Slashdot Mirror


Should a '9200' Brand Mean a 9200 GPU?

newsdee asks: "An enormous controversy is going on at the X1000 forums over laptop parts. Some Centrino-based laptops bear a label advertising the Mobility Radeon 9200 brand, but users have found out that the laptop actually contains the 9000 chip. The list of affected machines is as follows: Compaq Presario X1000, HP Pavilion ZT3000 and the HP Compaq NX7000. ATI's and HP's response have been that the label is promising performance and not a specific chip. Yet users seem to not like this at all, apparently because most of them define 'brand' as equating to product. According to reviews, there are no differences (same scores, same clock speed) between the chips other than AGP 8x support, which the Centrino chipset does not provide. I seem to remember that this is not the first time that this kind of thing has happened in PC hardware. Can anybody share insights of whether this is right or wrong? Should I complain about my 9000 chip that delivers what the 9200 brand promises, knowing it has not been overclocked?"

5 of 435 comments (clear)

  1. FIRST POST by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    props to GNAA! eat my cock taco

  2. A fond farewell by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Attention slashdot community: My work here is finished.

    "The man with the pla" (who would have been known as "The man with the plan" if not for an off-by-one bug in slashcode) has served his divine purpose here at slashdot, and it is time for him to fade into history.

    While he was an insightful poster and a dedicated jihadi against slashdot's editors, too many of the devil's minions now recognize his mission and quelsh him in favor of helping slashdot's editors mission of censorship and deception.

    But hark! His spirit will surely be reborn soon in another account, and the jihad will live on, until that sweet day when slashdot's editors realize their crimes and beg the slashdot community for forgiveness.

    May the blessings of Allah find their way into your hearts, and may the fire of Jihad warm your soul with justice and fufilment.

    jihadi_31337

  3. Ridiculous! by tr0llx0r · · Score: 0, Troll

    This makes no sense. The only difference between what these
    fools thought they were getting, and what they got, is something
    their mobo doesn't support anyway. They are delivering
    exactly what they promised - a 9200 in the same machine would
    be indistinguishable from a 9000.

    Nothing to see here folks.

  4. AMD by martingunnarsson · · Score: 0, Troll

    Come on, AMD got this idea years ago when they dropped the actual speed from their CPU model names and replaced it with a higher number.

    --
    Martin
  5. TRANSLATION: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    The loser slashbots have finally correlated my immense karmawhoring faggotry to my throw-away account so I'll come back with another loser faggot account soon to continue with my immense karmawhoring faggotry since I have no life and live in my parent's basement masturbating to anime tentical rape porn and playing The Sims and chatting with fellow immense karmawhoring faggots on IRC.