Slashdot Mirror


Orbdev Files US Federal Suit Over Asteroid Claim

chongo writes "Orbital Development has filed legal action against the United States by filing a Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Federal Court. After NASA's NEAR probe landed on the asteroid 433 Eros, Gregory W. Nemitz, who claims to have owned the asteroid since the 3rd of March 2000, sent NASA an $20 invoice for the first 100 years of parking and storage fees. NASA told him to "pound sand". OrbDev's Eros Project seeks to promote their ludicrous ideas about property rights in space."

17 of 733 comments (clear)

  1. Show us the homestead! by Allen+Varney · · Score: 3, Funny

    If that asteroid were in Texas, the guy wouldn't be able to collect rent unless he'd lived there at least a year.

    (Yes, I made that up.)

    1. Re:Show us the homestead! by sfjoe · · Score: 5, Funny

      Whoops, turns out there's no loophole!

      There is, actually, one loophole: Any government with a sufficiently large army can unilaterally abrogate any treaty they wish.

      --
      It's simple: I demand prosecution for torture.
  2. God by Neo-Rio-101 · · Score: 3, Funny

    "If I gave you everything in the world, where would you put all of it?" -God

    --
    READY.
    PRINT ""+-0
  3. Responsibility people. by Hexydes · · Score: 5, Funny
    If someone's asteroid crashes into the Earth, are they held responsible?

    What is the fine this sort of a thing?

    1. Re:Responsibility people. by Zork+the+Almighty · · Score: 4, Funny

      What is the fine this sort of a thing?

      I think the penalty is instant death, but it sort of applies to everyone.

      --

      In Soviet America the banks rob you!
  4. Hmmm.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny


    Gregory W. Nemitz
    Address: 8301-252 Mission Gorge Road, Santee, Calif. 92071 USA
    Tel: 775-450-6144
    Fax: 413-460-6480
    Email: gnemitz@orbdev.com

    Of course, this is all public information, and obviously I'm not encouraging anyone to contact or harrass Mr. Nemitz.

  5. He's in MY universe by SoVi3t · · Score: 4, Funny

    And I charge $100 bucks a week for rent. Me thinks he owes me quite a bit of back rent.

    --
    Defender of Microsoft and Communism!!!
    1. Re:He's in MY universe by Dr.+Photo · · Score: 4, Funny

      He's in MY universe
      And I charge $100 bucks a week for rent. Me thinks he owes me quite a bit of back rent.

      I think it's about time to send him an eviction notice.

  6. Tomorrow's countersuit by KFury · · Score: 5, Funny

    In a countersuit to be filed tomorrow, NASA plans to subpoena Orbdev officials under a claim that Orbdev owes NASA $38 million in parking fees for hitching their asteroid to NASA's probe.

    An unnamed NASA official claims, "It's [Orbdev's] gravity keeping the thing there. God knows our probe has other places it could be going if it didn't have to drag along this dead weight."

    Eros could not be reached for comment.

  7. Pound sand by Dr.+Photo · · Score: 5, Funny

    Dear OrbDev,

    Department policy forbids payment of parking tickets that have not first been duly affixed to the windshield of the vehicle. Please let us know when you have done so.

    Love,
    NASA

  8. I just phoned him.... by SoVi3t · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...and he threatened to crash his asteroid into my house. Not exactly how I hoped it would go.

    --
    Defender of Microsoft and Communism!!!
  9. Call the IRS... by umofomia · · Score: 4, Funny
    If this guy is going to claim that this is his property, he better start paying taxes for it. Gee... Mr. Nemitz, how much did you say it's worth?

    Typically iron found in Space is contaminated with platinium, normally by about .005 or one-half of one percent. Assuming that 433 Eros is only 5% iron, there are 22.5 billion tons of platinium on the asteroid. The current price for platinium is about $750 per troy ounce. There are 29,167 troy ounces per short ton for a total 656,250,000,000,000 troy ounces. At today's price, that is $492,187,500,000,000,000 (~1/2 quintillion dollars).

    Thanks for calculating it for us... now pay up. :)

    1. Re:Call the IRS... by cdrudge · · Score: 3, Funny

      People can't sue if it's outside the court's jurisdiction. He needs to bring this case to a Eros 433's district court first...

  10. "Sunshine" (SM) license fees due by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    To Gregory W. Nemitz

    Re: Amnesty for unauthorized use of service

    I, Helios Apollo, owner of a main sequence, spectral class G2 star of radius 696,000 km, situated approximately 1.5e8 kilometers from the planet Earth and known in the English language as "the Sun", have been advised that you may have been using the service known as "Sunshine", a stream of photons emitted by the above-mentioned star, for the purposes of visual navigation. Since, according to my records, you are not a licensed user of the service, I am asking that you account for your usage of the service beginning from 0h00 UTC January 1, 2000 according to either of the following billing plans and remit any amounts that may be payable.

    The Photon Count Plan. Count all photons emitted from the surface of the Sun of wavelength greater than 395 nanometers and less than 695 nanometers that directly impinge upon your person and all of your belongings including real estate, then multiply by the factor 4.0 times ten to the minus twenty-five to yield the amount in cents of U.S. currency.

    The Earth Residency Plan. Only 36 cents per day of use. Use shall be deemed to occur in a 24 hour period if at least one photon would have been used under the Photon Count Plan.

    To be exempted from accounting for use of the service, please submit a copy of Certificate of Vampire Status.

  11. Obligatory Eddie Izzard quote (but relevent :) by h4rm0ny · · Score: 5, Funny

    "Do you have a flag? If you don't have a flag it's not yours."

    This reminds me of that Eddie Izzard routine where the Europeans are seizing land from the Indians. After telling them repeatedly that they're not a nation and it's not their land unless they have a flag, the Indians go off and make themselves a flag. When they come back the English say... "Good - do you have a gun?" The Indians are... "Ooooh - you need a GUN and a flag." Sorry but this chap can wave around whatever bits of paper (and make as many flags) as he likes, but unless he has a 'gun' with which to threaten the government, it isn't going to work.

    Of course, Terran property rights ultimately come down to who has the most guns too, but people forget that (unless they're Iraqi.)

    --

    Aide-toi, le Ciel t'aidera - Jeanne D'Arc.
  12. Re:Is that your star? by TopShelf · · Score: 4, Funny

    On the other hand, the Sun's owner will then sue Japan for unlicensed use of its image on their national flag...

    --
    Stop by my site where I write about ERP systems & more
  13. Re:No - SIASL was correct by deander2 · · Score: 4, Funny


    Ouch... how embarrassing must it be to misspell "grok" when mocking someone else? :-P