Slashdot Mirror


Why Only Music?

The Importance of writes "Last week, Slashdot readers provided a number of answers to the question "What is Music?" in the context of compulsory licensing. Now LawMeme asks another question about compulsory licenses: Why Only Music? Many compulsory licensing schemes have been proposed to cover music alone, but most of the arguments in favor of a compulsory license for music apply equally as well to other media types. Millions share movies, P2P can't be stopped, the MPAA hasn't provided legitimate alternatives for what consumers want, etc. If music should have a compulsory license, why shouldn't movies, software, ebooks and other media also be covered by compulsory licenses?"

7 of 255 comments (clear)

  1. SLASHDOT MYTHS VS. REALITY by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    MYTH #2: "New, innovative companies won't start up overseas."

    Really? What do you think these laid-off chip designers are gonna do when they get back to Chennai? Sell trinkets to tourists?

    MYTH #3: "R&D jobs don't go overseas. Hell, they don't even leave the US east and west coast, for the most part."

    REALITY:

    MYTH #4: "If you're truly working on something high-tech, today's high-tech, you'll never have to worry about your job moving."

    Per nasscom.org, "A recent study on the biotech market by business intelligence firm, Ernst & Young, has shown that India has the potential to become a leading hub of biotech projects. Indian companies have the capability to enter segments such as manufacturing biogenerics, contract research services, clinical trials and even areas such as bio-informatics."

    MYTH #5: "Ultimately, what xenophobes need to realize is that writing shitty code doesn't make anyone "high-tech." You're no more entitled to an inflated salary than the auto workers who saw their work moved overseas - if someone with no education can do your job cheaper, you don't deserve your job."

    "Accenture in India has also been moving into front office work such as doing clinical data management for its pharma clients. Accenture's pharma team here, which consists of doctors, dentists and biologists, analyses data from tests and helps its pharma client to gain `time-to-market' advantage. "Normally, for a BPO, back office activities are the target, but we are beginning to spot opportunities in front office activities as well," Cole said."

    1. Re:SLASHDOT MYTHS VS. REALITY by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      HEy don't forget Hu JinTao was just rated the 3rd most influential man in technology. That's 2 levels above the Slashdot favorite Torvalds.

      Hu JinTao is highest leader in China.

      The reality is China and India are going to be the tech leaders in the new century. Deal with it.

    2. Re:SLASHDOT MYTHS VS. REALITY by cpeterso · · Score: -1, Offtopic



      MYTH #1: "There is a myth #1."

  2. CLARK = BUSH GO BYE BYE by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic



    I, for one, will feel ever so satisfactory.

    Joyous music, indeed.

  3. Welcome to GNU GVideo GProfessor! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic


    "Don't fumble through boring man pages. Try my product!" - Richard M. Stallman, GNU Founder and CEO

    GNU GVideo GProfessor is the leader in computer learning. We have taught over 5 million people, and we can teach you GNU/Linux, GNU/Emacs, GNU/gcc, and more! GNU GVideo GProfessor was founded in 1983 to provide consumers with training on software for their personal computers. Since that time, millions have successfully used and learned from GNU GVideo GProfessor's fool-proof "What-You-See-Is-What-You-Do" teaching method. The first lesson, GNU /Emacs 1.0, was available only on video tape. Over the years, GNU GVideo GProfessor has produced hundreds of titles on video, CD-ROM, and online. GNU GVideo GProfessor is the fastest, easiest way to learn computers. We guarantee it!

    It's FAST! You'll be up and running in an hour! Don't waste time sifting through man pages, commuting to classes or seminars. Just pop in the CD-ROM and you're learning!

    It's EASY! It's as simple as 1-2-3! GNU GVideo GProfessor's straightforward "What-You -See-Is-What-You-Do" approach makes learning as easy as watching TV!

    It's CONVENIENT! We're ready to teach you day and night! With your busy schedule, you don't have time to waste at classes or seminars. Don't fumble through boring man pages. Whatever your schedule, we're ready when you are!

    It's COMPLETE! These aren't short teaser lessons. Each 60-minute lesson takes you from installing the software to more advanced skills. And they're not just for beginners! We'll surprise you with the knowledge you'll gain!

    Why Am I Making This Incredible Offer? I'm so confident that once you try my exceptional " What-You-See-Is-What-You-Do" learning method, you'll turn to us for all your computer learning needs.

    * How it works!

    The bonus gift and ANY TWO of the three computer learning CD-ROMs are yours free without further obligation, PERIOD. Take 10 days to decide if you want to keep the complete set of CDs. After your 10 day free trial, if you decide to keep the complete set, we'll conveniently bill your credit card just $69.95. Or simply contact our customer care number at rtfm@gnu.org if you decide to return any one of the lessons, and you will be charged nothing more!

    Every day hundreds of people just like you learn with GNU GVideo GProfessor this same fast and easy way. If you decide to keep all three lessons, every five weeks you will continue learning by automatically receiving other GNU GVideo GProfessor subjects you have an interest in, billed on the same exact terms as your first shipment. Or simply call and cancel. Everything is up to you! But most important, you are never under any obligation to purchase a subject that you don't keep. Best of all, the bonus gift, and your choice of any two of the three computer learning CD-ROMs are yours to keep FREE!!11!!

  4. Re:Theft is not what anybody wants by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    This the same Jefferson who raped his slaves and left them to raise his illegitimate children?

    Yes, truly an American icon.

  5. Re:Theft is not what anybody wants by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    This the same Jefferson who raped his slaves and left them to raise his illegitimate children? Yes, truly an American icon.

    Congratulations, you've just commited the logical fallacy of Ad Hominem. Come back when you've thought of a real argument, you silly troll.