GUI Toolkits for the X Window System

TeachingMachines writes "Leslie Polzer has written a nice summary of the current state of GUI Toolkits for the X Windows System (article title of the same name). Those of you who are planning to spend hours and hours scouring the Internet for a mature cross-platform GUI toolkit may save some time and trouble by reading this summary. Leslie's review covers the pros and cons of using GTK+, Trolltech QT, FLTK, wxWindows, and the FOX Toolkit."

Comments

Exactly

[Anonymous Coward]

I need to write GUI code that works on all Linux, all HP-UX, all SUN Solaris, all SGI platforms without requiring more than a simple "make".

Our customers would not like it if I told them to find and install version 1.2 of GTK and stuff like that, because in all honestly, on any platform other than Linux most of these toolkit libraries have no simple install mechanism and tend to be buggy.

So Xlib all the way... Simple and it runs on even a 10 year old version of Linux.

Why the Qt bashing?

[arvindn]

Look at the last paragraph of the article:

I personally think Qt is made irrelevant by both of the others because they are not missing anything Qt offers. The tools that come with Qt may not be bundled with them, but comparable tools do exist and can be used free of charge, and most often as Free Software. Qt's biggest weaknesses are its relic called "MOC" and its business orientation. Yes, it's GPL, but not for MS Windows, so you're not really free. FOX and (especially) wxWindows offer similarly advanced sets of widgets and techniques, so you might as well throw Qt away. In terms of portability, it's the same, and wxWindows even adds OS/2 portability. Believe me, I don't want to be unfair to Trolltech or upset dedicated Qt developers. I tried to be objective, and that's my objective conclusion. Maybe we can discuss this point in the comments for this article.

There is a disturbing trend of recent articles that engage in Qt/KDE bashing. Can't help wondering whether it is really a coincidence or not. For instance, here's another freshmeat editorial from a few months back.

Re:One thing missed

[Telex4]

One way to avoid this problem of dependencies, and also to really boost the useability of your app, is to try hard to separate the GUI from the "guts" of the application, so it is reasonably easy to write multiple UIs (GUI or CLI) for the same application. Then you, or others, can come and develop new UIs for themselves. For example, when I started developing QuickRip, I began with a (Py)Qt interface. Someone requested a CLI interface, so I made the separation, and gave QuickRip two interfaces. Now some (Py)Gtk developers are adding a Gtk interface, because they don't want to use Qt. Lovely.

Of course this approach is only usually worth it when most of the hard work is done in the guts, and when the UI itself isn't that much work to redo in a different toolkit. Nor does it work when you need a feature than is only available in a specific toolkit. But in many instances, it works fine.

So often there's no need to choose between toolkits... just choose them all! :)

When wxWindows gets decent support for toolkits other than Gtk+, it will make this even more trivial.

Re:Missed the best

[UnuMondo]

I agree. I came across GNUstep two months ago and was amazed by its incredibly simple API. I quickly made my first app, Charmap, a character map which uses Unicode.org's standards files to provide a wealth of information about any character. This was easy and fast because GNUstep provided solid Unicode/UTF-8 support from the start. While for example GTK was a pain to use until 2.0 with regards to non-Latin scripts, GNUstep at the same time had one of the most advanced string classes.

Not only is GNUstep concise and simple, but because Apple's Cocoa is also an implementation of the OPENSTEP standard, one can use Cocoa docs in GNUstep programming. This allows the programmer to tap into abundant resources online and in print.

If you're interested in what's going on in the GNUstep world, my favourite resource is www.gnustep.us, which lists the latest news and updates. I hope I don't sound like a karma whore, I'm just super-enthused about a fantastic API that doesn't get the attention it deserves.