Slashdot Mirror


PA Child Porn-Blocking Law Challenged, Suspended

An anonymous reader submits: "Pennsylvania's controversial child porn controls have been challenged in court, and in a surprising twist, suspended by the state. If you recall, PA required ISPs within the state to block access to sites hosting child porn. The list (which used IP addresses) is compiled solely by the State Attorney General's Office. The use of IPs resulted in the unnecessary snagging of other sites on the same hosting service. The plaintiffs are the ACLU, CDT, and a Doylestown PA ISP. The State AG, in an odd move, suspended the law and the list indefinitely. [Note: Philly.com appeared to suffer a DDoS earlier today. Please be kind to their admins.]"

18 of 283 comments (clear)

  1. Yay! by Pig+Hogger · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    No more restriction for amish pr0n (that is, a film of a shirtless man talking about lunch on the phone with his wife)!!!!

  2. Re:fp by Neuropol · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    free Adrain Lamo!

  3. Re:DDoS, you say? by grolschie · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Yes this was a very "controvertial" decison by Slashdot.

  4. read the above by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    to see a troll in action

  5. For the sake of accuracy by Serzen · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Pennsylvania is actually a Commenwealth, not a State. Not that anyone pays attention or anything, but PA and VA (and probably a few others that I'm not thinking of at the moment) are not states...

  6. Re:fp by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Neuropol is gay.

  7. Why isn't song sharing like radio by PourYourselfSomeTea · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    OK. Some worthy slashdotter tell me why this doesn't work for the RIAA (philisophical rants about why music should be free aside).

    Sharing a music file is roughly equivalent to playing it on the radio. You share it for awhile, and people download and listen to it. Downloading a file and saving it to your harddrive is just like recording it to tape -- come to think of it, I remember a time when I recorded all files from my computer to tape...

    You don't AFAIK have to have a special license to play a song over the radio, you just have to pay a small fee whenever you play it.

    Since a file being shared is shared for a finite amount of time, and an unlimited number of listeners can download that file with their computer, just like they would listen to or record it off their car stereo (and the majority of encoding-of-your-choice files out there are roughly the same quality).

    So why not a flat fee of say .01 cents per song per 3 minutes of sharing that song (assuming the song is three minutes long). Not an entirely unreasonable price to pay. Could even payed by subscription to KaZaa which might pay the record companies, evil as their sorry asses are, monthly for the average number of RIAA copyrighted files on their service, thus distributing the cost of file-availability to all users.

    Anyone know why the RIAA hasn't thought of this? Anyone know anyone who's going to try the DJ argument in court?

  8. Re:fp by Neuropol · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    no. i am sorry. i am not gay. therefor, i cannot be with you.

    i suggest you should seek out the peronal ads in your local paper. i think men seekng men always post in those things.

  9. Re:A suggestion for Google by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Goatse is nothing. Have you seen Tubgirl? Don't!

  10. Re:Well by IM6100 · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    It sounds like you're trying to equate those other crimes with child pornography.

    Society doesn't agree with you. Child Porn is a special case. It's so abhorent to mainstream society that special prohibitions are deemed appropriate.

    You'd best deal with it. It's not going to change.

    --
    A Good Intro to NetBS
  11. Re:A suggestion for Google by Snake_Plisken · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Seriously, don't. Tubgirl makes Mr. Goatse look like wholesome family entertainment.

    --

    Eat recycled food - it's good for the environment, and OK for you.
  12. HEYYYYYY SPACE GHOST!!! YA KNOW WHAT? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Space Ghost: What.
    Brak: That's what! Hahahahahahahaha. Ah-hahahahaha Huh. That's what! Hahahahahahahaha. Hyeh!! Getit?
    Brak: Huhh. He-hey Spaceghost you know what? Hey Spaceghost you know what? No. Seriously. You know what?
    Spaceghost: What!?
    Brak: That's what! Hahahahahahahahaha! Ah-haha! Ahhhhh! Got you good buddy! That's what! Ahahaha! Huh-haha! Ah-hahahahahuhha! THAT'S WHAT!!!
    Spaceghost: Brak!! If you don't stop doing that annoying whatever it is you're doing, I'm going to blast Zorak.
    Brak: I don't don't believe you!
    Ghost: Ehehe. You don't...?
    Brak: No... I... don't...!
    Zorak: Believe him! BELIEVE HIM! Agggghhhh!!!

    Brak: I triple dog dare you to do that again.
    Zorak: No. No no no no no no! No you don't! No no!!! Aggghhhh!!! (Cough cough)

    Brak: So I guess ummm... blowin' up Zorak makes you feel like Mr. Big Stuff!?
    (Cough cough cough)
    Brak: Is that your answer to everything!!?

    Brak: Nice weather we're having.

    Brak: Spaceghost? Ummm. Can I make one little remark without you blowing Zorak up?

    Zorak: Hey! (Cough cough hack)
    Brak: I guess not!
    Zorak: Hey! Why don't you zap Brak? He started the whole thing.
    Brak: Oh he'd love to blast me, wouldn't you Spaceghost?! Wouldn't you Mr. Big Man, but he can't! You know why? Cause I'm not animated to explode! That's right! Right?!
    Spaceghost: Right.
    Brak: Even if I was I'm so well loved by all that if Spaceghost blasted one hair on my pretty little head he would get in BIG trouble!!!! Am I right or am I right or am I right or am I right or am I right or am I right?!
    Spaceghost: RIGHT!
    Brak: N'ya know what else?
    Spaceghost: WHAT!?
    Brak: Chicken butt!!! Hahahahahahahahahaha!!! Ahhh!!! Ohh man!! Put that arm down! Don't... don't you!!! Hey!!!! Don't point at me there buster!

  13. Re:A suggestion for Google by mlk · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I'm really regreat saying this, but

    Tubgirl? Pass a link (that'll I can open in Lynx, then forward to everyone in my brothers address book :)

    --
    Wow, I should not post when knackered.
  14. Edward Teller, Dead at 95 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I just heard some sad news on talk radio - physicist and inventor of the hydrogen bomb Edward Teller was found dead in his Stanford, California home this morning. There weren't any more details. I'm sure everyone in the Slashdot community will miss him - even if you didn't enjoy his work, there's no denying that we should drop his invention on every Islamic country we can find. Truly an American icon.

  15. Re:Off topic - PA Child Porn-Blocking by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Nigger con carne that is French for "black person with meat" and is usually used to identify Chili. Chili is the food made of beans and hot stuff. Perl and C++ with C and Python ESR Stallman Linus Perens wee WILDCAT and old Ike with the hard on that won't quit.Nigger con carne that is French for "black person with meat" and is usually used to identify Chili. Chili is the food made of beans and hot stuff. Perl and C++ with C and Python ESR Stallman Linus Perens wee WILDCAT and old Ike with the hard on that won't quit.Nigger con carne that is French for "black person with meat" and is usually used to identify Chili. Chili is the food made of beans and hot stuff. Perl and C++ with C and Python ESR Stallman Linus Perens wee WILDCAT and old Ike with the hard on that won't quit.

  16. Re:A suggestion for Google by jesser · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    To suggest a search result to Google, create a link. In this case, create a link with "child porn" as the link text and goatse as the link target.

    --
    The shareholder is always right.
  17. Uggg! by makoffee · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    I'm sure this will result in great karma, but seriously...

    FUCK THE RIAA!

    She's 12! 12! AHHHH! WTF is this world comeing to!? If this girl got caught stealing CDs in her home town you know she wouldn't be fined anywhere near that much money. So this settlement is a load of crap, I just hope that their lawyer will see threw this crap and actualy try and fight it, because any reasionable judge would just give her the old "first timer" warning.

    Trust me I got into some trouble as a kid, and I know how it goes. Besides, she's twelve, she's a minor, they can't toutch her.

    (just for this I'm never buying a CD again!)

    --
    -makoffee
  18. Re:A suggestion for Google by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Did anyone notice that the vagina is censored? This image really shows how absurd this japanese law is =)