cd 762222c50c46919c328c3dbf87b389148408d209b6fc7dcc7a c44daf70aa36c303c247580ba2ad350dab964828156d3c7d45 3759616fd8ae9f6c20e5d071ccf24c9627f16af52f5034bef1 6cc0bba3a92e719349dda06de72dac3448e1490177ed6be3d9 fc33b965e6e7a8534a8196bc8d56d2c46ae760d228e70af6f6 067b951cd08a561a4284fe7ed5a8b79496a6a04d462b02ad02 d1c650c10634bde60be07d4ed723744e0e83d99f2031ae7b37 f01ff25265859cf6a42ee30fbf321fd0b7f2a36b6838fe81fc ee29d2f410a2049ca0d6775e5b1f376269ac03826e81
Bayesian Filter Testing Data ed050d63932389c336ff5 by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:02 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

bbb5b9f6594e88480ba6ab7ba6c5b99d51d0db8fd406c65f f0 a07e46c1e607d1715a709dba82ce00968071a07e4fcc0ce5bb 391401062d002dd97a346b78eceed5e714549e9937f437d4fc 2edf35b8fb98a64c8df299f3ea153b18fa259776252ae549cf 604c064a34019c7bd4a81e24578d9dd532e0be0cdd050b5bec 4967a16b542509805b2618d880d79d813a51e953b1ab0fb541 59c63dc80b31554ed4738e6ffab08e23fc9363a8211570aa45 77e210da95dec22e376913d473886f4c222dacda7e6b45c917 c4d1c30e4c30e017595afbd7f5a99efd71556d99b39c268e62 5888729df4fcd5fae58a932b0f19153efe4e3f566810511a24 f0fa659c368822a28571a160923afe51dfaac00245581d13cc 462a9e47e78be2e8922697b96a0678ce3f8562ed9841f71ef9 2f6cb09a9c461d5c466391783ed52e11b0ed950d
Bayesian Filter Testing Data 39e1b5284d48c8f8a4c54 by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:14 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

b1d5a2252b8a73cd146b1140d783384cb1183560ea6301d6 e1 51c959b6984222a664984487cb1dddd637524f9c82c449adcd 97aee38024cf580409df8ff9b447caf30a513b294bb78168a3 2ba0dce36e357715d27f3544d689fb96c3fad28eefe8f51c26 98fbcced3bfe59f41b257292d6368eb1ada0146fbabee40e79 f3b4e4f08f86e95c9d083c89f058285f9ff636032910511bf4 ecb67bf31ba448278419256ef8e0860690057a70e2417a638f 155a1d21051452db84f0d7980c6a30f6ae5e93e97910814feb 7ea0902bad6182fb001c10d28e514c413b461eae83abdb4b1f 5b519cde67ac0d0fcab419aa3048a4ca35d9a03ac12db4c2f7 f5c0044e9692bf5ecfddd572bc0ddb8106d262600b7a
Bayesian Filter Testing Data ae8970f7d83581427155b by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:15 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

5d545ba02e631dc8917f9baee649d1cffa028cf21c88b7a8 41 94306e1b37968c078a8911a3d3f618aa39e1447e80b0ba5b8f 3306d1faf2217c02fb13487787c8c85196ee65db64d5955c31 dd6c6d8690
Bayesian Filter Testing Data a098a71bbbd49cdb511d2 by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:16 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

a4387208e38886fe95a8f8d4aa77157b462347d95923532d 61 cdd2d0c48d6129211fff9e65c0e47a790c629116e3299649ce 4fe6942d35a74640cf784b94e5d2745b601f1064f3e9a35cf1 747b740e5e5f31b58aa02a0e80fca86d53a6fac741ac0aa606 ffac829736e4d8bcef83a9c9462ef7d81ef9ceda455c38d6a7 c4349131e4b5d12b9d13865fc410864a48fe6ed53f539e0e5b 10ad4a14a5852132a5ddd2450555f921f45a0c0bf6f41bd95a 3dc08667a5c4e674eec06bb4b2875395ffaf96b1722e340a3b fbb4befb26cd7c9e39621ac65f498eabdb33cfbce569849eab bdec943eb78cfd58f21c55dad9c36353c2bdd5d508f5cbe324 77af2aeae3b014ea332d0684051d9fef033a5f1607dd5ae6ad e6f0e2863103a7e19a1abe18d2df5ac9f24b85ab0b37d76500 13516737
Bayesian Filter Testing Data bfecf8f10580b916be79c by Anonymous Coward · 2003-07-01 23:46 · Score: -1, Offtopic

Here is some test data to help you with testing Bayesian filters!!

CRaPFLooD

5328c873d3470e351e602ea7cba85180ba0c3a8d191e1921 f9 63c1ac3edcb044bfecf8f10580b916be79cd1f98a95840dcb8 8e77b00e85321d39b4e4097c1107409a410d6e59c8601f0e6c 0abc38912038b4584ab3dac6f3e8527021a1653770a03e5aa2 52e564c23062c4af8b7adf1e59225c895ad22cbc93691d496b 64aa617153f307b5c0c430849e99573d3f31762ec14612fd4f 01f8865e35f4c3b87ed18f71156e9df4967ceca8023b367106 73