Slashdot Mirror
Solar Sail Will Work, says Planetary Society
degauss writes "In response to Cornell Physicist Thomas Gold's paper declaring the theroy behind solar sails flawed (previously mentioned in this Slashdot article), Louis Freedman, executive director of the Planetary Society (the organization behind the COSMOS project), has written a brief rebuttal to the claims in Dr. Gold's paper regarding the feasibility of solar sails for use as a method of transportation in space. He does not go in to detail with equations and such, but does give an overview of the reasons he believes Gold's hypothesis is incorrect."
The interesting thing is that the Mercury orbiter that NASA launched (one of the pioneer series) used the pressure of sunlight on its solar panels, just like a solar sail would on the sail material, to give it a spin. That, IMO, gives the theory supporting solar sails working a whole lot more credibility.
Do you know why the road less traveled by is littered with the bones of the unwary?
a presigious US astronomer, wrote a paper in 1902 in which he concluded:
p 16 7y1977-78.pdf
"Flight by machines heavier than air," Simon Newcomb declared one day in 1902, "is unpractical and insignificant, if not utterly impossible."
His arguments were quite reasonable on the surface - Imagine a bird as a model. If you increase the size of the bird, the mass increases proportionally to the third power of its wingspan. But the surface area of the wings only increases proportionally to the square of its wingspan. Thus something much larger than a bird would never be able to fly, and all attempts to build heavier than air flying machines capable of carrying a human would prove futile.
Fortunately, the Wright brothers never read his paper, or at least never took him seriously.
About 40 years later it was argued by learned men that manned supersonic flight would never be achievable.
http://www.garfield.library.upenn.edu/essays/v3
Marconi wasn't formally educated, and he was laughed at for spending vast sums of money to send a radio signal across the Atlantic ocean. Any fool knows that radio waves couldn't penetrate the earth, and was limited to line of sight communication! Yet despite all logic, the damned fool contraption eventually worked. It was only later that they discovered the ionosphere could reflect certain frequencies back to earth.
Even great men of science make mistakes sometimes.
My rights don't need management.