Slashdot Mirror


Back To SCO

wampl3r writes " Eric Raymond and Bruce Perens deliver a great response to SCO's recent Letter to the Open Source Community. Their response does a good job of presenting many of the finer points we have been arguing about around here, but it's nice to see them in such a formal, well-thought-out letter." Munchola adds "Meanwhile, ComputerWire, from where McBride misquoted Perens in the first place, sets the record straight: 'In his statement McBride appears to have attributed a ComputerWire paraphrase as a quote from Perens.'" stefan points to this response to McBride's letter from Kevin Bedell, LinuxWorld Magazine's Editor. Below, find one reader's idea about the "stolen lines" SCO claims are in the Linux kernel, and one expert's claim that SCO might not know some of its own source code very well.

VikingBrad writes "The Sydney Morning Herald has an article on Dr Warwick Toomey of The Unix Heritage Society claiming that SCO may not know the origin of code in System V, including claims that there is a lot of BSD software in Sys V."

Alex writes "I wondered where the 100k+ lines of copied code in the linux kernel would come from in comparison to the SCO Unixware stuff. Then a thought popped up in my head: what if they just compared linewise? All those empty lines in the code would have the same content. But how many empty lines are in the Linux Kernel Code? This small shell script counts them for you:

emptylines=0; function parse_dir () { for file in $1/*; do if [ -d "$file" ]; then parse_dir $file; else while read line; do if [ "$line" = "" ]; then emptylines=$[$emptylines+1]; echo $emptylines; fi; done

Kernel 2.4.22, yet cleaned of the code which SCO claimed was stolen, has still 733140 empty lines, probably copied and pasted by the bad, bad kernel developers from the good, good SCO guys..."

12 of 560 comments (clear)

  1. We know SCO is in league with SATAN and his GNAA!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait
    Do your part for Jesus! Help us defeat Satan and his army of evil, SCO/GNAA!

    Defeat the GNAA! Join Landover Baptist Church's very own B.A.S.H. (Baptists Are Saving Homosexuals) Ministry!

    While we at BASH are yet unable to cure niggerism (or any other such God-inflicted curse of skin pigmentation), we have had record success turning limp-wristed, "Queer Eye" watching nancy-boys and bull-dyke lesbians back in to straight, God-fearing, Republican-voting human beings!

    All we need is your pious financial support, plenty of imprecatory prayer and a good-sized, Leviticus-charged stone or two, and soon the GNAA will be a thing of the past!

    To join, go here and read all about how you can start saving gay Negroes from Satan's clutches!

    This post was brought to you by a Landover Baptist Church Member.

    To obtain a copy of this source, and spread the loving, gay nigger-hating word of Jesus, go to BASH's source page and download it for yourself. Post it wherever you see the GNAA rearing its ugly, demonic head! GLORY!

    If you or anyone you know exhibits these signs they may be a homosexual and at risk of joining Satan's Army, or the GNAA.

  2. Re:FIRST PS0T FOR THE PEOPLE OF NYC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    No, but you took a couple of big planes up the ass.

  3. Re:How can one steal lines of code? by Zelatrix · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    What idiot modded this rather insightful comment "troll"?

  4. Re:Let's make this a press release! by ascalon · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    Why the hate on SCO, it's not like they attempted to legally rape a 12 year old girl

  5. A really nice response. by dhowells · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    I am pleased to see that although the letter is formally written it manages at the same time to be empassioned about the spirit of OSS which is something I am glad has not been lost in all this corporate embroilment.

    I would have liked it to address more directly SCO IP claims which can be countered by for example: Code that already has been negotiated to be allowed in BSD, Code from 'ancient unix' released by SCO themselves, etc.

    However the spirit of the letter itself is sufficient to address the bulls**t that SCO is prepared to throw at us.

    Just a shame that it was co-authored by that gun-toting fucktard ESR who makes the lot of us seem like a bunch of hillbillies from Utah.

    Anyway, Dom.

    --
    use Blunt::Instrument;
  6. Re:Let's make this a press release! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    It's not just the RIAA that's after 12 year old girls. It's me too.

  7. Things sure take long in the US... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    ...there is a country in europe where SCO has already been taken to court and fucked. In the US people are still "discussing" and effectively spreading the FUD. Which is cool because I got plenty of SCOX around. And I'm planning to purchase a $699 license to just for the controversy of it which will result in a slashdot post and more "discussions" and more SCOX $$$ for me. All this thanks to you and your fabulous legal system.

    "USA... USA... USA..."

  8. hah! by panda · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    Please mod me down, I'm a redundant, trolling, flamebait-loving dogmatist and I was a pro-DMCA lobbyist. It makes sense, when you really hunker down and think about it.

    RTFL = Read the Fucking License

    I've often heard of companies having a crack legal team, but this is the first time that I've heard of one being on crack. Five minutes after the code leaks, the world and his wife knows that SCO are completely full of shit and their law suit has suffered a mortal wound.

    This Comment was generated with the Comment-O-Matic for SCO Stories.

    --
    Just be sure to wear the gold uniform when you beam down -- you know what happens when you wear the red one.
  9. Re:SCO is not the problem. Canopy is. by DarkOx · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Yea, no more QT crap, finnally GNOME will be THE open source desktop.

    --
    Repeal the 17th Amendment TODAY! Also Please Read http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html
  10. Re:disappointed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    We all know that Microsoft gave money to SCO so they can spread bullshit. So why is there still debate going on? Instead of talking endlessly about crap, blah blah blah... why hasn't someone shot Bill Gates yet? Christ, I'll do it.

  11. Re:great news by stratjakt · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    What a bunch of candy asses and douchebags the leaders of Open Source are. I swear to god.

    Linus is about the only OSS figure I can think of with any sort of dignity. And that's because he writes code and keeps his mouth shut. I respect that.

    The only things RMS, ESR or Perens and their ilk 'contribute' is rhetoric and the image of the bearded loveless hippie.

    --
    I don't need no instructions to know how to rock!!!!
  12. Re:Let's make this a press release! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait
    There does seem to be a depressing amount of uninformed or misinformed people running around.

    Yeah, and most of them post and moderate on slashdot