Looking for Quark-Gluon Plasma?

uctbruce writes "Following the June press release from Brookhaven National Lab, nuclear physicists from around the world are discussing the results of the 4 RHIC experiments (PHOBOS, STAR, PHENIX and BRAHMS), the New York Times ran an article on the Quark Matter conference in Oakland. Have we re-created the first microseconds of the big bang in the lab? (Have a look at the Google cluster of stories)"

Comments

So are we making really short lived universes?

[kabocox]

IF they actually are reproducing the moments, are they making a really short lived universes that die because the following moments didn't mimic the rest?

Could each of these experiments create an another realty?

Re:So are we making really short lived universes?

[Ayaress]

They've really only recreated a *possible* representation of the material makeup of the very early universe. The potential for learning about the Big Bang is pretty impressive from this, but it's really only a surface feature of the universe's beginning.

The Big Bang wasn't just a bunch of material blasting outwards into space. It was space itself expanding out of what was, effectively, nothing (The laws of physics break in a singularity, which was what the universe was to begin with. Science can't say anything about it, since there's no proximate way to study or model it).

Also, this plasma is still a form of matter, however torn-apart it is. The first picoseconds of the big bang were nothing but intense energy. Plasma formed after a short time, and eventually associated into "large" structures like protons and such. We're making this plasma.

To think this is making a short-lived universe would be like thinking that making a bunch of smoke and throwing debris around would be making an explosion. It's not the Big Bang we're creating, but its product.

Re:Thank God we're still alive

[Anonymous Coward]

Actually, of those three, the only one to pose a large-scale danger is fission.

Fusion needs a lot of heat and pressure to occur. If a fusion chamber were to fail, the fusion would stop almost instantly, and a plume of hot hydrogen/helium would come out and rise upwards very quickly, where it would cool rapidly. The people near the reactor would be in serious danger, and an airplane directly over the plant may be in danger (Which is why it's a good idea to have no-fly zones over power plants in general), but people living a couple miles away would be safe as long as the fire department was running on time.

This experiment is another simmilar thing. It's just a bunch of plasma in a chamber. If it gets out, it cools rapidly and dissipates. Dangerous if you're sitting on it, but nothing to worry about otherwise.

Fission, on the other hand, can start cold, and even if it stops, the material you're left with is still radioactive. If fission stops, you just have a bunch of helium floating around, and it's not all that dangerous.

Good question

[Transcendent]

Have we re-created the first microseconds of the big bang in the lab?

Yes! ..oh wait... how the hell would I know what the first few miliseconds actually were like?

I think the only answer that you can respond with is "maybe."

Re:Duplicate article

[QEDog]

"his article has the same subject and some of the same references as this one [slashdot.org] from yesterday."

"Have we re-created the first microseconds of the big bang in the lab?"

The /. editors once again have re-created the article for scientific purposes

charmed life

[Doc Ruby]

"There are some things Man wasn't meant to know, Homer - important things." - Ned Flanders

During the Manhattan Project, some physicists feared that splitting the uranium atoms with a critical mass would start a chain reaction in the atmosphere, destabilizing all nuclei within reach, thereby consuming all the matter of Earth in a total mass->energy conversion. They guessed wrong. Out in Brookhaven (only about 0.00528s from me, as the photon flies), there were similar concerns a few years ago, prior to synthesis of the first all-strange quark matter, fearing a chain reaction turning the planet entirely strange. Also turned out to be merely a paper tiger. Now we're going for these exotic hi-energy plasmas. And our high-energy and exotic-order syntheses are only accelerating in their frequency of invention. Most of these researches are funded for weapons production, which values maximum destruction. How long will our luck hold out?

Re:charmed life

[Alsee]

some physicists feared that splitting the uranium atoms with a critical mass would start a chain reaction in the atmosphere... a total mass->energy conversion

The speculation was that it would ignite the nitrogen in the atmosphere. Not only was it immediately found to be nonsense, but it was pointless from the start. The universe has smacked the Earth around with astroids and comets that make nukes look like PopRocks candy.

The Hiroshima blast was around 13 kilotons.
The Chicxulub impact was around 100 billion kilotons.
(Chicxulub was the impact that wiped out the dinosaurs, it generated tidal waves, it splattered the earth's crust, it darkened the skies with dust and smoke, but it certainly didn't start a "chain reaction" igniting the atmosphere or starting a mass-energy conversion.)

synthesis of the first all-strange quark matter, fearing a chain reaction turning the planet entirely strange...
Now we're going for these exotic hi-energy plasmas

You forgot to mention the producing minature black holes.

And none of it is exotic. The universe bombards the earth with cosmic rays several orders of magnitude more powerful than anything we can dream of cooking up in any collider we could build. There is a steady bombardment of "exotic strange matter" and "exotic hi-energy plasmas" and minature black holes raining down over your head every day.

Our "high energy physicists" are nothing but little children playing with pop-guns. If this stuff was dangerous then they universe would wipe out the planet several times a day with it's big guns.

-

Re:charmed life

[HokieJP]

I agree with your description of the H/O reaction, but I think there are some problems with your last two statements.

There are very good reasons why this isn't a practical weapon. First, the volumes required to do significant damage are huge. Imagine filling a 1,000lb bomb casing with Hydrogen and Oxygen. It wouldn't accomplish much. Of course, you could liquify it, but then your cost skyrockets. I think the closest thing to what you're discussing is the Fuel/Air explosive, which has the wholehearted endorsement of the defense industry.

Second, if I were a pilot, and someone suggested to me that I fly around a combat zone with a cannister full of hydrogen and oxygen under my wing, I'd decline. Remember the Hindenberg? Centuries of development have given us explosives with higher activation energies.

As to your closing statement: the universe is huge, and not at all homogenous. There are a great many things in it that haven't come anywhere near us in our planet's relatively brief existence. I'm not arguing for the atmosphere-liquification particle, I'm just saying that your reasoning is specious.

Re:Thank God we're still alive

[Scott Carnahan]

The people near the reactor would be in serious danger, and an airplane directly over the plant may be in danger

Even this is doubtful. Because fusion is so efficient, there is no need for much plasma in a magnetic confinement reactor (current ignition attempts seem to work with densities on the order of 10^21/m^3 - about 1/10000 the particle density of the atmosphere at sea level), and should the walls fail, almost all of the excess thermal energy would be dissipated before the gas could leave the building. The main problem with a structural failure is the liberated magnetic field, which may throw chunks of metal around.

Sounds like a spam....

[dackroyd]

Looking for Quark-Gluon Plasma?

We make it easier and faster than ever to get the fundamental particles you need! Join online users who discreetly, safely and conveniently order prescription high energy particles like Quark-Gluon Plasma, Quantum Foam, Higgs Bosons, 1d-strings and almost any other HIGH ENGERY PARTICLES!

No forms to fill out... EVERYONE is approved... we respect your PRIVACY!

Guaranteed LOW PRICE ! ... We ship WORLDWIDE!...